In order to investigate the impact of different calcium sulfate (CS) sources and forms on the rheology, hydration, and mechanical properties of supersulfated cement (SSC), SSC pastes were produced with anhydrite from gypsum calcined at 650ºC and raw and calcined phosphogypsum (PG) at 150, 350, and 650ºC. Isothermal calorimetry, rheometry using parallel-plate geometry, compressive strength testing, and microstructural analysis through X-ray diffraction (XRD) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA/DTG) were performed. Results showed that SSC containing gypsum and PG calcined at 650ºC exhibited similar rheological behavior. Pastes containing PG calcined at 150ºC and raw PG respectively, exhibited the highest and lowest shear stress at a given shear rate. The calcination temperature and CS source did not significantly impact SSC compressive strength. Rietveld XRD analysis revealed that pastes with PG calcined at 350ºC and gypsum calcined at 650ºC had the lowest and highest ettringite development, respectively, from 7 to 28 days of curing.