Abstract The first marine circulus is the scale feature associated with marine entry and has been used to support research evaluating the relationships between size, growth, and survival for Atlantic salmon. Ambiguity in growth rates and circulus deposition during the transition from freshwater to the marine environment leads to difficulty in the correct identification of the first marine circulus. In this study, scale growth occurring after the last freshwater annulus (plus-growth) was characterized for Atlantic salmon smolts migrating out of the Narraguagus River in Maine. Plus-growth was present in over 95% of scales from smolts leaving the river and represented on average 12.2% of total freshwater growth. These findings suggest plus-growth presents a significant source of error in growth analyses, if ignored, and the characterization of this scale feature helps to inform accurate identification of marine entry for future studies. Run day was a driver of plus-growth, suggesting extended freshwater residency provides opportunity for growth prior to smolt emigration. The negative association between fork length and plus-growth suggests smaller smolts that delay migration are demonstrating compensatory growth. Cumulative air temperature was positively associated with plus-growth, suggesting warming spring temperatures driven by climate change may influence size at marine entry for smolts.