Toroidal Pore Research Articles

Quantified Efficiency of Membrane Leakage Events Relates to Antimicrobial Selectivity

In many therapeutic strategies like killing pathogenic microbes by antimicrobial peptides, drug delivery, endosomal escape, and in disease-related processes such as apoptosis, the membrane is permeabilized. Our concept for quantifying the efficiency of individual membrane leakage events replaces less stringent descriptions of dye leakage. The concept is applicable to many types of leakage events including thinning, defects, (toroidal) pores, or channels. We measure release and fluorescence lifetime of a self-quenching dye. Apart from the dose-response, our analysis also quantifies the efficiency of individual leakage events. Additionally, cumulative leakage kinetics can indicate certain membrane permeabilization mechanisms. For example, applying our concept to three series of antimicrobial peptide analogues shows how the leakage mechanism and leakage efficiency of a given compound change with lipid composition. Thus, lipids play an important role for the selectivity of membrane permeabilization. I will also point out aspects to consider when comparing leakage in vesicle of various sizes or cells, the possible occurrence of more than one type of leakage event, and artefacts from vesicle aggregation or fusion. The concept for the quantitative description of leakage behaviour and understanding of leakage mechanisms aids the design and improvement of membrane-active antimicrobials.

Curved or linear? Predicting the 3-dimensional structure of α-helical antimicrobial peptides in an amphipathic environment.

α-Helical membrane-active antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are known to act via a range of mechanisms, including the formation of barrel-stave and toroidal pores and the micellisation of the membrane (carpet mechanism). Different mechanisms imply that the peptides adopt different 3D structures when bound at the water-membrane interface, a highly amphipathic environment. Here, an evolutionary algorithm is used to predict the 3D structure of a range of α-helical membrane-active AMPs at the water-membrane interface by optimising amphipathicity. This amphipathic structure prediction (ASP) is capable of distinguishing between curved and linear peptides solved experimentally, potentially allowing the activity and mechanism of action of different membrane-active AMPs to be predicted. The ASP algorithm is accessible via a web interface at http://atb.uq.edu.au/asp/.

Membrane Remodeling by the Lytic Fragment of SticholysinII: Implications for the Toroidal Pore Model

Sticholysins are pore-forming toxins of biomedical interest and represent a prototype of proteins acting through the formation of protein-lipid or toroidal pores. Peptides spanning the N-terminus of sticholysins can mimic their permeabilizing activity and, together with the full-length toxins, have been used as a tool to understand the mechanism of pore formation in membranes. However, the lytic mechanism of these peptides and the lipid shape modulating their activity are not completely clear. In this article, we combine molecular dynamics simulations and experimental biophysical tools to dissect different aspects of the pore-forming mechanism of StII1–30, a peptide derived from the N-terminus of sticholysin II (StII). With this combined approach, membrane curvature induction and flip-flop movement of the lipids were identified as two important membrane remodeling steps mediated by StII1–30. Pore formation by this peptide was enhanced by the presence of the negatively curved lipid phosphatidylethanolamine in membranes. This lipid emerged not only as a facilitator of membrane interactions but also as a structural element of the StII1–30 pore that is recruited to the ring upon its assembly. Collectively, these, to our knowledge, new findings support a toroidal model for the architecture of the pore formed by StII1–30 and provide new molecular insight into the role of phosphatidylethanolamine as a membrane component that can easily integrate into the ring of toroidal pores, thus probably aiding in their stabilization. This study contributes to a better understanding of the molecular mechanism underlying the permeabilizing activity of StII1–30 and peptides or proteins acting via a toroidal pore mechanism and offers an informative framework for the optimization of the biomedical application of this and similar molecules.

Nano-viscosimetry analysis of the membrane disrupting action of the bee venom peptide melittin

Melittin is one of the most studied α-helical cationic membrane disrupting peptides. It is the main component of bee venom, however it is considered an antimicrobial peptide for its ability to kill bacteria. Melittin is believed to act by opening large toroidal pores in the plasma membrane of the targeted cells/bacteria, although this is questioned by some authors. Little is known, however, about the molecular mechanism leading to this activity. In this study the mechanism of action of melittin was studied by dye leakage and quartz crystal microbalance fingerprinting analysis in biomimetic model membranes. The results revealed the existence of multiple stages in the membrane disrupting action with characteristic differences between different membrane types. In bacterial-mimetic (charged) lipid mixtures the viscoelastic fingerprints suggest a surface-acting mechanism, whereas in mammalian-mimetic (neutral) membranes melittin appears to penetrate the bilayer already at low concentrations. In domain-forming mixed membranes melittin shows a preference for the domain containing predominantly zwitterionic lipids. The results confirm membrane poration but are inconsistent with the insertion-to-toroidal pore pathway. Therefore hypotheses of the two membrane disrupting pathways were developed, describing the membrane disruption as either surface tension modulation leading to toroidal pore formation, or linear aggregation leading to fissure formation in the membrane.

Magainin-H2 effects on the permeabilization and mechanical properties of giant unilamellar vesicles

Among the potential novel therapeutics to treat bacterial infections, antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are a very promising substitute due to their broad-spectrum activity and rapid bactericidal action. AMPs strongly interact with the bacterial membrane, and the need to have a correct understanding of the interaction between AMPs and lipid bilayers at a molecular level prompted a wealth of experimental and theoretical studies exploiting a variety of AMPs. Here, we studied the effects of magainin H2 (Mag H2), an analog of the well-known magainin 2 (wt Mag 2) AMP endowed with a higher degree of hydrophobicity, on giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) concentrating on its permeabilization activity and the effect on the lipid bilayer mechanical properties. We demonstrated that the increased hydrophobicity of Mag H2 affects its selectivity conferring a strong permeabilization activity also on zwitterionic lipid bilayers. Moreover, when lipid mixtures including PG lipids are considered, PG has a protective effect, at variance from wt Mag 2, suggesting that for Mag H2 the monolayer curvature could prevail over the peptide-membrane electrostatic interaction. We then mechanically characterized GUVs by measuring the effect of Mag H2 on the bending constant of lipid bilayers by flickering spectroscopy and, by using micropipette aspiration technique, we followed the steps leading to vesicle permeabilization. We found that Mag H2, notwithstanding its enhanced hydrophobicity, has a pore formation mechanism compatible with the toroidal pore model similar to that of wt Mag 2.

Membrane Permeabilization by Bordetella Adenylate Cyclase Toxin Involves Pores of Tunable Size.

RTX (Repeats in ToXin) pore-forming toxins constitute an expanding family of exoproteins secreted by many Gram-negative bacteria and involved in infectious diseases caused by said pathogens. Despite the relevance in the host/pathogen interactions, the structure and characteristics of the lesions formed by these toxins remain enigmatic. Here, we capture the first direct nanoscale pictures of lytic pores formed by an RTX toxin, the Adenylate cyclase (ACT), secreted by the whooping cough bacterium Bordetella pertussis. We reveal that ACT associates into growing-size oligomers of variable stoichiometry and heterogeneous architecture (lines, arcs, and rings) that pierce the membrane, and that, depending on the incubation time and the toxin concentration, evolve into large enough “holes” so as to allow the flux of large molecular mass solutes, while vesicle integrity is preserved. We also resolve ACT assemblies of similar variable stoichiometry in the cell membrane of permeabilized target macrophages, proving that our model system recapitulates the process of ACT permeabilization in natural membranes. Based on our data we propose a non-concerted monomer insertion and sequential mechanism of toroidal pore formation by ACT. A size-tunable pore adds a new regulatory element to ACT-mediated cytotoxicity, with different pore sizes being putatively involved in different physiological scenarios or cell types.

Correlation of an Antimicrobial Peptide's Potency and Its Influences on Membrane Elasticity

The killing power of membrane-active antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) lies in their ability to disrupt the structures of pathogenic membranes. While understanding the AMPs' mechanisms of action is key to realizing their therapeutic potentials, how the AMPs modulate membrane elasticity and thereby affect membrane structure remains an open question, even though the AMP-induced variations in membrane curvature are widely considered to be crucial. Here, we exploit the x-ray diffraction technique to examine how the dominant bacterial lipid, phosphatidylethanolamine, varies its monolayer elastic properties upon interacting with six artificial peptides mimicking the AMPs' common amino acid content. Remarkably, the monolayer spontaneous curvature ${C}_{0}$ is unaffected by any of the peptides. In contrast, the peptides designated as ${(\mathrm{K}2\mathrm{W})}^{2}$, K4W2, R6, and R9, mimicking the AMP mutants with microbicidal potency, are able to modify the monolayer bending moduli ${K}_{cp}$, while those derived from the impotent mutants cannot. The results are consistent with the scenario that the AMPs disrupt the structure of pathogenic monolayers by, additionally if not exclusively, modulating their ${K}_{cp}$'s, with stiffening and softening leading to two different modes of disruption, that is, toroidal pore formation and membrane micellation, respectively.

Membrane Permeabilization Mechanisms.

Many antimicrobial peptides are considered to kill microbes by permeabilizing cell membranes. This chapter summarizes the driving force of peptide binding to membranes; various mechanisms of lipid bilayer permeabilization including the barrel-stave, toroidal pore, and carpet models; and modes of permeabilization of bacterial and mammalian membranes.

Biophysical investigation into the antibacterial action of modelin-5-NH2.

Modelin-5-CONH2 (M5-NH2) is a synthetic antimicrobial peptide, which was found to show potent activity against Bacillus subtilis (minimum lethal concentration = 8.47 μM) and to bind strongly to membranes of the organism (Kd = 10.44 μM). The peptide adopted high levels of amphiphilic α-helical structure in the presence of these membranes (>50%), which led to high levels of insertion (Δπ ≥ 8.0 mN m-1). M5-NH2 showed high affinity for anionic lipid (Kd = 7.46 μM) and zwitterionic lipid (Kd = 14.7 μM), which drove insertion into membranes formed from these lipids (Δπ = 11.5 and 3.5 mN m-1, respectively). Neutron diffraction studies showed that M5-NH2 inserted into B. subtilis membranes with its N-terminal residue, L16, located 5.5 Å from the membrane centre, in the acyl chain region of these membranes, and promoted a reduction in membrane thickness of circa 1.8 Å or 5% of membrane width. Insertion into B. subtilis membranes by the peptide also promoted other effects associated with membrane thinning, including increases in membrane surface area (Cs-1 decreases) and fluidity (ΔGmix > 0 to ΔGmix < 0). Membrane insertion and thinning by M5-NH2 induced high levels of lysis (>55%), and it is speculated that the antibacterial action of the peptide may involve the toroidal pore, carpet or tilted-type mechanism of membrane permeabilization.

Styrene maleic acid copolymer induces pores in biomembranes.

We investigated the interactions between styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers and phospholipid bilayers, using confocal microscopy and surface acoustic wave resonance (SAR) sensing. For the first time we experimentally observed and followed pore formation by SMA copolymers in intact supported bilayers and unilamellar vesicles, showing that fluorescein, a water-soluble organic compound with a mean diameter of 6.9 Å, can traverse the membrane. Our findings are in agreement with recent theoretical predictions, which suggested that SMA copolymers may insert along the plane of the bilayer to form stable toroidal pores.

The effects of SDS at subsolubilizing concentrations on the planar lipid bilayer permeability: Two kinds of current fluctuations.

Detergent effects on lipid bilayers of artificial and biological membranes at subsolubilizing concentrations are known to include the membrane permeabilization which manifests itself through both a flip-flop of detergent molecules from the outer monolayer to the inner monolayer and the membrane leakage of entrapped solutes. We have explored the current fluctuations occurring in planar BLM of asolectin in the presence of ionic detergent SDS at subsolubilizing concentration. Two groups of current fluctuations which the average duration differs by two orders of magnitude can be distinguished. We assume that these differences in the duration of current fluctuations are associated with a different number of SDS molecules in the walls of the putative toroidal hydrophilic pores. We associated short pulses with the formation of short-lived lipid hydrophilic pores. Impulses of greater duration (steps) were associated with the formation of hydrophilic pores, the walls of which contain detergent. Taking into account the characteristics of these pores, we estimated the pore energy, as well as the edge energy of these two kinds of pores. We believe that the flip-flop of SDS molecules in liposomes is provided by long-lived pores, and the contents of the liposome leakage occurs through all pores.

Correlation of an antimicrobial peptide's potency and its influences on membrane elasticity

The killing power of membrane-active antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) lies in their ability to disrupt the structures of pathogenic membranes. While understanding the AMPs' mechanisms of action is key to realizing their therapeutic potentials, how the AMPs modulate membrane elasticity and thereby affect membrane structure remains an open question, even though the AMP-induced variations in membrane curvature are widely considered to be crucial. Here, we exploit the x-ray diffraction technique to examine how the dominant bacterial lipid, phosphatidylethanolamine, varies its monolayer elastic properties upon interacting with six artificial peptides mimicking the AMPs' common amino acid content. Remarkably, the monolayer spontaneous curvature ${C}_{0}$ is unaffected by any of the peptides. In contrast, the peptides designated as ${(\mathrm{K}2\mathrm{W})}^{2}$, K4W2, R6, and R9, mimicking the AMP mutants with microbicidal potency, are able to modify the monolayer bending moduli ${K}_{cp}$, while those derived from the impotent mutants cannot. The results are consistent with the scenario that the AMPs disrupt the structure of pathogenic monolayers by, additionally if not exclusively, modulating their ${K}_{cp}$'s, with stiffening and softening leading to two different modes of disruption, that is, toroidal pore formation and membrane micellation, respectively.

Topology of active, membrane-embedded Bax in the context of a toroidal pore.

Bax is a Bcl-2 protein critical for apoptosis induction. In healthy cells, Bax is mostly a monomeric, cytosolic protein, while upon apoptosis initiation it inserts into the outer mitochondrial membrane, oligomerizes, and forms pores that release proapoptotic factors like Cytochrome c into the cytosol. The structures of active Bax and its homolog Bak are only partially understood and the topology of the proteins with respect to the membrane bilayer is controversially described in the literature. Here, we systematically review and examine the protein-membrane, protein-water, and protein-protein contacts of the nine helices of active Bax and Bak, and add a new set of topology data obtained by fluorescence and EPR methods. We conclude based on the consistent part of the datasets that the core/dimerization domain of Bax (Bak) is water exposed with only helices 4 and 5 in membrane contact, whereas the piercing/latch domain is in peripheral membrane contact, with helix 9 being transmembrane. Among the available structural models, those considering the dimerization/core domain at the rim of a toroidal pore are the most plausible to describe the active state of the proteins, although the structural flexibility of the piercing/latch domain does not allow unambiguous discrimination between the existing models.

Dissecting the mechanism of action of actinoporins. Role of the N-terminal amphipathic α-helix in membrane binding and pore activity of sticholysins I and II.

Actinoporins sticholysin I and sticholysin II (St I, St II) are proposed to lyse model and biomembranes via toroidal pore formation by their N-terminal domain. Based on the hypothesis that peptide fragments can reproduce the structure and function of this domain, the behavior of peptides containing St I residues 12–31 (StI12-31), St II residues 11–30 (StII11-30), and its TOAC-labeled analogue (N-TOAC-StII11-30) was examined. Molecular modeling showed a good match with experimental structures, indicating amphipathic α-helices in the same regions as in the toxins. CD spectra revealed that the peptides were essentially unstructured in aqueous solution, acquiring α-helical conformation upon interaction with micelles and large unilamellar vesicles (LUV) of variable lipid composition. Fluorescence quenching studies with NBD-containing lipids indicated that N-TOAC-StII11-30’s nitroxide moiety is located in the membranes polar head group region. Pyrene-labeled phospholipid inter-leaflet redistribution suggested that the peptides form toroidal pores, according to the mechanism of action proposed for the toxins. Binding occurred only to negatively charged LUV, indicating the importance of electrostatic interactions; in contrast the peptides bound to both negatively charged and zwitterionic micelles, pointing to a lesser influence of these interactions. In addition, differences between bilayers and micelles in head group packing and in curvature led to differences in peptide-membrane interaction. We propose that the peptides topography in micelles resembles that of the toxins in the toroidal pore. The peptides mimicked the toxins permeabilizing activity, St II peptides being more effective than StI12-31. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration that differences in the toxins N-terminal amphipathic α-helix play a role in the difference between St I and St II activities.

Lipid Membrane Interactions of the Cationic Antimicrobial Peptide Chimeras Melimine and Cys-Melimine

Melimine and its derivatives are synthetic chimeric antimicrobial agents based on protamine and melittin. The binding of solubilized melimine and its derivative, with a cysteine on N-terminus, (cys-melimine) on tethered bilayer lipid membranes (tBLMs) was examined using ac electrical impedance spectroscopy. The addition of melimine and cys-melimine initially increased membrane conduction, which subsequently falls over time. The results were obtained for tBLMs comprising zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine, anionic phosphatidylglycerol, or tBLMs made using purified lipids from Escherichia coli. The effect on conduction is more marked with the cysteine variant than the noncysteine variant. The variation in membrane conduction most probably arises from individual melimines inducing increased ionic permeability, which is then reduced as the melimines aggregate and phase-separate within the membrane. The actions of these antimicrobials are modeled in terms of altering the critical packing parameter (CPP) of the membranes. The variations in the peptide length of cys-melimine were compared with a truncated version of the peptide, cys-mel4. The results suggest that the smaller molecule impacts the membrane by a mechanism that increases the average CPP, reducing membrane conduction. Alternatively, an uncharged alanine-replacement version of melimine still produced an increase in membrane conduction, further supporting the CPP model of geometry-induced toroidal pore alterations. All the data were then compared to their antimicrobial effectiveness for the Gram-positive and Gram-negative strains of bacteria, and their fusogenic properties were examined using dynamic light scattering in 1-oleoyl-2-hydroxy- sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine lipid spheroids. We conclude that a degree of correlation exists between the antimicrobial effectiveness of the peptides studied here and their modulation of membrane conductivity.

The novel cathelicidin of naked mole rats, Hg-CATH, showed potent antimicrobial activity and low cytotoxicity

We performed the in silico genome-wide identification of antimicrobial peptides against the available genome sequence of the naked mole rat Heterocephalus glaber (H. glaber). Our results showed the presence of Hg-CATH, the single cathelicidin containing the antimicrobial domain in H. glaber. We chemically synthesized a 25 amino-acid peptide (ΔHg-CATH) corresponding to the predicted antimicrobial-active core region of Hg-CATH, and evaluated its antibacterial activity against seven bacterial strains. The ΔHg-CATH peptide exhibited strong bactericidal activity against gram-negative bacteria, including a multi-drug resistant strain, while showing low toxicity towards mammalian cells, including erythrocytes. Scanning electron microscopy images of bacterial cells treated with ΔHg-CATH showed disruption of their membranes due to the formation of toroidal pores. Identifying novel antimicrobial peptides, such as Hg-CATH, may be important for identifying candidate peptides for the control of multi-drug resistant bacteria.

Comparative Study of Pore Formation Energy by High Intensity, Nanosecond Electrical Pulse.

Nanosecond, high intensity electric pulses create nanopores in the cell membrane. Pore formation energy is probed by taking account of the strain energy based on the continuum model. Maxwell stress acting on the cell membrane is included in the 3D model calculation as well as the effect of membrane curvature. In addition, comparison between cylindrical and toroidal pores were made to explore the difference of strain energy and force over the pores at a range of radii. Through the analyses the transmembrane potential were kept constant in order to obtain a transient response in that the electric pulse has a ultrashort duration and pore-evolving process is rapid as well. Our results demonstrate that under the same circumstances toroidal pores have higher strain energy than cylindrical pores due to the surface area and volume of the pore shape.

A synthetic enzyme built from DNA flips 107 lipids per second in biological membranes

Mimicking enzyme function and increasing performance of naturally evolved proteins is one of the most challenging and intriguing aims of nanoscience. Here, we employ DNA nanotechnology to design a synthetic enzyme that substantially outperforms its biological archetypes. Consisting of only eight strands, our DNA nanostructure spontaneously inserts into biological membranes by forming a toroidal pore that connects the membrane’s inner and outer leaflets. The membrane insertion catalyzes spontaneous transport of lipid molecules between the bilayer leaflets, rapidly equilibrating the lipid composition. Through a combination of microscopic simulations and fluorescence microscopy we find the lipid transport rate catalyzed by the DNA nanostructure exceeds 107 molecules per second, which is three orders of magnitude higher than the rate of lipid transport catalyzed by biological enzymes. Furthermore, we show that our DNA-based enzyme can control the composition of human cell membranes, which opens new avenues for applications of membrane-interacting DNA systems in medicine.

An Atlas of Anionic Antimicrobial Peptides from Amphibians

Anionic antimicrobial peptides (AAMPs) with net charges ranging from -1 to -8 have been identified in frogs, toads, newts and salamanders across Africa, South America and China. Most of these peptides show antibacterial activity and a number of them are multifunctional, variously showing antifungal activity, anticancer action, neuropeptide function and the ability to potentiate conventional antibiotics. Antimicrobial mechanisms proposed for these AAMPs, include toroidal pore formation and the Shai-Huang-Matsazuki model of membrane interaction along with pH dependent amyloidogenesis and membranolysis via tilted peptide formation. The potential for therapeutic and biotechnical application of these AAMPs has been demonstrated, including the development of amyloid-based nanomaterials and antiviral agents. It is concluded that amphibian AAMPs represent an untapped potential source of biologically active agents and merit far greater research interest.

Insights into Membrane Translocation of Protegrin Antimicrobial Peptides by Multistep Molecular Dynamics Simulations.

Protegrin-1 (PG-1) is a cationic arginine-rich antimicrobial peptide. It is widely accepted that PG-1 induces membrane disruption by forming pores that lead to cell death. However, the insertion mechanism for these highly cationic peptides into the hydrophobic membrane environment is still poorly understood at the molecular scale. It has previously been determined that the association of arginine guanidinium and lipid phosphate groups results in strong bidentate bonds that stabilize peptide–lipid complexes. It has also been suggested that arginine residues are able to drag phosphate groups as they insert inside the membrane to form a toroidal pore. However, whether bidentate bonds play a significant role in inducing a pore formation remains unclear. To investigate the role of bidentate complexes in PG-1 translocation, we conducted molecular dynamics simulations. Two computational electroporation methods were implemented to examine the translocation process. We found that PG-1 could insert into the membrane, provided the external electric potential is large enough to first induce a water column or a pore within the lipid bilayer membrane. We also found that the highly charged PG-1 is capable in itself of inducing molecular electroporation. Substitution of arginines with charge-equivalent lysines showed a markedly reduced tendency for insertion. This indicates that the guanidinium group likely facilitates PG-1 translocation. Potential of mean force calculations suggests that peptide insertion inside the hydrophobic environment of the membrane core is not favored. We found that formation of a water column or a pore might be a prerequisite for PG-1 translocation. We also found that PG-1 can stabilize the pore after insertion. We suggest that PG-1 could be a pore inducer and stabilizer. This work sheds some light on PG-1 translocation mechanisms at the molecular level. Methods presented in this study may be extended to other arginine-rich antimicrobial and cell-penetrating peptides.