Aerodynamic drag is often used as a proxy for fuel consumption in aircraft design. However, the aeroacoustic byproduct of airfoil design, such as trailing-edge noise (TEN), is yet to be considered in aircraft applications, despite its inclusion in wind turbine designs. To explore the impact of TEN in airfoil design for aircraft, we establish a mission-based aerodynamic shape optimization framework. A surrogate-based detailed flight mission analysis (that can simulate a flight mission from takeoff to landing) is incorporated into the optimization framework to obtain realistic flight conditions during takeoff and landing—which are important to assess TEN metrics—and calculate accurate fuel consumption, where both are used to evaluate the objective function. To assess its effectiveness, we compare the results against those of the conventional single-point optimization. Not surprisingly, the mission-based optimization simultaneously reduces fuel consumption and TEN, while the single-point optima (performed at the low Mach region) reduce TEN at the expense of higher fuel consumption. This is due to the tradeoff between aerodynamic performance in the transonic region and aeroacoustic performance in the low Mach region, which cannot be properly analyzed without including flight mission analysis in the optimization loop.
Read full abstract