Sum Frequency Spectroscopy Research Articles

Unconventional structural evolution of an oxide surface in water unveiled by in situ sum-frequency spectroscopy.

Oxide-water interfaces host a wide range of important reactions in nature and modern industrial applications; however, accurate knowledge about these interfaces is still lacking at the molecular level owing to difficulties in accessing buried oxide surfaces. Here we report an experimental scheme enabling in situ sum-frequency vibrational spectroscopy of oxide surfaces in liquid water. Application to the silica-water interface revealed the emergence of unexpected surface reaction pathways with water. With ab initio molecular dynamics and metadynamics simulations, we uncovered a surface reconstruction, triggered by deprotonation of surface hydroxylated groups, that led to unconventional five-coordinated silicon species. The results help demystify the multimodal chemistry of aqueous silica discovered decades ago, bringing in fresh information that modifies the current understanding. Our study will provide new opportunities for future in-depth physical and chemical characterizations of other oxide-water interfaces.

(Invited) Probe the Reaction Intermediates on Noble Metal Electrodes during Oer with Vibrational Sum Frequency Spectroscopy

Electrochemical water splitting on noble metal surface is an important reaction of both fundamental and application interest. It is well known that the bottleneck of this reaction is the poor kinetics for oxygen generation from water oxidation. Despite of years study, the mechanisms in terms of the roles of the thin oxides film that formed on the metal surface before/during oxygen evolution are still inexplicit. One of the main reasons is the lack of molecular level information about the oxide thin film structures. In this study, we investigated the electrochemical oxidation of gold and platinum in solutions with different pHs by employing surface specific vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy (VSFS)1-3. By analyzing the potential dependent behaviors of different types of adsorbed species, we could gain molecular level information regarding the structures and formation mechanisms of metal-oxides. The results of this study will provide essential data toward understanding the oxygen evolution mechanism and also suggest strategies for developing better water splitting catalysts. [1]. Zhang, I. Y.; Zwaschka, G.; Wang, Z.; Wolf, M.; Campen, R. K.; Tong, Y., Resolving the chemical identity of H2SO4 derived anions on Pt(111) electrodes: they're sulfate. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2019, 21 (35), 19147-19152.[2]. Zwaschka, G.; Wolf, M.; Campen, R. K.; Tong, Y., A Microscopic Model of the Electrochemical Vibrational Stark Effect: Understanding VSF Spectroscopy of (bi)Sulfate on Pt(111). Surf. Sci. 2018, 678, 78-85.[3]Gong, X.; Campen, R. K.; Tong, Y. Direct Observation of the Potential-Dependent Protonation and Reorientation of 4-(Dimethylamino)pyridine on Gold Electrodes. J. Phys. Chem. C 2023, 127 (33), 16615-16622. DOI: 10.1021/acs.jpcc.3c03038.

Spectral narrowing of a phonon resonance in time-domain sum-frequency spectroscopy

Spectral narrowing of a phonon resonance in time-domain sum-frequency spectroscopy

Relating the phase in vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy and second harmonic generation with the maximum entropy method.

Nonlinear optical methods, such as vibrational sum frequency generation (vSFG) and second harmonic generation (SHG), are powerful techniques to study elusive structures at charged buried interfaces. However, for the separation and determination of the Stern and diffuse layer spectra at these charged interfaces, complex vSFG spectra and, hence, the absolute phase need to be retrieved. The maximum entropy method is a useful tool for the retrieval of complex spectra from the intensity spectra; however, one caveat is that an understanding of the error phase is required. Here, for the first time, we provide a physically motivated understanding of the error phase. Determining the error phase from simulated spectra of oscillators with a spectral overlap, we show that for broadband vSFG spectra, such as for the silica/water interface, the diffuse and Stern layers' spectral overlap within the O-H stretching window results in a correlation between the error phase and the phase shift between the responses of these layers. This correlation makes the error phase sensitive to changes in Debye length from varying the ionic strength among other variations at the interface. Furthermore, the change in the magnitude of the error phase can be related to the absolute SHG phase, permitting the use of an error phase model that can utilize the SHG phase to predict the error phase and, hence, the complex vSFG spectra. Finally, we highlight limitations of this model for vSFG spectra with a poor overlap between the diffuse and Stern layer spectra (silica/HOD in D2O system).

Calcite Surfaces Modified with Carboxylic Acids (C2 to C18): Layer Organization, Wettability, Stability, and Molecular Structural Properties.

A fundamental understanding of the interactions between mineral surfaces and amphiphilic surface modification agents is needed for better control over the production and uses of mineral fillers. Here, we controlled the carboxylic acid layer formation conditions on calcite surfaces with high precision via vapor deposition. The properties of the resulting carboxylic acid layers were analyzed using surface-sensitive techniques, such as atomic force microscopy (AFM), contact angle measurements, angle resolved X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), and vibrational sum-frequency spectroscopy. A low wettability was achieved with long hydrocarbon chain carboxylic acids such as stearic acid. The stearic acid layer formed by vapor deposition is initially patchy, but with increasing vapor exposure time, the patches grow and condense into a homogeneous layer with a thickness close to that expected for a monolayer as evaluated by AFM and XPS. The build-up process of the layer occurs more rapidly at higher temperatures due to the higher vapor pressure. The stability of the deposited fatty acid layer in the presence of a water droplet increases with the chain length and packing density in the adsorbed layer. Vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy data demonstrate that the stearic acid monolayers on calcite have their alkyl chains in an all-trans conformation and are anisotropically distributed on the plane of the surface, forming epitaxial monolayers. Vibrational spectra also show that the stearic acid molecules interact with the calcite surface through the carboxylic acid headgroup in both its protonated and deprotonated forms. The results presented provide new molecular insights into the properties of adsorbed carboxylic acid layers on calcite.

Structure evolution at the gate-tunable suspended graphene-water interface.

Graphitic electrode is commonly used in electrochemical reactions owing to its excellent in-plane conductivity, structural robustness and cost efficiency1,2. It serves as prime electrocatalyst support as well as a layered intercalation matrix2,3, with wide applications in energy conversion and storage1,4. Being the two-dimensional building block of graphite, graphene shares similar chemical properties with graphite1,2, and its unique physical and chemical properties offer more varieties and tunability for developing state-of-the-art graphitic devices5-7. Hence it serves as an ideal platform to investigate the microscopic structure and reaction kinetics at the graphitic-electrode interfaces. Unfortunately, graphene is susceptible to various extrinsic factors, such as substrate effect8-10, causing much confusion and controversy7,8,10,11. Hereby we have obtained centimetre-sized substrate-free monolayer graphene suspended on aqueous electrolyte surface with gate tunability. Using sum-frequency spectroscopy, here we show the structural evolution versus the gate voltage at the graphene-water interface. The hydrogen-bond network of water in the Stern layer is barely changed within the water-electrolysis window but undergoes notable change when switching on the electrochemical reactions. The dangling O-H bond protruding at the graphene-water interface disappears at the onset of the hydrogen evolution reaction, signifying a marked structural change on the topmost layer owing to excess intermediate species next to the electrode. The large-size suspended pristine graphene offers a new platform to unravel the microscopic processes at the graphitic-electrode interfaces.

Comparative Thermodynamic and Structural Analysis of Polyfluorinated Dodecylphosphonic Acid Adsorption to Distilled and River Water Interfaces.

As concerns rise about the health risks posed by per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in the environment, there is a need to understand how these pollutants accumulate at environmental interfaces. Untangling the details of molecular adsorption, particularly when there are potential interactions with other molecules in environmental systems, can obscure the ability to focus on a particular contaminant with molecular specificity. Often adsorption studies of environmental interfaces require a reductionist approach, where laboratory experiments may not be fully tractable to environmental systems. In this work, we study polyfluorinated dodecylphosphonic acid (F21-DDPA) at the aqueous surfaces of distilled water (the most reduced "environmental" surface) and river water to explore the use of vibrational sum-frequency (VSF) spectroscopy as an experimental probe of fluorinated contaminants at natural environmental surfaces. We demonstrate how VSF spectroscopy offers advantages over nonspecific surface tension measurements when measuring PFAS adsorption isotherms at river water surfaces. VSF spectra of the C-F stretching region selectively probe the presence of F21-DDPA and can be used to extract meaningful structural insights and calculate surface concentrations, even at the complex river water surface. This study highlights the potential for VSF spectroscopy to be developed as a probe of fluorinated contaminants at natural environmental interfaces.

An Electrochemical Perspective on the Interfacial Width between Two Immiscible Liquid Phases.

Molecular dynamics simulations and vibrational sum-frequency spectroscopy are historically the main techniques applied to the description of the molecular structure and dynamics of the immiscible liquid/liquid interface. A molecular sharpness is estimated for oil/water interfaces, with an interfacial width that extends from hundreds of Å to 1 nm. However, electrochemical studies have elucidated a deeper liquid/liquid interface on the order of several micrometers. The breaking down of single-entity electrochemistry to simpler systems and the combination of high-resolution microscopies is confirming a larger extension of the interface. What can be the role of the electrochemist in clarifying this fundamental question? We try to give a suggestion at the end of a brief historical overview of the liquid/liquid interface studies.

2-Propanol interacting with Co3O4(001): A combined vSFS and AIMD study.

The interaction of 2-propanol with Co3O4(001) was studied by vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy and abinitio molecular dynamics simulations of 2-propanol dissolved in a water film to gain an insight, at the molecular level, into the pathways of catalytic oxidation. The experimental study has been performed under near ambient conditions, where the presence of water vapor is unavoidable, resulting in a water film on the sample and, thereby, allowing us to mimic the solution-water interface. Both experiment and theory conclude that 2-propanol adsorbs molecularly. The lack of dissociation is attributed to the adsorption geometry of 2-propanol in which the O-H bond does not point toward the surface. Furthermore, the copresent water not only competitively adsorbs on the surface but also inhibits 2-propanol deprotonation. The calculations reveal that the presence of water deactivates the lattice oxygen, thereby reducing the surface activity. This finding sheds light on the multifaceted role of water at the interface for the electrochemical oxidation of 2-propanol in aqueous solution as recently reported [Falk et al., ChemCatChem 13, 2942-2951 (2021)]. At higher temperatures, 2-propanol remains molecularly adsorbed on Co3O4(001) until it desorbs with increasing surface temperature.

Lipid-Specific Direct Translocation of the Cell-Penetrating Peptide NAF-144-67 across Bilayer Membranes.

The cell-penetrating peptide NAF-1 has recently emerged as a promising candidate for selective penetration and destruction of cancer cells. It displays numerous membrane-selective behaviors including cell-specific uptake and organelle-specific degradation. In this work, we explore membrane penetration and translocation of NAF-1 in model lipid bilayer vesicles as a function of lipid identity in zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine lipids mixed with anionic phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylglycerol, and phosphatidic acid lipids. By monitoring the digestion of NAF-1 using the protease trypsin located inside but not outside the vesicles, we determined that the translocation of NAF-1 was significantly enhanced by the presence of phosphatidic acid in the membrane compared to the other three anionic or zwitterionic lipids. These findings were correlated to fluorescence measurements of dansyl-labeled NAF-1, which revealed whether noncovalent interactions between NAF-1 and the bilayer were most stable either at the membrane/solution interface or within the membrane interior. Phosphatidic acid promoted interactions with fatty acid tails, while phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylserine, and phosphatidylglycerol stabilized interactions with polar lipid headgroups. Interfacial vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy experiments revealed that the phosphate moiety on phosphatidic acid headgroups was better hydrated than on the other three lipids, which helped to shuttle NAF-1 into the hydrophobic region. Our findings demonstrate that permeation does not depend on the net charge on phospholipid lipid headgroups in these model vesicles and suggest a model wherein NAF-1 crosses membranes selectively due to lipid-specific interactions at bilayer surfaces.

Unraveling Interactions and Catalytic Mechanisms of Ionic Liquid [Bmim][BF4] and Styrene Oxide Using Sum Frequency Spectroscopy

Unraveling Interactions and Catalytic Mechanisms of Ionic Liquid [Bmim][BF₄] and Styrene Oxide Using Sum Frequency Spectroscopy

Interaction of 2-propanol with predominantly SrO- and TiO2-terminated SrTiO3(100) surfaces studied by vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy

The interaction of 2-propanol with SrTiO3(100) surfaces is studied with a focus on the role of different surface terminations in the deprotonation upon adsorption.

Sum frequency spectroscopy studies on cell membrane fusion induced by divalent cations

Cell membrane fusion is a fundamental biological process involved in a number of cellular living functions. Regarding this, divalent cations can induce fusion of the lipid bilayers through binding and bridging of divalent cations to the charged lipids, thus leading to the cell membrane fusion. How-ever, the elaborate mechanism of cell membrane fusion induced by divalent cations is still needed to be elucidated. Here, surface/interface sensitive sum frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy (SFG-VS) and dynamic light scattering (DLS) were applied in this research to study the responses of phospholipid monolayer to the exposure of divalent metal ions i.e. Ca2+ and Mg2+. According to the particle size distribution results measured by DLS experiments, it was found that Ca2+ could induce inter-vesicular fusion while Mg2+ could not. An octadecyltrichlorosilane self-assembled monolayer (OTS SAM)-lipid monolayer system was designed to model the cell membrane for the SFG-VS experiment. Ca2+ could interact with the lipid PO2− head groups more strongly, resulting in cell membrane fusion more easily, in comparison with Mg2+. No specific interaction between the two metal cations and the C=O groups was observed. However, the C=O orientations changed more after Ca2+-PO2− binding than Mg2+ mediation on lipid monolayer. Meanwhile, Ca2+ could induce dehydration of the lipids (which should be related to the strong Ca2+-PO2− interaction), leading to the reduced hindrance for cell membrane fusion.

Vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy of thin film interfaces

We describe a basic theoretical treatment of how film-substrate and substrate-environment (air, water, and solution) interfaces can be selectively probed by controlling the film thickness and beam angles in a visible-infrared sum frequency generation experiment. In this model, we also account for the unique interfacial environment that may have optical properties that differ from the adjacent bulk phases. We see that this affects components of the electric field that are perpendicular to the surface such as when p-polarized light is used. We then provide an example using the glass-polydimethylsiloxane-air system and model the fields at both surfaces of the polymer. This is followed by some practical considerations for setting up such experiments and some typical experimental results.

Structure and Reactivity of α-Al2O3(0001) Surfaces: How Do Al–I and Gibbsite-like Terminations Interconvert?

The α-Al2O3(0001) surface has been extensively studied because of its significance in both fundamental research and application. Prior work suggests that in ultra-high-vacuum (UHV), in the absence of water, the so-called Al–I termination is thermodynamically favored, while in ambient, in contact with liquid water, a Gibbsite-like layer is created. While the view of the α-Al2O3(0001)/H2O(l) interface appears relatively clear in theory, experimental characterization of this system has resulted in estimates of surface acidity, i.e., isoelectric points, that differ by 4 pH units and surface structure that in some reports has non-hydrogen-bonded surface aluminol (Al–OH) groups and in others does not. In this study, we employed vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy (VSFS) and density functional theory (DFT) simulation to study the surface phonon modes of the differently terminated α-Al2O3(0001) surfaces in both UHV and ambient. We find that, on either water dosing of the Al–I in UHV or heat-induced dehydroxylation of the Gibbsite-like in ambient, the surfaces do not interconvert. This observation offers a new explanation for disagreements in prior work on the α-Al2O3(0001)/liquid water interface─different preparation methods may create surfaces that do not interconvert─and shows that the surface phonon spectral response offers a novel probe of interfacial hydrogen bonding structure.

Self-Suppression of the Giant Coherent Anti-Stokes Raman Scattering Background for Detection of Buried Interfaces with Submonolayer Sensitivity.

Despite its success in many fields, the implementation of coherent anti-Stokes Raman spectroscopy (CARS) in tackling the problems at interfaces was hindered by the enormous resonant and nonresonant background from the bulk. In this work, we have developed a novel CARS scheme that can probe a buried interface via ≥105-fold suppression of the nonresonant and resonant bulk contribution. The method utilizes self-destructive interference between the forward and backward CARS generated in the bulk near the Brewster angle. As a result, we can resolve the vibrational spectrum of submonolayer interfacial polar/apolar species immersed in the surrounding medium with huge CARS responses. We expect that our approach opens up the opportunity to interrogate the interfaces involving apolar molecules and benefits other nonlinear optical spectroscopic techniques, e.g., sum-frequency spectroscopy and four-wave mixing spectroscopy in general, to promote the signal-to-background noise ratio.

Contact Ion Pair Formation Is Not Necessarily Stronger than Solvent Shared Ion Pairing.

Vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy (VSFS) and pressure-area Langmuir trough measurements were used to investigate the binding of alkali metal cations to eicosyl sulfate (ESO4) surfactants in monolayers at the air/water interface. The number density of sulfate groups could be tuned by mixing the anionic surfactant with eicosanol. The equilibrium dissociation constant for K+ to the fatty sulfate interface showed 10 times greater affinity than for Li+ and approximately 3 times greater than for Na+. All three cations formed solvent shared ion pairs when the mole fraction of ESO4 was 0.33 or lower. Above this threshold charge density, Li+ formed contact ion pairs with the sulfate headgroups, presumably via bridging structures. By contrast, K+ only bound to the sulfate moieties in solvent shared ion pairing configurations. The behavior for Na+ was intermediate. These results demonstrate that there is not necessarily a correlation between contact ion pair formation and stronger binding affinity.

Anion Specific Effects at Negatively Charged Interfaces: Influence of Cl-, Br-, I-, and SCN- on the Interactions of Na+ with the Carboxylic Acid Moiety.

Unlike counterion interactions with charged interfaces, the influence of co-ions is only scarcely reported in the literature. In this work, the effect of SCN– and the halide co-ions in the interactions of Na+ with carboxylic acid Langmuir monolayers is investigated by using vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy. At 1 M concentrations in the subphase, the identity of the anion is shown to have a remarkable influence on the charging behavior and degree of deprotonation of the monolayer, with ions ordering in the sequence I– > SCN– > Cl– ≈ Br–. The same trend is observed at both pH 6 and pH 9 when the monolayer is intrinsically more charged. Spectroscopic evidence is found for both the presence of I– and SCN– in the interfacial region at levels close to their detection limits. The results contradict electrostatic theories on charged interfaces where co-ions are not expected to play any significant role. The higher propensity for the large polarizable anions to deprotonate the monolayer is explained in terms of their ability to modify the cations affinity toward the carboxylic acid groups present at the surface.

La3+ and Y3+ interactions with the carboxylic acid moiety at the liquid/vapor interface: Identification of binding complexes, charge reversal, and detection limits

Specific interactions of yttrium and lanthanum ions with a fatty acid Langmuir monolayer were investigated using vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy. The trivalent ions were shown to interact with the charged form of the carboxylic acid group from nanomolar concentrations (<300 nM). Analysis of the spectral features from both the symmetric and the asymmetric carboxylate modes reveals the presence of at least three distinct coordination structures linked to specific binding configurations. Although the same species were identified for both La3+ and Y3+, they display a different concentration dependence, highlighting the ion-specificity of the interaction. From the analysis of the response of interfacial water molecules, the reversal of the surface charge, as well as the formation of yttrium hydroxide complexes, were detected upon increasing the amount of salt in solution. The binding interaction and kinetics of absorption are sensitive to the solution pH, showing a distinct ion speciation in the interfacial region when compared to the bulk. Changing the subphase pH or adding a monovalent background electrolyte that promotes deprotonation of the carboxylic acid headgroup could further improve the detection limit of La3+ and Y3+ to concentrations < 100 nM. These findings demonstrate that nM concentrations of trace metals contaminants, typically found on monovalent salts, can significantly influence the binding structure and kinetics in Langmuir monolayers.

Playing Favorites: Preferential Adsorption of Nonionic over Anionic Surfactants at the Liquid/Liquid Interface.

While many studies have investigated synergic interactions between surfactants in mixed systems, understanding possible competitive behaviors between interfacial components of binary surfactant systems is necessary for the optimized efficacy of applications dependent on surface properties. Such is the focus of these studies in which the surface behavior of a binary surfactant mixture containing nonionic (Span-80) and anionic (AOT) components adsorbing to the oil/water interface was investigated with vibrational sum-frequency (VSF) spectroscopy and surface tensiometry experimental methods. Time-dependent spectroscopic studies reveal that while both nonionic and anionic surfactants initially adsorb to the interface, anionic surfactants desorb over time as the nonionic surfactant continues to adsorb. Concentration studies that vary the ratio of Span-80 to AOT in bulk solution show that the nonionic surfactant preferentially adsorbs to the oil/water interface over the anionic surfactant. These studies have important implications for applications in which mixed surfactant systems are used to alter interfacial properties, such as pharmaceuticals, industrial films, and environmental remediation.