The migration of industrial automation systems (IASs) to an edge-cloud hosted on factory premises can reduce the operation costs of a manufacturing line and increase its flexibility thanks to computation scalability and use of cloud-native operation concepts. However, the unclear assessment of costs of an edge-cloud automation system (ECAS) is a significant concern for manufacturing experts, which disincentives its adoption. An ECAS is expected to generate different costs than a traditional IAS, which depends on the requirements of the automation functions hosted in the edge-cloud. Because of this, methods to evaluate various realization concepts of an ECAS concerning their economic viability are required to support its engineering. In this paper, we provide a methodology that helps practitioners to define design specifications for an ECAS and assess their life-cycle costs (LCCs). To provide a robust and transparent LCCs assessment, we leverage the Monte Carlo method, which is a well-affirmed technique to address costs uncertainties. To do so, a cost model has been developed and implemented in a discrete-event simulator to calculate upfront and running costs of an ECAS. The application of the methodology is shown through an exemplar case study and its results are discussed. The presented work helps practitioners to evaluate whether an ECAS is economically viable for a manufacturing scenario, thus increasing the acceptance for this technology and fostering the transition towards flexible and smart manufacturing systems.
Read full abstract