Across international brewing operations corn grits from different suppliers vary substantially in terms of their physical properties and chemical composition. Present research aimed to highlight the key factors determining the brewing quality of stored corn grits. Six grits samples were sourced with different particle sizes (that ranged from 0% to 74% of particles ≤0.355 mm) and stored at 10 °C, 20 °C, or 30 °C for 0, 2, 4, 8, 12, and 16 months. Samples were analysed for moisture, extract, lipid, trihydroxy fatty acids (THFA) and pro-oxidant metal ion contents. Particle size range was measured using sieve analysis. Increasing levels of THFA occurred on storage due to lipid oxidation and are negative indicators of brewing quality. PLS-R modelling of THFA levels (R 2 = 0.83) revealed particle size (hence surface area for oxidation) was the most important factor (∼60% of the total R 2) followed by storage time (∼25%) and temperature (∼7%). Metal ion content and lipid content of grits were minor contributors. Results showed that coarser milling of grits offers protection against lipid oxidation even after 8 months at 30 °C. These insights into key factors determining the rate of lipid oxidation in stored corn grits will help to develop better supply chain management and storage practices with which to assure their brewing quality.