Surface Forces Apparatus Research Articles

Size compatibility and concentration dependent supramolecular host\u2013guest interactions at interfaces

The quantification of supramolecular host–guest interactions is important for finely modulating supramolecular systems. Previously, most host–guest interactions quantified using force spectroscopic techniques have been reported in force units. However, accurately evaluating the adhesion energies of host–guest pairs remains challenging. Herein, using a surface forces apparatus, we directly quantify the interaction energies between cyclodextrin (CD)-modified surfaces and ditopic adamantane (DAd) molecules in water as a function of the DAd concentration and the CD cavity size. The adhesion energy of the β-CD–DAd complex drastically increased with increasing DAd concentration and reached saturation. Moreover, the molecular adhesion energy of a single host–guest inclusion complex was evaluated to be ~9.51 kBT. This approach has potential for quantifying fundamental information toward furthering the understanding of supramolecular chemistry and its applications, such as molecular actuators, underwater adhesives, and biosensors, which require precise tuning of specific host–guest interactions.

Simulation of surface force apparatus

Simulation of the surface force apparatus (SFA: ESF-5000K, Elionix, Inc.) using elastic contact theory was performed to calculate the surface force and approach distance between sphere and plane. A series of experimental processes from contact to pull-off between a spherical probe and a plane sample was targeted in the simulation, and the mutual displacement of the sphere was calculated using JKR elastic contact theory and the van der Waals interaction force. In this study, the glass (BK7) was used for the spherical probe, while Si and Pt were used for the plane samples. Comparison of the theoretical calculation results with the experimental results confirmed the validity of the simulations and clarified the contact properties between the sphere and plane sample. The difference between the refractive index of the actual material and the ideal value may cause the theoretical curve to deviate from the experimental results.

Nano-confined electrochemical reaction studied by electrochemical surface forces apparatus.

Electrochemical reactions in a nano-space are different from those in bulk solutions due to structuring of the liquid molecules and peculiar ion behavior at the electric double layer and are important for applications involving sensors and energy devices. The electrochemical surface forces apparatus (EC-SFA) we developed enabled us to study the electrochemical reactions in a solution nano-confined between the electrodes with varying distance (D) at nm resolution. We recorded measurements of the current-distance profiles due to the electrochemical reaction of the redox couples in the electrolyte nano-confined between Pt electrodes using our EC-SFA. We observed a long-range feedback current due to redox cycling and the sudden current increase at a short distance, the latter for the first time. This sudden current increase was two orders greater than the conventional feedback current and was observed at D < 5 nm when the electrodes were approaching and D < 200 nm on separation. We simultaneously measured the electric double layer force and the current between the electrodes in the solution to study the mechanisms of this sudden current increase in the short distance range. The results revealed a molecular insight as to how the redox species affect the current between two electrodes under nano-confinement. This study demonstrated that EC-SFA is a powerful tool for obtaining fundamental knowledge about the nano-confined electrochemical reactions for nanoelectrodes which can be applied to sensors and energy devices.

Microscopic origin of the effect of substrate metallicity on interfacial free energies

We investigate the effect of the metallic character of solid substrates on solid-liquid interfacial thermodynamics using molecular simulations. Building on the recent development of a semiclassical Thomas-Fermi model to tune the metallicity in classical molecular dynamics simulations, we introduce a thermodynamic integration framework to compute the evolution of the interfacial free energy as a function of the Thomas-Fermi screening length. We validate this approach against analytical results for empty capacitors and by comparing the predictions in the presence of an electrolyte with values determined from the contact angle of droplets on the surface. The general expression derived in this work highlights the role of the charge distribution within the metal. We further propose a simple model to interpret the evolution of the interfacial free energy with voltage and Thomas-Fermi length, which allows us to identify the charge correlations within the metal as the microscopic origin of the evolution of the interfacial free energy with the metallic character of the substrate. This methodology opens the door to the molecular-scale study of the effect of the metallic character of the substrate on confinement-induced transitions in ionic systems, as reported in recent atomic force microscopy and surface force apparatus experiments.

The contribution of plastic sink-in to the static friction of single asperity microscopic contacts

We report microscale friction experiments for diamond/metal and diamond/silica contacts under gigapascal contact pressures. Using a new nanoprobe technique that has a sufficient dynamic range of force and stiffness, we demonstrate the processes involved in the transition from purely interface sliding at the nanoscale to the situation where at least one of the sliding bodies undergoes some plastic deformation. For sliding of micrometre-sized tips on metallic substrates, additional local plastic yielding of the substrate resulting from tangential tractions causes the tip to sink into the surface, increasing the contact area in the direction of loading and resulting in a static friction coefficient higher than the kinetic during ploughing. This sink-in is largely absent in fused silica, and no friction drop is observed, along with lower friction in general. The transition from sink-in within the static friction regime to ploughing in the sliding friction regime is mediated by failure of the contact interface, indicated by a sharp increase in energy dissipation. At lower contact pressures, the elastic interfacial sliding behaviour characteristic of scanning probe or surface force apparatus experiments is recovered, bridging the gap between the exotic realm of nanotribology and plasticity-dominated macroscale friction.

Adsorption and interaction forces of commercial Poly(naphthalene sulfonate) (PNS) and Poly(carboxylate ether) (PCE) polyelectrolytes with negatively charged surfaces in monovalent and divalent electrolytes

Adsorption of polyelectrolytes on colloidal particles alters the interaction forces and rheological properties of colloidal suspensions. Poly(naphthalene sulfonate) (PNS) and poly(carboxylate ether) (PCE) polyelectrolytes are commonly added to improve the flowability of hydrated cement paste in low-water conditions. The interactions of commercial PNS and PCE admixtures with negatively charged mica in aqueous electrolytes were directly studied with a surface forces apparatus in this work. In 0.1 M K2SO4, robust adsorption of PNS induced a strong steric repulsion. A slightly thicker adsorption layer formed in low ionic strength 5 mM Ca(NO3)2 exhibiting long-range electrostatic repulsion and short-range steric repulsion. Increasing the Ca(NO3)2 concentration to 0.1 M doubled the adsorption layer thickness and strongly screened any electrostatic repulsion. Contact of the adsorbed PNS layers caused weak physical cohesion under both low and high calcium concentrations presumably due to Ca2+ ion bridging of the opposing PNS layers. These findings indicate that (i) divalent Ca2+ possesses a much stronger ability than monovalent K+ to assemble PNS molecules resulting in significantly thicker adsorption and (ii) the interaction force between PNS adsorption layers in high ionic strength conditions is dominated by steric repulsion. In comparison, PCE did not appreciably adsorb from 0.1 M Ca(NO3)2. This finding challenges the well-accepted divalent ion bridging adsorption mechanism of PCE onto negatively charged surfaces and warrants further study.

Mussel-Inspired Multiloop Polyethers for Antifouling Surfaces.

Despite the widespread use of polymers for antifouling coatings, the effect of the polymeric topology on the antifouling property has been largely underexplored. Unlike conventional brush polymers, a loop conformation often leads to strong steric stabilization of surfaces and antifouling and lubricating behavior owing to the large excluded volume and reduced chain ends. Herein, we present highly antifouling multiloop polyethers functionalized with a mussel-inspired catechol moiety with varying loop dimensions. Specifically, a series of polyethers with varying catechol contents were synthesized via anionic ring-opening polymerization by using triethylene glycol glycidyl ether (TEG) and catechol-acetonide glycidyl ether (CAG) to afford poly(TEG-co-CAG)n. The versatile adsorption and antifouling effects of multiloop polyethers were evaluated using atomic force microscopy and a quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation. Furthermore, the crucial role of the loop dimension in the antifouling properties was analyzed via a surface force apparatus and a cell attachment assay. This study provides a new platform for the development of versatile antifouling polymers with varying topologies.

Lipid Anchoring Improves Lubrication and Wear Resistance of the Collagen I Matrix.

Osteoarthritis is a prevalent degenerative joint disease characterized by progressive articular cartilage loss and destruction. The resultant increase in friction causes severe pain. The collagen I matrix (COL I) has been used clinically for cartilage repair; however, how COL I acts at cartilage surfaces is unclear. Here, we studied adsorption and lubrication of synovial fluid components, albumin, γ-globulin, and the phospholipid DPPC, on COL I under physiological conditions using surface plasmon resonance and an in situ sensing surface force apparatus. Our results revealed COL I had poor lubrication ability, a fairly high coefficient of friction (COF, μ = 0.651 ± 0.013), and surface damage under a 7 mN load. DPPC formed an improved lubricating layer on COL I (μ = 0.072 ± 0.016). In sharp contrast, albumin and γ-globulin exhibited poor lubrication with an order of magnitude higher COF but still provided benefits by protecting COL I from wear. Hence, DPPC on COL I may help optimize COL I implantation design.

Understanding and Controlling Mode Hybridization in Multicavity Optical Resonators Using Quantum Theory and the Surface Forces Apparatus.

Optical fields in metal-dielectric multilayers display typical features of quantum systems, such as energy level quantization and avoided crossing, underpinned by an isomorphism between the Helmholtz and Schrödinger wave equations. This article builds on the fundamental concepts and methods of quantum theory to facilitate the understanding and design of multicavity resonators. It also introduces the surface forces apparatus (SFA) as a powerful tool for rapid, continuous, and extensive characterization of mode dispersion and hybridization. Instead of fabricating many different resonators, two equal metal-dielectric-metal microcavities were created on glass lenses and displaced relative to each other in a transparent silicone oil using the SFA. The fluid thickness was controlled in real time with nanometer accuracy from more than 50 μm to less than 20 nm, reaching mechanical contact between the outer cavities in a few minutes. The fluid gap acted as a third microcavity providing optical coupling and producing a complex pattern of resonance splitting as a function of the variable thickness. An optical wave in this symmetric three-cavity resonator emulated a quantum particle with nonzero mass in a potential comprising three square wells. Interference between the wells produced a 3-fold splitting of degenerate energy levels due to hybridization. The experimental results could be explained using the standard methods and formalism of quantum mechanics, including symmetry operators and the variational method. Notably, the interaction between square wells produced bonding, antibonding, and nonbonding states that are analogous to hybridized molecular orbitals and are relevant to the design of “epsilon-near-zero” devices with vanishing dielectric permittivity.

Nanometer-Scale Force Profiles of Short Single- and Double-Stranded DNA Molecules on a Gold Surface Measured Using a Surface Forces Apparatus.

Using a surface forces apparatus (SFA), we have studied the nanomechanical behavior of short single-stranded and partially and fully double-stranded DNA molecules attached via one end to a self-assembled monolayer on a gold surface. Our results confirm the previously proposed "mushroom-like" polymer structure for surface-attached, single-stranded DNA at low packing density and a "brush-like" structure for the same construct at higher density. At low density we observe a transition to "rigid rod" behavior upon addition of DNA complementary to the surface-attached single strand as the fraction of molecules that are double-stranded increases, with a concomitant increase in the SFA-observed thickness of the monolayer and the characteristic length of the observed repulsive forces. At higher densities, in contrast, this transition is effectively eliminated, presumably because the single-stranded state is already extended in its "brush" state. Taken together, these studies offer insights into the structure and physics of surface-attached short DNAs, providing new guidance for the rational design of DNA-modified functional surfaces.

Mechanistic understanding of catechols and integration into an electrochemically cross-linked mussel foot inspired adhesive hydrogel

Catechol reaction mechanisms form the basis of marine mussel adhesion, allowing for bond formation and cross-linking in wet saline environments. To mimic mussel foot adhesion and develop new bioadhesive underwater glues, it is essential to understand and learn to control their redox activity as well as their chemical reactivity. Here, we study the electrochemical characteristics of functionalized catechols to further understand their reaction mechanisms and find a stable and controllable molecule that we subsequently integrate into a polymer to form a highly adhesive hydrogel. Contradictory to previous hypotheses, 3,4-dihydroxy-L-phenylalanine is shown to follow a Schiff-base reaction whereas dopamine shows an intramolecular ring formation. Dihydrocaffeic acid proved to be stable and was substituted onto a poly(allylamine) backbone and electrochemically cross-linked to form an adhesive hydrogel that was tested using a surface forces apparatus. The hydrogel's compression and dehydration dependent adhesive strength have proven to be higher than in mussel foot proteins (mfp-3 and mfp-5). Controlling catechol reaction mechanisms and integrating them into stable electrochemically depositable macroscopic structures is an important step in designing new biological coatings and underwater and biomedical adhesives.

Forces between mica and end-grafted statistical copolymers of sulfobetaine and oligoethylene glycol in aqueous electrolyte solutions

This study quantified the interfacial forces associated with end-grafted, statistical (AB) co-polymers of sulfobetaine methacrylate (SBMA) and oligoethylene glycol methacrylate (OEGMA) (poly(SBMA-co-OEGMA)). Surface force apparatus measurements compared forces between mica and end-grafted copolymers containing 0, 40, or 80 mol% SBMA. Studies compared forces measured at low grafting density (weakly overlapping chains) and at high density (brushes). At high density, the range of repulsive forces did not change significantly with increasing SBMA content. By contrast, at low density, both the range and the amplitude of the repulsion increased with the percentage of SBMA in the chains. The ionic strength dependence of the film thickness and repulsive forces increased similarly with SBMA content, reflecting the increasing influence of charged monomers and their interactions with ions in solution. The forces could be described by models of simple polymers in good solvent. However, the forces and fitted model parameters change continuously with the SBMA content. The latter behavior suggests that ethyene glycol and sulfobetaine behave as non-interacting, miscible monomers that contribute independently to the interfacial forces. The results suggest that molecular scale properties of statistical poly (SBMA-co-OEGMA) films can be readily tuned by simple variation of the monomer ratios.

Lateral and Normal Capillary Force Evolution of a Reciprocating Liquid Bridge.

Capillary forces of a shearing liquid bridge can significantly affect the friction and adhesion of interacting surfaces, but the underlying mechanisms remain unclear. We custom built a surface force apparatus (SFA, ±2 μN) equipped with in situ optical microscopy and performed normal and lateral force measurements on a reciprocating water bridge formed between two flat plates. A modified wedge method was developed to correct the unique force measurement errors caused by the changing bridge geometry and position. The results found (1) strong linear relations among the bridge shear displacement, the cosine difference between the left and right contact angles, and the lateral adhesion force and (2) the normal adhesion force increased monotonically up to 13% as the bridge geometry approached its axisymmetric state. Quasi-static force analyses based on a newly developed decahedral model showed good agreement with the experiments and improved accuracy compared with that of cylindrical or rectangular column models previously proposed in the literature. Although limited in certain aspects, this study may (1) prove helpful to the design and analysis of liquid bridge force experiments on platforms similar to the SFA used in this study and (2) help to bridge the gap between friction and liquid bridge physics in the literature.

Hydration Forces Dominate Surface Charge Dependent Lipid Bilayer Interactions under Physiological Conditions.

Lipid bilayer interactions are essential to a vast range of biological functions, such as intracellular transport mechanisms. Surface charging mediated by concentration dependent ion adsorption and desorption on lipid headgroups alters electric double layers as well as van der Waals and steric hydration forces of interacting bilayers. Here, we directly measure bilayer interactions during charge modulation in a symmetrically polarized electrochemical three-mirror interferometer surface forces apparatus. We quantify polarization and concentration dependent hydration and electric double layer forces due to cation adsorption/desorption. Our results demonstrate that exponential hydration layer interactions effectively describe surface potential dependent surface forces due to cation adsorption at high salt concentrations. Hence, electric double layers of lipid bilayers are exclusively dominated by inner Helmholtz charge regulation under physiological conditions. These results are important for rationalizing bilayer behavior under physiological conditions, where charge and concentration modulation may act as biological triggers for function and signaling.

Multiresponsive Microgels: Toward an Independent Tuning of Swelling and Surface Properties.

Dual-responsive poly-(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM) microgels surface-functionalized with polyethylene glycol (PEG) or poly-2-dimethylaminoethyl methacrylate (PDMAEMA) were developed to enable the swelling behavior and surface properties of the microgels to be tuned independently. The thermo-triggered swelling and pH-triggered surface properties of the microgels were investigated in aqueous suspensions using dynamic light scattering and on substrates using the surface forces apparatus. Grafting polymer chains on the microgel surface did not impede the thermo-triggered swelling behavior of the microgels in suspensions and immobilized on substrates. An unprecedented decoupling of the swelling behavior and surface properties could be obtained. More particularly, the thermo-triggered swelling behavior of the PNIPAM underlying microstructure could be tuned below and above the phase transition temperature with no change in the surface potential and adhesion provided by the surface non-responsive PEG.

Molecular Context of Dopa Influences Adhesion of Mussel-Inspired Peptides.

Improving adhesives for wet surfaces is an ongoing challenge. While the adhesive proteins of marine mussels have inspired many synthetic wet adhesives, the mechanisms of mussel adhesion are still not fully understood. Using surface forces apparatus (SFA) measurements and replica-exchange and umbrella-sampling molecular dynamics simulations, we probed the relationships between the sequence, structure, and adhesion of mussel-inspired peptides. Experimental and computational results reveal that peptides derived from mussel foot protein 3 slow (mfp-3s) containing 3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine (Dopa), a post-translationally modified variant of tyrosine commonly found in mussel foot proteins, form adhesive monolayers on mica. In contrast, peptides with tyrosine adsorb as weakly adhesive clusters. We further considered simulations of mfp-3s derivatives on a range of hydrophobic and hydrophilic organic and inorganic surfaces (including silica, self-assembled monolayers, and a lipid bilayer) and demonstrated that the chemical character of the target surface and proximity of cationic and hydrophobic residues to Dopa affect peptide adsorption and adhesion. Collectively, our results suggest that conversion of tyrosine to Dopa in hydrophobic, sparsely charged peptides influences peptide self-association and ultimately dictates their adhesive performance.

Lubricin-Inspired Loop Zwitterionic Peptide for Fabrication of Superior Antifouling Surfaces.

Biofouling represents great challenges in many applications, and zwitterionic peptides have been a promising candidate due to their biocompatibility and excellent antifouling performance. Inspired by lubricin, we designed a loop-like zwitterionic peptide and investigated the effect of conformation (linear or loop) on the antifouling properties using a combination of surface plasma resonance (SPR), surface force apparatus (SFA), and all atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulation techniques. Our results demonstrate that the loop-like zwitterionic peptides perform better in resisting the adsorption of proteins and bacteria. SFA measurements show that the loop-like peptides reduce the adhesion between the modified surface and the modeling foulant lysozyme. All atomistic MD simulations reveal that the loop-like zwitterionic peptides are more rigid than the linear-like zwitterionic peptides and avoid the penetration of the terminus into the foulants, which lower the interaction between the zwitterionic peptides and foulants. Besides, the loop-like zwitterionic peptides avoid the aggregation of the chains and bind more water, improving the hydrophilicity and antifouling performance. Altogether, this study provides a more comprehensive understanding of the conformation effect of zwitterionic peptides on their antifouling properties, which may contribute to designing novel antifouling materials in various biomedical applications.

Ionic strength dependent forces between end-grafted Poly(sulfobetaine) films and mica

The molecular surface properties of zwitterionic polymer coatings are central to their ultra-low fouling properties and effectiveness as steric stabilizers in concentrated salt solutions. Here, Surface Force Apparatus measurements quantified the molecular forces between end-grafted poly(sulfobetaine) methacrylate thin films and mica, as a function of the chain grafting density and ionic strength. These results demonstrate that, at the ionic strengths considered, end-grafted poly(sulfobetaine) films can be described by models for polymers in good solvent. Parameters determined from data fits to the Milner-Witten-Cates or Dolan and Edwards models for dense or dilute chains, respectively, varied with ionic strength, in ways that reflect poly(sulfobetaine) swelling and the increased excluded volume strength of chain segments. These force measurements provide new insight into how polymer coverage and salt cooperate to regulate repulsive poly(sulfobetaine) steric barriers. These findings have implications for the design of grafted poly(sulfobetaine) as colloidal stabilizers or nonfouling surface coatings.

Adaptive amphiphilic interaction mechanism of hydroxypropyl methylcellulose in water

Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC), an FDA-approved water-soluble cellulose derivative, has been used in various wet-adhesion applications in construction products, paints, and drug delivery for 70 years. Despite the various applications, its adhesion mechanism in water has not been elucidated. Here, we measure the adhesion characteristics of HPMC against itself, hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfaces as a function of temperature using a surface forces apparatus (SFA) in water. The results show that HPMC adheres strongly to all tested surfaces, regardless of hydrophobicity. The adhesive strength of HPMC increases with temperature because of entropy-driven hydrophobic interactions and is comparable to or exceeds the wet-adhesion strength of most biological adhesives, including those of mussels and cephalopods. In addition, the elevated temperature induces swelling in HPMC layer, resulting in the exposure of more hydrogen bonding sites, thereby increasing adhesion with the hydrophilic surface. The bulk compression test of the HPMC–silica composite material is consistent with the SFA data and indicates that the water content and temperature are critical variables for the adhesion of HPMC to inorganic surfaces regardless of hydrophobicity. Because adhesive and coating technologies have shifted toward environmentally-friendly systems, these results provide a basis for the fabrication of organic solvent-free HPMC-based composites for future applications.

Effect of Hydrophobicity and Charge Separation on the Antifouling Properties of Surface-Tethered Zwitterionic Peptides.

Zwitterionic peptides emerge as a class of highly effective antifouling material in a wide range of applications such as biosensors, biomedical devices, and implants. We incorporated neutral amino acid spacers with different hydrophobicities, including serine (Ser), glycine (Gly), and leucine (Leu), into zwitterionic peptides with lysine-glutamic acid repeating units and investigated the structure and antifouling performance of the zwitterionic peptide brushes by surface plasma resonance, surface force apparatus (SFA), and all-atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulation techniques. Our results demonstrate that the hydrophilicity of neutral spacers alters the structure and antifouling performance of the peptide-modified surface. Hydrophilic Ser-inserted peptides reduced the interaction between the peptide monolayer and protein foulants, while hydrophobic Leu significantly increased the protein adhesion. SFA force measurements show that the presence of more spacers would increase the adhesion between the peptide monolayer and the modeling foulant lysozyme, especially for the hydrophobic spacers. MD simulations reveal that hydrophilic Ser spacers retain the hydrophilicity of the peptide monolayer and improve the antifouling performance, and Gly spacers give rise to more interchain cross-links. Leu spacers result in a more hydrophobic peptide monolayer, which leads to dehydration of the peptide monolayer and reduces the antifouling performances.