Suicide Gene Therapy Approach Research Articles

Engineered Human tmpk/AZT As a Novel Enzyme/Prodrug Axis for Suicide Gene Therapy

Gene therapy and stem cell transplantation safety could be enhanced by control over the fate of therapeutic cells. Suicide gene therapy uses enzymes that convert prodrugs to cytotoxic entities; however, heterologous moieties with poor kinetics are employed. We describe a novel enzyme/prodrug combination for selectively inducing apoptosis in lentiviral vector-transduced cells. Rationally designed variants of human thymidylate kinase (tmpk) that effectively phosphorylate 3'-azido-3'-deoxythymidine (AZT) were efficiently delivered. Transduced Jurkat cell lines were eliminated by AZT. We demonstrate that this schema targeted both dividing and non-dividing cells, with a novel killing mechanism involving apoptosis induction via disruption of the mitochondrial inner membrane potential and activation of caspase-3. Primary murine and human T cells were also transduced and responded to AZT. Furthermore, low-dose AZT administration to non-obese diabetic/severe combined immunodeficiency (NOD/SCID) mice injected with transduced K562 cells suppressed tumor growth. This novel suicide gene therapy approach can thus be integrated as a safety switch into therapeutic vectors.

Anti-CD25 Targeted Killing of Bicistronically Transduced Cells: A Novel Safety Mechanism Against Retroviral Genotoxicity

Anti-CD25 Targeted Killing of Bicistronically Transduced Cells: A Novel Safety Mechanism Against Retroviral Genotoxicity

Antitumor effects of cytosine deaminase and thymidine kinase fusion suicide gene under the control of mdr1 promoter in mdr1 positive leukemia cells

The multidrug resistance (mdr) mediated by P-glycoprotein (P-gp), the mdr1 gene product, is one of the major obstacles in leukemia treatment. The present study was designed to explore a suicide gene therapy approach targeting mdr1 for reversal of P-gp-mediated mdr in the mdr positive K562/A02 cells. To study targeted killing effects of cytosine deaminase (CD)-thymidine kinase (TK) fusion suicide gene on multi-drug resistant leukemia, the CD-TK fusion suicide gene expression vector driven by mdr1 promoter was constructed and transferred into K562 and K562/A02 cells using lipofectin™ 2000. RT-PCR was used to demonstrate that there were CD and TK genes expression in K562/A02 cells, but not in K562 cells. MTT analysis showed that, compared with that in K562/CDTK, the survival rate of K562/A02-CDTK cells decreased and at the same time the apoptotic rate increased after treatment with GCV and 5-FC (P < 0.05). In vivo studies showed that the tumor volume in the prodrug treated K562/A02-CDTK groups was significantly less than that in the NS-control and K562-CDTK groups (P < 0.05). These findings show that the CD and TK fusion suicide gene expression driven by mdr1 promoter is effective in killing multidrug resistant K562/A02 cells.

Viral Vectors for Gene-Directed Enzyme Prodrug Therapy

Conventional cancer treatments are often hampered by a lack of tumour selectivity, resulting in toxicity to healthy tissue. Gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (GDEPT) is a suicide gene therapy approach that aims to improve the selectivity of chemotherapy by enabling cancer cells to convert non-cytotoxic prodrugs to cytotoxic drugs. Many enzyme/prodrug systems have been described, some of which have already been tested in clinical trials. A key component of GDEPT is a foreign enzyme that is expressed selectively at the tumour site where it converts the prodrug into the cytotoxic agent. The gene encoding the prodrug-activating enzyme needs to be expressed selectively and efficiently in tumour cells in order to spare normal tissue from damage. Substantial efforts have been made to develop gene therapy vectors that are capable of targeting cancer cells. A large number of gene delivery systems have been described for GDEPT: Viral vectors are the most advanced. They include replication-deficient and replication-selective (oncolytic) viruses. Recent advances in engineering viruses for GDEPT are reviewed in this article and data from both preclinical studies and clinical trials are discussed.

Targeting the CYP2B1/Cyclophosphamide Suicide System to Fibroblast Growth Factor Receptors Results in a Potent Antitumoral Response in Pancreatic Cancer Models

The CYP2B1/cyclophosphamide (CPA) suicide gene therapy approach has been shown to be highly promising in clinical trials for the treatment of pancreatic cancer. However, delivering the therapeutic gene to a sufficient number of tumor cells able to trigger a complete response remains a challenge. Target-specific delivery of adenovirus to fibroblast growth factor receptors (FGFRs) has been obtained in a variety of tumor models and has been shown to highly increase transduction efficiency. In the present paper we have tested the therapeutic outcome of retargeting the adenoviral vector, Ad-CYP2B1, to FGFRs, using an FGF2-Fab' conjugate, in pancreatic cancer models. First, we show a heterogeneous subcellular distribution of overexpressed FGFR-1 in pancreatic cancer cells. Higher transduction efficiency was observed in five of the six cell lines studied after FGF2-AdGFPLuc infection. Interestingly, an association between FGFR-1 membrane cell expression and viral entry was found. Moreover, tumors injected with FGF2-AdGFPLuc showed enhanced and persistent transgene expression. Importantly, we demonstrate the relevant enhanced cytotoxic effect of the FGF2-Ad-CYP2B]/CPA system in four of the six cell lines studied. Moreover, retargeting Ad-CYP2B1/CPA to FGFRs resulted in a potent antitumoral effect and in an increased survival rate, in two human pancreatic xenograft models. Thus, our results indicate that redirecting adenoviruses to FGFRs highly increases the potency of the suicide system CYP2B1/CPA. Consequently, it may constitute a promising approach to the treatment of patients with pancreatic tumors, in which a high proportion of FGF receptors precisely localize to the plasma membrane.

A Novel Suicide Gene Therapy Approach for Reduction of GvHD Using Lentiviral Delivery of a Modified Human Thymidylate Monophosphate Kinase.

The infusion of donor lymphocytes in allogenic BMT recipients provides potent antitumor activity to treat recurrent malignancies. One complication, however, is severe GvHD, which is mediated by T cells in the graft. One approach to control GvHD is to employ ‘suicide' gene therapy. In the customary adaptation of this approach, the herpes simplex virus type 1 thymidine kinase (HSV1-tk) gene, combined with the antiviral prodrug ganciclovir (GCV), is used to control GvHD after introduction of this suicide gene into donor T lymphocytes. However, the efficiency of HSV1-tk is suboptimal and the issue of host immunogenicity against this heterologous effector gene product can hamper outcomes. In addition, prophylactic GCV is often used to control cytomegalovirus infection after BMT. This confounds the broad clinical implementation of this approach. Our novel suicide gene therapy strategy combines the use of human thymidylate monophosphate kinase (tmpk) and the prodrug Zidovudine (AZT) in a lentiviral vector (LV) format. Since tmpk is endogenously expressed in human cells, immunogenic responses will be limited. We constructed a LV expression system carrying wild-type or one of two modified forms of tmpk. These engineered tmpk mutants (F105Y and BL) show substantially increased catalytic conversion of AZT compared to wild-type tmpk. Our vector also includes a truncated form of human CD19 (hCD19Δ), not normally expressed on the T cell lineage, that can be used to enrich and track transduced cells. Highly efficient (95%) transduction of Jurkat cells (human T cell leukemia line) was attained by a single infection with our LVs (MOI of 10). Transduced cells were efficiently and selectively killed in a dose-dependent manner by AZT (IC50 of 2 μM), while wild-type tmpk transduced cells were unaffected by AZT up to 100 μM. In response to AZT treatment, the apoptotic cell indices of cells transduced with wild-type tmpk, F105Y, or BL were 6.2 ± 0.3 %, 40.7 ± 1.7 %, and 46.1 ± 4.6 %, respectively (n=3). We next established by HPLC that cells transduced with a LV encoding a mutant form of tmpk effectively convert AZT into its active anti-metabolite form, AZT-triphosphate (AZT-TP). Intracellular ratio of AZT-TP to AZT-monophosphate (MP) is 11.3 in cells transduced with a LV encoding the BL mutant of tmpk, compared to 0.02 in non-transduced cells and 0.10 in wild-type tmpk transduced cells. Our findings also revealed that following incubation with indirubin-3′-oxime, which inhibits cellular proliferation, and AZT treatment, transduced cells were successfully killed. Thus the cytotoxic mechanism differs from HSV1-tk mediated cell killing and is independent of cell proliferation. We also succeeded in the infection of primary mouse and human T cells to over 40% and 70% transduction efficiency, respectively. Lastly, we have shown that in vivo growth of tumor cells transduced with these mutant tmpk LVs was totally inhibited by treatment with AZT. These results demonstrate that our novel suicide gene therapy system has significant potential for many clinical applications.

1008. Prostate-Specific Oncolytic Adenovirus Based on Bidirectional TSTA System

Top of pageAbstract Due to the exceptionally limited treatment options currently available for recurrent hormone refractory prostate cancer (HRPC), gene therapy can provide a tool to fight this Herculean disease. To develop a safe and efficient vector-based gene delivery approach, we employed a prostate-targeted gene expression system. The combination of a modified PSA promoter/enhancer and two-step transcriptional amplification (TSTA) system enabled us to achieve robust expression of transgenes in our vectors while maintaining prostate specificity. Furthermore, integration of an efficient adenovirus-mediated gene delivery approach and noninvasive optical imaging allowed us to continuously monitor and evaluate our system on human prostate cancer mouse xenografted models (Sato, et al. Mol Ther, '03). We have also shown that the TSTA system can be usable for clinically-translatable mPET radionuclide imaging, applicable to HRPC where androgen receptor (AR) is expressed (Sato, et al. Clin Cancer Res, '05), and that the suicide gene therapy approach with the TSTA system exhibited promising results, as well as remarkably lower liver toxicity compared to conventional CMV promoter (Johnson et al. submitted). To further explore therapeutic approaches to utilize the TSTA system, we have taken an oncolytic approach to eradicate prostate cancer. Previously we had confirmed that two distinct genes can be expressed from a single construct because of the structural nature of the TSTA system. A pair of firefly luciferase (FL) and HSV-1 sr39tk genes flanking five repeats of GAL4 binding sites were both expressed from a single adenovirus vector simultaneously. We successfully obtained both optical and mPET imaging on the same animal by this bidirectional vector. Based on this, we developed an oncolytic adenovirus utilizing the TSTA system. In this new vector, both E1A and E1B driven by GAL4 binding sites will make the virus replication competent by the GAL4VP16 activator expressed in trans. Therefore, where the TSTA is active, E1A and E1B will be expressed, and this should lead to oncolytic adenoviral replication. In a preliminary study, virus replication was suggested by the increase of the FL activity from the AdTSTA-FL co-infected in the AR+ prostate cell line, LNCaP, following the transfection of the plasmid with E1A and E1B flanking two GAL4 repeats (G2). However, no increase of the FL activity was seen with the E1A and E1B plasmid with no GAL4 repeat (G0), possibly because of no virus production. The viral production was actually confirmed by a plaque formation in the transfection study with a G2 or G4 driving E1 proteins but was not for G0 in addition to the expression of E1 proteins. Viral replication was also confirmed by co-infection study using G4 adenovirus but not with G0 adenovirus. Currently we are working on analyzing G0, G2, and G4 adenovirus to see oncolytic activity and constructing all-in-one TSTA oncolytic adenoviruses. We foresee that this oncolytic approach based on the TSTA system can be another promising gene therapy strategy for the advanced stages of prostate cancer.

RD114‐pseudotyped retroviral vectors kill cancer cells by syncytium formation and enhance the cytotoxic effect of the TK/GCV gene therapy strategy

Wild-type RD114 virus is capable of generating syncytia during its replication, and it is believed that cell-free viruses direct the fusion of neighboring cells. The RD114 envelope (Env) that mediates this fusion event is now widely used to pseudotype retroviral and lentiviral vectors in gene therapy. Indeed, vectors pseudotyped with RD114 Env are very efficient to transfer genes into human hematopoietic cells, and they are resistant to human complement inactivation. In this study, we have tested the potential of RD114-pseudotyped vectors produced from the FLYRD18 packaging cell line to induce syncytia. RD114-pseudotyped vectors produced from the FLYRD18 packaging cells were added on tumor cell lines, and the formation of syncytia was assessed by microscopy after cell fixation and methylene blue staining. The kinetics of syncytium formation was analyzed by time-lapse microscopy. Finally, the cytotoxic effect of RD114-pseudotyped vectors was measured by the MTT assay on tumor cells, and in combination with the TK/GCV strategy. We have found that these vectors were able to mediate cell-to-cell fusion of human tumor cell lines. A few hours after addition of the vector, cells started to aggregate to form syncytia that eventually evolved toward cell death 48 h postinfection. RD114-pseudotyped vectors were very efficient at killing human cancer cells, and they were also able to enhance dramatically the cytotoxic effect of the TK/GCV strategy. These findings indicate that RD114-pseudotyped vectors used alone, or in combination with a suicide gene therapy approach, have great potential for the treatment of cancer.

Cancer cells as targets for lentivirus-mediated gene transfer and gene therapy

Lentiviruses have been used as gene transfer vectors for almost 10 years and their utility has been demonstrated in a variety of different applications. However, their value in cancer gene therapy has not been studied thoroughly. Here we show that VSV-G pseudotyped HIV-1-based lentiviruses are efficient vectors for human tumor cells in vitro and in vivo. Lentiviral gene transfer efficiency was demonstrated by transducing 42 different cell lines, representing 10 different human tumor types. It was shown that most of the cell lines were good or excellent targets for lentiviral transduction, allowing 50-95% gene transfer efficiency. These results were comparable to those obtained with an E1/E3 deleted, serotype 5 adenovirus vector. Analysis of lentivirus vector structure revealed that virus particles devoid of HIV-1 accessory proteins appeared to be more efficient, but the presence of enhancing elements cPPT and WPRE did not play a major role in transduction efficiency to four different human tumor cell lines. However, their effect on the gene expression level in these cells was apparent. To examine the impact of lentiviral gene expression level on suicide gene therapy approach, human osteosarcoma cells were transduced with lentivirus- or adenovirus vectors carrying the fusion gene HSV-TK-GFP and exposed to ganciclovir. Cell viability analysis after the treatment revealed that both vector types induced similar level of cytotoxicity, suggesting that lentiviral expression of a suicide gene is adequate for tumor cell destruction. Finally, in vivo transduction studies with subcutaneous tumors showed that lentivirus vectors can yield similar gene transfer efficiency than adenovirus vector, despite three orders of magnitude lower titer of the lentiviral preparation. In conclusion, these data show that lentiviruses are efficient gene transfer vehicles for human tumor cells and justify their use in further preclinical cancer gene therapy studies.

A neuroblastoma-selective suicide gene therapy approach using the tyrosine hydroxylase promoter.

In this study, selective expression of therapeutic transgenes was evaluated in neuroblastoma cells. Promoter fragments of the genes for neuron-specific enolase (NSEp), tyrosine hydroxylase (THp), and dopamine-beta-hydroxylase (DBHp) were studied in neuroblastoma and nonneuronal cell lines by transient transfection experiments using fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) analysis of enhanced green fluorescent protein (egfp) and luciferase (luc+) assay. Both reporter gene assays revealed a neuroblastoma-selective expression mediated by NSEp and THp, whereas DBHp was active only in a murine neuroblastoma cell line. Reporter gene expression by NSEp in neuroblastoma cells was markedly higher than expression by THp, but NSEp also showed considerable background activity in nonneuronal cells. THp-driven expression of egfp was 35-fold higher in human neuroblastoma MHH-NB11 compared with nonneuronal HeLa cells. Thus, THp was chosen for a neuroblastoma-selective suicide gene therapy approach using the herpes simplex virus type 1 thymidine kinase (HSV-tk)/ganciclovir (GCV) system. A retrovirus vector that contained an expression cassette of a HSV-tk/egfp fusion gene and THp in antisense orientation was generated. Stably transduced human neuroblastoma cells and nonneuronal cell lines were generated, and HSV-tk/egfp expression was measured by FACS and GCV cytotoxicity assay. There was a 2.2-fold difference in green fluorescence and a 1.4-fold difference in cell killing between the human neuroblastoma MHH-NB11 and HeLa cells after HSV-tk/egfp gene transfer. The overall difference in THp-HSV-tk/egfp-mediated cell killing between neuroblastoma and nonneuronal tumor cell lines was statistically significant (P = 0.001). In conclusion, the present study demonstrated the feasibility of a neuroblastoma-selective gene therapy approach using the THp/HSV-tk/egfp expression cassette.

Methods to improve efficacy in suicide gene therapy approaches: targeting prodrug-activating enzymes carboxypeptidase G2 and nitroreductase to different subcellular compartments.

AbstractCurrent cancer chemotherapy strategies are often hampered by the lack of tumor selectivity, resulting in unwanted damage to healthy tissue. Gene-directed enzyme-prodrug therapy (GDEPT) (1) and virus-directed enzyme-prodrug therapy (VDEPT) (2) are suicide gene therapy approaches that aim to deliver cytotoxic agents to tumor cells in a specific manner, thus improving the selectivity of chemotherapy and protecting normal cells from adverse side effects. In the first step, a gene encoding a foreign enzyme is delivered to tumor cells (see Fig. 1). The aim is to express the enzyme only in the tumor cells and then administer a prodrug. Prodrugs are small molecules that are nontoxic to normal cells, but are converted to potent cytotoxic agents in tumors. In GDEPT, the foreign enzyme performs this conversion, so if the enzyme is successfully targeted, the toxin will only be produced in the tumor, sparing normal tissues from excessive damage. Schematic diagram of GDEPT. (A) Delivery of the gene encoding the prodrug-activating enzyme by recombinant viruses. (B) expression of the enzyme by cells that have been transduced. Upon prodrug administration, the enzyme converts the prodrug into the active, cytotoxic drug (magnified square), which spreads to adjacent cells that do not express the enzyme (bystander effect). (C) The cytotoxic drug induces cell death in expressing and nonexpressing cells. KeywordsThymidine KinaseBystander EffectHerpes Simplex VirusCPG2 ActivityDirect Cell KillingThese keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Characterization of CD20-transduced T lymphocytes as an alternative suicide gene therapy approach for the treatment of graft-versus-host disease.

We have previously proposed the CD20 molecule as a novel suicide gene for T lymphocytes in the context of allogeneic bone marrow transplantation, because CD20 can be used both as a selection marker and as a killer gene after exposure to the anti-CD20 therapeutic antibody rituximab. We now report on preclinical studies using this novel system, in which the best transduction protocol, reproducibility, yield, feasibility, and functionality of the transduced T lymphocytes have been investigated with a large donor series. Wild-type human CD20 cDNA was transduced into human T lymphocytes, using a Moloney-derived retroviral vector. Alternative protocols were tested by employing either one or four spinoculations (in which cells are centrifuged in the presence of retroviral vector supernatant) and stimulating T cells with phytohemagglutinin (PHA) or anti-CD3/CD28. One spinoculation alone was sufficient to obtain approximately 30% CD20-positive cells within four experimental days. Four spinoculations significantly increased transduction to 60%. A small difference in transduction efficiency was observed between the two stimulation methods, with PHA being superior to anti-CD3/CD28. Transduced cells could be purified on immunoaffinity columns, with purity reaching 98% and yield being on average 50%. Finally, 86-97% of immunoselected T lymphocytes could be killed in vitro with rituximab and complement. More importantly, the CD20 transgene did not alter the functionality of T lymphocytes with respect to allogeneic recognition and cytotoxic response, anti-Epstein-Barr virus cytotoxic response, antigenic response to tetanus toxoid antigen, interleukin 2 (IL-2), IL-4, and interferon gamma production; chemotaxis in the presence of stromal cell-derived factor 1, phenotype for several activation markers including HLA-DR, CD25, CD69, and CD95, and T cell repertoire.

Herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase-mediated suicide gene therapy for hepatocellular carcinoma using HIV-1-derived lentiviral vectors

Background/AimsGene therapy is a promising approach for treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). However, transduction of non-tumoral hepatocytes may lead to severe hepatitis when using suicide gene therapy approaches. The aim of our study was to evaluate the gene transfer efficiency into HCC cells and normal hepatocytes using human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-derived lentiviral vectors in vitro and in vivo. MethodsLentiviral vectors encoding for the LacZ gene or the fusion gene HSV-Tk/GFP were tested in vitro in human HCC cells and human hepatocytes in primary culture and in vivo in a chemically induced rat model of HCC. ResultsWe show that HIV-1-derived lentiviral vectors are efficient in transducing HCC cells in vitro and in vivo. No significant transduction of non-tumorous hepatocytes was observed in vivo whatever the route of administration used. Measurement of tumor growth following direct intratumoral injection of a lentiviral vector containing the HSV-Tk gene and GCV treatment showed a strong antitumoral efficacy in the absence of normal liver toxicity. ConclusionsThese observations suggest that lentiviral vectors allow an antitumoral effect with low liver toxicity when using suicide gene therapy approach and could be efficient tools for HCC gene therapy.

Structural Basis for Substrate Specificity of Escherichia coli Purine Nucleoside Phosphorylase

Purine nucleoside phosphorylase catalyzes reversible phosphorolysis of purine nucleosides and 2'-deoxypurine nucleosides to the free base and ribose (or 2'-deoxyribose) 1-phosphate. Whereas the human enzyme is specific for 6-oxopurine ribonucleosides, the Escherichia coli enzyme accepts additional substrates including 6-oxopurine ribonucleosides, 6-aminopurine ribonucleosides, and to a lesser extent purine arabinosides. These differences have been exploited in a potential suicide gene therapy treatment for solid tumors. In an effort to optimize this suicide gene therapy approach, we have determined the three-dimensional structure of the E. coli enzyme in complex with 10 nucleoside analogs and correlated the structures with kinetic measurements and computer modeling. These studies explain the preference of the enzyme for ribose sugars, show increased flexibility for active site residues Asp204 and Arg24, and suggest that interactions involving the 1- and 6-positions of the purine and the 4'- and 5'-positions of the ribose provide the best opportunities to increase prodrug specificity and enzyme efficiency.

Gene therapy of thyroid cancer via retrovirally-driven combined expression of human interleukin-2 and herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase.

Based on our clinical experience with combined gene therapy of glioblastoma, we developed a retroviral vector expressing two therapeutic genes (i.e. thymidine kinase of herpes simplex virus, HSV-TK, and interleukin-2, IL-2) and evaluated its efficiency in vitro and in vivo. Expression of therapeutic genes in transduced thyroid carcinoma cells was analyzed by real-time RT-PCR. Ganciclovir sensitivity of infected cells was assessed in vitro in thyroid carcinoma cell lines and in vivo in nude mice bearing xenografted thyroid cancers. The combined effect of IL-2/HSV-TK was compared with the effect of IL-2 alone. Expression of therapeutic genes was higher in differentiated than in anaplastic thyroid carcinoma cells. Ganciclovir treatment led to dose- and time-dependent killing of transduced cells in vitro. A bystander effect was demonstrated by using mixtures of infected and non-infected cells. In vivo studies showed a significant reduction of growth and the presence of an inflammatory infiltrate in transduced thyroid tumors expressing IL-2 alone, as compared with non-infected tumors. By using the retroviral vector expressing IL-2/HSV-TK, treatment with ganciclovir led to complete eradication of anaplastic tumors and a >80% reduction of the size of differentiated thyroid carcinomas. Histological analysis of tumor specimens showed extensive necrosis and inflammatory cell infiltrates. The combination of IL-2/HSV-TK plus ganciclovir was significantly more efficient than IL-2 alone in eradicating tumor masses. The bystander effect was also obtained in vivo. These findings demonstrate the feasibility and efficiency of a combined immunomodulating and suicide gene therapy approach for thyroid carcinomas.

Adenovirus vector-mediated delivery of the prodrug-converting enzyme carboxypeptidase G2 in a secreted or GPI-anchored form: High-level expression of this active conditional cytotoxic enzyme at the plasma membrane.

Carboxypeptidase G2 (CPG2) is a powerful prodrug-converting enzyme. Without a requirement for endogenous enzymes or cofactors, it can directly activate mustard alkylating prodrugs to cytotoxic species, killing both quiescent and dividing cells. This paper provides the first report of its use in the context of a clinically relevant delivery vehicle using adenovirus vectors. To strengthen the efficacy of the prodrug-activating system, the enzyme has been engineered to be secreted or glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchored to the extracellular membrane of tumor cells, resulting in an enhanced bystander effect by facilitating diffusion of the active drug through extracellular, rather than intracellular, activation. Using the vectors, we have achieved expression of functional secreted or GPI-anchored CPG2 in a panel of tumor cell lines demonstrating no loss in efficacy as a result of GPI anchor retention. Despite variable transduction efficiencies inherent to these vectors, greater than 50% cell kill was achievable in all of the cell lines tested following only a single exposure to the prodrug ZD2767P. Even in cell lines refractive to infection with the vectors, substantial cell death was recorded, indicative of the enhanced bystander effect generated following extracellular prodrug activation. A direct evaluation of the efficacy of our system has been made against adenoviral delivery of herpes simples virus thymidine kinase plus ganciclovir (GCV), a suicide gene therapy approach already in the clinic. In a short-term human glioma culture (IN1760) resistant to the clinical chemotherapeutic drug CCNU (1-(2-chloroethyl)-3-cyclohexyl-1-nitrosourea), thymidine kinase/GCV effected no cell killing compared to 70% cell killing with our system.

Appropriate subcellular localisation of prodrug-activating enzymes has important consequences for suicide gene therapy.

Escherichia coli B nitroreductase (NR) has been expressed stably in MDA-MB-361 human breast adenocarcinoma cells either as the wild-type protein (wtNR), which is distributed evenly between the cytoplasmic and nuclear compartments, or targeted to the mitochondrion (mtNR). Whereas bacterial NR is active as a dimer, a proportion of wtNR is monomeric. In contrast, mtNR is mostly dimeric, suggesting that it adopts a more stable, native conformation. Despite this, when tested in gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy cell cytotoxicity studies, cells expressing wtNR or mtNR had similar sensitivity to the prodrug CB1954 and mounted similar bystander killing effects. Furthermore, when short prodrug exposures were given, wtNR was more efficient at killing cells than mtNR. These data demonstrate that the site of enzyme expression and prodrug activation is an important variable that requires consideration in suicide gene therapy approaches.

VP22 enhanced intercellular trafficking of HSV thymidine kinase reduced the level of ganciclovir needed to cause suicide cell death.

The inefficiency of herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (TK) gene transfer and toxicity of ganciclovir (GCV) at high concentrations in vivo limits the use of this suicide gene therapy approach for the treatment of cancers in clinical settings. To overcome the problem, we have sought evidence of amplification of cytotoxicity by co-transfer of the TK gene fused with the gene encoding HSV-1 structural protein VP22 which has a remarkable ability for intercellular trafficking. The expression of the fusion proteins from the chimeric VP22-TK or VP22-EGFP genes was shown by Western blot and VP22 promoted TK or EGFP intercellular trafficking by an indirect immunofluorescent assay. The cytotoxicity was demonstrated by a colorimetric cell proliferation assay followed by an assessment of the bystander effect on admixtures of transfected with non-transfected naive cells. Our results show the expression of the VP22 fusion proteins and their spread to varying numbers of bystander cells (up to 30, observed in viable cells with VP22-EGFP as well as after methanol fixation), confirming that VP22 assisted intercellular trafficking of the fusion proteins. This VP22 promoted TK spreading resulted in killing by 2.5 microg/ml GCV of virtually all cells in cultures that had been transfected at an efficiency of only 27.5%. In contrast, fewer than 80% of cells were killed when transfected with 'tk alone' at the same efficiency. The cell killing effect was exponentially dependent on GCV concentration in cells transfected with 'tk alone' at GCV concentrations between 0.25 and 0.5 microg/ml, but not those transfected with VP22-TK, probably due to the continuously variable, high sensitivity of about 50% of cells. Even at low concentration of GCV (0.2 microg/ml), the enhancement of cell killing by VP22 was four-fold higher in cells transfected with VP22-TK than in cells transfected with 'tk alone'. VP22 enhanced intercellular trafficking of TK and amplified the TK/GCV killing effect, especially in the lower range of GCV concentrations. This offers a new strategy to enhance the effectiveness of suicide gene therapy for the treatment of cancers.

Enhanced ganciclovir killing and bystander effect of human tumor cells transduced with a retroviral vector carrying a herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase gene mutant.

Gene transfer of the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (TK) gene associated with ganciclovir (GCV) treatment can lead to death of TK-expressing cells, and of neighboring TK- cells because of the bystander effect. Thus, a small proportion of TK+ cells in a tumor can lead to its complete regression after GCV treatment. However, a lack of efficacy of gene transfer into tumors associated with low GCV sensitivity and poor bystander effect of human cancer cells currently limit the clinical use of this suicide gene therapy approach. To increase the potency of suicide gene therapy, we have tested the GCV sensitivity and the bystander effect of TK mutants that have been previously described. After retroviral transduction of the TK mutants into human tumor cells of various origins, we have found a strong killing effect of GCV with cells expressing the mutants TK30 or TKF161C. The GCV sensitivity of several human tumor cell types expressing TK30 was 9- to 500-fold higher than cells containing wild-type TK. Furthermore, TK30-expressing cells were able to kill bystander cells much more efficiently than TK-expressing cells. Thus, TK30 mutant is a promising candidate for suicide gene therapy clinical trials.

Gene therapy of metastatic colon carcinoma: regression of multiple hepatic metastases by adenoviral expression of bacterial cytosine deaminase.

Colon carcinoma accounts for 20% of deaths due to malignancies in the Western world. Once metastases occur, therapeutic options are limited, with an approximate 5-year survival of only 5%. To investigate the potential of new gene therapeutic approaches, a hepatic micrometastasis model of colon carcinoma in BALB/c mice was established. Inoculation of syngeneic MCA26 colon carcinoma cells into the spleens of 18- to 20-week-old mice resulted in the formation of multiple hepatic metastases. Selective transduction of developing hepatic metastases was demonstrated using a beta-galactosidase-expressing recombinant adenovirus. Cytosine deaminase (CD) can metabolize 5-fluorocytosine into the chemotherapeutic reagent 5-fluorouracil (5FU). The antitumoral potential of this suicide gene therapy approach was explored by systemic application of a recombinant replication-deficient adenovirus encoding for the bacterial CD gene under the control of the cytomegalovirus promoter (Ad.CMV-CD). Injection into the tail vein of tumor-bearing mice resulted in delayed tumor growth with significant reduction in hepatic metastases. The potential of this experimental approach for possible future clinical applications was evaluated by investigating adenoviral transduction efficiency, 5FU sensitivity, and 5-fluorocytosine-dependent Ad.CMV-CD toxicity in a variety of human colon cancer cell lines. Although the murine cell lines MCA26 and CC36 were highly sensitive to 5FU, the human colon cancer cell lines showed a 1-100 times higher resistance to 5FU. Specific Ad.CMV-CD toxicity correlates with 5FU toxicity. Transduction efficiency in human colon carcinoma cell lines was shown to be 10-1700 times higher compared with murine cell lines, thus compensating for 5FU resistance. In conclusion, suicide gene therapy using CD may be promising as an adjuvant treatment regimen for hepatic micrometastases of human colon carcinoma.