While high entropy alloys and multi principal element alloys have been largely studied and developed as single solid solutions, fewer investigations have focused on phase transformations in these multicomponent alloys. This study reports on the aging behavior at 500 °C of a non-equimolar CrFeMnNi alloy. The results unveil a complex evolution, leading to complete decomposition into three main phases, namely an L10 NiMn phase, an FCC Fe-rich phase, and a BCC Cr-rich phase. The intricate microstructure is achieved in stages through continuous precipitation of L10 Ni-Mn nanoscale precipitates, which are progressively overtaken by a sweeping discontinuous front involving the co-precipitation of the L10 NiMn and BCC Cr-rich phases in addition to the parent FCC Fe-rich phase. Furthermore, the Cr-rich phase initially forms with metastable compositions leading to further precipitation of Fe-rich precipitates within the Cr-rich region behind the transformation front. Understanding these transformation pathways through metastable states emphasizes the potential for expanding the range of achievable properties through deliberate microstructure tailoring of multi principal element alloys.