Sum Frequency Generation Signal Research Articles

Photon antibunching in single-molecule vibrational sum-frequency generation

Abstract Sum-frequency generation (SFG) enables the coherent upconversion of electromagnetic signals and plays a significant role in mid-infrared vibrational spectroscopy for molecular analysis. Recent research indicates that plasmonic nanocavities, which confine light to extremely small volumes, can facilitate the detection of vibrational SFG signals from individual molecules by leveraging surface-enhanced Raman scattering combined with mid-infrared laser excitation. In this article, we compute the degree of second order coherence (g (2)(0)) of the upconverted mid-infrared field under realistic parameters and accounting for the anharmonic potential that characterizes vibrational modes of individual molecules. On the one hand, we delineate the regime in which the device should operate in order to preserve the second-order coherence of the mid-infrared source, as required in quantum applications. On the other hand, we show that an anharmonic molecular potential can lead to antibunching of the upconverted photons under coherent, Poisson-distributed mid-infrared and visible drives. Our results therefore open a path toward bright and tunable source of indistinguishable single photons by leveraging “vibrational blockade” in a resonantly and parametrically driven molecule, without the need for strong light-matter coupling.

DFT-based calculation of vibrational sum frequency generation spectral features of crystalline β-sheets in silk: Polarization and azimuth angle dependences.

Sum frequency generation (SFG) necessitates both noncentrosymmetry and coherence over multiple length scales. These requirements make vibrational SFG spectroscopy capable of probing structural information of noncentrosymmetric organic crystals interspersed in polymeric matrices and their three-dimensional spatial distributions within the matrices without spectral interferences from the amorphous components. However, this analysis is not as straightforward as simple vibrational spectroscopy or scattering experiments; it requires knowing the molecular hyperpolarizability of SFG-active vibrational modes and their interplay within the coherence length. This study demonstrates how density function theory (DFT) calculations can be used to construct the molecular hyperpolarizability of a model system and combine it with the SFG theory to predict the polarization and azimuth angle dependences of SFG intensities. A model system with short peptide chains mimicking β-sheet domains in Bombyx mori silk was chosen. SFG signals of the amide-I, II, III, and A bands and one of the CH deformation modes were simulated and compared with the experimental results and the predictions from the group theory. The SFG features of amide-I and A bands of antiparallel β-sheet could be explained with DFT-based theoretical calculations. Although vibrational coupling with neighboring groups breaks the symmetry of the D2 point group, the group theory approach and DFT calculations gave similar results for the amide-I mode. The DFT calculation results for amide-II did not match with experimental data, which suggested vibrational coupling within a larger crystalline domain may dominate the SFG spectral features of these modes. This methodology can be applied to the structural analysis of other biopolymers.

Extracting the Heterogeneous 3D Structure of Molecular Films Using Higher Dimensional SFG Microscopy.

Ultrathin molecular films are widespread in both natural and industrial settings, where details of the molecular structure such as density, out-of-plane tilt angles, and in-plane directionality determine their physicochemical properties. Many of these films possess important molecular-to-macroscopic heterogeneity in these structural parameters, which have traditionally been difficult to characterize. Here, we show how extending sum-frequency generation (SFG) microscopy measurements to higher dimensionality by azimuthal-scanning can extract the spatial variation in the three-dimensional molecular structure at an interface. We extend the commonly applied theoretical assumptions used to analyze SFG signals to the study of systems possessing in-plane anisotropy. This theoretical framework is then applied to a phase-separated mixed lipid monolayer to investigate the variation in molecular density and 3D orientation across the chirally packed lipid domains. The results show little variation in out-of-plane structure but a distinct micron-scale region at the domain boundaries with a reduction in both density and in-plane ordering.

Orientation Distribution of Crystalline β-Sheet Domains in Bombyx mori Silk Fiber Studied with Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation Spectroscopy.

Silk fibers have good biocompatibility and mechanical properties, which make them attractive in biomaterial applications as well as textile industries. It is believed that the superior mechanical property is associated with the crystalline β-sheet structure in the fiber; but a deeper understanding of the structure-property relationship is still needed for full exploitation of its physical properties. Especially, accurate information on hydrogen-bonding interactions within β-sheet domains at the nanoscale and their spatial distributions at the mesoscale are critically needed. In this study, we demonstrate the selective detection of crystalline β-sheet domains in Bombyx mori silk fiber using sum frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy and its use to determine the angular distribution of the β-sheet crystallites with respect to the fiber axis. Numerical simulations of the SFG signal of the amide-I band were carried out using tensors based on the B2 symmetry of the D2 point group and compared with experimental data. This comparison found that the crystalline β-sheet domains are aligned along the fiber axis with a standard deviation of ∼27° and parallel to the fiber surface with a standard deviation of ∼5°. It was also found that the amide bands in the SFG spectra cannot be fully explained with the assumption that the crystalline β-sheet vibrations can be described with the D2 point group. Being able to monitor the amide group vibrations sensitive to both interchain hydrogen bonding and crystallite orientations, SFG analysis has a potential to unveil the structure-mechanical property relationship that may not be readily assessable with other characterization techniques.

Simulating the ionic liquid mixing with organic-solvent clarifies the mixture’s SFG spectral behavior and the specific surface region originating SFG

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation of the green ionic liquid [C₄mim][PF₆] mixed with polar benzonitrile (BNZ) solvent provides detailed insights into their structural and dynamic properties, essential for electrochemistry and materials science applications. The simulations we carried out at varying mole fractions (XBZN) reveal the mixtures’ physical, structural, and dynamic properties, with radial, spatial, and combined distribution functions, highlighting the effective interaction through H-bonding involved. The simulation indicates that BZN stacks on the cation butyl tail, providing a significant explanation for the unique experimental observations (following). Adding BZN causes the mixture’s liquid dynamics to increase linearly at low XBZN and exponentially at high XBZN, with a notable singular transition at 0.5XBZN. Comprehensive efforts were made to verify and support experimental sum frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy by simulating the surface structure of the mixtures. Consequently, the simulated BZN stacking structure explains (1) the absence of the C≡N vibrational mode in the SFG spectrum for XBZN < 0.8, and (2) the gradual diminishing of the CH3 SFG signal, which disappears as XBZN approaches 0.5. Finally, this research removes a persistent ambiguity, proving that only the molecular moieties on the surface generate the SFG vibrational signal, while those in the subsurface do not.

Ligand-induced conformational changes in protein molecules detected by sum-frequency generation

We present the first demonstration of ligand-induced conformational changes in a biological molecule, a protein, by sum-frequency generation (SFG). Constructs of KRasG12D protein were prepared by selectively deuterating residues of a single amino acid type using isotope-labeled amino acids and cell-free protein synthesis. By attaching labeled protein to a supported bilayer membrane via a His-tag to Ni-NTA-bearing lipids, we ensured that single layers of ordered molecules were formed while preserving the protein’s native structure. Exceptionally large SFG amide I signals were produced in both labeled and unlabeled proteins, demonstrating a high degree of orientational order upon attachment to the bilayer. Deuterated protein also produced SFG signals in the CDx spectral region, which were not present in the unlabeled protein. The CDx signals were measured before and after binding a peptide inhibitor, KRpep-2d, revealing shifts in SFG intensity due to conformational changes at the labeled sites. In particular, peaks associated with CDx stretching vibrations for alanine, valine, and glycine changed substantially in amplitude upon inhibitor binding. By inspection of the crystal structure, these three residues are uniquely colocated on the protein surface in and near the nucleotide binding site, which is in allosteric communication with the site of peptide inhibitor binding, suggesting an approach to identify a ligand’s binding site. The technique offers a highly sensitive, nonperturbative method of mapping ligand-induced conformational changes and allosteric networks in biological molecules for studies of the relationship between structure and function and mechanisms of action in drug discovery.

Monovalent ion-graphene oxide interactions are controlled by carboxylic acid groups: Sum frequency generation spectroscopy studies.

Graphene oxide (GO) is a two-dimensional, mechanically strong, and chemically tunable material for separations. Elucidating GO-ion-water interactions at the molecular scale is highly important for predictive understanding of separation systems. However, direct observations of the nanometer region by GO surfaces under operando conditions are not trivial. Therefore, thin films of GO at the air/water interface can be used as model systems. With this approach, we study the effects of alkali metal ions on water organization near graphene oxide films at the air/water interface using vibrational sum frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy. We also use an arachidic acid Langmuir monolayer as a benchmark for a pure carboxylic acid surface. Theoretical modeling of the concentration-dependent sum frequency signal from graphene oxide and arachidic acid surfaces reveals that the adsorption of monovalent ions is mainly controlled by the carboxylic acid groups on graphene oxide. An in-depth analysis of sum frequency spectra reveals at least three distinct water populations with different hydrogen bonding strengths. The origin of each population can be identified from concentration dependent variations of their SFG signal. Interestingly, an interfacial water structure seemed mostly insensitive to the character of the alkali cation, in contrast to similar studies conducted at the silica/water interface. However, we observed an ion-specific effect with lithium, whose strong hydration prevented direct interactions with the graphene oxide film.

Polysulfide-mediated solvation shell reorganization for fast Li+ transfer probed by in-situ sum frequency generation spectroscopy

Understanding of interfacial Li+ solvation shell structures and dynamic evolution at the electrode/electrolyte interface is requisite for developing high-energy-density Li batteries. Herein, the reorganization of Li+ solvation shell at the sulfur/electrolyte interface along with the presence of a trace amount of lithium polysulfides is verified by in-situ sum frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy together with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Both the spectroelectrochemical and DFT calculation results reveal a strongly competitive anion adsorption of the polysulfide anion additive against the pristine electrolyte anion on the sulfur cathode surface, reorganizing the interfacial local solvation shell structure facilitating rapid Li ion transfer and conduction. Meanwhile, the evolution of the SFG signals along with the discharging/charging cycle exhibits improved reversibility, indicating the transformation of the inner Helmholtz plane layer into a stable molecular-layer polysulfide interphase rather than a dynamic diffusion layer. Consequently, applications in practical Li-S batteries reveal the capacity and cycling stability of the corresponding cells are significantly enhanced. Our work provides a methodology using in-situ SFG for probing solvation reorganization of charge carriers at electrochemical interfaces.

Multi-spectroscopic study of electrochemically-formed oxide-derived gold electrodes.

Oxide-derived metals are produced by reducing an oxide precursor. These materials, including gold, have shown improved catalytic performance over many native metals. The origin of this improvement for gold is not yet understood. In this study, operando non-resonant sum frequency generation (SFG) and ex situ high-pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (HP-XPS) have been employed to investigate electrochemically-formed oxide-derived gold (OD-Au) from polycrystalline gold surfaces. A range of different oxidizing conditions were used to form OD-Au in acidic aqueous medium (H3PO4, pH = 1). Our electrochemical data after OD-Au is generated suggest that the surface is metallic gold, however SFG signal variations indicate the presence of subsurface gold oxide remnants between the metallic gold surface layer and bulk gold. The HP-XPS results suggest that this subsurface gold oxide could be in the form of Au2O3 or Au(OH)3. Furthermore, the SFG measurements show that with reducing electrochemical treatments the original gold metallic state can be restored, meaning the subsurface gold oxide is released. This work demonstrates that remnants of gold oxide persist beneath the topmost gold layer when the OD-Au is created, potentially facilitating the understanding of the improved catalytic properties of OD-Au.

Operando measurements of top-emission organic light-emitting diode using electric-field-induced doubly resonant sum-frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy

We performed sum-frequency generation (SFG) measurements on top-emission (TE) organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) during operation. These measurements require the detection of SFG light using probe laser beams transmitted through a 9 nm thick semitransparent Mg:Ag metal electrode. Only the SFG signals from the hole transport material (4,4′-bis[N-(1-naphthyl)-N-phenylamino]-biphenyl, NPD) are observed for the device configuration of the OLEDs in this study. The SFG peak (at approximately 1603 cm−1) shows a linear dependence on the applied voltage. This indicates that the NPD-derived SFG is enhanced by an electric-field-induced (EFI) effect owing to injected charges. In addition, the SFG efficiency of the TE OLED is considerably higher than that of a bottom-emission (BE) OLED manufactured in the same batch using the same material and film thickness. The difference in the SFG responses of the BE and TE OLEDs is caused by structural differences rather than the layer composition. The results of this study indicate that EFI-doubly resonant-SFG operando measurements can be applied to analyze the carrier behavior and charge transport of not only BE OLEDs but also TE OLEDs, the latter of which are used more commonly as commercial products.

Sum-frequency generation at interfaces: A Fresnel story. II. Analytical expressions for multilayer systems.

The well-known formalism for Sum-Frequency Generation (SFG) reflected or transmitted by a three-layer system involves three equations defining the emitted SFG intensity, the effective nonlinear susceptibility, and a set of Fresnel factors specific to the three-layer system. We generalize the equations to an N-layer system, where all media have non-vanishing thicknesses, by leaving the first two equations unchanged and modifying only the Fresnel factors. These universal Fresnel factors bear all the complexity of light propagation and interference in the system, in amplitude and phase. They are analytically known anywhere in the N-layer system, either at any interface or in any of the bulks, and share common expressions for the three beams, incoming or emitted, of the SFG process in reflection. Enclosing an ultrathin layer (e.g., a molecular monolayer) in the system does not modify the Fresnel factors except for boundary conditions at this layer, as in the three-layer case. Specific rules are elaborated to simplify systems containing macroscopic layers. Equations for the four- and five-layer systems are explicitly provided. Simulations in the four-layer system allow for the recovery of the results of the transfer matrix formalism at a lower complexity cost for SFG users. Finally, when several interfaces in the system produce SFG signals, we show that it is possible to probe only the most buried one by canceling all the SFG responses except at this last interface, generalizing the results of the three-layer system.

Differentiating Two Adsorption Modes of Membrane-Bound Antimicrobial Peptides via Sum Frequency Generation.

Multidrug-resistant (MDR) pathogens have been a growing threat to human health over the years. Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) with broad-spectrum antibiotic activity, as a promising therapeutic candidate, have shown tremendous capability against MDR pathogens. To acquire novel AMPs with better efficacy, we should dig into the antimicrobial mechanism by which AMPs perform their functions. In this study, the interaction processes between three representative AMPs (maculatin 1.1-G15, cupiennin 1a, and aurein 1.2) and the model membrane dDPPG/DPPG bilayer were investigated via sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy. Two interaction modes for the membrane-bound AMPs were differentiated, i.e., the loosely adsorbed one and the tightly adsorbed one. In the loosely adsorbed mode, AMPs are bound to the bilayer mainly by the electrostatic attraction between the positively charged residues of AMPs and the negatively charged head groups of the lipids. After the charged AMPs and lipids were neutralized by the counter ions, the desorption of AMPs from the membrane lipids happened, as evidenced by the disappearance of the SFG signals from membrane-bound AMPs. While in the tightly adsorbed mode, besides the charged attraction, AMPs are additionally inserted into the membrane lipids via the hydrophobic interaction. Even when the electrostatic attraction was neutralized by the counter ions, the hydrophobic interaction still led to the firm adsorption of AMPs onto the already-neutralized bilayer lipids, as evidenced by the presence of clear SFG signals from membrane-bound AMPs. We thus established a feasible protocol to expand the application of SFG, namely classifying the adsorption modes of AMPs. Such knowledge will surely promote the development and application of AMPs with high efficacy.

Does the Sum-Frequency Generation Signal of Aromatic C-H Vibrations Reflect Molecular Orientation?

Organic molecules with aromatic groups at the aqueous interfaces play a central role in atmospheric chemistry, green chemistry, and on-water synthesis. Insights into the organization of interfacial organic molecules can be obtained using surface-specific vibrational sum-frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy. However, the origin of the aromatic C-H stretching mode peak is unknown, prohibiting us from connecting the SFG signal to the interfacial molecular structure. Here, we explore the origin of the aromatic C-H stretching response by heterodyne-detected SFG (HD-SFG) at the liquid/vapor interface of benzene derivatives and find that, irrespective of the molecular orientation, the sign of the aromatic C-H stretching signals is negative for all the studied solvents. Together with density functional theory (DFT) calculations, we reveal that the interfacial quadrupole contribution dominates, even for the symmetry-broken benzene derivatives, although the dipole contribution is non-negligible. We propose a simple evaluation of the molecular orientation based on the aromatic C-H peak area.

Electric double layer contribution to sum frequency generation signal from Au electrode.

Understanding the electric double layer (EDL) of the metal electrode-electrolyte interface is essential to electrochemistry and relevant disciplines. In this study, potential-dependent electrode Sum Frequency Generation (SFG) intensities of polycrystalline gold electrodes in HClO4 and H2SO4 electrolytes were thoroughly analyzed. The potential of zero charges (PZC) of the electrodes was -0.06 and 0.38V in HClO4 and H2SO4, respectively, determined from differential capacity curves. Without specific adsorption, the total SFG intensity was dominated by the contribution from the Au surface and increased similar to that of the visible (VIS) wavelength scanning, which pushed the SFG process closer to the double resonant condition in HClO4. However, the EDL contributed about 30% SFG signal with specific adsorption in H2SO4. Below PZC, the total SFG intensity was dominated by the Au surface contribution and increased with potential at a similar slope in these two electrolytes. Around PZC, as the EDL structure became less ordered and the electric field changed direction, there would be no EDL SFG contribution. Above PZC, the total SFG intensity increased much more rapidly with potential in H2SO4 than in HClO4, which suggested that the EDL SFG contribution kept increasing with more specific adsorbed surface ions from H2SO4.

Electrostatic charges and their distribution on the charged surfaces probed by sum-frequency generation spectroscopy

We examined the electrostatic charging states of insulating polymer surfaces using sum-frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopy. For the negatively charged polypropylene, the SFG peak amplitudes increased significantly with increasing surface potential, indicating that the electric-field formed by the electrostatic charges directly affects the SFG signal intensities. In the organic thin films stacked on top of PMMA, an increase in the SFG signal of buried PMMA is observed, indicating that the electrostatic field formed by the electrical charges is extended into the bulk direction. In addition, visualization of the location and distribution of the charges is demonstrated using the SFG intensity variations.

Enhanced Sum Frequency Generation for Monolayers on Au Relative to Silica: Local Field Factors and SPR Effect

Using metals as signal magnified substrates, surface plasmon-enhanced sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy is a promising technique to probe weak molecular-level signals at surfaces and interfaces. In this study, the vibrational signals of the n-alkane monolayer on the gold (Au) and silica substrates are investigated using the broadband femtosecond SFG. The enhancement factors are discovered to be up to ∼1076 and ∼31 for the methyl symmetric and asymmetric stretching (ss and as) modes of the monolayer, respectively. By systematically analyzing the second-order nonlinear susceptibility tensor components (χijks), the Fresnel coefficients (Fijks), and the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) effect, we find that the interplay between Fijk and χijk terms and the SPR effect dominate the SFG signal enhancement. Our study reveals that the relative contributions of different influencing factors (i.e., Fresnel coefficients and SPR) to the SFG signal enhancement provide an approach to interpreting enhanced SFG vibrational signals detected from probe molecules on distinct substrates and may finally guide the design of the experimental methodology to improve the detection sensitivity and signal-to-noise ratio.

Sum frequency generation vibrational spectra of perovskite nanocrystals at the single-nanocrystal and ensemble levels

Determination of molecular structures of organic-inorganic hybrid perovskite (OIHP) nanocrystals at the single-nanocrystal and ensemble levels is essential to understanding the mechanisms responsible for their size-dependent optoelectronic properties and the nanocrystal assembling process, but its detection is still a bit challenging. In this study, we demonstrate that femtosecond sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy can provide a highly sensitive tool for probing the molecular structures of nanocrystals with a size comparable to the Bohr diameter (∼10 nm) at the single-nanocrystal level. The SFG signals are monitored using the spectral features of the phenyl group in (R-MBA)PbBr3 and (R-MBA)2PbI4 nanocrystals (MBA: methyl-benzyl-ammonium). It is found that the SFG spectra exhibit a strong resonant peak at 3067±3 cm−1 (ν2 mode) and a weak shoulder peak at 3045±4 cm−1 (ν7a mode) at the ensemble level, whereas a peak of the ν2 mode and a peak at 3025±3 cm−1 (ν20b mode) at the single-nanocrystal level. The nanocrystals at the single-nanocrystal level tend to lie down on the surface, but stand up as the ensemble number and the averaged sizes increase. This finding may provide valuable information on the structural origins for size-dependent photo-physical properties and photoluminescence blinking dynamics in nanocrystals.

Deprotonation of phenol linked to a silicon dioxide surface using adaptive feedback laser control with a heterodyne detected sum frequency generation signal.

The development of laser-controlled surface reactions has been limited by the lack of decisive methods for detecting evolving changes in surface chemistry. In this work, we demonstrate successful laser control of a surface reaction by combining the adaptive feedback control (AFC) technique with surface sensitive spectroscopy to determine the optimally shaped laser pulse. Specifically, we demonstrate laser induced deprotonation of the hydroxyl group of phenol bound to a silicon dioxide substrate. The experiment utilized AFC with heterodyne detected vibrational sum frequency generation (HD-VSFG) as the surface sensitive feedback signal. The versatile combination of AFC with HD-VSFG provides a route to potentially control a wide range of surface reactions.

Hydrolysis and Condensation of Tetraethyl Orthosilicate at the Air–Aqueous Interface: Implications for Silica Nanoparticle Formation

The silica (SiO2) nanoparticles of a well-known silica precursor tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS) are generally synthesized via a promising solution-gelation inorganic polymerization process. The monodisperse silica nanoparticles have potential applications ranging from the formation of dental nanocomposites to antireflective coatings. In the present study, we have systematically investigated the in situ interfacial molecular structure of TEOS and its impact on the interfacial water structure during the processes of hydrolysis and condensation at the air–aqueous interface using sum-frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy. With the presence of water, a gradual decrease in the SFG intensity in the CH-stretch region for each concentration of TEOS with time reflects the elimination of ethoxy groups, which is a signature of the hydrolysis process. Further, the impact of the hydrolysis process is revealed from the significant enhancement in the SFG signal in the OH-stretch region. The hydrolysis of TEOS is then followed by condensation in which the ≡Si─O– charged species are replaced by forming the ≡Si─O─Si≡ bridging network. The signature of the condensation process is reflected with the gradual decrease in the observed enhanced SFG signal in the OH-stretch region. The formation of monodispersed silica nanoparticles as an end product of size variation from 1.75 to 4.67 nm with the increase in TEOS concentration is confirmed with the DLS measurements. We have also probed the pH-dependent SFG studies at three different pH values (2.0, 5.8, and 9.0). The dominant pH-dependent hydrolysis process is revealed from the observed molecular structure of TEOS at the air–aqueous interface.

Direct Observation of the Orientation of Urea Molecules at Charged Interfaces.

Dissolving urea into water induces special solvation properties that play a crucial role in many biological processes. Here we probe the properties of urea molecules at charged aqueous interfaces using heterodyne-detected vibrational sum-frequency generation (HD-VSFG) spectroscopy. We find that at the neat water/air interface urea molecules do not yield a significant sum-frequency generation signal. However, upon the addition of ionic surfactants, we observe two vibrational bands at 1660 and 1590 cm–1 in the HD-VSFG spectrum, assigned to mixed bands of the C=O stretch and NH2 bend vibrations of urea. The orientation of the urea molecules depends on the sign of the charge localized at surface and closely follows the orientation of the neighboring water molecules. We demonstrate that urea is an excellent probe of the local electric field at aqueous interfaces.