Case Presentation: A 23-year-old female rugby player presented for recurrent chest pain. She has a history of atrial septal defect (ASD) repaired with robotic ASD closure. She developed acute pericarditis postoperatively and was treated with naproxen and colchicine inpatient. Her subsequent recurrences occurred with playing rugby and were treated with ibuprofen, colchicine, and prednisone. Electrocardiogram showed sinus bradycardia at 59 beats per minute but without ST segment changes. Cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) imaging showed mild-to-moderate circumferential pericardial late gadolinium enhancement (LGE) without signal hyperintensity on T2 STIR imaging. She was diagnosed with chronic recurrent pericarditis secondary to post-cardiac injury syndrome (PCIS) and was started on rilonacept. On follow-up after 1 year, the patient remained symptom-free. She gradually increased her activity level to walking 3 miles per day and weaned down to rilonacept monotherapy. Repeat CMR showed mild pericardial LGE that was improved from before. Discussion: PCIS is a known cause of pericarditis due to local and systemic inflammatory responses to cardiothoracic surgery. Robotic ASD closure is a minimally invasive endoscopic procedure that has a favorable safety profile; PCIS is not a previously documented complication. Treatment of pericarditis secondary to PCIS includes NSAIDs plus 3 months of colchicine for acute pericarditis, NSAIDs plus 6 months of colchicine for a first recurrence, with corticosteroids or interleukin-1 inhibitors added for further recurrences. Incomplete treatment of acute pericarditis, as in this patient's case, is a risk factor for recurrent pericarditis. The risk of recurrences with physical activity is debated and current guidelines recommend restriction from physical activity until there is no evidence of active disease, though the data is not robust. In clinical practice, a gradual return-to-play program is frequently utilized.