Reviewed by: Propaganda in Revolutionary Ukraine: Leaflets, Pamphlets, and Cartoons, 1917–1922 by Stephen Velychenko Mollie Arbuthnot (bio) Stephen Velychenko, Propaganda in Revolutionary Ukraine: Leaflets, Pamphlets, and Cartoons, 1917–1922 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2019). 292 pp., ill. Index. ISBN: 978-1-4875-0468-7. The years of revolution and violence that immediately followed the collapse of the Russian Empire have beguiled historians for decades, and yet some angles remain underexplored. Foremost among these are what we might term the revolutionary peripheries: spaces that for reasons of both geography and politics have been marginalized in established narratives of revolution, civil war, and Bolshevik conquest. Propaganda in Revolutionary Ukraine sheds light on one such neglected area and introduces a swathe of hitherto underused primary sources to an Anglophone readership. The book focuses on propaganda texts that circulated across the territory of Ukraine in the form of leaflets and pamphlets, and the ways in which they were produced and disseminated by various actors (although the subtitle also refers to cartoons, these receive less attention in the text). It is, therefore, a study of the tactics and rhetoric employed by rival elites and political parties to sway opinion in revolutionary Ukraine, and the difficult conditions in which they operated. It may be regarded as a companion work to Stephen Velychenko's previous publications on the bureaucracy and the processes of state building in Ukraine in the same period, and the development of national and anti-imperial thought among Ukrainian Marxist intellectuals.1 Propaganda in Revolutionary Ukraine foregrounds its primary material: it is a survey text that aims to summarize and categorize the governmental and party-printed materials that appeared and circulated in Ukraine in the years 1917 to 1922, and to describe the organizational infrastructure that underpinned their dissemination. The main reason for focusing on leaflets and pamphlets, as outlined in the introduction, is that they were a true mass medium, intended for all and enjoying a wide reach in wartime conditions: "The impact of printed text on mobilizing, democratizing, socializing, and nationalizing populations should not be underestimated in societies in which few people had a telephone or a radio or a daily newspaper" (P. [End Page 275] 6).2 The author notes that since many of these ephemeral publications have not been located or cataloged, his sample is illustrative rather than representative, but it is nonetheless a large and extraordinarily rich source base. Some of the pamphlets are reproduced in the book itself, and many more are included in an online supplement, which is a most welcome resource.3 This book and its online companion undoubtedly provide the fullest account yet published of political media in Ukraine in the civil war period. The first chapter, "Message and Medium," begins with a discussion of commercial advertising and governmental propaganda in Europe, especially during World War I. It then gives an overview of the production capacities and distribution networks for printed texts in prerevolutionary Ukraine; the journalists, admen, and printers who powered the industry; and public consumption of printed texts in the context of widespread semiliteracy. The three subsequent chapters present a vast array of archival material with minimal added commentary. They are organized broadly chronologically, addressing in turn the propaganda texts published by the Central Rada and the Ukrainian state (chapter 2), the Ukrainian National Republic, radical socialist groups (comprising the left-SR/Borotbisty, left-SD/Independentist/Ukrainian Communist Party, and the Ukrainian Bolsheviks/Communist Party of Ukraine), and anti-Bolshevik warlords (chapter 3), and finally, the Bolsheviks (chapter 4). There are some notable omissions from this list – the monarchist Whites, for instance, are not included – but it is nonetheless refreshing to see the propaganda publications of such a range of groups, governments, and movements presented side by side in this way, extending our view beyond the Bolsheviks. Each chapter is divided into sections discussing "message" and "medium," and the messages are arranged around various themes, allowing Velychenko to illustrate the similarities and differences in both the content and the reach of each group's publications. Removing the Bolsheviks from center stage thus achieves two important things: first it enables this comparative perspective, and second, it adjusts our sense of centrality and...
Read full abstract