Objectives: This study aimed to compare two surgical techniques-the free flap of the superficial palmar branch of the radial artery (SPBRA) and the free venous flap (FVF)-to evaluate their efficacy and aesthetic outcomes in repairing finger tissue defects. The goal was to determine which procedure offers faster healing curves and better overall patient outcomes, ultimately improving the quality of life for individuals undergoing these surgeries. Materials and Methods: A retrospective study was conducted using the clinical database of Sanliurfa Mehmet Akif Inan Education and Research Hospital, University of Health Sciences, from 1 January 2019 to 1 January 2022. A total of 44 patients with finger tissue defects, excluding thumb defects, were randomly divided into two groups: 21 patients underwent the SPBRA free flap procedure and 23 patients underwent the FVF procedure. Primary endpoints included flap survival rates, sensory recovery rates, aesthetic satisfaction scores, and complication rates. Data were collected during preoperative assessments and postoperative follow-ups at 1, 3, and 6 months. Results: The SPBRA group demonstrated a higher success rate (95% vs. 92%) and greater patient satisfaction in terms of restoring normal appearance and function. The SPBRA technique also showed superior sensory recovery with a lower two-point discrimination score (mean SPBRA = 6 mm vs. mean FVF = 8 mm). Functional outcomes, assessed by the Michigan Hand Outcomes Questionnaire, indicated higher scores for the SPBRA group (85/100) compared to the FVF group (80/100). Additionally, the SPBRA procedure was associated with fewer complications, highlighting its effectiveness and safety. Conclusions: The findings suggest that the SPBRA free flap technique offers better outcomes than the FVF procedure for repairing finger tissue defects. It provides superior functional restoration, enhanced cosmetic satisfaction, and a lower rate of complications. These results support the preference for the SPBRA technique in addressing complex finger tissue defects and improving patient outcomes.
Read full abstract