ABSTRACT This review is focused on the bee structure observed by atomic force microscopy (AFM). For more than 20 years, the chemical origin and formation mechanism of the bee structure have been studied with the aid of AFM, resulting in numerous perspectives and controversies. Specifically, two dominant views dominate the debate on the chemical origin of bee structures. Some scholars tend to believe that the chemical composition of the bee structure is highly related to wax, while others consider that it is related to asphaltenes. In recent years, it has been acknowledged that the bee structure solely pertains to the microstructure on the surface of bitumen rather than its internal structure. The formation mechanism of the bee structure is elucidated by introducing the surface wrinkling theory of multilayer composites from the field of elastic-viscoelastic material. Based on the investigation of articles, this review concludes that the bee structure is more likely the wax crystallisation and surface wrinkling, and there exist certain specific correlations between the morphology of bee structures and macroscopic properties of bitumen. Furthermore, it is recommended that the bitumen research community adopt a standardised and simplified sample preparation procedure to enhance experimental comparability.
Read full abstract