Tip-enhanced Raman Scattering Research Articles

Numerical investigations on the electromagnetic enhancement effect to tip-enhanced Raman scattering and fluorescence processes

In the present work, we theoretically study the electromagnetic (EM) enhancement of the Raman and fluorescence signals for a molecule placed in a nanocavity formed by a metallic tip and substrate that mimics a tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) setup using three-dimensional finite element method calculations. The influence of tip size and tip-molecule distance on the EM enhancements of the incident field as well as the radiative and non-radiative decay rates of the molecule are systematically investigated. Simulation results show that the maximum EM enhancement to the incident light as provided by the localized surface plasmon resonance in the nanocavity can reach ∼285 for the configuration considered in the present work. Meanwhile, it was found that, at the classical limit, decreasing the apex radius or the tip-molecule distance can both reduce the spatial distribution (as characterized by the full width at half maximum) of the Raman enhancement in a linear fashion. Moreover, simulation results show that the nonlocal dielectric response of the tip and the substrate plays a key role to the fluorescence quantum yield of the molecule. However, it was found that the strong EM excitation enhancement is the dominating factor for the tip enhanced fluorescence (TEF) effect and stronger fluorescence enhancement has been found when increasing the apex radius or reducing the tip-molecule distance with an incident wavelength of 532 nm. The best TERS and TEF enhancements were found to be ∼ and ∼, respectively, with the tip-molecule distance around 1 nm.

Taking the Plunge: Nanoscale Chemical Imaging of Functionalized Gold Triangles in H2O via TERS

We demonstrate fast (0.25 s/pixel) nanoscale chemical imaging in aqueous solution via tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS), with sub-15 nm spatial resolution. The substrate consists of 4-mercaptobe...

Nano-scale image rendering via surface plasmon-driven reaction controlled by tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy

Plasmon-driven selective oxidation reaction of p-aminothiophenol (PATP) to p,p′-dimercaptoazobenzene (DMAB) can be realized in a local electromagnetic field (hot spot) because of surface plasmon resonance (SPR). To a remarkable extent, the size and movement of the hot spot can be freely controlled, via tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) spectroscopy. In a particular TERS system, the hot spot can move by following the TERS tip, and the PATP molecules located in the trajectory of the TERS tip, but not in other areas, can be transformed into DMAB molecules. Through this feature, we can realize artificially drawn DMAB molecular graphics on a flat surface equably covered by PATP molecules at the micronano scale using TERS. We analyzed the range and effect of the instant hot spot according to the results of simulation using the finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) method for the TERS system and surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) mapping. The selectivity and controllability of catalysis in the TERS system provides a new technique for marking, with this work contributing to the field of nanotechnology by providing a new method to obtain nanoscale patterns.

Correlative force and tip-enhanced Raman microscopy

Tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) microscopy attracts increasing attention for visualization and characterization of strain distribution on crystalline samples at a nanoscale due to nano-sized fields localized at a metal tip. However, as the metal tip approaches close to a sample surface, a force acts between the tip and sample, which can induce unwanted perturbation on the local strain of the sample. Analysis and evaluation of intrinsic strains on samples with a high reliability demands a technique to correlate TERS spectra with the tip-sample force. Here, we present a TERS microscope based on a frequency-modulation atomic force microscope (FM-AFM) using a quartz tuning fork (QTF) as a force sensor. By continuously monitoring a shift in the resonance frequency of the QTF during TERS, the tip-sample force can be directly measured in both attractive and repulsive force regions, which is not possible by other AFMs. TERS spectra of single-walled carbon nanotubes (CNTs) were measured simultaneously while changing the tip-sample distance and hence the tip-sample force acting on the CNTs. We found that TERS occurs at the tip-sample distance where the repulsive force dominantly works and mostly decays out in the attractive force region.

Intensity Fluctuations in Single-Molecule Surface-Enhanced Raman Scattering.

Around 20 years ago, the first reports of single-molecule surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SM-SERS) caused a revolution in nanotechnology. Several researchers were quick to recognize the importance of a technique that can provide molecular vibrational fingerprinting at the SM level. Since then, a large amount of work has been devoted to the development of nanostructures capable of SM-SERS detection. A great effort has also been geared toward elucidating the different mechanisms that contribute to the effect. The understanding of the concept of plasmonic SERS hotspots, the role of chemical effects, and the dynamics of atomic and cluster rearrangements in nanometric domains has significantly advanced, driven by new computational and experimental methods used to study SM-SERS. In particular, SERS intensity fluctuations (SIFs) are now recognized as a hallmark of SM-SERS. Interpretation of SM-SERS data must take into consideration temporal and spatial variations as a natural consequence of the extreme localization inherent to surface plasmon resonances. Further analysis of variations in spectral signature, due to either molecular reorientation or photo (or thermal) processes, pointed to a new area that combines the power of SERS fingerprinting at the SM level to modern concepts of catalysis, such as hot-electrons-driven chemistry. This large body of work on the fundamental characteristics of the SM-SERS effect paved the way to the interpretation of other related phenomena, such as tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS). Despite all the fundamental progress, there are still very few examples of real applications of SM-SERS. In recent years, our research group has been studying SIFs, focused on different ways to use SM-SERS. The obvious application of SM-SERS is in analytical chemistry, particularly for quantification at ultralow concentrations (below 1 nM). However, quantification using SM-SERS faces a fundamental sampling problem: the analytes (adsorbed in very small amounts, i.e., low surface coverage) must find rare SERS hotspots (areas with intense electric field localization that yields SERS). This limitation leads to strong temporal and spatial variations in SERS intensities, which translates into very large error bars in an experimental calibration curve. We tackled this problem by introducing the concept of "digital SERS". This approach provided a roadmap for SERS quantification at ultralow concentrations and a potential pathway for a better understanding of the "reproducibility problem" associated with SERS. In this Account, we discuss not only the analytical applications but also other implementations of SM-SERS demonstrated by our group. These include the use of SM-SERS as a tool to probe colloidal aggregation, to evaluate the efficiency of SERS substrates, and to characterize the energy of localized resonances. SERS involves a series of random processes: hotspots are rare; surfaces/clusters constantly reconstruct; and molecules diffuse, adsorb, and desorb. All these pathways contribute to strong fluctuations in SERS intensities. Our work indicates that a statistical view of the effect can lead to interesting insights and the potential to fulfill the promise of this SM technique for real-world applications.

The role of a plasmonic substrate on the enhancement and spatial resolution of tip-enhanced Raman scattering.

Since the first report in the early 2000s, there have been several experimental configurations that have demonstrated enhancement and spatial resolution of tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS). The combination of a plasmonic substrate and a metallic tip is one suitable approach to achieve even higher enhancement and lateral resolution. In this contribution, we demonstrate TERS on a monolayer of MoS2 on an array of Au nanodisks. The Au nanodisks were prepared by electron beam writing. Thereafter, MoS2 was transferred onto the plasmonic substrate via the exfoliation technique. We witness an unprecedented enhancement and spatial resolution in the experiments. In the TERS image a ring-like shape is observed that matches the edges of the nanodisks. TERS enhancement at the edges is about 170 times stronger than at the center of the nanodisks. For a better understanding of the experimental results, finite element method (FEM) simulations were employed to simulate the TERS image of the MoS2/plasmonic heterostructure. Our calculations show a higher electric field concentration at the edges that exponentially decays to the center. Therefore, it reproduces the ring-like shape of the experimental image. Moreover, the calculations suggest a TERS enhancement of 135 at the edges compared to the center, which is in very good agreement with the experimental data. According to our calculations, the spatial resolution is also increased at the edges. For comparison, FEM simulations of a tip-flat metal substrate system (conventional gap-mode TERS) were carried out. The calculations confirmed a 110 times stronger enhancement at the edges of the nanodisks than that of conventional gap-mode TERS and explained the experimental maps. Our results provide not only a deeper understanding of the TERS mechanism of this heterostructure, but can also help in realizing highly efficient TERS experiments using similar systems.

Tip-Enhanced Raman Imaging of Single-Stranded DNA with Single Base Resolution.

Tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) is a promising optical and analytical technique for chemical imaging and sensing at single molecule resolution. In particular, TERS signals generated by a gap-mode configuration where a silver tip is coupled with a gold substrate can resolve a single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) molecule with a spatial resolution below 1 nm. To demonstrate the proof of subnanometer resolution, we show direct nucleic acid sequencing using TERS of a phage ssDNA (M13mp18). M13mp18 provides a known sequence and, through our deposition strategy, can be stretched (uncoiled) and attached to the substrate by its phosphate groups, while exposing its nucleobases to the tip. After deposition, we scan the silver tip along the ssDNA and collect TERS signals with a step of 0.5 nm, comparable to the bond length between two adjacent DNA bases. By demonstrating the real-time profiling of a ssDNA configuration and furthermore, with unique TERS signals of monomeric units of other biopolymers, we anticipate that this technique can be extended to the high-resolution imaging of various nanostructures as well as the direct sequencing of other important biopolymers including RNA, polysaccharides, and polypeptides.

Probing Adsorption Configurations of Small Molecules on Surfaces by Single-Molecule Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy.

Determining the adsorption configurations of organic molecules on surfaces, especially for relatively small molecules, is a key issue for understanding the microscopic physical and chemical processes in surface science. In this work, we have applied low-temperature ultrahigh-vacuum tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) technique to distinguish the configurations of small 4,4'-bipyridine (44BPY) molecules adsorbed on the Ag(111) surface. The observed Raman spectra exhibit notable differences in the spectral features which can be assigned to three different molecular orientations, each featuring a specific fingerprint pattern based on the TERS selection rule that determines the distribution of the relative intensities of different vibrational peaks. Furthermore, such a small molecule can in turn act as a local probe to provide information on the local electric field distribution at the tip apex. Our work showcases the capability of TERS technique for obtaining information on adsorption configurations of small molecules on surfaces down to the single-molecule level, which is of fundamental importance for many applications in the fields of molecular science and surface chemistry.

Facilitating Tip-Enhanced Raman Scattering on Dielectric Substrates via Electrical Cutting of Silver Nanowire Probes.

TERS is a powerful tool for nanoscale optical characterization of surfaces. However, even after 20 years of development, the parameters for optimal TERS tips are still up for debate. As a result, routine measurements on bulk or dielectric substrates remain exceptionally challenging. Herein we help to alleviate this by using electrical cutting to strategically modify silver nanowire TERS probes. Following cutting, the tips present a large, spherical apex and are often nanostructured with numerous nanoparticles, which we argue improve light collection and optical coupling. This doubles TERS signals on a highly enhancing, gap-mode substrate compared to our standard nanowire tips while maintaining a high reproducibility and resolution. More interestingly, on a dielectric substrate (graphene on SiO2) the tips give ∼7× higher signals than our standard tips. Further investigations point to the nonlocal nature of the enhancement using standard, smooth TERS probes without gap-mode, making such nanostructuring highly beneficial in these cases.

Probing Membrane Receptors with Enhanced Raman Imaging.

Our lab has shown that nanoparticles functionalized with short peptides can selectively bind to receptor proteins in vitro. Our results indicate that the Raman signals observed from purified receptors in surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) experiments match those observed with tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) experiments performed on membrane receptors in intact cell membranes. Analysis of the observed Raman signals suggest the signals arise from the amino-acids in the protein receptor responsible for binding and recognition of the ligand attached to the nanoparticle probe. Further experiments show the variance in the data correlates with affinity of the nanoparticle probe with a specific receptor. This result illustrates a new approach to studying membrane receptors.

Nanoscopic imaging of oxidized graphene monolayer using tip-enhanced Raman scattering

Tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) can be used for the structural and chemical characterization of materials with a nanoscale resolution, and offers numerous advantages compared to other forms of imaging. We use TERS to track the local structural features of a CVD-grown graphene monolayer. Ag nanoparticles were added to AFM probes using ion-beam sputtering in order to make them TERS-active. Such modification provides probes with large factors of enhancement and good reproducibility. TERS measurements on graphene show an emergence of a defect-induced D-Raman band and a strain-induced shoulder of the graphene’s G-band. Comparison of TERS results with micro-Raman for oxidized graphene suggests that local oxidation occurs with the introduction of sp3 defects, under TERS conditions.

Tip-Enhanced Raman Scattering Microscopy: A Step toward Nanoscale Control of Intrinsic Molecular Properties

Tip-enhanced Raman scattering microscopy, a family of scanning probe microscopy techniques, has been recognized as a powerful surface analytical technique with both single-molecule sensitivity and angstrom-scale spatial resolution. This review covers the current status of tip-enhanced Raman scattering microscopy in surface and material nanosciences, including a brief history, the basic principles, and applications for the nanoscale characterization of a variety of nanomaterials. The focus is on the recent trend of combining tip-enhanced Raman scattering microscopy with various external stimuli such as pressure, voltage, light, and temperature, which enables the local control of the molecular properties and functions and also enables chemical reactions to be induced on a nanometer scale.

Tip-Enhanced Raman Scattering from Nanopatterned Graphene and Graphene Oxide.

Tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) is particularly sensitive to analytes residing at plasmonic tip-sample nanojunctions, where the incident and scattered optical fields may be localized and optimally enhanced. However, the enhanced local electric fields in this so-called gap-mode TERS configuration are nominally orthogonal to the sample plane. As such, any given Raman active vibrational eigenstate needs to have projections (of its polarizability derivative tensor elements) along the sample normal to be detectable via TERS. The faint TERS signals observed from two prototypical systems, namely, pristine graphene and graphene oxide are a classical example of the aforementioned rather restrictive TERS selection rules in this context. In this study, we demonstrate that nanoindentation, herein achieved using pulsed-force lithography with a sharp single-crystal diamond atomic force microscope probe, may be used to locally enhance TERS signals from graphene and graphene oxide flakes on gold. Nanoindentation locally perturbs the otherwise flat graphene structure and introduces out-of-plane protrusions that generate enhanced TERS. Although our approach is nominally invasive, we illustrate that the introduced nanodefects are highly localized, as evidenced by TERS nanoscale chemical mapping. As such, the described protocol may be used to extend and generalize the applicability of TERS for the rapid identification of two-dimensional material systems on the nanoscale.

Tip-enhanced Raman scattering of DNA aptamers for Listeria monocytogenes

Optical detection and conformational mapping of aptamers are important for improving medical and biosensing technologies and for better understanding of biological processes at the molecular level. The authors investigate the vibrational signals of deoxyribonucleic acid aptamers specific to Listeria monocytogenes immobilized on gold substrates using tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) spectroscopy and nanoscale imaging. The authors compare topographic and nano-optical signals and investigate the fluctuations of the position-dependent TERS spectra. They perform spatial TERS mapping with 3 nm step size and discuss the limitation of the resulting spatial resolution under the ambient conditions. TERS mapping provides information about the chemical composition and conformation of aptamers and paves the way to future label-free biosensing.

Local structural changes in graphene oxide layers induced by silver nanoparticles.

Structural changes of graphene oxide (GO) in silver/graphene oxide (AGO) nanocomposites are investigated using tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS). Because of markedly high spatial resolution of the TERS technique, the measurements of molecular information at specific nano-scaled positions can be achieved by constructing line-profile TERS spectra straight from the center of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) on GO layers. The results show evidences that AgNPs cause shortening of C-C bonds beneath AgNPs, flattening of GO layers, and critical bending on GO layers. Additionally, a connection of carbon atoms via a C-C network subsequently expands structural changes with a distance of 200-250 nm from the center of AgNPs, even though this distance is larger than the size of AgNPs. The proposed model of GO structural changes unveils new understanding about changes in properties from GO to AGO nanocomposites, which will contribute to a development of advanced nanostructures/nanocomposites in the near future.

Nanospectroscopy Imaging Techniques: Using NSOM and TERS for Semiconductor Materials Imaging

In this article, we introduce the theory and instrumentation that is relevant to nanospectroscopy imaging techniques, including near-field scanning optical microscope (NSOM) and tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) imaging. We also demonstrate the NSOM and TERS imaging functions in emiconductor samples. Our findings support the view that NSOM and TERS imaging techniques can increase the space resolution and emphasize the surface information for the target surface layer. Thus, these techniques are applicable to the studies of materials with nanoscale patterns in the future.

Breakdown of Far-Field Raman Selection Rules by Light–Plasmon Coupling Demonstrated by Tip-Enhanced Raman Scattering

We present an experimental study on the near-field light-matter interaction by tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) with polarized light in three different materials: germanium-doped gallium nitride (GaN), graphene, and carbon nanotubes. We investigate the dependence of the TERS signal on the incoming light polarization and on the sample carrier concentration, as well as the Raman selection rules in the near-field. We explain the experimental data with a tentative quantum mechanical interpretation, which takes into account the role of plasmon polaritons, and the associated evanescent field. The driving force for the breakdown of the classical Raman selection rules in TERS is caused by photon tunneling through the perturbation of the evanescent field, with the consequent polariton annihilation. Predictions based on this quantum mechanical approach are in good agreement with the experimental data, which are shown to be independent of incoming light polarization, leading to new Raman selection rules for TERS.

Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectromicroscopy on the Angstrom Scale: Bare and CO-Terminated Ag Tips.

The tip is key to the successful execution of tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) measurements in the single molecule limit. We show that nanoscopically smooth silver tips, batch produced through field-directed sputter sharpening, reliably attain TERS with enhancement factors that reach 1013, as measured by the Raman spectra of single CO molecules attached to the tip apex. We validate the bare tips by demonstrating spectromicroscopy with submolecular spatial resolution and underscore that TERS is a near-field effect that does not obey simple selection rules. As a more gainful analytical approach, we introduce TERS-relayed molecular force microscopy using CO-terminated tips. By taking advantage of the large Stark tuning rate of the CO stretch, molecular structure and charges can be imaged with atomic resolution. As illustration, we image a single Ag atom adsorbed on Au(111) and show that the adatom carries +0.2e charge.

Visualizing Electric Fields at Au(111) Step Edges via Tip-Enhanced Raman Scattering.

Tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) can be used to image plasmon-enhanced local electric fields on the nanoscale. This is illustrated through ambient TERS measurements recorded using silver atomic force microscope tips coated with 4-mercaptobenzonitrile molecules and used to image step edges on an Au(111) surface. The observed two-dimensional TERS images uniquely map electric fields localized at Au(111) step edges following 671 nm excitation. We establish that our measurements are not only sensitive to spatial variations in the enhanced electric fields but also to their vector components. We also experimentally demonstrate that (i) few nanometer precision is attainable in TERS nanoscopy using corrugated tips with nominal radii on the order of 100-200 nm, and (ii) TERS signals do not necessarily exhibit the expected E4 dependence. Overall, we illustrate the concept of electric field imaging via TERS and establish the connections between our observations and conventional TERS chemical imaging measurements.

Probing Membrane Receptor-Ligand Specificity with Surface- and Tip- Enhanced Raman Scattering.

The specific interaction between a ligand and a protein is a key component in minimizing off-target effects in drug discovery. Investigating these interactions with membrane protein receptors can be quite challenging. In this report, we show how spectral variance observed in surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) and tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) can be correlated with ligand specificity in affinity-based assays. Variations in the enhanced Raman spectra of three peptide ligands (i.e., cyclic-RGDFC, cyclic-isoDGRFC, and CisoDGRC), which have different binding affinity to αvβ3 integrin, are reported from isolated proteins and from receptors in intact cancer cell membranes. The SERS signal from the purified proteins provides basis spectra to analyze the signals in cells. Differences in the spectral variance within the SERS and TERS data for each ligand indicate larger variance for nonspecific ligand–receptor interactions. The SERS and TERS results are correlated with single particle tracking experiments of the ligand-functionalized nanoparticles with purified receptors on glass surfaces and living cells. These results demonstrate the ability to elucidate protein–ligand recognition using the observed vibrational spectra and provide perspective on binding specificity for small-molecule ligands in intact cell membranes, demonstrating a new approach for investigating drug specificity.