The immune competence of a group of 276 patients with suspected breast cancer has been assessed using a spectrum of tests: the peripheral lymphocyte count, serum immunoglobulin levels, lymphocyte response to phytohemagglutinin (PHA), Mantoux test, and dinitrochlorobenzene (DNCB) skin test. All tests were completed prior to any form of treatment as the initial part of an ongoing, long-term assessment which will ultimately relate immune competence to prognosis. 225 patients with breast cancer were allocated into stages based on their TNM status. The remaining 51 patients proved to have benign breast disease and made up the control group. In analysis, control patients were compared with “early” breast cancer patients, while the effect of advancing disease was assessed by betweenstage comparisons in the cancer group. There were no significant differences between “early” breast cancer and control patients or between cancer stages in peripheral lymphocyte count, serum immunoglobulin levels, lymphocyte response to PHA, or Mantoux responses. Age was found to have a crucial effect on some of these parameters and some apparent differences between the various groups lost significance after appropriate allowances were made for age. Important differences seen with the DNCB test persisted after allowing for age effects. Responses to DNCB were significantly depressed in patients with “early” breast cancer compared to controls. Patients with disseminated cancer showed greater depression than early breast cancer patients, but surprisingly, patients with locally advanced tumors had good responses to DNCB. Possible reasons for the paradoxical preservation of DNCB reactivity in patients with locally advanced cancer are discussed. The DNCB test is the most discriminating of the five tests of immune function studied.
Read full abstract