Peripheral nerve-crush injury is a well-established model of neuromuscular junction (NMJ) denervation and subsequent re-innervation. Functionally, the skeletal muscle follows a similar pattern as neural recovery, with immediate loss of force production that steadily improves in parallel with rates of re-innervation. On the other hand, traumatic injury to the muscle itself, specifically volumetric muscle loss (VML), results in an irrecoverable loss of muscle function. Recent work has indicated significant impairments to the NMJ following this injury that appear chronic in nature, alongside the lack of functional recovery. Thus, the goal of this study was to compare the effects of nerve and muscle injury on NMJ remodeling. Even numbers of adult male and female mice were used with three experimental groups: injury Naïve, nerve crush, and VML injury; and three terminal timepoints: 3-, 48-, and 112-days post-injury. Confirming the assumed recoverability of the two injury models, we found in vivo maximal torque was fully restored following nerve-crush injury but remained at a significant deficit following VML. Compared to injury Naïve and nerve-crush injury, we found VML results in aberrantly high trophic signaling (e.g., neuregulin-1) and numbers of supporting cells, including terminal Schwann cells and sub-synaptic nuclei. In some cases, sex differences were detected, including higher rates of innervation in females than males. Both nerve crush and VML injury display chronic changes to NMJ morphology, such as increased fragmentation and nerve sprouting, highlighting the potential of VML for modeling NMJ regeneration in adulthood, alongside the established nerve-injury models.