Threshold Of Toxicological Concern Concept Research Articles

Migration of oligomers from Tritan™ copolyester: application of hydrolysis for overall oligomer determination

Tritan™ (a kind of glycol-modified polycyclohexylene dimethylene terephthalate) is a novel copolyester mainly in use for the production of sports bottles and food storage containers. Oligomers in three food-grade Tritan™ samples were identified after dissolution-precipitation by high performance liquid chromatography with diode array detection and mass spectrometry and quantified after alkaline hydrolysis to the monomers. The obtained overall oligomer content <1000 Da determined by hydrolysis ranged from 7.2 to 10.6 mg/g material. Three consecutive migration experiments were performed according to the Commission Regulation (EU) No 10/2011. Oligomer migration values decreased from first to third migration during all simulations. Less than 25 µg/kg (third migrate) were detected in bottle migrates when tested under room temperature storage conditions (40 °C, 24 h) with simulants 3% acetic acid, 20 and 50% ethanol and during hot-fill testing (70 °C, 2 h) with simulants 3% acetic acid and 20% ethanol, respectively, while 170 µg/kg were determined in 50% ethanol after migration at 70 °C for 2 h. Food storage containers that were labelled as microwave-suitable by the supplier were tested according to the Joint Research Centre recommendations for microwave dishware. A strong deformation of the containers as well as a loss of transparency were observed during the tests (100 °C, 2 h with 10% ethanol and 3% acetic acid in an autoclave, 121 °C, 30 min with sunflower oil), questioning the suitability of the material for microwave applications. Maximum oligomer migration was 379 µg/kg during the third migration (sunflower oil at 121 °C for 30 min). Based on the migration data and an in silico oligomer evaluation according to the threshold of toxicological concern concept, no exceedances of daily thresholds for oligomers are expected from a proper use of Tritan™ drinking bottles, even with hot drinks.

Oligomers in polybutylene terephthalate for food contact—strategies on identification, quantification, and risk assessment

Oligomers are a significant group of migrating substances from food contact materials made of polyesters like polybutylene terephthalate (PBT). Twenty-three cyclic and linear oligomers with different end groups including olefin-terminated oligomers, which are associated with thermal stress of the material, were tentatively identified in PBT extracts by high-performance liquid chromatography with mass spectrometry and diode array detection. Quantification approaches based on chromophore concentration, relative response factors, and overall oligomer determination after hydrolysis to the monomer terephthalic acid were employed. An exhaustive extraction of thirteen PBT samples yielded an overall oligomer content of 1.87–6.10 mg/g material (sum of individual oligomers < 1,000 Da) with a predominant content of cyclic over linear oligomers. Migration experiments were performed according to Regulation (EU) No. 10/2011 using the official food simulants as well as cows’ milk. A total of 218 µg cyclic oligomers/L milk were detected in the third migrate relevant for risk assessment of repeated-use articles under hot-fill conditions (70 °C, 2 h). The official food simulant for milk, 50% ethanol, was found to overestimate the actual migration into milk by a factor of four. Frying conditions using sunflower oil as the food simulant (200 °C, 10 min) resulted in a migration of 7.5 mg cyclic oligomers/kg oil. The exposure to migrating oligomers is critical in some scenarios when evaluated by the threshold of toxicological concern concept; however, the toxicological evaluation poses a challenge due to the possible hydrolysis of cyclic oligomers in the human gastrointestinal tract. Our experiments display the need for a toxicological evaluation of PBT oligomers because the migration of cyclic oligomers is expected to exceed the current in silico–based thresholds under foreseeable conditions of use.

Prioritization of chemicals in food for risk assessment by integrating exposure estimates and new approach methodologies: A next generation risk assessment case study.

Next generation risk assessment is defined as a knowledge-driven system that allows for cost-efficient assessment of human health risk related to chemical exposure, without animal experimentation. One of the key features of next generation risk assessment is to facilitate prioritization of chemical substances that need a more extensive toxicological evaluation, in order to address the need to assess an increasing number of substances. In this case study focusing on chemicals in food, we explored how exposure data combined with the Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) concept could be used to prioritize chemicals, both for existing substances and new substances entering the market. Using a database of existing chemicals relevant for dietary exposure we calculated exposure estimates, followed by application of the TTC concept to identify substances of higher concern. Subsequently, a selected set of these priority substances was screened for toxicological potential using high-throughput screening (HTS) approaches. Remarkably, this approach resulted in alerts for a selection of substances that are already on the market and represent relevant exposure in consumers. Taken together, the case study provides proof-of-principle for the approach taken to identify substances of concern, and this approach can therefore be considered a supportive element to a next generation risk assessment strategy.

Threshold of Toxicological Concern: Extending the chemical space by inclusion of a highly curated dataset for organosilicon compounds

The Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) for non-genotoxic substances, a risk assessment tool to establish safe exposure levels for chemicals with insufficient toxicological data, is based on the 5th percentile of cumulated distributions of Point of Departures in a high amount of repeat-dose, developmental and reproductive toxicity studies, grouped by Cramer Classes. The lack of organosilicon compounds in this dataset has resulted in regulatory concerns over the applicability of the TTC concept for this chemistry. We collected publicly available, scientifically robust oral repeat-dose and DART studies for 71 organosilicon substances for inclusion in the existing TTC dataset, using criteria for evaluation of studies and derivation of points of departure analogous to the Munro and COSMOS TTC publications. The resulting 5th percentile of this dataset was 13-fold higher than the 5th percentile for Cramer Class III compounds reported by Munro (which is the default for silicon-containing substances). Both the existing TTC for Cramer Class III compounds from Munro (1.5 μg/kg bw/day) and the COSMOS TTC (2.3 μg/kg bw/day), recommended by the SCCS for cosmetics-related substances, provide a conservative and sufficiently protective approach for this class of chemistry.

Exploring the utility of the Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) as a screening approach for complex substances

The Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) has been applied to assess chemical safety for use, particularly in the food safety area. Although the TTC was developed for application to an individual chemical structure, more recently this concept has been suggested for the assessment of combined exposures to multiple chemicals. This study evaluated the potential for applying the TTC to a specific type of co-exposure, that of a complex substance of variable composition which contains multiple constituents, following the World Health Organization/International Programme on Chemical Safety framework for risk assessment of combined exposure to multiple chemicals. The results indicated that the TTC threshold was lower (i.e., more conservative) than regulatory thresholds derived for the same substance or even its most toxic constituent, providing assurance that the TTC could meet the requirements for a conservative screening process. This case study indicates that the TTC concept can be a useful tool to screen for potential risks from complex substances, with the consideration of additional aspects such as variability in chemical constituents and their relative proportions within the substance.

Threshold of Toxicological Concern-An Update for Non-Genotoxic Carcinogens.

The Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) concept can be applied to organic compounds with the known chemical structure to derive a threshold for exposure, below which a toxic effect on human health by the compound is not expected. The TTC concept distinguishes between carcinogens that may act as genotoxic and non-genotoxic compounds. A positive prediction of a genotoxic mode of action, either by structural alerts or experimental data, leads to the application of the threshold value for genotoxic compounds. Non-genotoxic substances are assigned to the TTC value of their respective Cramer class, even though it is recognized that they could test positive in a rodent cancer bioassay. This study investigated the applicability of the Cramer classes specifically to provide adequate protection for non-genotoxic carcinogens. For this purpose, benchmark dose levels based on tumor incidence were compared with no observed effect levels (NOELs) derived from non-, pre- or neoplastic lesions. One key aspect was the categorization of compounds as non-genotoxic carcinogens. The recently finished CEFIC LRI project B18 classified the carcinogens of the Carcinogenicity Potency DataBase (CPDB) as either non-genotoxic or genotoxic compounds based on experimental or in silico data. A detailed consistency check resulted in a dataset of 137 non-genotoxic organic compounds. For these 137 compounds, NOEL values were derived from high quality animal studies with oral exposure and chronic duration using well-known repositories, such as RepDose, ToxRef, and COSMOS DB. Further, an effective tumor dose (ETD10) was calculated and compared with the lower confidence limit on benchmark dose levels (BMDL10) derived by model averaging. Comparative analysis of NOEL/EDT10/BMDL10 values showed that potentially bioaccumulative compounds in humans, as well as steroids, which both belong to the exclusion categories, occur predominantly in the region of the fifth percentiles of the distributions. Excluding these 25 compounds resulted in significantly higher but comparable fifth percentile chronic NOEL and BMDL10 values, while the fifth percentile EDT10 value was slightly higher but not statistically significant. The comparison of the obtained distributions of NOELs with the existing Cramer classes and their derived TTC values supports the application of Cramer class thresholds to all non-genotoxic compounds, such as non-genotoxic carcinogens.

The Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) is a pragmatic tool for the safety assessment: Case studies of cosmetic ingredients with low consumer exposure

The Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) is an internationally accepted pragmatic and conservative tool for the safety assessment of substances, which is used in a wide range of regulatory contexts. The TTC approach produces human exposure threshold values (TTC values) originally derived by Munro from oral toxicity data on cancer and non-cancer toxicity endpoints. This database has been recently substantially enlarged by the COSMOS database, an enhanced oral non-cancer TTC dataset on a larger chemical domain, thereby resulting in a new, transparent and public TTC database also including 552 cosmetics-related chemicals. The 5th percentile point of departure value for each Cramer Class was determined, from which human exposure TTC values have been derived. The combined COSMOS/Munro dataset provided TTC values of 46, 6.2 and 2.3 μg/kg bw/day for Cramer Classes I, II or III, respectively. In order to demonstrate the diverse scope and successful application of the TTC concept to cosmetic ingredients including hair dyes, fragrances and plant-derived ingredients, Cosmetics Europe has prepared several case studies. Overall, the TTC concept is not only useful to replace animal testing but can also successfully be applied to the safety evaluation of cosmetic ingredients in the marketed formulas with low human exposure.

Establishment of a Threshold of Toxicological Concern Concept for Skin Sensitization by in Vitro/in Silico Approaches

Establishment of a Threshold of Toxicological Concern Concept for Skin Sensitization by <i>in Vitro/in Silico</i> Approaches

Characterisation, release and migration of phenolic compounds from resoles used in polyester-phenol coatings intended for food contact materials

ABSTRACT Resoles are multifarious pre-polymeric resins produced by the condensation of basic chemicals phenols, formaldehyde and optionally aliphatic alcohols like butanol. They are widely used as cross-linkers to form resistant internal coatings on metal surfaces of cans, containers or closures. Although the application of resoles is common in food contact, usually little is known about their exact composition, the toxicological hazards of their individual constituents and the migration of phenolic compounds, e.g., of the potentially endocrine-disrupting chemical bisphenol F. Our study fills major gaps of knowledge in risk assessment, using the example of a two-layer polyester-phenol coating system, which is based on three different resoles and is commercially used for closures of infant food glass jars. Various analytical approaches, namely size-exclusion chromatography, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry, fluorescence and diode array detection as well as gas chromatography-mass spectrometry were evaluated to quantitatively characterise resoles. Additionally, derivatisation with dansyl chloride as well as Folin–Ciocalteu colorimetric assay was adapted first times to determine the total phenol content from technical resoles. Individual mono- and bisphenols were determined in resoles up to about 120 mg/g, while the concentration of bisphenol F isomers was below 10 mg/g. Migration from the coating system was determined after sterilisation (121°C, 1 h, 20% ethanol). Results were ~2 µg/dm2 for identified individual mono-phenols like 2-hydroxybenzyl alcohol and up to ~120 µg/dm2 for total phenolic compounds, representing approximately 7% of the overall migration. The migration of bisphenol F isomers was negligible below 0.3 µg/dm2. Potential exposure to migrating phenols was assessed based on the threshold of toxicological concern concept to be significantly below for individual phenols and in the same order of magnitude for total phenols compared to the respective thresholds calculated for infants.

Release and migration of cyclic polyester oligomers from bisphenol A non-intent polyester–phenol-coatings into food simulants and infant food – a comprehensive study

ABSTRACTCoatings for cans or closures are essential to protect the metal from corrosion and the food from migration of hazardous metal ions. Since coatings are no inert materials, they can release substances of potential health concern into food. In the present study, a comprehensive analysis is presented for a complex two-layered polyester–phenol-coating commercially used for metal closures of complementary infant food in sterilised glass jars. Focussed on the identity and migration of cyclic polyester oligomers as a kind of predictable non-intentionally added substances, polyester resin raw materials (n = 3) as well as individual coating layers (n = 3) were characterised by several analytical strategies (size exclusion chromatography, high-performance liquid chromatography mass spectrometry, diode array detection, charged aerosol detection, monomer determination after alkaline hydrolysis, overall migrate). The main polyester monomers were terephthalic acid, isophthalic acid, trimellitic acid, ethylene glycol, diethylene glycol, neopentylglycol, 2-methyl-1,3-propanediol, 1,4-butanediol and tricyclodecanedimethanol. The coatings were extracted with solvents acetonitrile and ethanol (24 h, 60°C), food simulants 50% ethanol, 20% ethanol and water (1 h, 121°C) as well as homemade and commercial baby food (1 h, 121°C). The released total polyester content determined by alkaline hydrolysis ranged from 288 µg/dm2 (water, 1 h, 121°C) to 6154 µg/dm2 (acetonitrile, 24 h, 60°C). However, individual cyclic oligomers, mainly dimers, were released from the coating to up to about 140 µg/dm2. Migration into infant food was best represented by the food simulants water (up to 1% fat) and 20% ethanol (up to 5% fat). Cyclic polyester oligomers are classified as Cramer III substances by the threshold of toxicological concern concept associated to an exposure threshold of 1.5 µg/kg body weight per day. Exposure to cyclic polyester oligomers might be a potential concern for highly exposed infants.

Exposure assessment of epoxy fatty acids through consumption of specific foods available in Belgium

ABSTRACTEpoxy fatty acids (EFAs) are secondary oxidation products formed from unsaturated fatty acid hydroperoxides. Seventeen food categories were analysed for C18 monoEFAs of food products available on the Belgian market. A quantitative exposure assessment was performed based on deterministic and probabilistic approaches combining these concentration data with consumption data obtained from the Belgian National Food Consumption Survey of 2004. A preliminary evaluation of any potential risk related to the intake of the studied EFAs through the studied foods was performed by applying the threshold of toxicological concern (TTC) concept. Three food categories out of 17 foods, mayonnaise, butter–margarine and ready-to-eat meals were found to contribute most to the intake of EFAs. According to probabilistic determination, these foods had P50 intakes of 0.4085, 0.3328 and 0.2997 mg kg–1 bw day–1 respectively. They had P99.5 intakes of 3.7183, 2.7921 and 38.6068 mg kg–1 bw day–1 respectively. The intake below the TTC was from the consumption of cooked meat, smoked salmon and raw cured ham, with P50 intakes of 0.0006, 0.0007 and 0.0011 mg kg–1 bw day–1 respectively, and the other foods were above the TTC. Based on the TTC concept, a risk to human health could be identified related to the consumption of cheese, snacks foods, plant oils, French fries, dry nuts, chips, cured minced raw meat, cookies, fresh and frozen salmon and bacon.

Relevance of bioaccumulating substances in the TTC concept

Recently, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) stated that the Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) thresholds should not be used for substances that are known or predicted to accumulate. Bioaccumulation of substances is usually considered unfavourable but so far a relation with toxicity at low dose exposure is insufficiently investigated to draw conclusions on the relevance of bioaccumulation at low dose exposure. In this manuscript it is investigated which physical chemical properties are related to bioaccumulation in order to predict accumulating properties of a substance, and is evaluated if the toxicity of known bioaccumulating substances is higher than for non-accumulating substances. Based on the evaluation it is concluded that the current TTC thresholds are derived with a dataset in which bioaccumulating substances are present, whereas the toxicity of the bioaccumulating substances is already taken into account in the TTC thresholds. The authors demonstrated that there is no need to exclude potential bioaccumulating substances from the TTC concept.

Exposure assessment of Malondialdehyde, 4-Hydroxy-2-(E)-Nonenal and 4-Hydroxy-2-(E)-Hexenal through specific foods available in Belgium

Malondialdehyde (MDA), 4-Hydroxy-2-(E)-Nonenal (HNE) and 4-Hydroxy-2-(E)-Hexenal (HHE) are reactive aldehydes found in foods and are formed due to decomposition of polyunsaturated fatty acid hydroperoxides. In the present study, sixteen food categories were analyzed for the aforementioned aldehydes and in combination with consumption data obtained from a national representative sample of the Belgian population, a quantitative exposure assessment was performed. MDA was detected above the detection limit in 84% of the analyzed samples while HNE and HHE in 63% and 16% of the samples respectively. Consumption of dry nuts, fried snacks, French fries and cured minced meat products were found to contribute the most to the intake of MDA and HNE. Intake of HHE from the foods analyzed was found not to be significant. An evaluation of any potential risk related to the intake of the studied aldehydes through the studied foods was performed by applying the threshold of toxicological concern concept. No risk to human health could be identified related to the consumption of these foods for the vast majority of the consumers, with the only exception of a small proportion (3.8%) of those who consume cured and minced raw meat, that could be at risk.

Feasibility study: refinement of the TTC concept by additional rules based on in silico and experimental data.

Starting from a single generic limit value, the threshold of toxicological concern (TTC) concept has been further developed over the years, e.g., by including differentiated structural classes according to the rules of Cramer et al. (Food Chem Toxicol 16: 255-276, 1978). In practice, the refined TTC concept of Munro et al. (Food Chem Toxicol 34: 829-867, 1996) is often applied. The purpose of this work was to explore the possibility of refining the concept by introducing additional structure-activity relationships and available toxicity data. Computer modeling was performed using the OECD Toolbox. No observed (adverse) effect level (NO(A)EL) data of 176 substances were collected in a basic data set. New subgroups were created applying the following criteria: extended Cramer rules, low bioavailability, low acute toxicity, no protein binding affinity, and consideration of predicted liver metabolism. The highest TTC limit value of 236 µg/kg/day was determined for a subgroup that combined the criteria "no protein binding affinity" and "predicted liver metabolism." This value was approximately eight times higher than the original Cramer class 1 limit value of 30 µg/kg/day. The results of this feasibility study indicate that inclusion of the proposed criteria may lead to improved TTC values. Thereby, the applicability of the TTC concept in risk assessment could be extended which could reduce the need to perform animal tests.

Mutagenic impurities in pharmaceuticals: A critique of the derivation of the cancer TTC (Threshold of Toxicological Concern) and recommendations for structural-class-based limits

The cancer TTC (Threshold of Toxicological Concern) concept is currently employed as an aid to risk assessment of potentially mutagenic impurities (PMIs) in food, cosmetics and other sectors. Within the pharmaceutical industry the use of one default cancer TTC limit of 1.5μg/day for PMIs is being increasingly questioned. Its derivation, originally in the context of foodstuffs, can be broken down into five key elements: dataset composition; determination of carcinogenicity/mutagenicity status and carcinogenic potency (based on TD50s) of compounds in the dataset; linear extrapolation of carcinogenic potencies; evaluation of the more potent compounds in each structural category, and presence of representative structural alerts amongst the more potent compounds. A detailed evaluation reveals that the derivation process is distorted by the use of the lowest statistically significant TD50s (which can produce a false-carcinogen phenomenon) and by employing linear extrapolation for non-mutagenic carcinogens. By correcting for these two factors, it is concluded that only around 50% of conventional structural-alert categories were adequately addressed and that limits higher than the default value appear to be justified in many cases. Using similar criteria for PMIs in pharmaceuticals, four distinct potency categories of conventional structural alerts can be distinguished, ranging from alerts with questionable validity to those with high potency, which are considered to provide a range of flexible and pragmatic limits for such impurities.

Threshold of toxicological concern (TTC) task force: a strategy to support application of TTC to dermally applied cosmetic ingredients

Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) is a tool that aids assessment of human health risks from exposure to low levels of chemicals in the diet, when specific toxicity data are not available. It provides threshold toxicity values for oral dosing in structural categories (Cramer classes 1, 2 and 3 (1800, 540 and 90 ug/day1.8, 2 0.54 and 3 0.09 mg/d ). Our aim is to adapt the TTC concept to cosmetics applied to the skin and address the importance of differences in bioavailability between oral and dermal exposures.This poster describes a decision tree approach for estimating systemic availibility following dermal exposure, allowing application of oral TTC. .... Objectives

Application of the threshold of toxicological concern concept when applied to pharmaceutical manufacturing operations intended for short-term clinical trials

In the manufacture of pharmaceuticals, if a multiproduct facility shares equipment amongst drug substances/products it is incumbent upon the manufacturer to demonstrate removal of the pharmaceutical through a robust cleaning validation/verification program. Removal must be to below limits considered acceptable from a quality and toxicological perspective. In order to address the toxicological concerns, an acceptable daily exposure (ADE) was developed which is the “dose that is unlikely to cause an adverse effect if … exposed, by any route … at or below this dose every day for a lifetime” (ISPE, 2010). For compounds in development, defaulted ADEs were proposed by Dolan et al. (2005) and adopted by the International Society of Pharmaceutical Engineers (ISPE) as conservative cutoffs for compounds with limited data. In Phase 1 clinical trials, exposure is typically short-term (single dose or repeated doses for ≤30days) compared to the chronic doses used to derive ADE and defaulted ADEs. An analysis of publicly available databases for toxicological and pharmacological effects supports the use of 10-fold higher defaulted values when the residual drug substance is in a developmental pharmaceutical intended for Phase 1 clinical trials (exposure ≤30days).

Applicability of thresholds of toxicological concern in the dietary risk assessment of metabolites, degradation and reaction products of pesticides

Applicability of thresholds of toxicological concern in the dietary risk assessment of metabolites, degradation and reaction products of pesticides

Thresholds of toxicological concern for endocrine active substances in the aquatic environment

The threshold of toxicological concern (TTC) concept proposes that an exposure threshold value can be derived for chemicals, below which no significant risk to human health or the environment is expected. This concept goes further than setting acceptable exposure levels for individual chemicals, because it attempts to set a de minimis value for chemicals, including those of unknown toxicity, by taking the chemical's structure or mode of action (MOA) into consideration. This study examines the use of the TTC concern concept for endocrine active substances (EAS) with an estrogenic MOA. A case study formed the basis for a workshop of regulatory, industry and academic scientists held to discuss the use of the TTC in aquatic environmental risk assessment. The feasibility and acceptability, general advantages and disadvantages, and the specific issues that need to be considered when applying the TTC concept for EAS in risk assessment were addressed. Issues surrounding the statistical approaches used to derive TTCs were also discussed. This study presents discussion points and consensus findings of the workshop.

Exposure-driven safety assessment strategies; Application of the Threshold of Toxicological Concern-concept in safety assessment of chemically complex matrices

Exposure-driven safety assessment strategies; Application of the Threshold of Toxicological Concern-concept in safety assessment of chemically complex matrices