Mark Twain, Westward Expansion, Immigrant UnrestBaseball and American Growing Pains in Darryl Brock's If I Never Get Back Peter Carino (bio) Darryl Brock's If I Never Get Back recounts the time traveling adventure of Sam Fowler, a recently divorced and down-on-his-luck San Francisco newspaperman with a degree of athletic talent who awakens in 1896 to become a member of the Cincinnati Red Stockings, baseball's first professional team. But the novel is far more than a baseball adventure tale. Like Mark Twain's Hank Morgan of A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court, Sam initially brings a naive condescension to the past before becoming enmeshed in the richness and complexity of private, public, and political life in 1896. Upon his return to the present, Sam is a chastened, wiser, and more loving man. Sam's adventures are driven by the chaotic energy of post-Civil War America. In the course of his season with the Red Stockings, Sam befriends Mark Twain, takes the transcontinental railroad west to San Francisco, is ensnared in a political plot hatched by the Fenian Brotherhood to invade Canada and ransom it for Irish freedom, and falls in love with a young Fenian widow, Cait Leonard. He then discovers that his twentieth-century life may be a reincarnation of that of her husband, Colm, who was murdered in the Civil War by his supposed best friend, a Fenian leader and secret rival for Cait's affections. Mixing fantasy and historical fact, this episodic plot generates a panorama of an America in flux, an America looking for an identity but moving too fast to fix on one. Baseball is a part of this identity, as the Red Stockings become some of the nation's first popular culture celebrities. Yet, as a professional enterprise, the team also reflects the growing pains of a nation moving from its Anglo-centric and agrarian roots to expansionism, economic competition, and multicultural strife. Brock's rendering of nineteenth-century baseball both reflects and is informed by the instability of the times, and against this backdrop, his protagonist's development demonstrates the malleability of individual and cultural identity in the United States. [End Page 83] Blacking out on a twentieth-century Amtrak platform on his way back west from his father's funeral in Cleveland, Sam finds himself on a train with the famous "base ballists," as they call themselves, and becomes fast friends with the team's left fielder, Andy Leonard, the Huck Finn-like brother of Cait. Acclimating himself to his trip through time, Sam, as would be expected, feels a pronounced sense of dislocation, wondering, "Was my old body back on that station dock? . . . There must be a rationale to all this, a purpose. If I looked for clues surely I'd figure it out. But the whole thing was scary, like plunging into a void. Even with Andy's help, how was I going to cope?"1 Sam's sense of temporal dislocation, while an expected part of the time travel plot, parallels Brock's portrayal of the post-Civil War nation in change. The various locales the Red Stockings visit, as well as their home city of Cincinnati, constitute an unstable melange of rural past and urban aspiration. In Rochester, on the way to a match with the Troy Haymakers, Sam admires the still green channel of the Genesee River but is assaulted by the dust in the air and the roar of heavy machinery coming from the flour mills. He notes the bustling docks and barges that signal the river's impending transformation from pastoral landscape to commercial waterway and, passing the new brick streets of the business district, he recoils from "garbage [that] lay in stinking heaps before buildings, hogs and chickens picking through it" (p. 33). Similarly, on the sidewalks of New York with Mark Twain, after meeting the author on a train, Sam contrasts the gray stone facade, steam-powered elevator, gas chandelier, and plush carpeting of the Astor House with streets reeking of horse manure and markets "hung [with] meat and poultry crawling with flies" (p. 115). One of his strongest senses of culture shock comes...
Read full abstract