Sweet-tasting Protein Research Articles

Developments in biotechnological production of sweet proteins

Most proteins are tasteless and flavorless, while some proteins elicit a sweet-taste response on the human palate. Six proteins, thaumatin, monellin, mabinlin, brazzein, egg lysozyme, and neoculin (previously considered as curculin) have been identified as sweet-tasting proteins. However, no common features among them have been observed. Herein, recent advances in the research of sweet-tasting proteins and the production of such proteins by biotechnological approaches are reviewed. Information on the structure-sweetness relationship for these proteins would help not only in the clarification of the mechanism of interaction of sweet-tasting proteins with their receptors, but also in the design of more effective low-calorie sweeteners.

Expression of the sweet-tasting plant protein brazzein in Escherichia coli and Lactococcus lactis: a path toward sweet lactic acid bacteria

Brazzein is an intensely sweet-tasting plant protein with good stability, which makes it an attractive alternative to sucrose. A brazzein gene has been designed, synthesized, and expressed in Escherichia coli at 30 degrees C to yield brazzein in a soluble form and in considerable quantity. Antibodies have been produced using brazzein fused to His-tag. Brazzein without the tag was sweet and resembled closely the taste of its native counterpart. The brazzein gene was also expressed in Lactococcus lactis, using a nisin-controlled expression system, to produce sweet-tasting lactic acid bacteria. The low level of expression was detected with anti-brazzein antibodies. Secretion of brazzein into the medium has not led to significant yield increase. Surprisingly, optimizing the codon usage for Lactococcus lactis led to a decrease in the yield of brazzein.

Extracellular Production of Neoculin, a Sweet-Tasting Heterodimeric Protein with Taste-Modifying Activity, by Aspergillus oryzae

Neoculin (NCL), a protein with sweetness approximately 500-fold that of sugar, can be utilized as a nonglycemic sweetener. It also has taste-modifying activity to convert sourness to sweetness. NCL is a heterodimer composed of an N-glycosylated acidic subunit (NAS) and a basic subunit (NBS), which are conjugated by disulfide bonds. For the production of recombinant NCL (rNCL) by Aspergillus oryzae, alpha-amylase with a KEX2 cleavage site, -K-R-, was fused upstream of each of NAS and NBS and the resulting fusion proteins were simultaneously expressed. For accurate and efficient cleavage of the fusion construct by KEX2-like protease, a triglycine motif was inserted after the KEX2 cleavage site. As NBS showed lower production efficiency than did NAS, a larger amount of the NBS expression plasmid than of NAS expression plasmid was introduced during cotransformation, resulting in successful production of rNCL in the culture medium. Moreover, to obtain a higher production yield of rNCL, the active form of hacA cDNA encoding a transcription factor that induces an unfolded protein response was cloned and expressed constitutively. This resulted in a 1.5-fold increase in the level of rNCL production (2.0 mg/liter). rNCL was purified by chromatography, and its NAS was found to be N-glycosylated as expected. The original sweetness and taste-modifying activity of rNCL were comparable to those of native NCL when confirmed by calcium imaging with human embryonic kidney cells expressing the human sweet taste receptor and by sensory tests.

Structure–Sweetness Relationship in Egg White Lysozyme: Role of Lysine and Arginine Residues on the Elicitation of Lysozyme Sweetness

Lysozyme is one of the sweet-tasting proteins. To clarify the structure-sweetness relationship and the basicity-sweetness relationship in lysozyme, we have generated lysozyme mutants with Pichia systems. Alanine substitution of lysine residues demonstrated that two out of six lysine residues, Lys13 and Lys96, are required for lysozyme sweetness, while the remaining four lysine residues do not play a significant role in the perception of sweetness. Arginine substitution of lysine residues revealed that the basicity, but not the shape, of the side chain plays a significant role in sweetness. Single alanine substitutions of arginine residues showed that three arginine residues, Arg14, Arg21, and Arg73, play significant roles in lysozyme sweetness, whereas Arg45, Arg68, Arg125 and chemical modification by 1,2-cyclohexanedione did not affect sweetness. From investigation of the charge-specific mutations, we found that the basicity of a broad surface region formed by five positively charged residues, Lys13, Lys96, Arg14, Arg21, and Arg73, is required for lysozyme sweetness. Differences in the threshold values among sweet-tasting proteins might be caused by the broadness and/or the density of charged residues on the protein surface.

Phylogenetic distribution, functional epitopes and evolution of the CSalphabeta superfamily.

A superfamily of proteins often conserves a common structural scaffold but develops diverse biochemical and biological functions during evolution. The understanding of evolutionary mechanisms responsible for this diversity is of fundamental importance not only in structural genomics but also in nature-guided drug design. A superfamily of peptides with a conserved CSalphabeta structural motif provides a considerably intriguing example to approach such an issue. The peptides from this superfamily have wide origins, ranging from plants to animals, and exhibit diverse biological activities, varying from a sweet-tasting protein to antibacterial defensins and animal toxins targeting ion channels. This review describes the phylogenetic distribution and structural classifi cation of this unique scaffold and provides new insights into its functional diversity from the perspective of sequence, structure and evolution.

Resolution of the structure of the allergenic and antifungal banana fruit thaumatin-like protein at 1.7-Å

The structure of a thaumatin-like protein from banana ( Musa acuminata) fruit, an allergen with antifungal properties, was solved at 1.7-Å-resolution, by X-ray crystallography. Though the banana protein exhibits a very similar overall fold as thaumatin it markedly differs from the sweet-tasting protein by the presence of a surface exposed electronegative cleft. Due to the presence of this electronegative cleft, the banana thaumatin-like protein (Ban-TLP) acquires a strong (local) electronegative character that eventually explains the observed antifungal activity. Our structural analysis also revealed the presence of conserved residues of exposed epitopic determinants that are presumably responsible for the allergenic properties of banana fruit towards susceptible individuals, and provided evidence that the Ban-TLP shares some structurally highly conserved IgE-binding epitopes with thaumatin-like proteins from fruits or pollen from other plants. In addition, some overlap was detected between the predicted IgE-binding epitopes of the Ban-TLP and IgE-binding epitopes previously identified in the mountain cedar Jun a 3 TLP aeroallergen. The presence of these common epitopes offers a molecular basis for the cross-reactivity between aeroallergens and fruit allergens.

Effects of Chemical Modification of Lysine Residues on the Sweetness of Lysozyme

Lysozyme is a sweet-tasting protein with a sweetness threshold value of around 7 microM. To clarify the effect of basicity at the side chain of lysine residues on the threshold values of sweetness, charge-specific chemical modifications such as guanidination, acetylation and phosphopyridoxylation of lysine residues were performed. Sensory analysis showed that the sweetness threshold value of lysozyme was not changed by guanidination, whereas it was increased markedly by acetylation and phosphopyridoxylation. To confirm the importance of the basicity in the lysine residues in detail, purification of acetylated (Ac-) and phosphopyridoxylated (PLP-) lysozymes using SP-ion exchange column chromatography was performed. The threshold values were not changed by modification with fewer than two residues (approximately 7 microM), whereas the threshold values significantly increased to 15 and 34 microM when tetra-Ac and tri-PLP, respectively. Furthermore, sweetness was not detected at 30 microM (hexa-, penta-Ac and tetra-PLP). It should be noted that removal of the negative charges of the phosphate groups in the tri-PLP lysozyme by acid phosphatase resulted in the recovery of sweetness (6.4 microM), indicating that basicity at the position of the lysine residues is responsible for lysozyme sweetness and that strict charge complementarities might be required for interaction to its putative receptor.

Brazzein, a Small, Sweet Protein: Effects of Mutations on its Structure, Dynamics and Functional Properties

The demand for non-calorigenic protein-based sweeteners with favorable taste properties is high. The optimal design of such sweeteners requires knowledge about structure–function relationships and the identification of chemical entities that trigger the sweetness response. Among the known, naturally occurring, sweet-tasting proteins, brazzein has properties that make it particularly attractive as a potential economic sweetener. It is highly stable over wide temperature and pH ranges and has taste properties that resemble those of carbohydrate sweeteners. Brazzein is a single polypeptide of 54 standard amino acids and contains no carbohydrate. The brazzein protein originally was purified from the fruit of Pentadiplandra brazzeana, a climbing vine that grows in Gabon, Zaire and Cameroon (Ming and Hellekant, 1994). The fruit is consumed by the local population and is prized for its sweetness. Pure brazzein has been shown to elicit sweetness responses in humans by taste trials and in a non-human primate (rhesus monkey) as determined from electrophysiological recordings of signals from the chorda tympani (van der Wel et al., 1989). Recently receptor proteins have been discovered that are responsive to sweet ligands. The human receptor appears to be a heterodimer of two conventional seven-transmembrane-helix Gcoupled type receptors (T1R2/T1R3) but with unusually large ectodomains ((Nelson et al., 2001; Li et al., 2002); P. Jiang and M. Max, personal communication). Different sweet proteins interact with and activate the same heterodimeric receptor in somewhat different ways and tentative models for such interactions have been elaborated ((Temussi, 2002); M. Max, personal communication). The discovery of the sweet taste heteroreceptor opens up exciting new avenues for research on the mechanism of action of sweet substances. Brazzein is an excellent candidate for experimental investigations of the chemical and structural requirements for extracellular triggering of a sweet response in humans and for understanding the mechanism of the signal transduction.

High yield secretion of the sweet-tasting protein lysozyme from the yeast Pichia pastoris

Hen egg lysozyme (HEL) is one of the sweet-tasting proteins. To understand why lysozyme is sweet, the enzyme was synthesized at high yields by a recombinant method. The mature HEL gene was cloned from a Taq polymerase-amplified PCR product into the Pichia pastoris expression and secretion vector pPIC6α. This expression vector contains both the Saccharomyces cerevisiae pre-pro α-mating factor secretion signal and the blasticidin resistance gene ( bsd) for selection of transformants in bacteria and yeast. Expression of HEL was carried out in fermenter cultures. Culture supernatants were concentrated by ultrafiltration and purified by CM-ion exchange chromatography. Approximately 400 mg L −1 of recombinant HEL was obtained. The high yield of recombinant lysozyme enabled us to perform a sensory analysis in humans. The purified recombinant lysozyme elicited as a sweet taste sensation as does the lysozyme purified directly from egg white, and showed full lytic activity against cells of Micrococcus luteus. These results demonstrate that the P. pastoris expression system with the blasticidin S selection system is useful in producing recombinant sweet-tasting protein in active form at a high yield.

The Mechanism of Interaction of Sweet Proteins with the T1R2-T1R3 Receptor: Evidence from the Solution Structure of G16A-MNEI

The mechanism by which sweet proteins elicit a response on the T1R2-T1R3 sweet taste receptor is still mostly unknown but has been so far related to the presence of “sweet fingers” on the protein surface able to interact with the same mechanism as that of low molecular mass sweeteners. In the search for the identification of sweet fingers, we have solved the solution structure of G16A MNEI, a structural mutant that shows a reduction of one order of magnitude in sweetness with respect to its parent protein, MNEI, a single-chain monellin. Comparison of the structures of wild-type monellin and its G16A mutant shows that the mutation does not affect the structure of potential glucophores but produces a distortion of the surface owing to the partial relative displacement of elements of secondary structure. These results show conclusively that sweet proteins do not possess a sweet finger and strongly support the hypothesis that the mechanism of interaction of sweet-tasting proteins with the recently identified T1R2-T1R3 GPC receptor is different from that of low molecular mass sweeteners.

Variable properties of transgenic cucumber plants containing the thaumatin II gene from Thaumatococcus daniellii

Thaumatin represents a unique class of the sweet-tasting plant proteins. Transgenic cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) plants with stable integrated constructs consisting of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter and thaumatin II cDNA were produced. Transformed cucumber plants were obtained using Agrobacterium tumefaciens, with one, two or five integration sites in diploid cucumber and with inheritance confirmed by a 3:1 Mendelian ratio and normal morphologies and viable seeds. Inter- and intra-transformant variabilities in the expression of the thaumatin II gene were observed. The variability was independent of integrated copy number of the T-DNA. Variation in thaumatin II protein accumulation levels in the ripe fruits and the lack of correlation between protein and mRNA levels were observed, suggesting that thaumatin may be controlled at the levels of both transcription and translation. Transgenic fruits accumulating thaumatin II protein exhibited sweet phenotype and positive correation between thaumatin accumulation levels and sweet taste intensity was noticed. Thaumatin II belongs to the pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins family. Some of the T2 progeny plants expressing thaumatin II protein did not exhibit tolerance for pathogenic fungus Pseudoperonospora cubensis. These results, together with previously reported results, suggest no relationship between transgenic protein levels and the increased tolerance phenotype.

Multistep nucleus formation and a separate subunit contribution of the amyloidgenesis of heat-denatured monellin.

Monellin (MN) is a sweet-tasting plant protein known to form fibrous aggregates in the heat-denatured state. Here the amyloid-type aggregation process of MN is extensively characterized. The amyloidgenesis was initiated in a highly denatured state of MN. A seeding effect of skipping a lag phase of the amyloid formation kinetics established a nucleation-dependent aggregation mechanism. A finely controlled experimental protocol revealed an additional prenucleus stage preceding the maturation of the nucleus, indicating that the initial lag phase is composed of multiple conformational events. The results obtained for the aggregation properties of the separate A and B subunit chains of MN and a recombinant single-chain MN suggest that the B chain exclusively contributed to the amyloid-type aggregation. These findings suggest a scheme for the amyloidgenesis of MN and their subunits, and provide a unique model of amyloidgenesis that is regulated by the subunit composition of protein.

Purification of an osmotin-like protein from the seeds of Benincasa hispida and cloning of the gene encoding this protein

A pathogenesis-related (PR) protein was purified from the seeds of Benincasa hispida, which is a medicinal plant and a member of the Cucurbitaceae family. Purification was achieved by using a procedure consisting of an acid treatment step followed by two chromatography steps. The protein is a basic protein with molecular mass of ∼28 kDa. The sequences of the N-terminal 30 amino acids and four peptides generated from protease digestion were determined. These sequences indicated that the protein is an osmotin-like protein (OLP). Osmotin and OLPs are members of the thaumatin-like, PR-5 family of the PR proteins. A genomic clone of the gene encoding the protein was isolated and sequenced. The predicted protein has a signal peptide of 18 amino acids, and the mature protein has a molecular mass of 24.8 kDa with an isoelectric point of 7.67. The protein has 17 cysteine residues, of which 16 appear in the same positions as those appear in the sweet-tasting protein thaumatin and several other thaumatin-like proteins. Southern hybridization analysis indicated that the gene encoding the protein is a single copy gene. A computer-generated, three-dimensional model of the protein is presented.

Overexpression and lack of degradation of thaumatin in an aspergillopepsin A-defective mutant of Aspergillus awamori containing an insertion in the pepA gene.

A gene encoding the sweet-tasting protein thaumatin (tha) with optimized codon usage was expressed in Aspergillus awamori. Mutants of A. awamori with reduced proteolytic activity were isolated. One of these mutants, named lpr66, contained an insertion of about 200 bp in the pepA gene, resulting in an inactive aspergillopepsin A. In vitro thaumatin degradation tests confirmed that culture broths of mutant lpr66 showed only a small thaumatin-degrading activity. A. awamori lpr66 has been used as host strain for thaumatin expression cassettes containing the tha gene under the control of either the cahB (cephalosporin acetylhydrolase) promoter of Acremonium chrysogenum or the gdhA (glutamate dehydrogenase) promoter of Aspergillus awamori. Residual proteolytic activities were repressed by using a mixture of glucose and sucrose as carbon sources and L-asparagine as nitrogen source. Degradation of thaumatin by acidic proteases was prevented by maintaining the pH value at 6.2 in the fermentor. Expression of cassettes containing the gdhA promoter was optimal in ammonium sulfate as nitrogen source, whereas transformants expressing the tha gene from the cahB promoter yielded higher thaumatin levels using L-asparagine as nitrogen source. Under optimal fermentation conditions, yields of 105 mg thaumatin/l were obtained, thus making this fermentation a process of industrial interest.

Characterization of five new low-molecular-mass trypsin inhibitors from white mustard (Sinapis alba L.) seed.

Five new low-molecular-mass trypsin inhibitors belonging to the RTI/MTI-2 family were identified from white mustard (Sinapis alba L. ; MTI-2) seed. Purified MTI-2 consisted of a peptide mixture, displaying Ile or Arg at position 43, Trp or kynurenine (Kyn) at position 44, and C-terminal ragged ends. The occurrence of Ile or Arg at position 43 suggested that MTI-2 inhibitors originated from different genes. The presence of 5-oxo-proline (pyroglutamic acid; 5-oxoPro1) and Kyn44 reflected post-translational processing of the serine proteinase inhibitor. MTI-2 showed approximately 70% amino-acid identity with low-molecular-mass trypsin inhibitors isolated from oil rape (Brassica napus var. oleifera; RTI-III) seed and with serine proteinase inhibitors mapped in Arabidopsis thaliana chromosome II (ATTI). Furthermore, MTI-2 was homologous to brazzein, the sweet-tasting protein from Pentadiplandra brazzeana Baillon fruit ( approximately 30% amino-acid identity). Although snake-venom toxins showed a low amino-acid identity (< 20%) with MTI-2, RTI-III, and ATTI, some structurally relevant residues were conserved. The disulfide bridge pattern of MTI-2 (Cys5-Cys27, Cys18-Cys31, Cys42-Cys52, and Cys54-Cys57) corresponded to that of RTI-III and of snake-venom toxins, being different from that of brazzein. Therefore, protein similarity might be attributable to the three-dimensional arrangement rather than to the amino-acid sequence. Values of Ka for MTI-2 binding to bovine beta-trypsin (trypsin) and bovine alpha-chymotrypsin were 6.3 x 109 M-1 and 2.0 x 106 M-1, respectively, at pH 8.0 and 21.0 degrees C. Moreover, values of kon for MTI-2 binding to trypsin and of koff for the dissociation of the serine proteinase:inhibitor complex were 5.6 x 105 M-1.s-1 and 8.9 x 10-5 M-1.s-1, respectively, at pH 8.0 and 21.0 degrees C. Despite the heterogeneity of the purified inhibitor peptide mixture, the inhibition properties of the different MTI-2 inhibitors were indistinguishable.

Refolding the sweet-tasting protein thaumatin II from insoluble inclusion bodies synthesised in Escherichia coli

A synthetic gene encoding the amino acid sequence of the strongly sweet-tasting protein thaumatin II has been expressed in Escherichia coli. The recombinant protein has been renatured from inclusion bodies using a reduced/oxidized glutathione system to yield a purified protein preparation that is indistinguishable from native thaumatin with respect to its biochemical, spectroscopic and organoleptic properties.

Efficient Production of Recombinant Brazzein, a Small, Heat-Stable, Sweet-Tasting Protein of Plant Origin

Brazzein is a 54-amino-acid sweet-tasting protein first isolated from the fruit of Pentadiplandra brazzeana Baillon found in West Africa. Brazzein, as isolated from the fruit, is 500 times sweeter than sucrose on a weight basis (9500 times sweeter on a per-molecule basis). A minor component of brazzein from fruit, des-pGlu1-brazzein, has 53 amino acid residues and has twice the sweetness of the parent protein. We have designed a gene for des-pGlu1- brazzein that incorporates codons that are optimal for protein production in Escherichia coli. Production of brazzein from the chemically synthesized gene resulted in recombinant protein with sweetness similar to that of brazzein isolated from the original source. The best yields were achieved by producing brazzein as a fusion with staphylococcal nuclease with a designed cyanogen bromide cleavage site. Because of its intense sweetness and stability at high pH and temperature, brazzein is an ideal system for investigating the chemical and structural requirements involved in sweet-taste properties. This efficient protein production system for brazzein will facilitate such investigations.

Sweetness Determinant Sites of Brazzein, a Small, Heat-Stable, Sweet-Tasting Protein

Brazzein, originally isolated from the fruit of the African plant Pentadiplandra brazzeana Baillon, is the smallest, most heat-stable and pH-stable member of the set of proteins known to have intrinsic sweetness. These properties make brazzein an ideal system for investigating the chemical and structural requirements of a sweet-tasting protein. We have used the three-dimensional structure of the protein (J. E. Caldwell et al. (1998) Nat. Struct. Biol. 5, 427–431) as a guide in designing 15 synthetic genes in expression constructs aimed at delineating the sweetness determinants of brazzein. Protein was produced heterologously in Escherichia coli, isolated, and purified as described in the companion paper (Assadi-Porter, F. M., Aceti, D., Cheng, H., and Markley, J. L., this issue). Analysis by one-dimensional 1H NMR spectroscopy indicated that all but one of these variants had folded properly under the conditions used. A taste panel compared the gustatory properties of solutions of these proteins to those of sucrose and brazzein isolated from fruit. Of the 14 mutations in the des-pGlu1-brazzein background, four exhibited almost no sweetness, six had significantly reduced sweetness, two had taste properties equivalent to des-pGlu1-brazzein (two times as sweet as the major form of brazzein isolated from fruit which contains pGlu1), and two were about twice as sweet as des-pGlu1-brazzein. Overall, the results suggest that two regions of the protein are critical for the sweetness of brazzein: a region that includes the N- and C-termini of the protein, which are located close to one another, and a region that includes the flexible loop around Arg43.

Studies on solution NMR structure of brazzein

Brazzein is a sweet-tasting protein isolated from the fruit of West African plantPentadiplandra brazzeana Baillon. It is the smallest and the most water-soluble sweet protein discovered so far and is highly thermostable. The proton NMR study of brazzein at 600 MHz (pH 3.5, 300 K) is presented. The complete sequence specific assignments of the individual backbone and sidechain proton resonances were achieved using through-bond and through-space connectivities obtained from standard two-dimensional NMR techniques. The secondary structure of brazzein contains one alpha-helix (residues 21-29), one short 3(10)-helix (residues 14-17), two strands of antiparallel beta-sheet (residues 34-39, 44-50) and probably a third strand (residues 5-7) near the N-terminus. A comparative analysis found that brazzein shares a so-called 'cysteine-stabilized alpha-beta' (CSalphabeta) motif with scorpion neurotoxins, insect defensins and plant gamma - thionins. The significance of this multi-function motif, the possible active sites and the structural basis of themostability were discussed.

Amyloid-like aggregates of a plant protein: a case of a sweet-tasting protein, monellin

We report here a novel case of amyloid-like aggregation of a plant protein. A sweet-tasting protein, monellin, experiences an irreversible heat denaturation at pH 2.5 and 85°C. Addition of 100 mM NaCl couples this process with protein aggregation. The aggregates were structured as regular fibers with ∼10 nm width and capable of binding to Congo red, similarly to well-known amyloid fibrils. The amyloid-like aggregation process was also successfully monitored with a calorimetric method. This work supports the universality of the amyloid-like aggregation, not restricted to some special categories of protein.