The film thickness characteristics and traction behavior, two of the more important elastohydrodynamic lubrication (EHL) properties, of two important classes of synthetic lubricants have been studied. The effect of viscosity index (VI) improvers on these properties has been determined for both hydrogenated polyalphaolefin (PAO) base fluids and chlorotrifluoroethylene oligomer (CTFE) base fluids. A polyalkylmethacrylate (PMM) VI improver was studied in PAO and a copolymer of vinylidine fluoride and chlorotrifluoroethylene was studied in CTFE. The VI improvers demonstrated insignificant improvement in the EHL film thickness of both the PAO and CTFE base fluids as determined by comparing the measured film thickness of the VI-improved fluids to the predicted film thickness based on measured pressure-viscosity characteristics and kinematic viscosities determined at low shear rates. Similarly, the traction behavior of VI-improved PAO and CTFE fluids was nearly equivalent to that of the respective base fluids, demonstrating very little effect of the VI improvers on these properties. The minimal contribution is attributed to the non-Newtonian behavior of the VI improved fluids under the high shear rates and stresses found in an EHL contact. Physical properties of the base oil determine the true behavior of a VI-improved fluid under EHL conditions; therefore, the properties of the base fluid should be used in theoretical predictions instead of the properties of the formulated fluid.