In this study, potentiometric titration was used to determine the stability constants of mono- and bis(pyridine) complexes with silver(I) in mixed methanol–acetonitrile solvents. Gibbs free energies of transfer of pyridine from methanol to methanol–acetonitrile mixtures were determined by the method of distribution between two immiscible phases. The effect of solvent composition on change in the solvation state of pyridine was analyzed. The replacement of methanol by acetonitrile leads to the desolvation of pyridine. The resolvation of pyridine occurs predominantly due to the resolvation of the nitrogen atom at the concentration of acetonitrile >0.5 mol fr. The enthalpic contribution was shown to have a major contribution in ΔtrG0(Py)MeOH→(MeOH-AN). The effect of reagents solvation on the stability of [AgPy]+ and [AgPy2]+ complexes upon the change of the solvent composition was investigated. The resolvation of silver(I) was established to be a key factor controlling the stability of both complexes in MeOH-AN mixtures. The possibility of predictive calculation of the stability constants [AgPy]+ in individual and mixed non-aqueous solvents through the change in the Gibbs free energy of the solvation of the complexing ion was shown. Proper data are compared with data reported in the literature.