Purpose: A variety of retinal topographical changes occur after internal limiting membrane (ILM) peeling for macular holes including a movement of the fovea toward the optic nerve. This study was carried out to assess the effect of the extent of ILM-peeled area on these changes and postoperative visual acuity. Methods: Prospective single-center study of a consecutive series of patients undergoing macular hole surgery. Preoperative and postoperative optical coherence tomography images were used to assess a variety of measures of retinal morphology. Transmission electron microscopy of the peeled ILM was used to assess residual retinal and vitreous side debris. The area of the ILM peeled was calculated from intraoperative images. Results: Fifty-six eyes of 56 patients were included. The mean area of ILM peeled was 9.5 mm2 (2.4-28.3 mm2). The mean disc-to-fovea distance (DFD) preoperatively was 3703 μm with a mean reduction of 52 μm postoperatively, representing a change of −1.29% with a wide range of −7.04% to 1.36%. Using stepwise linear regression, ILM-peeled area was significantly associated with a change in DFD ( P < .001), extent of a dissociated optic nerve fiber layer appearance ( P < .001), and postoperative visual acuity ( P = .025). Nasotemporal retinal thickness asymmetry was associated with the minimum linear diameter ( P < .001). Conclusion: The ILM-peeled area has a significant effect on changes in retinal topography and postoperative visual acuity separate from macular hole size. Further study is needed to assess the effect of ILM peeled size on visual function and to guide clinical practice.