To determine whether a policy based on provisional replacement of catheters every 5 days had an impact on the incidence of arterial catheter-related bloodstream infections in a population of adult surgical intensive care unit patients. Prepost study in which all patients with an arterial catheter who were admitted between 1997 and 2004 were observed. Scheduled replacement of arterial catheters every 5 days during period A (before 2000) was compared to nonscheduled replacement during period B (after 2000). A 20-bed surgical intensive care unit at a French university hospital. All intensive care unit patients requiring an arterial catheter. Modification to the catheter maintenance policies between period A and period B. A total of 1,672 consecutive patients were included, and 3,247 arterial catheters were analyzed, yielding an average number of 1.9 (sd, 1.7) arterial catheters per patient. The rate of colonization (14.2% before 2000 vs. 16.4% after 2000; p = .10) and the incidence density of arterial catheter colonization (31.32 [95% confidence interval] 27.07-36.25 per 1,000 catheter-days before 2000 vs. 29.79 [95% confidence interval, 26.72-33.21] per 1,000 catheter-days after 2000; p = .11) did not differ significantly between the two periods. However, the rate of arterial catheter-related bloodstream infections (1.4% before 2000 vs. 0.6% after 2000; p = .01) and the arterial catheter-related bloodstream infections incidence density (3.13 [95% confidence interval, 1.97-4.97] before 2000 vs. 1.01 [95% confidence interval, 0.56-1.82] per 1,000 catheter-days after 2000; p < .0001) was significantly higher before 2000. Discontinuation of scheduled replacement of arterial catheters every 5 days did not increase the risk of colonization but decreased the risk of bloodstream infections.