Deletion Of Thymocytes Research Articles

Dysregulation of Thymic Clonal Deletion and the Escape of Autoreactive T Cells

Events ongoing in the thymus are critical for deleting developing thymocytes specific for tissue antigens, and establishing self-tolerance within the T cell compartment. Aberrant thymic negative selection, however, is believed to generate a repertoire with increased self-reactivity, which in turn can contribute to the development of T cell-mediated autoimmunity. In this review, mechanisms that regulate the efficacy of negative selection and influence the deletion of autoreactive thymocytes will be discussed.

Thymocyte-Specific Truncation of the Deubiquitinating Domain of CYLD Impairs Positive Selection in a NF-κB Essential Modulator-Dependent Manner

The cylindromatosis tumor suppressor gene (Cyld) encodes a deubiquitinating enzyme (CYLD) with immunoregulatory function. In this study, we evaluated the role of Cyld in T cell ontogeny by generating a mouse (Cyld(Delta9)) with a thymocyte-restricted Cyld mutation that causes a C-terminal truncation of the protein and reciprocates catalytically inactive human mutations. Mutant mice had dramatically reduced single positive thymocytes and a substantial loss of peripheral T cells. The analyses of polyclonal and TCR-restricted thymocyte populations possessing the mutation revealed a significant block in positive selection and an increased occurrence of apoptosis at the double-positive stage. Interestingly, in the context of MHC class I and II restricted TCR transgenes, lack of functional CYLD caused massive deletion of thymocytes that would have been positively selected, which is consistent with an impairment of positive selection. Biochemical analysis revealed that Cyld(Delta9) thymocytes exhibit abnormally elevated basal activity of NF-kappaB and JNK. Most importantly, inactivation of NF-kappaB essential modulator fully restored the NF-kappaB activity of Cyld(Delta9) thymocytes to physiologic levels and rescued their developmental and survival defect. This study identifies a fundamental role for functional CYLD in establishing the proper threshold of activation for thymocyte selection by a mechanism dependent on NF-kappaB essential modulator.

The fusion kinase ITK-SYK mimics a T cell receptor signal and drives oncogenesis in conditional mouse models of peripheral T cell lymphoma

Peripheral T cell lymphomas (PTCLs) are highly aggressive malignancies with poor prognosis. Their molecular pathogenesis is not well understood and small animal models for the disease are lacking. Recently, the chromosomal translocation t(5;9)(q33;q22) generating the interleukin-2 (IL-2)–inducible T cell kinase (ITK)–spleen tyrosine kinase (SYK) fusion tyrosine kinase was identified as a recurrent event in PTCL. We show that ITK-SYK associates constitutively with lipid rafts in T cells and triggers antigen-independent phosphorylation of T cell receptor (TCR)–proximal proteins. These events lead to activation of downstream pathways and acute cellular outcomes that correspond to regular TCR ligation, including up-regulation of CD69 or production of IL-2 in vitro or deletion of thymocytes and activation of peripheral T cells in vivo. Ultimately, conditional expression of patient-derived ITK-SYK in mice induces highly malignant PTCLs with 100% penetrance that resemble the human disease. Our work demonstrates that constitutively enforced antigen receptor signaling can, in principle, act as a powerful oncogenic driver. Moreover, we establish a robust clinically relevant and genetically tractable model of human PTCL.

Dendritic cell expression of CD24 inhibits autoantigen-mediated deletion of T lymphocytes in the thymus (36.30)

Abstract Despite negative selection, significant numbers of autoreactive T cells can be easily detected and expanded even in normal individuals. While lack of self antigen expression has been largely attributed as a key factor, we have reported that CD24, a GPI-anchored glycoprotein, regulates thymic deletion of autoreactive T lymphocytes. CD24-deficient 2D2 TCR transgenic mice (2D2+CD24-/-), whose TCR recognize myelin antigen MOG, failed to generate functional 2D2 T cells. Here we further show that elimination of MOG antigen expression in 2D2+CD24-/- mice (through creation of 2D2+CD24-/-MOG-/- mice), completely restored thymic cellularity and function of 2D2 T cells. Restoration of CD24 expression on dendritic cells, but not on thymocytes also restored 2D2 T cell generation in 2D2+CD24-/- mice. Taken together, we propose that CD24 expression on dendritic cells inhibits autoantigen-mediated deletion of autoreactive thymocytes.

Peptide-Specific, TCR-α–Driven, Coreceptor-Independent Negative Selection in TCR α-Chain Transgenic Mice

As thymocytes differentiate, Ag sensitivity declines, with immature CD4-CD8- double-negative (DN) cells being most susceptible to TCR signaling events. We show that expression of alphabetaTCR from the DN3 stage lowers the threshold for activation, allowing recognition of MHC peptides independently of the TCR beta-chain and without either T cell coreceptor. The MHC class I-restricted C6 TCR recognizes the Y-chromosome-derived Ag HYK(k)Smcy. Positive selection in C6 alphabetaTCR females is skewed to the CD8 compartment, whereas transgenic male mice exhibit early clonal deletion of thymocytes. We investigated the effect of the HYK(k)Smcy complex on developing thymocytes expressing the C6 TCR alpha-chain on a TCR-alpha(-/-) background. On the original selecting haplotype, the skew to the CD8 lineage is preserved. This is MHC dependent, as the normal bias to the CD4 subset is seen on an H2b background. In male H2k C6 alpha-only mice, the presence of the HYK(k)Smcy complex leads to a substantial deletion of thymocytes from the DN subset. This phenotype is replicated in H2k C6 alpha-only female mice expressing an Smcy transgene. Deletion is not dependent on the beta variable segment of the C6 TCR or on a restricted TCR-beta repertoire. In contrast, binding of HYK(k)Smcy and Ag-specific activation of mature CD8+ T cells is strictly dependent on the original C6 beta-chain. These data demonstrate that, in comparison with mature T cells, alphabetaTCR+ immature thymocytes can recognize and transduce signals in response to specific MHC-peptide complexes with relaxed binding requirements.

Thymocyte deletion can bias Treg formation toward low‐abundance self‐peptide

Autoreactive CD4+ T cells can undergo deletion and/or become CD25+Foxp3+ Treg as they develop intrathymically, but how these alternative developmental fates are specified based on interactions with self-peptide(s) is not understood. We show here that thymocytes expressing an autoreactive TCR can be subjected to varying degrees of deletion that correlate with the amount of self-peptide. Strikingly, among thymocytes that evade deletion, similar proportions acquire Foxp3 expression. These findings provide evidence that Foxp3+ Treg can develop among members of a cohort of autoreactive thymocytes that have evaded deletion by a self-peptide, and that deletion and Treg formation can act together to bias the Treg repertoire toward low-abundance self-peptide(s).

Cutting edge: Extracellular signal-related kinase is not required for negative selection of developing T cells.

Signals initiated through the TCR during development can result in either survival and differentiation or cell death. High affinity signals that induce death elicit a robust yet transient activation of signaling pathways, including Erk, whereas low affinity ligands, which promote survival, generate a gradual and weaker activation of the same pathways. It was recently demonstrated that Erk localizes to distinct cellular locations in response to high and low affinity ligands. Although a requirement for Erk in positive selection is well established, its role in negative selection is controversial and, thus, the importance of Erk relocalization during development is not understood. In this study, we examined the role of Erk in negative selection using mice that are genetically deficient in both Erk1 and Erk2 in T cells. Results from three different models reveal that thymocyte deletion remains intact in the absence of Erk.

β-Catenin/Tcf Determines the Outcome of Thymic Selection in Response to αβTCR Signaling

Thymic maturation of T cells depends on the intracellular interpretation of alphabetaTCR signals by processes that are poorly understood. In this study, we report that beta-catenin/Tcf signaling was activated in double-positive thymocytes in response to alphabetaTCR engagement and impacted thymocyte selection. TCR engagement combined with activation of beta-catenin signaled thymocyte deletion, whereas Tcf-1 deficiency rescued from negative selection. Survival/apoptotis mediators including Bim, Bcl-2, and Bcl-x(L) were alternatively influenced by stabilization of beta-catenin or ablation of Tcf-1, and Bim-mediated beta-catenin induced thymocyte deletion. TCR activation in double-positive cells with stabilized beta-catenin triggered signaling associated with negative selection, including sustained overactivation of Lat and Jnk and a transient activation of Erk. These observations are consistent with beta-catenin/Tcf signaling acting as a switch that determines the outcome of thymic selection downstream the alphabetaTCR cascade.

Central tolerance: Essential for preventing autoimmune disease?

Recessive central tolerance of developing T cells is caused by antigen-induced deletion of immature cortical double positive and medullary single positive thymocytes in the absence of TCR editing. There are few examples where it can be convincingly shown that recessive tolerance plays an essential role in preventing autoimmune disease. This is in part due to the fact that genetic factors predisposing to autoimmune disease could conceivably contribute to both recessive tolerances in the thymus and antigen-induced generation of Treg. Of considerable interest is the notion that several epitopes recognized by disease-causing T-cell clones exhibit poor class II MHC binding consistent with the notion that the limited availability of such epitopes in the thymus could lead to failing recessive tolerance, while more abundant quantities in peripheral lymphoid tissues could result in activation of T cells that have escaped central tolerance.

The Gli3 Transcription Factor Expressed in the Thymus Stroma Controls Thymocyte Negative Selection Via Hedgehog-Dependent and -Independent Mechanisms

The Hedgehog (Hh) responsive transcription factor Gli3 is required for efficient thymocyte development in the fetus. In this study we show that Gli3, not detected in adult thymocytes, is expressed in the murine fetal and adult thymus stroma. PCR array analysis revealed Cxcl9, Rbp1, and Nos2 as novel target genes of Gli3. We show that Gli3 positively regulates the expression of these genes, most likely by suppressing an intermediate repressor. Deletion of autoreactive thymocytes depends on their interactions with the thymus stroma. Repression of the proapoptotic gene Nos2 in Gli3 mutants coincides with reduced apoptosis of double positive thymocytes undergoing negative selection in vitro and in vivo, and the production of autoreactive thymocytes. Taken together these data indicate that Gli3 controls thymocyte apoptosis and negative selection possibly via the regulation of Nos2. Defective Gli3 expression in the thymus stroma also resulted in decreased CD5 expression on mature thymocytes and inappropriate production of MHC class I-selected CD4(+) cells, both consistent with reduced TCR signal strength. Overall our data indicate that Gli3 expressed in the thymus stroma regulates negative selection and TCR signal strength via Hh-dependent and -independent mechanisms, with implications for autoimmunity.

Control of Thymic T Cell Maturation, Deletion and Egress by the RNA-Binding Protein HuR

HuR emerged as a posttranscriptional regulator of mRNAs involved in cellular control, stress, and immunity but its role in governing such responses remains elusive. In this study, we assessed HuR's role in the staged progression of thymic T cell differentiation by means of its genetic ablation. Mice with an early deletion of HuR in thymocytes possess enlarged thymi but display a substantial loss of peripheral T cells. We show that this discordant phenotype related to specific defects in thymic cellular processes, which demonstrated HuR's involvement in: 1) intrinsic checkpoint signals suppressing the cell cycle of immature thymocyte progenitors, 2) TCR and antigenic signals promoting the activation and positive selection of mature thymocytes, 3) antigenic and death-receptor signals promoting thymocyte deletion, and 4) chemokine signals driving the egress of postselection thymocytes to the periphery. The cellular consequences of HuR's dysfunction were underlined by the aberrant expression of selective cell cycle regulators, TCR, and death-receptor signaling components. Our studies reveal the signal-dependent context of HuR's cellular activities in thymocytes and its importance in the generation of a physiological T cell pool.

The threshold for negative selection and regulatory T-cell development is defined by peptide-MHC density (78.41)

Abstract High avidity TCR/pMHC binding results in the deletion of thymocytes by negative selection. However, for natural regulatory T-cell (TR) precursors, high avidity TCR/pMHC interaction leads to differentiation and escape from negative selection. The process of diverting thymocytes into alternative pathways of development is incompletely understood. In this study, we consider the role that pMHC density may have in this process. Using two TCR transgenic mice against differentially presented Hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) epitopes, we evaluated negative selection and Foxp3+CD4SP T cell development in response to graded amounts of intravenously injected HEL. In both mice, thymocyte sensitivity to negative selection and TR induction depended on antigen dose and reflected the level of presentation of their cognate epitopes. The absolute increase in TR occurred at doses of HEL lower than the dose required for complete negative selection of conventional CD4SP. TR induction was inefficient in the absence of TCRα gene rearrangement and was not a result of TR subset expansion. Our data shows that pMHC density provides an important signal in the routing of TR precursors away from negative selection towards development as regulatory T-cells.

Aire

Mutations in the transcriptional regulator, Aire, cause APECED, a polyglandular autoimmune disease with monogenic transmission. Animal models of APECED have revealed that Aire plays an important role in T cell tolerance induction in the thymus, mainly by promoting ectopic expression of a large repertoire of transcripts encoding proteins normally restricted to differentiated organs residing in the periphery. The absence of Aire results in impaired clonal deletion of self-reactive thymocytes, which escape into the periphery and attack a variety of organs. In addition, Aire is a proapoptotic factor, expressed at the final maturation stage of thymic medullary epithelial cells, a function that may promote cross-presentation of the antigens encoded by Aire-induced transcripts in these cells. Transcriptional regulation by Aire is unusual in being very broad, context-dependent, probabilistic, and noisy. Structure/function analyses and identification of its interaction partners suggest that Aire may impact transcription at several levels, including nucleosome displacement during elongation and transcript splicing or other aspects of maturation.

Complement-dependent T-cell lymphopenia caused by thymocyte deletion of the membrane complement regulator Crry

AbstractAlthough complement lysis is frequently used for the purification of lymphocyte subpopulations in vitro, how lymphocytes escape complement attack in vivo has not been clearly delineated. Here, we show that conditional gene targeting of a murine membrane complement regulator Crry on thymocytes led to complement-dependent peripheral T-cell lymphopenia. Notably, despite evidence of hypersensitivity to complement attack, Crry-deficient T cells escaped complement injury and developed normally in the thymus, because of low intrathymic complement activity. Crry-deficient T cells were eliminated in the periphery by a C3- and macrophage-mediated but C5-independent mechanism. Thus, Crry is essential for mature T-cell survival in the periphery but not for lymphogenesis in the thymus. The observation that the thymus is a complement-privileged site may have implications for complement-based antitumor therapies.

Gadd45β-induced prolonged activation of p38 kinase defines a novel pathway mediating negative selection of thymocytes

The clonal deletion of thymocytes by negative selection is an important process to ensure immunologic tolerance, even though the underlying molecular mechanisms are poorly understood. Here, we show that Gadd45β, a regulator of mitogen-activated protein kinases, is critically involved in triggering negative selection. Gadd45β expression was inducible in different models of negative selection. Strikingly, only TCR-ligating peptides resulting in negative selection, but not positively selecting ligands or dexamethasone, a TCR-independent apoptosis agonist, induced Gadd45β expression. Expression of Gadd45β maintained a sustained activation of p38 kinase and thereby promoted TCR-mediated apoptosis. In contrast, inhibition of Gadd45β expression or p38 activity impaired cell death. Moreover, thymocytes from Gadd45β-deficient mice revealed only transient p38 activation, reduced caspase activation and cell death. Thus, we provide evidence that Gadd45β and a resulting persistent activation of p38 constitute a novel apoptotic pathway involved in negative selection.

Abnormal Regulatory and Effector T Cell Function Predispose to Autoimmunity following Xenogeneic Thymic Transplantation

Porcine thymus grafts support robust murine and human thymopoiesis, generating a diverse T cell repertoire that is deleted of donor and host-reactive cells, achieving specific xenograft tolerance. Positive selection is mediated exclusively by the xenogeneic thymic MHC. Although thymectomized, T cell-depleted normal mice usually remain healthy following xenogeneic thymic transplantation, thymus-grafted congenitally athymic mice frequently develop multiorgan autoimmunity. We investigated the etiology of this syndrome by adoptively transferring lymphocyte populations from fetal pig thymus-grafted BALB/c nude mice to secondary BALB/c nude recipients. Fetal pig thymus-grafted nude mice generated normal numbers of CD25(+)Foxp3(+)CD4 T cells, but these cells lacked the capacity to block autoimmunity. Moreover, thymocytes and peripheral CD4(+)CD25(-) cells from fetal pig thymus-grafted nude mice, but not those from normal mice, induced autoimmunity in nude recipients. Injection of thymic epithelial cells from normal BALB/c mice into fetal pig thymus grafts reduced autoimmunity and enhanced regulatory function of splenocytes. Our data implicate abnormalities in postthymic maturation, expansion, and/or survival of T cells positively selected by a xenogeneic MHC, as well as incomplete intrathymic deletion of thymocytes recognizing host tissue-specific Ags, in autoimmune pathogenesis. Regulatory cell function is enhanced and negative selection of host-specific thymocytes may potentially also be improved by coimplantation of recipient thymic epithelial cells in the thymus xenograft.

Functional Analysis of FOXP3

Tolerance to self antigens is established in two ways: first in the thymus through the deletion of thymocytes expressing self-reactive T cell receptors; and second, in the periphery through multiple mechanisms involving deletion, anergy, and suppression. Dominant tolerance to self antigens in the periphery is primarily the function of the CD4(+)CD25(+)FOXP3(+) subset of T cells, which have the capability of suppressing autoreactive T cells that have escaped deletion during thymic selection. The essential role of the transcription factor FOXP3 in the development and function of these cells has been well documented. However, the underlying mechanisms by which FOXP3 controls this process are less well understood. This review will focus on the role of FOXP3 in regulating CD4 T cell function in both humans and mice, with an emphasis on recent work in human systems.

Clonal deletion of thymocytes can occur in the cortex with no involvement of the medulla

The thymic medulla is generally held to be a specialized environment for negative selection. However, many self-reactive thymocytes first encounter ubiquitous self-antigens in the cortex. Cortical epithelial cells are vital for positive selection, but whether such cells can also promote negative selection is controversial. We used the HYcd4 model, where T cell receptor for antigen (TCR) expression is appropriately timed and a ubiquitous self-antigen drives clonal deletion in male mice. We demonstrated unambiguously that this deletion event occurs in the thymic cortex. However, the kinetics in vivo indicated that apoptosis was activated asynchronously relative to TCR activation. We found that radioresistant antigen-presenting cells and, specifically, cortical epithelial cells do not efficiently induce apoptosis, although they do cause TCR activation. Rather, thymocytes undergoing clonal deletion were preferentially associated with rare CD11c+ cortical dendritic cells, and elimination of such cells impaired deletion.

The variable immunological self: Genetic variation and nongenetic noise in Aire-regulated transcription

The Aire transcription factor plays an important role in immunological self-tolerance by mediating the ectopic expression of peripheral self-antigens by thymic medullary epithelial cells (MECs), and the deletion of thymocytes that recognize them. In Aire-deficient humans or mice, central tolerance is incomplete and multiorgan autoimmune disease results. We examined the variability of Aire's effects on ectopic transcription among individual mice of three different inbred strains. Aire's function was, overall, quite similar in the three backgrounds, although generally stronger in C57BL/6 than in BALB/c or NOD mice, and a minority of Aire-regulated genes did show clear differences. Gene expression profiling of wild-type MECs from single mice, or from the two thymic lobes of the same mouse, revealed significantly greater variability in Aire-controlled ectopic gene expression than in Aire-independent transcripts. This "noisy" ectopic expression did not result from parental or early developmental imprinting, but from programming occurring after the formation of the thymic anlage, resulting from epigenetic effects or from the stochastic nature of Aire activity. Together, genetic and nongenetic variability in ectopic expression of peripheral antigens in the thymus make for differences in the portion of self determinants presented for tolerance induction. This variable self may be beneficial in preventing uniform holes in the T-cell repertoire in individuals of a species, but at the cost of variable susceptibility to autoimmunity.

TSCOT + Thymic Epithelial Cell-Mediated Sensitive CD4 Tolerance by Direct Presentation

Although much effort has been directed at dissecting the mechanisms of central tolerance, the role of thymic stromal cells remains elusive. In order to further characterize this event, we developed a mouse model restricting LacZ to thymic stromal cotransporter (TSCOT)-expressing thymic stromal cells (TDLacZ). The thymus of this mouse contains approximately 4,300 TSCOT+ cells, each expressing several thousand molecules of the LacZ antigen. TSCOT+ cells express the cortical marker CDR1, CD40, CD80, CD54, and major histocompatibility complex class II (MHCII). When examining endogenous responses directed against LacZ, we observed significant tolerance. This was evidenced in a diverse T cell repertoire as measured by both a CD4 T cell proliferation assay and an antigen-specific antibody isotype analysis. This tolerance process was at least partially independent of Autoimmune Regulatory Element gene expression. When TDLacZ mice were crossed to a novel CD4 T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic reactive against LacZ (BgII), there was a complete deletion of double-positive thymocytes. Fetal thymic reaggregate culture of CD45- and UEA-depleted thymic stromal cells from TDLacZ and sorted TCR-bearing thymocytes excluded the possibility of cross presentation by thymic dendritic cells and medullary epithelial cells for the deletion. Overall, these results demonstrate that the introduction of a neoantigen into TSCOT-expressing cells can efficiently establish complete tolerance and suggest a possible application for the deletion of antigen-specific T cells by antigen introduction into TSCOT+ cells.