Sudden Stratospheric Warming Research Articles

Technical note: Multi-year changes in the Brewer–Dobson circulation from Halogen Occultation Experiment (HALOE) methane

Abstract. This study makes use of Halogen Occultation Experiment (HALOE) methane (CH4) in a search for multi-year changes in the Brewer–Dobson circulation (BDC). Changes in CH4 are determined for three successive 5-year time spans from 1992 to 2005, and there are significant differences between them. There is a clear separation between the changes in the Northern Hemisphere near 30 hPa and at the transition of the shallow and deep branches of the BDC. The CH4 changes are positive and large in the shallow branch following the eruption of Pinatubo, but they then decrease and agree with tropospheric trends in the late 1990s and early 2000s. CH4 decreases in the upper part of the deep branch from 1992 to 1997 or following the eruption of Pinatubo. CH4 continues to decrease in the deep branch in the late 1990s but then increases in the early 2000s, although those changes are small compared with the seasonal and interannual variations of CH4. Multi-year changes are due, in part, to wave forcings during the El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) of 1997–1998 and beyond and to episodic, sudden stratospheric warming (SSW) events during both time spans. It is concluded that time series of HALOE CH4 provide effective tracer diagnostics for studies of the nature of the BDC from 1992 to 2005.

A CMIP6 Analysis of Past and Future Arctic Winter Stratospheric Temperature Trends

AbstractReanalysis data reveal a weak warming trend in the midwinter Arctic stratosphere, contrary to the cooling expectation based on the greenhouse gas effect. This trend is also influenced by the occurrence of sudden stratospheric warmings (SSWs). Using Phase 6 of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6) we investigate temperature trends over a similar timescale as ERA5 and find that CMIP6 models can replicate the positive midwinter temperature trend in the mid‐lower stratosphere. However, when considering the multi‐model mean, this positive temperature trend is much weaker than ERA5. Extrapolating to the future, we find that the SSW‐driven positive temperature trend will likely not continue in the future based on the SSP2‐4.5 and SSP5‐8.5 climate scenarios. Instead, the models project there will be widespread cooling throughout the Arctic winter stratosphere regardless of the occurrence of SSWs. Using a subsample of CMIP6 models which replicate the seasonality of the Arctic winter stratosphere most similarly to that of ERA5, we also find that the zonal wind strength during SSWs correlates the most with the temperature trends found there. However, trends in the zonal wind strength alone cannot account for the observed temperature trends among the CMIP6 models.

The tropical influence on sub‐seasonal predictability of wintertime stratosphere and stratosphere–troposphere coupling

AbstractA unique set of relaxation experiments with a forecast model initialized during December–January 1999–2019 is used to explore tropical influence on the Northern Hemisphere polar stratosphere and stratosphere–troposphere coupling, to quantify predictability benefits due to the perfect knowledge of the tropical variability. On average, predictability of the polar stratosphere, as represented by the 50 hPa geopotential height anomalies north of 50°N (Z50), increases from 17 days in freely running (control) forecasts to 21 days in the tropical relaxation experiments. At sub‐seasonal time‐scales, a statistically significant improvement in weekly mean skill scores can be demonstrated in 14%–20% of individual forecast ensembles, mostly in cases when the skill of the corresponding control forecast is worse than average. In these forecasts, root‐mean‐square errors and forecast spread of Z50 during forecast weeks 3–5 are decreased by 10%–15%. Stratospheric improvements are detected during periods of both vortex strengthening and vortex weakening, including most major Sudden Stratospheric Warmings that occurred during the study period, via modulation of the upward wave activity fluxes. An active Madden–Julian Oscillation (MJO) is found in most of these events with MJO phase 5–7 preceding vortex weakening and MJO phase 3–4 preceding vortex strengthening. Forecasts with improved stratospheric circulation also have improved tropospheric circulation during and after the periods when improvements are detected in the stratosphere. We attribute these improvements to both stratosphere–troposphere coupling and tropospheric tropical teleconnections.

Characteristics and Mechanism of Interhemispheric Coupling in Austral Winter Revealed by Long‐Term Reanalysis Data for the Whole Middle Atmosphere

AbstractGlobal characteristics of dynamical fields for the interhemispheric coupling (IHC) initiated with a sudden stratospheric warming (SSW) in the southern hemisphere in the austral winter were examined using the global reanalysis for the whole neutral atmosphere from a data assimilation with satellite observations over 15 years of 2005–2019. Even in the austral winter, a strong cold equatorial stratosphere associated with the SSW, which is essential for the IHC, occurs about once every two years. The mechanism of the IHC in the austral winter is basically similar to that in the boreal winter. However, there are two significant differences in the IHC characteristics between the austral and boreal winters. One is that the SSW in the austral winter occurs mainly at midlatitudes, whereas the SSW in the boreal winter occurs mainly at high latitudes. As a result, a warm temperature anomaly simultaneously appears in the southern polar mesosphere in the austral winter, which is not observed for the boreal winter. The other is related to the seasonal variation of the quasi‐two‐day wave activity and induced forcing and gravity wave forcing in the summer mesosphere. For the IHC events occurring in July, when these wave activities and forcings are high, the response in the summer mesosphere is similar to that of the boreal winter. In contrast, for late August and September, when these wave forcings are weak, the response in the summer mesosphere is small. This result indicates that the IHC characteristics are largely influenced by the seasonal variation of these waves.

Impact of sudden stratospheric warming on middle atmospheric circulation in the southern hemisphere: A comparative study

A comparative study on the impact of rare Southern Hemisphere (SH) Sudden Stratospheric Warmings (SSW) on the middle atmospheric circulation is investigated using a global reanalysis dataset. Since the SH SSW generally occur around spring equinox marking the seasonal transition, so an attempt has been made to isolate the seasonal transition effect from the actual data by carrying out deseasoning to delineate the effects mainly due to the warming. The deseasoned winds are able to extract relatively weak dynamical signatures of SSW at lower altitudes in terms of prominent zonal mean easterly forcing around the peak warming day (PWD) which are not evident from the actual winds. The influence of 2002 SSW seems to reach the troposphere in terms of easterly deseasoned forcing, which is not the case in 2019. Also the deseasoned winds in the stratosphere reveals earlier occurrence of easterly forcing in the extratropical latitudes, which progresses poleward around the PWD indicating a possible tropical precursor to the SH SSW. In general, the actual upper mesospheric wind is dominated by seasonal transition but the deseasoned winds reveal easterly and southerly forcing due to the SSW. Interestingly, the horizontal flow is found to be very different or even opposite in direction at different longitudes indicating uneven longitudinal response of the atmosphere to the warming events across the globe. Overall, the present study provides a detailed and comparative overview of the middle atmospheric circulation in terms of zonal mean flow and concomitant zonal variability during two rare major and minor SSW events in the SH.

Analysis of gravity wave activity during stratospheric sudden warmings in the northern hemisphere

Analysis of gravity wave activity during stratospheric sudden warmings in the northern hemisphere

Long-term variation of Arctic Sudden Stratospheric Warmings (SSW) and potential causes

Long-term variation of Arctic Sudden Stratospheric Warmings (SSW) and potential causes

Identifying Perturbations That Tipped the Stratosphere Into a Sudden Warming During January 2013

AbstractWe present a new methodology demonstrating that specific small‐magnitude regional perturbations can cause large systematic responses in subseasonal predictions. We show this with ensemble forecasts of the January 2013 Sudden Stratospheric Warming (SSW) from an operational long‐range global prediction system. In forecast members which predict the SSW, tropospheric ridging over the North Atlantic is strengthened 10 days prior to the event. This subsequently enhances planetary wave forcing and weakens the stratospheric polar vortex. Transplanting tropospheric conditions in this region from “correct” to “incorrect” forecasts (and vice versa) significantly alters the SSW forecast probability. The occurrence of this SSW is therefore strongly controlled by the troposphere several days prior. Tipping more members into a sudden warming also significantly affects surface predictions the following month. Despite chaotic behavior of the climate system, small‐magnitude synoptic‐scale perturbations can drive different dynamical states and systematically impact medium and long‐range predictions.

A Data-Driven Study of the Drivers of Stratospheric Circulation via Reduced Order Modeling and Data Assimilation

Stratospheric dynamics are strongly affected by the absorption/emission of radiation in the Earth’s atmosphere and Rossby waves that propagate upward from the troposphere, perturbing the zonal flow. Reduced order models of stratospheric wave–zonal interactions, which parameterize these effects, have been used to study interannual variability in stratospheric zonal winds and sudden stratospheric warming (SSW) events. These models are most sensitive to two main parameters: Λ, forcing the mean radiative zonal wind gradient, and h, a perturbation parameter representing the effect of Rossby waves. We take one such reduced order model with 20 years of ECMWF atmospheric reanalysis data and estimate Λ and h using both a particle filter and an ensemble smoother to investigate if the highly-simplified model can accurately reproduce the averaged reanalysis data and which parameter properties may be required to do so. We find that by allowing additional complexity via an unparameterized Λ(t), the model output can closely match the reanalysis data while maintaining behavior consistent with the dynamical properties of the reduced-order model. Furthermore, our analysis shows physical signatures in the parameter estimates around known SSW events. This work provides a data-driven examination of these important parameters representing fundamental stratospheric processes through the lens and tractability of a reduced order model, shown to be physically representative of the relevant atmospheric dynamics.

Conjugate hemispheric response of Earth’s ionosphere due to 2019 Antarctic minor Sudden Stratospheric Warming (SSW): Comparison with 2013 Arctic major SSW

In this paper, we attempt to compare the Antarctic SSW of 2019 with the Arctic SSW of 2013. Despite being a minor SSW, the rare Antarctic event of September 2019 caused a significant enhancement of stratospheric temperature at high latitudes with more temperature deviation than the Arctic major SSW of 2013. On the basis of the duration and extent of stratospheric zonal mean zonal wind, the 2019 SSW is comparable to major SSWs. An exceptionally strong wave 1 planetary wave was observed during the 2019 SSW. We have investigated the response of the ionospheric total electron content (TEC) during both the SSWs over two low mid-latitude locations Okinawa and Darwin, which form magnetic conjugate pair. The extent of maximum ionospheric deviations during the 2019 SSW is almost comparable to the 2013 SSW in their respective hemispheres. We have observed mostly night time enhancement in TEC during the Arctic SSW, while daytime enhancement is noted during the Antarctic SSW. Hemispheric asymmetry is observed during both the SSWs. Minor geomagnetic storm has been noticed coinciding with each SSW during different phases of the warming. The SSW, solar flux, and storm contribution on the TEC have been calculated during both the SSWs, which shows clear contribution of SSW on the total TEC despite the presence of storm and during moderately high solar activity. We have also investigated the foF2 variations from ionosonde and IRI-16 at the same two locations. The peak electron density from ionosonde responds to the warming in a manner similar to TEC. The foF2 of IRI-16 exhibits overestimation during daytime and underestimation during nighttime on quiet days during low solar activity (2019), while during moderate solar activity (2013), it overestimates during morning hours. However, it can not predict the enhancements of foF2 during SSWs.

Mesospheric Water Vapor From SABER as a Tracer for the Residual Mean Circulation During SSW Events

AbstractThe sparse wind observations and reanalysis winds in the mesosphere make it challenging to accurately determine the residual mean meridional circulation (MMC). As winds distribute tracers, an alternative approach is to utilize long‐lived trace species such as water vapor (H2O). The recently released H2O data from Sounding of the Atmosphere using Broadband Emission Radiometry (SABER) version 2.07, combined with simulations by the Whole Atmosphere Community Climate Model eXtension with specified dynamics (SD‐WACCM‐X) and with the Data Assimilation Research Testbed (WACCMX + DART), provide an opportunity to assess the accuracy of using H2O isopleths to derive the vertical component of the residual MMC during the 2009 sudden stratospheric warming (SSW) event. In winter, the impact of photochemistry and diffusion on the distribution of mesospheric H2O is negligible compared to advective processes. H2O poleward of 70°N accurately captures the anomalous ascent that occurs a few days prior to the onset of the SSW and the subsequent descent. The derived vertical velocity in SD‐WACCM‐X and WACCMX + DART is qualitatively consistent with SABER observations. However, the derivation of vertical motion from isopleth analysis has limitations at the beginning of 2009 when the meridional transport is stronger than the vertical transport. While measuring winds in the mesosphere is challenging, satellite observations of mesospheric H2O prove to be an effective dynamical tracer during time periods characterized by strong vertical coupling.

Antarctic polar vortex dynamics in 2019 and 2020 under the influence of the subtropical stratosphere

The trend of strengthening of the Antarctic polar vortex in late spring and early summer (November–December) has been observed in recent decades. A good example of this trend is the dynamics of the Antarctic polar vortex in 2020 when it existed until the last week of December. In 2019, conversely, on the contrary, an unusually early breakup of the polar vortex occurred, a minor sudden stratospheric warming was recorded. Strengthening (or weakening) of the Antarctic polar vortex occurs as a result of an increase (or decrease) in the stratospheric meridional temperature gradient under conditions of growth (or decline) in the temperature of the lower subtropical stratosphere. We considered the temperature variations in the lower subtropical stratosphere in the spring of 2019 and 2020 and the corresponding response of the Antarctic polar vortex. The dynamics of the Antarctic polar vortex in September–October 2019 and November 2020 was largely synchronized with the temperature changes in the lower subtropical stratosphere relative to climatological means. Using correlation analysis, we show that the Antarctic polar vortex dynamics in December is largely due to the temperature changes in the lower subtropical stratosphere that occurred in the second half of November, which manifested itself in 2020.

Role of Southern Hemisphere sudden stratospheric warming in altering the intensity of Brewer-Dobson circulation and its impact on stratospheric ozone and water vapor

The changes in the intensity of Brewer-Dobson circulation (BDC) in the record-breaking Southern Hemisphere sudden stratospheric warming (SH SSW) event in 2019 are investigated in the present study. Wave driving was observed to be at its highest in 2019 SH SSW, despite the event being classified as a minor warming event. The Eliassen-Palm flux divergence, indicative of wave driving, was observed to be increasing before the SSW, and subsiding afterwards. The stratospheric circulation followed the wave driving and intensified along the warming episode. The resulting stratospheric distribution from Aura Microwave Limb Sounder showed a negative ozone anomaly (∼20%) in the tropical lower stratosphere and a downward propagating positive anomaly in the Southern Hemisphere polar stratosphere around the central dates. The water vapor mixing ratio showed an increase of more than 25% in the polar lower stratosphere and 10% in the tropical upper stratosphere. A cooling of about 5 K was observed in the tropical middle stratosphere. The results indicate that SH SSW can change the intensity of the stratospheric circulation which in turn affects the ozone and water vapor transport from the tropics to the pole.

Precursory Analysis Ensemble Spread Signals That Foreshadow Stratospheric Sudden Warmings

Abstract This study conducts a thorough investigation into the behaviors of analysis ensemble spreads linked to stratospheric sudden warming (SSW) events. A stratosphere-resolving ensemble data assimilation system is used here to document the evolution of analysis spread leading up to a pair of warming events. Precursory signals of the increased ensemble spreads were found a few days prior to two SSW events that occurred during December 2018 and August–September 2019 in the Northern and Southern Hemispheres, respectively. The signals appeared in the upper and middle stratosphere and did not appear at lower heights. When the signals appeared, it was found that both tendency by forecast and analysis increment in a forecast-analysis (data assimilation) cycle simultaneously became large. An empirical orthogonal function analysis showed that the dominant structures of the precursory signals were equivalent barotropic and were 90° out-of-phase with the analysis ensemble-mean field. Over the same period, the upper and middle stratosphere became more susceptible to barotropic instability than in their previous states. We conclude that the differing growth of barotropically unstable modes across ensemble members can amplify spread during the lead-up to SSW events. Significance Statement Winds in the winter stratospheric polar vortex are typically westerly. Occasionally, however, warming over the pole leads to a reversal of the flow through a process known as stratospheric sudden warming. These events are difficult to predict even in state-of-the-art analysis and forecasting systems. In this study, we identify a precursor signal in the form of increased ensemble spread that appears to originate from differing realizations of growing barotropic modes across the ensemble. This signal could serve as a useful forecasting tool by enhancing situational awareness in the lead-up to potential stratospheric sudden warming events.

The Evolution of Solar Tide‐Like Signatures in the Ionospheric Total Electron Content During Major Sudden Stratospheric Warming Events

AbstractBy using total electron content (TEC) from the global ionospheric maps, the solar tide‐like signatures in the ionosphere are explored. We further study how the main components evolve during the 2009 and 2018 major stratospheric sudden warming events (SSWs). The method of a least‐square fit is applied for extracting the solar tide‐like components. The three predominant components are SW2, D0, and SW1, amplitude of which increase in the equatorial ionization anomaly region after the onset of both SSW events, especially in the northern hemisphere. During the SSW events, the solar tide‐like components vary significantly with latitude and their evolutions show hemispherical asymmetries. Each same component presents similar evolutionary trend during both events. The characteristics of ionospheric tide‐like signatures and related mechanisms are discussed. The SW2 tide‐like responses in TEC closely follow the changes in the tidal wind fields in the lower thermosphere, which provide evidences of the atmosphere‐ionosphere coupling during SSW events. In addition, the latitudinal asymmetric distributing of stratospheric ozone and ionospheric TEC background during the SSW may be influence factors for the hemispherical asymmetries in tide‐like signatures responses in TEC.

Stratospheric Warming Events in the Period January–March 2023 and Their Impact on Stratospheric Ozone in the Northern Hemisphere

In this investigation, a comparison is presented between variations in temperature and ozone concentration at different altitude levels in the stratosphere for the Northern Hemisphere in the conditions of Sudden Stratospheric Warming (SSW) for the period January–March 2023. Spatial and altitude distribution of atmospheric characteristics derived from MERRA-2 are represented by their Fourier decomposition. A cross-correlation analysis between temperature and Total Ozone Column (TOC) is used. The longitudinal inhomogeneities in temperature, caused by stationary Planetary Waves with wavenumber 1 (SPW1), are found to be significant at altitudes around the maximum of the maximum of the ozone number density vertical distribution. As a result, it is established that the latitudinal and longitudinal distribution of TOC has a noticeable similarity with that of the temperature at altitudes close to the ozone concentration maximum. The results of correlation between temperature at individual stratospheric levels and ozone concentration show that (i) in the region around the ozone concentration maximum, the correlation is high and positive, (ii) at higher altitudes the sign of the correlation changes to negative (~37 km). The examination shows that the anomalous increases in TOC during SSW are due to an increase in ozone concentration in the altitudes between 10 km and 15 km.

Reasons for Low Fraction of Arctic Stratospheric Cloud in 2014/2015 Winter

AbstractPolar stratospheric clouds (PSCs) play a key role in Arctic amplification and stratospheric ozone destruction in polar regions. In this paper, we used the CALIPSO data to analyze the spatiotemporal distribution of Arctic PSCs from 2006 to 2021. We found that Arctic PSCs mainly appear in December, peak in late December and early January, disappearing in late February and early March. PSCs can extend from heights near the tropopause to over 25 km. However, there is the lowest fraction of PSCs in the 2014/2015 winter. This study found that the temperature in the 2014/2015 winter was warmer than the 15‐year average temperature, with the lowest temperature slightly below the PSCs formation temperature of about 5 K. The formation of the Ural blocking high accompanied by the poleward propagation of the planetary wave caused a sudden stratospheric warming (SSW) event on 3 January 2015, during which the warm air entered the polar vortex and divided it into two lobes. Additionally, a reduction in SO2 column mass density before the SSW event resulted PSCs occurring with a frequency of only 0.148 and dissipating rapidly in December. Moreover, the concentration of H2O and HNO3 in the gravitational settling process of PSCs decreased by 20–50%, the reduction of condensation nuclei made PSCs with the highest frequency of 0.074 in February appear briefly and then disappear. The chemical and dynamic analysis of PSCs formation is needed to further understand the spatiotemporal distribution of Arctic PSCs and to better predict future Arctic amplification and ozone destruction.

Statistics of sudden stratospheric warmings using a large model ensemble

AbstractUsing a large ensemble of initialised retrospective forecasts (hindcasts) from a seasonal prediction system, we explore various statistics relating to sudden stratospheric warmings (SSWs). Observations show that SSWs occur at a similar frequency during both El Niño and La Niña northern hemisphere winters. This is contrary to expectation, as the stronger stratospheric polar vortex associated with La Niña years might be expected to result in fewer of these extreme breakdowns. Here we show that this similar frequency may have occurred by chance due to the limited sample of years in the observational record. We also show that in these hindcasts, winters with two SSWs, a rare event in the observational record, on average have an increased surface impact. Multiple SSW events occur at a lower rate than expected if events were independent but somewhat surprisingly, our analysis also indicates a risk, albeit small, of winters with three or more SSWs, as yet an unseen event.

Influence of Sudden Stratospheric Warmings on the Migrating Diurnal Tide in the Equatorial Middle Atmosphere Observed by Aura/Microwave Limb Sounder

The Microwave Limb Sounder (MLS) onboard the satellite Aura measures the temperature at 01:44 LST (after midnight) and at 13:44 LST after noon in the equatorial middle atmosphere. The signatures of the migrating solar diurnal tide (DW1) show up in the difference between the night-time and the daytime temperature profiles. We find a good agreement between the equatorial DW1 proxy of the Aura/MLS observations and the migrating diurnal tide estimated by the Global Scale Wave Model (GSWM) in March. The equatorial DW1 proxy is shown for the time interval from 2004 to 2021 reaching a temporal resolution of 1 day. The amplitude modulations of the DW1 proxy are correlated at several altitudes. There are indications of a semi-annual and annual oscillation (SAO and AO) of the DW1 proxy. The composite of 17 events of major sudden stratospheric warmings (SSWs) shows that the equatorial, mesospheric DW1 proxy is reduced by about 10% during the first week after the SSW event. The nodes and bellies of the equatorial DW1 proxy are shifted downward by about 1–2 km in the first week after the SSW. The 14 day-oscillation of the DW1 proxy in the equatorial mesosphere is enhanced from 25 days before the SSW onset to 5 days after the SSW onset.

Boundary of nighttime ozone chemical equilibrium in the mesopause region: long-term evolution determined using 20-year satellite observations

Abstract. The assumption of nighttime ozone chemical equilibrium (NOCE) is widely employed for retrieving the Ox-HOx components in the mesopause from rocket and satellite measurements. In this work, the recently developed analytical criterion of determining the NOCE boundary is used (i) to study the connection of this boundary with O and H spatiotemporal variability based on 3D modeling of chemical transport and (ii) to retrieve and analyze the spatiotemporal evolution of the NOCE boundary in 2002–2021 from the SABER/TIMED dataset. It was revealed, first, that the NOCE boundary reproduces well the transition zone dividing deep and weak photochemical oscillations of O and H caused by the diurnal variations of solar radiation. Second, the NOCE boundary is sensitive to sporadic abrupt changes in the middle-atmosphere dynamics, in particular due to powerful sudden stratospheric warmings leading to the events of an elevated (up to ∼ 80 km) stratopause, which took place in January–March 2004, 2006, 2009, 2010, 2012, 2013, 2018, and 2019. Third, the space–time evolution of this characteristic expressed via pressure altitude contains a clear signal of an 11-year solar cycle in the 55∘ S–55∘ N range. In particular, the mean annual NOCE boundary averaged in this range of latitudes anticorrelates well with the F10.7 index with the coefficient of −0.95. Moreover, it shows a weak linear trend of 56.2±42.2 m per decade.