ABSTRACT We investigate the possibility of determining the mass distribution of a gravitational lens via lensing observations. We consider an extended, compact gravitational lens, representing its static external gravitational potential via an infinite set of symmetric trace free (STF) multipole moments. Within the wave-optical treatment, we evaluate the caustics formed in the lens’s point spread function (PSF). We study the only quantity that is available in astronomical lensing observations: the image of that PSF formed by an imaging telescope. This observable may be used to recover some physical characteristics of the lens, including its shape, orientation, and composition. Illustrating this, we study exotic gravitational lenses formed by several well-known solids with uniform density. We show that when moments beyond the quadrupole are observed, some of the symmetry properties of the lens can be recovered. The presence of an octupole moment implies breaking the ‘north–south’ symmetry of the mass distribution in the lens. The presence of a rotated hexadecapole moment implies breaking axial symmetry. As such, if observations of lensed images allow the reconstruction of these moments, important information about the mass distribution and dynamics of the lens can be obtained. This may help with choosing the most appropriate mass profile that is used to characterize the mass distribution of astrophysical lenses, such as the dark matter haloes that are presumed to contain most of the mass of galaxies and clusters of galaxies. Our results are novel and offer new insight into gravitational lensing by realistic astrophysical systems.