Reviewed by: Musical Portraits: The Composition of Identity in Contemporary and Experimental Music by Joshua S. Walden Elizabeth Hoover Musical Portraits: The Composition of Identity in Contemporary and Experimental Music. By Joshua S. Walden. New York: Oxford University Press, 2018. [xiii, 184 p. ISBN 9780190653507 (hardback), $74; ISBN 9780190653521 (e-book), varies; also available in Oxford Scholarship Online.] Figures, music examples, bibliography, endnotes, index. Musical Portraits: The Composition of Identity in Contemporary and Experimental Music complements literature by Joshua S. Walden on musical representation and identity through the exploration of musical portraiture, "a genre of compositions that operate as musical evocations of aspects of individual identities in the manner of portraits in the visual arts and literature" (p. 2). Walden pioneered the study of musical portraiture by discussing Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach in relation to eighteenth-century theories of portraiture in the visual arts, and correlations between music and painting ("Composing Character in Musical Portraits: Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach and L'Aly Rupalich," Musical Quarterly 91, nos. 3–4 [Fall-Winter 2008]: 379–411; "What's in a Name? C. P. E. Bach and the Genres of the Character Piece and Musical Portrait," in Genre in Eighteenth-Century Music, ed. Anthony R. DelDonna [Ann Arbor, MI: Steglein Publishing, 2008], 111–38). In Musical Portraits, Walden contemporizes the discussion by extending his work on portraiture composed since 1950 initiated in "Representation and Musical Portraiture in the Twentieth Century" (in Representation in Western Music, ed. Joshua S. Walden [Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013], 127–43), which focuses on compositions that challenge traditional modes of representation in parallel to, or inspired by, experiments in literature, painting, and multimedia. In the introduction, four chapters, and epilogue that make up the text, Walden investigates a series of case studies to demonstrate how contemporary musical portraiture constructs human identity and questions formations of the self for both artists and audience. Although quite brief and in no way comprehensive, the introduction, "Portraiture as a Musical Genre," highlights how portraiture has served as metaphor for internal identity. Walden establishes that the nature of twentieth-century portraiture represents this identity apart from mimesis and compares the roles of metaphor in portraiture and music. By calling on select theories of identity construction in postmodern performance, Walden emphasizes the social, performative, and hermeneutic construction of identity in contemporary musical portraiture. Walden explores four main types of musical portraiture, as indicated by the chapter titles: (1) "Musical and Literary Portraiture," (2) "Musical Portraits of Visual Artists," (3) "Listening in on Composers' Self-Portraits," and (4) "Celebrity, Music, and the Multimedia Portrait." To study the complex and multifaceted construction of identity in these types of portraiture, Walden depends on musical, literary, visual, and dramatic texts as evidence. His interpretive, cross-disciplinary analysis is accessible to readers across the humanities and is often enhanced by authoritative artist statements about the works. Mirroring the trajectory of abstract art in the twentieth century and portraiture's break from aesthetic realism outlined in the introduction, Musical Portraits, although often rooted in comparative studies of musical ekphrasis, departs from this approach to question who is represented in musical portraiture and the truthfulness of such representations. The first two chapters compare musical portraits of artists whose styles inspired composers, who name them [End Page 460] in the title. Chapter one analyzes the influence of Gertrude Stein's poetic insistence—gradually varied repetitions of linguistic motifs—on Virgil Thomson's musical portraiture and then turns to Stéphane "Mallarmé's complex ideas about the relationships between poetry and music" as enacted in Pierre Boulez's Pli selon pli: Portrait de Mallarmé (p. 37). Drawing from A. S. Byatt, Walden introduces these case studies by underlining a kinship between music and language that, as Byatt claims, both depend on time and "the unfolding of description" (p. 23) to reveal internal character. Byatt establishes this connection in opposition to the supposed stasis of visual art (painting), but curiously Walden does not probe the aesthetic question of what designates "a temporal art" (or also a "time art"), a much-debated question in the disciplines of music and painting (Jerrold Levinson, Musical Concerns: Essays in Philosophy of Music [Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015]; Jonathan...
Read full abstract