Systematic Literature Review Technique Research Articles

A Comprehensive Review of Path Planning for Agricultural Ground Robots

The population of the world is predicted to reach nine billion by 2050, implying that agricultural output must continue to rise. To deal with population expansion, agricultural chores must be mechanized and automated. Over the last decade, ground robots have been developed for a variety of agricultural applications, with autonomous and safe navigation being one of the most difficult hurdles in this development. When a mobile platform moves autonomously, it must perform a variety of tasks, including localization, route planning, motion control, and mapping, which is a critical stage in autonomous operations. This research examines several agricultural applications as well as the path planning approach used. The purpose of this study is to investigate the current literature on path/trajectory planning aspects of ground robots in agriculture using a systematic literature review technique, to contribute to the goal of contributing new information in the field. Coverage route planning appears to be less advanced in agriculture than point-to-point path routing, according to the finding, which is due to the fact that covering activities are usually required for agricultural applications, but precision agriculture necessitates point-to-point navigation. In the recent era, precision agriculture is getting more attention. The conclusion presented here demonstrates that both field coverage and point-to-point navigation have been applied successfully in path planning for agricultural robots.

Drivers and barriers of travel behaviors during and post COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic literature review and future agenda

PurposeThe purpose of this study is to examine the drivers and barriers of travel behavior associated with tourist behavior during/post-COVID-19 pandemic to provide a knowledge base as well as an agenda for future research.Design/methodology/approachThe authors utilized the Systematic Literature Review (SLR) technique for searching the articles published inWeb of Science (WOS)andScopus, to identify the main drivers and barriers affecting the tourist behavior during/post-COVID-19 pandemic. Eventually, 47 articles were chosen for the final analysis.FindingsThe findings are reported in three sections, (1) quantitative research profile, (2) qualitative synthesis and (3) future agenda. This study addresses the nuanced questions regarding the significant change in tourist travel behavior, emotional dynamics and a detailed understanding of mechanisms, such as which drivers and barriers affect tourist behavior in a particular destination. Drivers and barriers to tourist travel behavior were characterized in personal-related, destination-related, and health-related factors. Moreover, this study provides thought-provoking ideas in theory, policy and practice in the field of tourism and hospitality.Research limitations/implicationsThis study has three limitations, as follows. First, the authors searched only two databases,ScopusandWeb ofScience, due to which the authors might be missing some related studies existing on the other databases. Although these databases provide an extensive range of academic literature, further studies could extend the data collection from the other databases (e.g. viaTaylor & Francis). However, our systematic literature review (SLR) coverage is quite extensive, since journals are listed on these three main databases. Second, the authors followed a main study search protocol based on the synonyms and related keywords, however, some of the studies that may be related to the tourist behavior towards the destination are missing on account of the lack of our keywords in there, title, author, keyword and abstract. Furthermore, future research could endeavor to add other keywords to expand the results of studies. Third, although the accurate analysis was conducted to reduce subjectivity in identifying themes for drivers and barriers of tourist behavior, future studies on categorization could work to ensure that other sub-themes categorize.Practical implicationsThe recent study has some key practical implications. First, this study is valuable for all the stakeholders in a unique way, including destination managers, academicians and policymakers, because it provides insight into barriers and drivers that influence the development of tourist behavior towards the destination. Second, the current study also offers practical implications for people involved in tourism service industries including governments and private businesses. Policymakers and other leaders are increasingly interested in harnessing the economic potential of tourism. Therefore, identifying the barrier which is inhibiting the tourist traffic towards the destination is beneficial to understand and effectively develop strategies to minimize the effect of such factors. Moreover, drivers and barriers of tourist behavior towards the destination in the COVID-19 pandemic situation towards the destination may help to create a framework for the development of destinations according to the current vulnerable situation. Third, current findings suggest that tourism marketers understand the drivers and barrier constructs found in this study and tailor their marketing strategies for attracting existing and new tourists. For instance, marketers should understand the drivers and barriers of tourist behavior for effective strategy development to increase the positive effect of drivers and to reduce the negative effect of barriers.Originality/valueThis is the first systematic literature review on the impact of drivers and barriers of tourist travel behavior. This paper analyses the methods and approaches that have been used in the previous literature to examine the drivers and barriers of tourist travel behavior. The paper ends with the research implication and limitations of the studies.

The Role of Smart Farming in Sustainable Development

This paper intends to explore the development of agriculture in to smart farming and how smart farming can contribute to the sustainable development goals. The paper focuses on how smart farming can be imparted in sustainable agriculture by analyzing the environmental, economic and social impact. This paper applied a systematic literature review technique to assess published academic literature on smart farming and sustainable agriculture in Southeast Asia. The review identified that smart farming can lead to less environmental damage, lower cost and higher productivity and has the potential to create decent jobs for the youth ultimately leading to a sustainable food system.

감성 품질 만족도 요인 도출 방법에 대한 체계적 문헌 고찰

Objective: In this study, we analyzed methodological studies for deriving the basic factors of emotional quality satisfaction evaluation and organized using a systematic literature review technique.<BR><BR>Background: In general, the satisfaction evaluation index is derived through the process of emotional expression survey, classification, and systematization. The methodologies used in the process are diverse, and the fields used are also diverse. However, it is difficult to clearly find research that can be referred to as a guide when developing an index in a specific field because the literature to be referred to define an index for evaluation in a certain field varies by method and field. Therefore, research on a methodology that can guide for new development is needed, and in order to do so, systematic analysis of existing related studies must first be prioritized.<BR><BR>Method: Related literature was searched based on DBPIA, an academic research database, and search Keyword was based on

A SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEW: HAPPINESS OF SANTRI IN PESANTREN

Happiness is everyone's purpose. Every individual has a goal in life that needs to be fulfilled with effort, and that ultimate goal is happiness. There are many ways to achieve happiness, including religion. Pondok Pesantren is a typical Indonesian education system in which the people in it study religion. This study was conducted to see how happiness is in Islamic boarding schools, especially for santri. Using a systematic literature review technique by searching for published articles that match the theme on Google Scholar and DOAJ for the last 10 years (2011-2022) with the keywords "happiness, santri, pesantren". The selected articles are the results of research conducted in Indonesia. Found 8 articles that match the criteria after the screening process. In general, the happiness of santri in Islamic boarding schools shows a fairly good condition on average. Several factors were found related to the happiness of the santri in the pesantren, including social relations, self-quality, and feeling close to Allah SWT.

Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence: The Superlative Approach to Achieve Sustainable Development Goals in the Fourth Industrial Revolution

Artificial intelligence (AI) is currently being developed by large corporations, and governments all over the world are yearning for it. AI isn’t a futuristic concept; it is already here, and it is being implemented in a range of industries. Finance, national security, health care, criminal justice, transportation, and smart cities are all examples of this. There are countless examples of AI having a substantial impact on the world and complementing human abilities. However, due to the immense societal ramifications of these technologies, AI is on the verge of disrupting a host of industries, so the technique by which AI systems are created must be better understood. The goal of the study was to look at what it meant to be human-centred, how to create human-centred AI, and what considerations should be made for human-centred AI to achieve sustainability and the SDGs. Using a systematic literature review technique, the study discovered that a human-centred AI strategy strives to create and implement AI systems in ways that benefit mankind and serve their interests. The study also found that a human-in-the-loop concept should be used to develop procedures for creating human-centred AI, as well as other initiatives, such as the promotion of AI accountability, encouraging businesses to use autonomy wisely, to motivate businesses to be aware of human and algorithmic biases, to ensure that businesses prioritize customers, and form multicultural teams to tackle AI research. The study concluded with policy recommendations for human-centred AI to help accomplish the SDGs, including expanding government AI investments, addressing data and algorithm biases, and resolving data access issues, among other things.

Strategy to Build Organizational Culture to Improve Teacher Performance During the COVID-19 Pandemic

A strong organizational culture is a force that can unite goals, create motivation, commitment, loyalty, and performance of all school residents, and provide the necessary structure and control without relying on formal bureaucracy. Organizational culture is expected to improve school quality, performance, as well as foster a healthy, dynamic or active, positive, and professional life. The goal of this study was to find out the strategies to build organizational culture to improve teacher performance in this pandemic period. This research was conducted using qualitative descriptive research methods. The data sources used in this study are primary and secondary data with systematic literature review techniques carried out in three stages, namely planning, implementation, and reporting of the results of literature reviews. The results obtained in this study are expected to provide an overview of how efforts in obtaining cultural strategies are limited to performance during pandemics.&#x0D; Keywords: organizational culture, teacher performance, COVID pandemic

A systematic review on forensic accounting and its contribution towards fraud detection and prevention

PurposeThis paper aims to determine how forensic accounting contributes to fraud detection and prevention and answer the following research questions: What are the standard techniques for fraud detection and prevention; and What are the significant challenges that hinder the application of forensic accounting in fraud prevention and detection?Design/methodology/approachThe authors use the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) method to carry out a systematic literature review (SLR) to identify and assess the existing literature on forensic accounting.FindingsThere exists a positive correlation between forensic accounting and fraud detection and prevention. Moreover, in both the empirical and non-empirical findings, the authors note that fraud is complex, and in carrying out fraud investigations, one must be aware of its complexity.Practical implicationsAlthough drug counterfeiting is a sector where forensic accountants have paid less attention, it is a rapidly expanding fraud area. This paper finds that to detect fraud at an early stage, one must increase consumer understanding of basic forensic accounting techniques by implementing accurate supply chain monitoring systems and inventory management controls and conducting adequate and effective regulatory, honest and legitimate customs inspections.Social implicationsThe major factors that restrict forensic accounting are a lack of awareness and education. Hence, it is essential to incorporate forensic accounting in undergraduate and post-graduate courses.Originality/valueFrom the existing literature, it has been observed that very few studies have been conducted in this field using the PRISMA and SLR techniques. Also, the authors carried out a holistic study that focuses on three different areas – fraud detection, fraud prevention and the challenges in forensic accounting.

Pedestrian Area Development in Smart City Concept in Tangerang City

The city government of Tangerang has not been able to apply the concept of smart cities, while urban development has not used the concept of smart (intelligen) and attractive (attractive) which facilitates infrastructure, technology, and attracts local people based on a forward vision regarding the needs, capabilities and resources that exist. , safe and comfortable pedestrian facilities, and public spaces for pedestrians that can create an urban cultural concept that can provide business controversies that can help migrants and communities enjoy the city by foot. The purpose of this study is to study how the Tangerang City government can implement a development system that can be lived in and can be visited in accordance with the Tangerang Direct motto. This study uses a qualitative method that studies the literature with systematic literature review techniques by descriptive data analysis. The results of this study indicate that the Tangerang city government has just realized the construction of a pedestrian lane with a ratio of 72.40% of the length of the city road which has a length of 316.46 km with a very narrow space dimension of 1.5 meters combined with greening areas.

Potential functionality and workability of blockchain within a building information modelling (BIM) environment

PurposeAlthough building information modelling (BIM) brings various benefits and open up the construction industry to many new possibilities, it is not without some challenges. Blockchain has the potential to resolve some of these problems. It has shown that blockchain and BIM can potentially work together in bringing various benefits to all project stakeholders. However, there is a lack of research and knowledge in relation to blockchain-based BIM. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to close this gap by looking into the potential functionality and workability of blockchain within a BIM environment.Design/methodology/approachA four-stage preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses systematic literature review technique has been used to review the blockchain- and BIM-related information sources published. A total of 53 journal articles, 13 books and 27 other resources including that of reports and websites have been included in this paper.FindingsBlockchain-based BIM has countless possibilities, ranging from simple tasks such as tracking of orders to automation of construction payment claims. The literatures have suggested that the several weaknesses that BIM possesses including trust issue, asset ownership issue and data reliability issue could be resolved by incorporating blockchain into its processes.Originality/valueBecause of the lack of researches on the workability of blockchain and BIM, this paper aims to close this gap by proposing a framework for the interaction between blockchain and BIM for a typical building project. This paper has reviewed a substantial amount of currently available knowledge on blockchain-based BIM and its relevancy to the construction industry. This paper believes that the information could be of use to potential BIM tools maker and the construction industry for the betterment of BIM implementation throughout a project life cycle.

Augmented reality in design and construction: thematic analysis and conceptual frameworks

PurposeThis study aims to present a comprehensive review, critical analysis and implications of the augmented reality (AR) application and implementation in the construction industry arena and demonstrate the gaps along with the future research agenda.Design/methodology/approachThe construction industry has been under pressure to improve its productivity, quality and sustainability. However, the conventional methods and technologies cannot respond to this industry's ever-growing demands while emerging and innovative technologies such as building information modelling, artificial intelligence (AI), virtual reality (VR) and AR have emerged and can be used to address this gap. AR application has been acknowledged as one of the most impactful technologies in the construction digitalization process. However, a comprehensive understanding of the AR application, its areas of effectiveness and overarching implications in a construction project life cycle remain vague. Therefore, this study uses an integration of systematic literature review and thematic analysis techniques to identify the phases of a construction project life cycle in which AR is the most effective, the current issues and problems of the conventional methods, the augmented parameters, the immediate effects of using AR on each phase and, eventually, the overall influence of AR on the entire project. Nvivo qualitative data analysis software was used to code, categorize and create themes from the collected data. The result of data analysis was used to develop four principal frameworks of the AR applications – design and constructability review session; construction operation; construction assembly; and maintenance and defect inspection and management – and the gap analysis along with the future research agenda.FindingsThe findings of this study indicated that the application of AR can be most effective in the following four stages of a project life cycle: design and constructability review session; construction operation; construction assembly; and site management and maintenance, including site management and defect inspection. The results also showed that the application of AR technology in the construction industry can align and address building industry objectives by various elements such as: reducing project costs through the application of digital technologies, saving time, meeting deadlines and reduction in project delays through integrated, live scheduling and increased safety and quality of the construction work and workers.Research limitations/implicationsOne of the main limitations of this study was the lack of materials and resources on the downfalls and shortcomings of using immersive technologies, AR, in the construction project life cycle. In addition, most of the reviewed papers were focused on the experiments with simulations and in the lab environment, rather than real experiments in real construction sites and projects. This may cause limitations and inaccuracy of the collected and reported data.Practical implicationsThe results of this study indicated that the application of AR technology in construction industry can align and address building industry objectives by various elements such as: reducing project costs through the application of digital technologies; saving time; meeting deadlines and reduction in project delays through integrated, live scheduling; and increased safety and quality of the construction work and workers.Social implicationsApplication of AR in the various stages of a project life cycle can increase the safety and quality of the construction work and workers.Originality/valueThe reviewed literature indicated that substantial research and studies are yet to be done, to demonstrate the full capacity and impact of these emerging technologies in the field. The collected data and literature indicate that amongst the digital technologies, AR is one of the least researched topics in the field. Therefore, this study aims to examine the application of AR in construction projects’ life cycle to identify the stages and practices of a project life cycle where AR and its capabilities can be exploited and to identify the respective problems and issues of the conventional methods and the ways in which AR can address those shortcomings. Furthermore, this study focuses on identifying the overall outcome of AR applications in a construction project in terms of cost and time efficiency, process precision and safety.

Comic Media in Learning of Elementary Schools: Systematic Literature Review

Comics are alternative media that can be used by teachers in carrying out learning in elementary schools. Learning comics are stories made by teachers with certain characters with the aim of making it easier for students to understand the material. This research using the concept of literature review uses the Systematic Literature Review (SLR) technique. The Systematic Literature Review technique is carried out by reviewing articles that are in accordance with the topic of the research question and then making an in-depth study of the articles that have been reviewed. The results of the data analysis that has been carried out are that the use of comics can improve students' understanding of the material which results in improving student learning outcomes in elementary schools. In addition, the cultivation of good character values can be done through the use of comics. Another result is that the local culture of the local area in the elementary school can be used as a good alternative in setting up comic stories. It is necessary to choose a good topic so that the comics used can make it easier for students to understand the material.

Analysis of the benefits, challenges and risks for the integrated use of BIM, RFID and WSN: a mixed method research

PurposeThe purpose of this study is to identify, classify and prioritize the benefits, challenges and risks for the integrated use of building information modeling (BIM), radio frequency identification (RFID) and wireless sensor network (WSN) in the architecture, engineering, construction and operation (AECO) industry.Design/methodology/approachThis study relies on the mixed method approach which consists of systematic literature review, semistructured interviews and Delphi technique. A systematic literature review was performed and face-to-face semistructured interviews with seven subject matter experts (SMEs) were conducted for identification and classification purposes. Delphi method was applied in two structured rounds with eleven SMEs for prioritization purpose. These three research techniques were chosen to reach the most accurate data by combining different perspectives on the subject matter. Data gathered by these three methods was triangulated to increase the validity and reliability of this research.FindingsThirteen benefits, ten challenges and four risks for the integrated use of BIM, RFID and WSN were identified. The results could aid the practitioners and researchers comprehend the pros and cons of this integration by representing SMEs’ valuable insights and perspectives about the current and future status, trends, limitations and requirements of the AECO industry. The identified risks and challenges show the requirements for future studies while the benefits demonstrate the capabilities and the potential contributions of this hybrid integration to the AECO industry.Originality/valueThe integration of BIM, RFID and WSN is still not commonly implemented in the AECO industry. Some studies focused on this topic; however, none of them reveals the benefits, risks and challenges for integrating BIM, RFID and WSN in a holistic manner. This research makes a significant contribution to the AECO literature and industry by uncovering the benefits, challenges and risks for the integrated use of BIM, RFID and WSN that could increase industry applications.

Dimensions of Internet of Things: Technological Taxonomy Architecture Applications and Open Challenges—A Systematic Review

We are traversing the growing emerging technology paradigms in today’s advanced technological world. In this present era, the Internet of Things (IoT) is extensively used in all sectors. IoT is the ecosystem of smart devices which contains sensors, smart objects, networking, and processing units. These integrated devices provide better services to the end user. IoT is impacting our environment and is becoming one of the most popular technologies. The leading use of IoT in human life is to track activities anywhere at any time. The utmost utilities achieved by IoT applications are decision-making and monitoring for efficient and effective management. In this paper, an extensive literature review on IoT has been done using the systematic literature review (SLR) technique. The main focus areas include commercial, environmental, healthcare, industrial, and smart cities. The issues related to the IoT are also discussed in detail. The purpose of this review is to identify the major areas of applications, different popular architectures, and their challenges. The various IoT applications are compared in accordance with technical features such as quality of service and environmental evaluation. This study can be utilized by the researchers to understand the concept of IoT and provides a roadmap to develop strategies for their future research work.

Advanced Security Framework for Internet of Things (IoT)

The stimulus to carry out this research was to identify and propose a secure framework for the Internet of Things (IoT). Due to the massive accessibility and interconnection of IoT devices, systems are at risk of being exploited by hackers. Therefore, there is a need to find an advanced security framework that covers data security, data confidentiality, and data integrity issues. The study uses a systematic literature review (SLR) technique and complete substantive literature is reviewed to find out the constructs and themes in the existing literature. We performed it in four steps, which were inclusion, eligibility, screening, and identification. We reviewed around 568 articles from well-reputable journals, and after exclusion, 260 articles and 54 reports were analyzed. We performed an analysis using MAXQDA in which the nodes and themes were first identified. After the classification, a qualitative model was generated using MAXQDA. The proposed model is supported by the literature so it will be useful for the IT managers, developers, and the users of IoT.

Factors Influencing the Implementation of Gamification for Learning in Information Systems Education

Current technological advancements urge institutions to generate graduates capable of contributing to the industrial world. Information Systems is one of the scientific subjects whose graduates play a significant part in the advancement of modern technology. As a result, lecturers in Information Systems education, particularly at the undergraduate level, must be able to retain and even improve students' interest in studying this field. Gamification is one method that can be used to accomplish this purpose. The goal of this study is to identify factors that determine the successful implementation of gamification for learning, particularly in the context of Information Systems Education at the undergraduate level. This study's methodology is based on a systematic literature review technique from previous studies. Motivation, engagement, perceived utility, game design, and student perspective were identified as elements influencing the effective use of gamification for learning, particularly in the field of Information Systems education.

Sustainable Human Resource Management: A Conceptual Framework

Organizations now a days strive for sustainability to follow regulations, fulfill customer requirements for sustainable products and to remain competitive in the market. Sustainability is an approach creating long term value for the organization by focusing on social, economic and environmental aspects. The concept of sustainability is incorporated in various sectors such as manufacturing, consumer goods, and food etc., however limited studies are conducted by focusing human resources. Using a systematic literature review technique, this study discusses the research work on sustainable human resource management (SHRM). Based on the findings, a conceptual framework is proposed for effective implementation of sustainable human resource management practices. The framework highlights 19 factors that constitute the three pillars of SHRM i.e. economy, society and environment. The findings will be beneficial for academicians and practitioners interested in exploring SHRM implementation issues and challenges at the workplace.

Micro-Level Factors that Affect Females’ Decisions Towards Leadership in Higher Education: a Literature Review

This paper is based on an ongoing PhD research named “Understanding the Lack of Female Leadership in Higher Education of Kazakhstan”. The aim of this study is to identify empirical studies that explored micro-level factors affecting female leadership in higher education. Thus, a systematic literature review technique was used to synthesise research from a gender perspective of leadership in higher education. An initial screening process resulted in a final sample of 37 appropriate studies. The synthesis of these empirical studies revealed that there are different leadership domains in higher education: academic and professional. Therefore, the micro-level factors that affect these domains include the purpose of doctoral studies, the change of interests, identity and gender, self-awareness, self-management, self esteem, self efficacy and work-life balance. This study contributes to the development of female leadership in higher education.

CULTURE, EDUCATION AND WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT: A LITERATURE REVIEW HIGHLIGHTING NEW RESEARCH OPPORTUNITIES

Given that water is a conditioning and irreplaceable element to the existence of life on Earth, equally present and future populations also depend on water to ensure their continuity and economic activities, biological and sociocultural factors that develop. Based on a review of the scientific literature available in EBSCO and Web of Science databases, this study aimed to investigate and discuss the existing relationships between culture and education in the context of water resources management. We conducted a systematic literature review technique in conjunction with a bibliometric analysis with the support of Rayyan, Microsoft Excel, and VOSviewer software. For the data collection, we evaluated the sample regarding the number of annual publications, the mapping of publications, and the relations network between the keywords created to identify new trends and a research agenda. The results highlighted the complexity of the relationship between culture, education, and water resources, revealing the need to deepen and advance research on the subject. In the analysis, we identified the need to consider man as the leading actor in a new structure in which education will be the leading mobilizer for constructing a new cultural perspective on water resource management.

Component Learning Community for Informal Education to Support Culinary Community at Era New Normal Covid-19: A Systematic Literature Review

Informal education will be successful as an alternative for the community because not all people are able to receive formal education. This study uses a qualitative method with a systematic literature review (SLR) technique to look for learning community components in informal education to support learning in the culinary community in the new normal era of Covid-19. The author collects, studies, and analyzes reference sources according to the specified keywords. Found 53 papers from 2002 to 2021 with background authors from academia, industry, and the public sector with reference sources from journals, conferences, white papers, and research reports. Systematic literature review results obtained 6 components of learning community in informal education, namely content, forum, method, technology, figure/layout, and human/social resources. The six components as a reference and the author's first step in the next research through searching for the characteristics of the learning community in the culinary field, then making a learning model of the culinary community. Because of the importance of the learning community component in informal education to help community members share knowledge, solve problems, share common goals and interests among community members.