TOL Plasmid Research Articles

Increasing Signal Specificity of the TOL Network of Pseudomonas putida mt-2 by Rewiring the Connectivity of the Master Regulator XylR

Prokaryotic transcription factors (TFs) that bind small xenobiotic molecules (e.g., TFs that drive genes that respond to environmental pollutants) often display a promiscuous effector profile for analogs of the bona fide chemical signals. XylR, the master TF for expression of the m-xylene biodegradation operons encoded in the TOL plasmid pWW0 of Pseudomonas putida, responds not only to the aromatic compound but also, albeit to a lesser extent, to many other aromatic compounds, such as 3-methylbenzylalcohol (3MBA). We have examined whether such a relaxed regulatory scenario can be reshaped into a high-capacity/high-specificity regime by changing the connectivity of this effector-sensing TF within the rest of the circuit rather than modifying XylR structure itself. To this end, the natural negative feedback loop that operates on xylR transcription was modified with a translational attenuator that brings down the response to 3MBA while maintaining the transcriptional output induced by m-xylene (as measured with a luxCDABE reporter system). XylR expression was then subject to a positive feedback loop in which the TF was transcribed from its own target promoters, each known to hold different input/output transfer functions. In the first case (xylR under the strong promoter of the upper TOL operon, Pu), the reporter system displayed an increased transcriptional capacity in the resulting network for both the optimal and the suboptimal XylR effectors. In contrast, when xylR was expressed under the weaker Ps promoter, the resulting circuit unmistakably discriminated m-xylene from 3MBA. The non-natural connectivity engineered in the network resulted both in a higher promoter activity and also in a much-increased signal-to-background ratio. These results indicate that the working regimes of given genetic circuits can be dramatically altered through simple changes in the way upstream transcription factors are self-regulated by positive or negative feedback loops.

Deepening TOL and TOU catabolic pathways of Pseudomonas sp. OX1: Cloning, sequencing and characterization of the lower pathways

Pseudomonas sp. OX1 is able to metabolize toluene and o-xylene through the TOU catabolic pathway, whereas its mutant M1 strain was found to be able to use m- and p-xylene as carbon and energy source, using the TOL catabolic pathway. Here we report the complete nucleotide sequence of the phe lower operon of the TOU catabolic pathway, and the sequence of the last four genes of the xyl-like lower operon of the TOL catabolic pathway. DNA sequence analysis shows the gene order within the operons to be pheCDEFGHI (phe operon) and xyl-likeQKIH (xyl-like operon), identical to the order found for the isofunctional genes of meta operons in the toluene/xylene pathway of TOL plasmid pWW0 from Pseudomonas putida mt-2 and the phenol/methylphenol pathway of pVIl50 from Pseudomonas sp. CF600. The nucleotide and the deduced amino acid sequences are homologous to the equivalent gene and enzyme sequences from other Pseudomonas meta pathways. Recombinant 2-hydroxymuconic semialdehyde dehydrogenase (HMSD) and 2-hydroxymuconic semialdehyde hydrolase (HMSH), coded by pheCD genes, respectively, and ADA and HOA enzymes from both phe and xyl operons were expressed in E.coli and steady-state kinetic analysis was carried out. The analysis of the kinetic parameters of HMSD and HMSH showed that the enzymes from Pseudomonas sp. OX1 are more specialized to channel metabolites into the two branches of the lower pathway than homologous enzymes from other pseudomonads. The kinetics parameters of recombinant ADA from phe and xyl-like operon were found to be similar to those of homologous enzymes from other Pseudomonas strains. In addition, the enzyme from xyl-like operon showed a substrate affinity three times higher than the enzyme from phe operon.

Stochasticity of TOL plasmid catabolic promoters sets a bimodal expression regime in Pseudomonas putida mt‐2 exposed to m‐xylene

The expression dynamics of the catabolic promoters of the TOL plasmid pWW0 has been examined in single cells of Pseudomonas putida mt-2 exposed to m-xylene. To this end, we employed an á la carte bi-cistronic gfp-lacZ reporter system for generating monocopy transcriptional fusions to each of the four promoters (Pr, Ps, Pu and Pm) of the regulatory network. Whereas expression of xylR (the master regulatory gene of the TOL system) behaved in a unimodal fashion, the activation of Pu and Pm displayed a high degree of stochasticity. This event resulted in a time-dependent shift in the bacterial population between two induction states without intermediate expression levels. Bimodality of the Pm promoter for the lower TOL pathway was largely due to the propagation of the Ps output throughout the network, which caused stochastic overproduction of the second regulator of the system, XylS. Surprisingly, activation of Pm by the form of XylS that was bound to the pathway intermediate 3-methylbenzoate was relatively minor. These stochastic phenomena in response to m-xylene disappeared in the stationary phase. Taken together, the data suggests that genetically homogeneous populations of P. putida mt-2 employ a strategy of phenotypic variation (metabolic bet-hedging) when confronted with mixtures of nutrients.

Genetic bioaugmentation as an effective method for in situ bioremediation

Genetic bioaugmentation is an in situ bioremediation method that stimulates horizontal transfer of catabolic plasmids between exogenous donor cells and indigenous bacteria to increase the biodegradation potential of contaminants. A critical outcome of genetic bioaugmentation is the expression of an active catabolic phenotype upon plasmid conjugation. Using a pWW0-derivative TOL plasmid, we showed that certain genetic characteristics of the recipient bacteria, including genomic guanine-cytosine (G + C) content and phylogeny, may limit the expression of the transferred catabolic pathway. However, such genetic limitations observed in transconjugants could be overcome by the presence of an additional carbon source. Glucose and Luria-Bertani broth were shown to enhance the toluene degradation rates of transconjugants; these enhancement effects were dependent on transconjugant genomic G + C contents. Based on these observations, thorough genetic characterization of the indigenous microbial community in the contaminated environment of interest may provide a predictive tool for assessing the success of genetic bioaugmentation.

Genetic bioaugmentation as an effective method for in situ bioremediation: Functionality of catabolic plasmids following conjugal transfers

Genetic bioaugmentation is an in situ bioremediation method that stimulates horizontal transfer of catabolic plasmids between exogenous donor cells and indigenous bacteria to increase the biodegradation potential of contaminants. A critical outcome of genetic bioaugmentation is the expression of an active catabolic phenotype upon plasmid conjugation. Using a pWW0-derivative TOL plasmid, we showed that certain genetic characteristics of the recipient bacteria, including genomic guanine-cytosine (G + C) content and phylogeny, may limit the expression of the transferred catabolic pathway. However, such genetic limitations observed in transconjugants could be overcome by the presence of an additional carbon source. Glucose and Luria-Bertani broth were shown to enhance the toluene degradation rates of transconjugants; these enhancement effects were dependent on transconjugant genomic G + C contents. Based on these observations, thorough genetic characterization of the indigenous microbial community in the contaminated environment of interest may provide a predictive tool for assessing the success of genetic bioaugmentation.

Impacts of organic carbon availability and recipient bacteria characteristics on the potential for TOL plasmid genetic bioaugmentation in soil slurries

The effectiveness of genetic bioaugmentation relies on efficient plasmid transfer between donor and recipient cells as well as the plasmid’s phenotype in the recipient cell. In the present study, the effects of varying organic carbon substrates, initial recipient-to-donor cell density ratios, and mixtures of known recipient bacterial strains on the conjugation and function of a TOL plasmid were tested in sterile soil slurry batch reactors. The presence of soil organic carbon was sufficient in ensuring TOL plasmid transconjugant occurrence (up to 2.1±0.5%) for most recipient strains in soil slurry batch mating experiments. The addition of glucose had limited effects on transconjugant occurrence; however, glucose amendment increased the specific toluene degradation rates of some Enterobacteriaceae transconjugants in soil slurry. Initial cell density ratios and mixtures of recipient strains had smaller impacts on plasmid conjugation and resulting phenotype functionality. These observations suggest that genetic bioaugmentation may be improved by minimal altering of environmental conditions.

Evolution of antibiotic resistance, catabolic pathways and niche colonization

Evolution of antibiotic resistance, catabolic pathways and niche colonization

Functionality of the TOL plasmid under varying environmental conditions following conjugal transfer

Conjugation of catabolic plasmids in contaminated environments is a naturally occurring horizontal gene transfer phenomenon, which could be utilized in genetic bioaugmentation. The potentially important parameters for genetic bioaugmentation include gene regulation of transferred catabolic plasmids that may be controlled by the genetic characteristics of transconjugants as well as environmental conditions that may alter the expression of the contaminant-degrading phenotype. This study showed that both genomic guanine-cytosine contents and phylogenetic characteristics of transconjugants were important in controlling the phenotype functionality of the TOL plasmid. These genetic characteristics had no apparent impact on the stability of the TOL plasmid, which was observed to be highly variable among strains. Within the environmental conditions tested, the addition of glucose resulted in the largest enhancement of the activities of enzymes encoded by the TOL plasmid in all transconjugant strains. Glucose (1g/L) enhanced the phenotype functionality by up to 16.4 (±2.22), 30.8 (±7.03), and 90.8 (±4.56)-fold in toluene degradation rates, catechol 2,3-dioxygenase enzymatic activities, and xylE gene expression, respectively. These results suggest that genetic limitations of the expression of horizontally acquired genes may be overcome by the presence of alternate carbon substrates. Such observations may be utilized in improving the effectiveness of genetic bioaugmentation.

The logic layout of the TOL network of Pseudomonas putida pWW0 plasmid stems from a metabolic amplifier motif (MAM) that optimizes biodegradation of m-xylene

BackgroundThe genetic network of the TOL plasmid pWW0 of the soil bacterium Pseudomonas putida mt-2 for catabolism of m-xylene is an archetypal model for environmental biodegradation of aromatic pollutants. Although nearly every metabolic and transcriptional component of this regulatory system is known to an extraordinary molecular detail, the complexity of its architecture is still perplexing. To gain an insight into the inner layout of this network a logic model of the TOL system was implemented, simulated and experimentally validated. This analysis made sense of the specific regulatory topology out on the basis of an unprecedented network motif around which the entire genetic circuit for m-xylene catabolism gravitates.ResultsThe most salient feature of the whole TOL regulatory network is the control exerted by two distinct but still intertwined regulators (XylR and XylS) on expression of two separated catabolic operons (upper and lower) for catabolism of m-xylene. Following model reduction, a minimal modular circuit composed by five basic variables appeared to suffice for fully describing the operation of the entire system. In silico simulation of the effect of various perturbations were compared with experimental data in which specific portions of the network were activated with selected inducers: m-xylene, o-xylene, 3-methylbenzylalcohol and 3-methylbenzoate. The results accredited the ability of the model to faithfully describe network dynamics. This analysis revealed that the entire regulatory structure of the TOL system enables the action an unprecedented metabolic amplifier motif (MAM). This motif synchronizes expression of the upper and lower portions of a very long metabolic system when cells face the head pathway substrate, m-xylene.ConclusionLogic modeling of the TOL circuit accounted for the intricate regulatory topology of this otherwise simple metabolic device. The found MAM appears to ensure a simultaneous expression of the upper and lower segments of the m-xylene catabolic route that would be difficult to bring about with a standard substrate-responsive single promoter. Furthermore, it is plausible that the MAM helps to avoid biochemical conflicts between competing plasmid-encoded and chromosomally-encoded pathways in this bacterium.

Functional analysis of the integration host factor site of the σ54Pu promoter of Pseudomonas putida by in vivo UV imprinting

The integration host factor (IHF) of Pseudomonas putida connects cell growth to transcriptional activity of distinct promoters. The IHF site of the σ(54) promoter Pu of the TOL (m-xylene biodegradation) plasmid pWW0 of P. putida has been examined to define experimentally a relationship between occupation of the promoter by this factor, the biological activity of the protein and the tolerance of the target site to single-base changes through the bound DNA core sequence. The use of an in vivo high-intensity UV imprinting procedure to examine such an occupation of Pu by IHF allowed inspection of the interplay between the factor and cognate site variants under the physiologically relevant conditions of monocopy gene dosage. The resulting data were merged in a structural model for establishing key features of the IHF-DNA interaction. A functional consensus for first-order IHF binding was instrumental for a genome-wide survey of sequences with potential regulatory value. This search revealed that very few, if any, of the maximum 330 sites within intergenic regions were placed in locations controlling expression of central metabolic genes. It thus seems that the IHF regulon of P. putida has a degree of functional specialization that is not evenly distributed through all gene categories.

An efficient design strategy for a whole-cell biosensor based on engineered ribosome binding sequences

In prokaryotes, the ribosome binding sequence (RBS), located in the 5' untranslated region (5' UTR) of an mRNA, plays a critical role in enhancing mRNA translation and stability. To evaluate the effect of the RBS on the sensitivity and signal intensity of an environmental whole-cell biosensor, three Escherichia coli-based biosensors that respond to benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and the xylenes (BTEX) were constructed; the three biosensors have the same Pu promoter and xylR regulator from the Pseudomonas putida TOL plasmid but differ in the engineered RBS in their reporter genes. The results from time and dose-dependent induction of luminescence activity by 2-chlorotoluene showed that the BTEX-SE and BTEX-SD biosensors with engineered RBS had signal intensities approximately 10-35 times higher than the primary BTEX-W biosensor. The limits of detection (LOD) of the BTEX-SE and BTEX-SD biosensors were also significantly lower than the LOD of the BTEX-W biosensor (20 ± 5 μmol L(-1) and 25 ± 5 μmol L(-1) vs. 120 ± 10 μmol L(-1)). Moreover, the BTEX-SE and BTEX-SD biosensors responded three times more rapidly to the analytes. These results suggest that rationally designed RBS in the 5' UTR of a reporter gene may be a promising strategy for increasing the sensitivity, signal intensity, and response speed of whole-cell biosensors.

Improving the prediction of Pseudomonas putida mt-2 growth kinetics with the use of a gene expression regulation model of the TOL plasmid

The molecular and genetic events responsible for the growth kinetics of a microorganism can be extensively influenced by the presence of mixtures of substrates leading to unusual growth patterns, which cannot be accurately predicted by mathematical models developed using analogies to enzyme kinetics. Towards this end, we have combined a dynamic mathematical model of the Ps/ Pr promoters of the TOL (pWW0) plasmid of Pseudomonas putida mt-2, involved in the metabolism of m-xylene, with the growth kinetics of the microorganism to predict the biodegradation of m-xylene and succinate in batch cultures. The substrate interactions observed in mixed-substrate experiments could not be accurately described by models without directly specifying the type of interaction even when accounting for enzymatic interactions. The structure of the genetic circuit–growth kinetic model was validated with batch cultures of mt-2 fed with m-xylene and succinate and its predictive capability was confirmed by successfully predicting independent sets of experimental data. Our combined genetic circuit–growth kinetic modelling approach exemplifies the critical importance of the molecular interactions of key genetic circuits in predicting unusual growth patterns. Such strategy is more suitable in describing bioprocess performance, which current models fail to predict.

Linking genes to microbial growth kinetics—An integrated biochemical systems engineering approach

The majority of models describing the kinetic properties of a microorganism for a given substrate are unstructured and empirical. They are formulated in this manner so that the complex mechanism of cell growth is simplified. Herein, a novel approach for modelling microbial growth kinetics is proposed, linking biomass growth and substrate consumption rates to the gene regulatory programmes that control these processes. A dynamic model of the TOL (pWW0) plasmid of Pseudomonas putida mt-2 has been developed, describing the molecular interactions that lead to the transcription of the upper and meta operons, known to produce the enzymes for the oxidative catabolism of m-xylene. The genetic circuit model was combined with a growth kinetic model decoupling biomass growth and substrate consumption rates, which are expressed as independent functions of the rate-limiting enzymes produced by the operons. Estimation of model parameters and validation of the model's predictive capability were successfully performed in batch cultures of mt-2 fed with different concentrations of m-xylene, as confirmed by relative mRNA concentration measurements of the promoters encoded in TOL. The growth formation and substrate utilisation patterns could not be accurately described by traditional Monod-type models for a wide range of conditions, demonstrating the critical importance of gene regulation for the development of advanced models closely predicting complex bioprocesses. In contrast, the proposed strategy, which utilises quantitative information pertaining to upstream molecular events that control the production of rate-limiting enzymes, predicts the catabolism of a substrate and biomass formation and could be of central importance for the design of optimal bioprocesses.

Cooperative amino acid changes shift the response of the σ54‐dependent regulator XylR from natural m‐xylene towards xenobiotic 2,4‐dinitrotoluene

XylR is a σ⁵⁴-dependent transcriptional factor of Pseudomonas putida that activates the Pu promoter of the TOL plasmid upon binding its natural effector, m-xylene. The search for mutants of the signal-sensing module of XylR that respond to the xenobiotic compound 2,4-dinitrotoluene recurrently yields protein variants with a broad effector range. These mutants had amino acid changes not only in the effector recognition moiety (A module), but also in the inter-domain B linker of the protein. A random mutagenesis and selection/counterselection setup was adopted to optimize the 2,4-DNT reaction of XylRv17, one of the best 2,4-DNT responders and thus recreate how this regulator can adjust its specificity to novel effectors by individual changes on the evolving protein. Site-specific mutagenesis was then used to decipher the contribution of individual mutations in XylRv17 and in one of the mutants evolved from it (XylR28) to the 2,4-DNT response. This approach allowed us to capture a new XylR version with novel mutations that fixed the protein in an intermediate stage of the progress from an effector-promiscuous, pluri-potent protein type to a more specific form where the natural response to m-xylene was decreased and the non-native acquired response to 2,4-DNT was increased.

An individual-based approach to explain plasmid invasion in bacterial populations

We present an individual-based experimental framework to identify and estimate the main parameters governing bacterial conjugation at the individual cell scale. From this analysis, we have established that transient periods of unregulated plasmid transfer within newly formed transconjugant cells, together with contact mechanics arising from cellular growth and division, are the two main processes determining the emergent inability of the pWW0 TOL plasmid to fully invade spatially structured Pseudomonas putida populations. We have also shown that pWW0 conjugation occurs mainly at advanced stages of the growth cycle and that nongrowing cells, even when exposed to high nutrient concentrations, do not display conjugal activity. These results do not support previous hypotheses relating conjugation decay in the deeper cell layers of bacterial biofilms to nutrient depletion and low physiological activity. We observe, however, that transient periods of elevated plasmid transfer in newly formed transconjugant cells are offset by unfavorable cell-to-cell contact mechanics, which ultimately precludes the pWWO TOL plasmid from fully invading tightly packed multicellular P. putida populations such as microcolonies and biofilms.

Construction and Characterization of Escherichia coli Whole-Cell Biosensors for Toluene and Related Compounds

The XylR regulatory protein is a transcriptional activator from the TOL plasmid of Pseudomonas putida mt-2 that is involved in the toluene and benzene degradation pathway. Here we describe the construction and laboratory characterization of recombinant biosensors (pGLPX plasmids) based on XylR and its cognate promoter (Pu). In the pGLPX plasmid, the reporter luc gene is under the control of the Pu promoter. We evaluated the ability of two distinct nucleotide sequences to function as SD elements and improve sensitivity of bioreporting. We also evaluated the effect of introducing the T₂rrnβ terminator on the specificity of the construct. E. coli transformed with pGLPX plasmids were used to sense toluene and its derivatives. The pattern of induction was different for each derivative. In general, more luciferase activity was induced by toluene and benzene than by TNT and DNT at most tested concentrations. The bioluminescence response of the reporter strains to the nitrotoluenes was significantly stronger at lower concentrations (≥ 50 μmol) than at higher concentrations. Our results show that the SD sequence (taaggagg) is crucially important for biosensor sensitivity. The presence of the T₂rrnβ terminator in the bioreporter plasmid prevents nonspecific responses and also reduces biosensor sensitivity upon exposure to inducers. These data suggest that pGLPX strains can be used as whole-cell biosensors to detect toluene and related compounds. Further investigation will be required to optimize the application of pGLPX biosensors.

TOL plasmid carriage enhances biofilm formation and increases extracellular DNA content in Pseudomonas putida KT2440

Adherent growth of Pseudomonas putida KT2440 with and without the TOL plasmid (pWWO) at the solid-liquid and air-liquid interface was examined. We compared biofilm formation on glass in flow cells, and assayed pellicle (air-liquid interface biofilm) formation in stagnant liquid cultures by confocal laser scanning microscopy. The TOL-carrying strains formed pellicles and thick biofilms, whereas the same strains without the plasmid displayed little adherent growth. Microscopy using fluorescent nucleic acid-specific stains revealed differences in the production of extracellular polymeric substances: TOL carriage leads to more extracellular DNA (eDNA) in pellicles and biofilms. Pellicles were dissolved by DNase I treatment. Enhanced cell lysis due to plasmid carriage was ruled out as the mechanism for eDNA release. We report, for the first time, that carriage of a conjugative plasmid leads to increased biofilm formation by production of eDNA.

High stability and fast recovery of expression of the TOL plasmid-carried toluene catabolism genes of Pseudomonas putida mt-2 under conditions of oxygen limitation and oscillation.

Pseudomonas putida mt-2 harbors the TOL plasmid (pWWO), which contains the genes encoding the enzymes necessary to degrade toluene aerobically. The xyl genes are clustered in the upper operon and encode the enzymes of the upper pathway that degrade toluene to benzoate, while the genes encoding the enzymes of the lower pathway (meta-cleavage pathway) that are necessary for the conversion of benzoate to tricarboxylic acid cycle intermediates, are encoded in a separate operon. In this study, the effects of oxygen availability and oscillation on the expression of catabolic genes for enzymes involved in toluene degradation were studied by using P. putida mt-2 as model bacterium. Quantitative reverse transcription-PCR was used to detect and quantify the expression of the catabolic genes xylM (a key gene of the upper pathway) and xylE (a key gene of the lower pathway) in cultures of P. putida mt-2 that were grown with toluene as a carbon source. Toluene degradation was shown to have a direct dependency on oxygen concentration, where gene expression of xylM and xylE decreased due to oxygen depletion during degradation. Under oscillating oxygen concentrations, P. putida mt-2 induced or downregulated xylM and xylE genes according to the O₂ availability in the media. During anoxic periods, P. putida mt-2 decreased the expression of xylM and xylE genes, while the expression of both xylM and xylE genes was immediately increased after oxygen became available again in the medium. These results suggest that oxygen is not only necessary as a cosubstrate for enzyme activity during the degradation of toluene but also that oxygen modulates the expression of the catabolic genes encoded by the TOL plasmid.

The regulatory logic of m‐xylene biodegradation by Pseudomonas putida mt‐2 exposed by dynamic modelling of the principal node Ps/Pr of the TOL plasmid

The structure of the extant transcriptional control network of the TOL plasmid pWW0 born by Pseudomonas putida mt-2 for biodegradation of m-xylene is far more complex than one would consider necessary from a mere engineering point of view. In order to penetrate the underlying logic of such a network, which controls a major environmental cleanup bioprocess, we have developed a dynamic model of the key regulatory node formed by the Ps/Pr promoters of pWW0, where the clustering of control elements is maximal. The model layout was validated with batch cultures estimating parameter values and its predictive capability was confirmed with independent sets of experimental data. The model revealed how regulatory outputs originated in the divergent and overlapping Ps/Pr segment, which expresses the transcription factors XylS and XylR respectively, are computed into distinct instructions to the upper and lower catabolic xyl operons for either simultaneous or stepwise consumption of m-xylene and/or succinate. In this respect, the model reveals that the architecture of the Ps/Pr is poised to discriminate the abundance of alternative and competing C sources, in particular m-xylene versus succinate. The proposed framework provides a first systemic understanding of the causality and connectivity of the regulatory elements that shape this exemplary regulatory network, facilitating the use of model analysis towards genetic circuit optimization.

A new extant respirometric assay to estimate intrinsic growth parameters applied to study plasmid metabolic burden

Start-up phenomena in microbial biokinetic assays are not captured by the most commonly used growth-related equations. In this study we propose a new respirometric experimental design to estimate intrinsic growth parameters that allow us to avoid these limitations without data omission, separate mathematical treatment, or wake-up pulses prior to the analysis. Identifiability and sensitivity analysis were performed to confirm the robustness of the new approach for obtaining unique and accurate estimates of growth kinetic parameters. The new experimental design was applied to establish the metabolic burden caused by the carriage of a pWW0 TOL plasmid in the model organism Pseudomonas putida KT2440. The metabolic burden associated was manifested as a reduction in the yield and the specific growth rate of the host, with both plasmid maintenance and the over-expression of recombinant proteins from the plasmid contributing equally to the overall effect.