Successful Biocontrol Agent Research Articles

The aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum exhibits a greater survival after a heat shock when parasitized by the wasp Aphidius ervi

The pea aphid Acyrthosiphon pisum is a common pest of many species of legumes and its parasitoid Aphidius ervi is regarded as a successful biocontrol agent. In this study, we report a greater survival rate of parasitized aphids compared with unparasitized ones, after exposure to a very high temperature (39°C for 30min). After the heat shock, the survival of unparasitized aphids decreases according to their age at the heat shock treatment, suggesting a different adaptation of the aphid life stage to the different microclimatic conditions they experience. Survival of parasitized aphids does not change according to the time of the heat shock treatment, but it is always significantly higher compared with the unparasitized ones. Parasitized aphids are very quickly subjected to a wide range of physiological modifications and the observed increased survival could be a consequence of these modifications before the heat shock treatment. The possible explanations as well as the possible adaptive nature of the observed phenomenon are discussed.

Differential antagonistic responses of Bacillus pumilus MSUA3 against Rhizoctonia solani and Fusarium oxysporum causing fungal diseases in Fagopyrum esculentum Moench

Chitinase and surfactin-mediated biocontrol of Rhizoctonia solani and Fusarium oxysporum causing wilt and root rot of Fagopyrum esculentum respectively has been studied in this communication. Bacillus pumilus MSUA3 as a potential bacterial strain strongly inhibited the growth of R. solani and F. oxysporum involving the chitinolytic enzymes and an antibiotic surfactin. Plant growth promoting attributes seem to be involved in plant growth promotion and yield attributes. The action of cell-free culture supernatant (CFCS) was found deleterious to F. oxysporum and R. solani even in the heat-treated (boiled/autoclaved) CFCS. The possible involvement of surfactin in disease control was revealed by colony PCR amplification of SrfA. Chitinolytic enzyme and antibiotic surfactin evidenced differential biocontrol of F. oxysporum and R. solani by B. pumilus MSUA3. A significant reduction in disease index under gnotobiotic conditions and productivity enhancement of F. esculentum using vermiculite-based bioformulation revealed B. pumilus MSUA3 as a successful potential biocontrol agent (BCA) and an efficient plant growth promoting rhizobacterium (PGPR) for disease management and productivity enhancement of buckwheat crop.

Phytoseiid mites: Successful biocontrol agents of mite pests in protected vegetables

Phytoseiid mites: Successful biocontrol agents of mite pests in protected vegetables

Signatures of genetic bottleneck and differentiation after the introduction of an exotic parasitoid for classical biological control

As biological invasions, intentional introductions often result in a loss of genetic diversity in the new founder populations. In classical biological control programs, natural enemies introduced into novel environments are likely to suffer from population bottlenecks. Unlike invasive populations, individuals for biological control are typically kept in quarantine during several generations before being released in the field. This procedure reduces further the effective population size of the introduced populations, which thus increases the effects of inbreeding and genetic drift, resulting in a greater loss of genetic diversity. This study addresses the genetic consequences of the introduction of the parasitoid wasp Aphidius ervi, a successful biocontrol agent of important aphid target-pests in Chile. This was assessed by examining the genetic diversity and differentiation at nuclear and mitochondrial genetic markers in terms of (1) the magnitude of the genetic diversity loss after 38 years of the introduction of A. ervi, (2) the current level of genetic differentiation between Chilean introduced populations and putative native populations from France, and (3) the genetic relationships and magnitude of the genetic diversity loss between introduced populations of A. ervi in Chile compared to those introduced in North America. The results provide evidence that parasitoid populations suffered the effects of a moderate genetic bottleneck during the introduction, showing further a strong geographical genetic differentiation between populations in the natal and novel environments. In addition mtDNA sequences analysis showed evidence of a single main event of introduction in Chile, unlike the North American situation, where there is evidence for multiple introductions. The significance of the loss of genetic diversity during introductions related to the success of parasitoids as biocontrol agents in classical biological control programs is discussed.

High population densities of Macrolophus pygmaeus on tomato plants can cause economic fruit damage: interaction with Pepino mosaic virus?

The zoophytophagous predator Macrolophus pygmaeus Rambur (Hemiptera: Miridae) is a successful biocontrol agent against several pest species in protected tomato crops. This predator is considered to be harmless for the crop. However, in recent years, Heteroptera feeding punctures on tomato fruit in Belgian and Dutch greenhouses have been misinterpreted as Pepino mosaic virus (PepMV) symptoms. In this study, three hypotheses were tested: (1) M. pygmaeus causes fruit damage that increases with population density and surpasses economic thresholds; (2) the presence of prey or alternative prey reduces the damage; (3) an infection of the tomato plants by PepMV triggers or aggravates M. pygmaeus fruit damage. At increasing M. pygmaeus densities, the severity of fruit damage increased from a few dimples towards yellowish discoloration and deformed fruits. A correlation with an infection with PepMV was found. The severity of the symptoms was independent of the presence of prey. A minimum economic density threshold was estimated at 0.32 M. pygmaeus per leaf. M. pygmaeus can cause economic damage to tomato fruits at densities common in practice. An infection of the plants with PepMV enhances fruit symptoms significantly. Interacting plant defence responses are most likely the key to explaining this, although confirmation is required. © 2015 Society of Chemical Industry.

Natural parasitism of Romanomermis iyengari (Welch) (Nematoda: Mermithidae) on various species of mosquitoes breeding in rice fields in Pondicherry, India

Natural habitat of Romanomermis iyengari, an entomophilic mermithid nematode, is rice field. Parasitism of this nematode on mosquito larvae breeding in rice fields in Pondicherry, India, has been studied in 1979. The present study was to find out its persistence in the same habitat, after many years of agricultural practices. Evaluation of parasitism on mosquito larvae was carried out during two rice cultivation seasons at a schedule of 1week prior, and 1 and 2weeks after transplantation of paddy. Larval stages of mosquito species such as Culex tritaeniorhynchus, Culex vishnui, Anopheles vagus, and Anopheles subpictus showed parasitism of R. iyengari. Parasitism was the highest on C. tritaeniorhynchus with a maximum of 15.38% during season I and 17.85% during season II. Followed by this, it was on A. vagus (10.82% and 9.43%), C. vishnui (7.37% and 8.69%), and A. subpictus (3.70% and 6.36%). The overall density of mosquito larvae and level of parasitism of R. iyengari on them during season II was significantly higher than that of season I. The parasitism was maximum at 1week before transplantation and showed a decreasing trend towards 2weeks after transplantation, during both the seasons. The level of natural parasitism of R. iyengari during the present investigation was higher than that observed in the same ecosystem almost 35years ago. This is clearly an indication towards the capability of the nematode to withstand several years of agricultural practices, including pesticide and agrichemical application. Hence, if applied at sufficient level and frequency, this nematode could act as a successful biocontrol agent against mosquitoes breeding in rice fields.

Amblyseius swirskii: what made this predatory mite such a successful biocontrol agent?

The predatory mite Amblyseius swirskii quickly became one of the most successful biocontrol agents in protected cultivation after its introduction into the market in 2005 and is now released in more than 50 countries. There are several key factors contributing to this success: (1) it can control several major pests including the western flower thrips, Frankliniella occidentalis, the whiteflies Bemisia tabaci and Trialeurodes vaporariorum and the broad mite, Polyphagotarsonemus latus, simultaneously in vegetables and ornamental crops; (2) it can develop and reproduce feeding on non-prey food sources such as pollen, which allows populations of the predator to build up on plants before the pests are present and to persist in the crop during periods when prey is scarce or absent; and (3) it can be easily reared on factitious prey, which allows economic mass production. However, despite the fact that A. swirskii provides growers with a robust control method, external demands were initially a key factor in promoting the use of this predator, particularly in Spain. In 2006, when exports of fresh vegetables from Spain were stopped due to the presence of pesticide residues, growers were forced to look for alternatives to chemical control. This resulted in the massive adoption of biological control-based integrated pest management programmes based on the use of A. swirskii in sweet pepper. Biological control increased from 5 % in 2005, 1 year before A. swirskii was commercially released, to almost 100 % of a total 6,000 ha of protected sweet pepper in Spain within 3 years. Later, it was demonstrated that A. swirskii was equally effective in other crops and countries, resulting in extensive worldwide use of A. swirskii in greenhouses.

Evaluation of intraguild interactions between two species of insect herbivores on Pistia stratiotes

Pistia stratiotes L. (Araceae) is an important weed in many waterways around the world. The South American weevil Neohydronomus affinis Hustache (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) is a successful biocontrol agent for this weed but additional agents are needed for some areas. The planthopper Lepidelphax pistiae Remes Lenicov (Hemiptera: Delphacidae) is a specific herbivore of P. stratiotes and is highly damaging in laboratory conditions. A field experiment was designed to evaluate the damage potential of L. pistiae compared to N. affinis and to assess the potential for competition between the two herbivores. Both herbivore species were reared inside floating cages on a P. stratiotes-infested lake. Plant growth indices assessed were clonation levels, biomass and plant diameter. The growth indices of plants exposed to the herbivores, individually and combined, were comparable, and significantly lower than in the control treatments. Population levels of N. affinis inside the cages were not significantly different when alone or together with L. pistae. Conversely, the density of L. pistiae was significantly lower in combination with the weevil. This suggests that L. pistiae is a damaging herbivore that will not reduce the biological control effectiveness of N. affinis.

Introduction of some new endophytic bacteria from Bacillus and Streptomyces genera as successful biocontrol agents against Sclerotium rolfsii

Endophytic bacteria live inside plant tissues without causing disease and not only promote plant growth but can also protect plants against plant pathogens. During 2010–2011 crop years, some endophytic bacteria were collected and are then biochemically and molecularly identified (16srRNA) from bean farms of East Azarbaijan, Iran. Among these bacteria isolates, four isolates from Bacillus genera and four isolates from Streptomyces genera were selected for evaluation of their ability for biocontrol of Sclerotium rolfsii in laboratory and glasshouse conditions. Except one isolate named Streptomyces parvus, the rest of isolates could significantly inhibit mycelial growth in dual culture on PDA medium. All seven selected isolates showed significant inhibition in disease treatments in glasshouse experiments. Biological traits, such as length, wet and dry weight of roots and stems in endophytic bacterial treatment showed no differences with healthy control.

A new improved strategy for the selection of cold-adapted antagonist yeasts to control postharvest pear diseases

Postharvest diseases cause considerable losses of harvested fruits during transportation and storage. Many yeast species have been reported as good antagonists against postharvest pear pathogens. In this work, we used a novel selection strategy that involves the isolation of yeasts from washing fluids, showing biocontrol activity against a regional Penicillium expansum strain (primary screening), originally obtained from fruit wounds after long time storage at −1/0°C. About 26 isolates representative of the 11 yeast species identified in the 27 selected washing waters were chosen to be evaluated in a secondary screening against a regional Botrytis cinerea strain on pear wounds. Among yeasts tested, 38% showed complete control of P. expansum, but only 15% reduced the decay incidence of B. cinerea to 60–80% at −1/0°C. These results reveal that some of the yeasts found can be biological alternatives to fungicides in the control of P. expansum and B. cinerea infections. Based on the data obtained, our strategy seems to be much more effective than the previously reported methods in obtaining successful biocontrol agents.

Characterization of siderophore producing bacterial strain Pseudomonas fluorescens Mst 8.2 as plant growth promoting and biocontrol agent in wheat

A set of 28 Pseudomonas bacterial strains were examined for siderophore production by chrome azurol sulphonate (CAS) assay. Among the 28 strains tested, 14 were found to be siderophore producers. These strains were evaluated for their biocontrol potential againstRhizoctonia solani using various dual culture assays. The role of siderophores in the inhibition of R. solani was confirmed by iron chloride (FeCl3) experiment. The eight strains that showed best antagonism were found to have the potential of nitrogen fixation, phosphate solubilization, indole acetic acid, hydrolytic enzymes, hydrogen cyanide and antibiotics production. Spectrochemical analysis of siderophores indicated that all the bacterial strains produce catecholate siderophores. Our data demonstrated that bacterial strain Mst 8.2 produces more than one antifungal agents but the siderophore production is the key mechanism involved in the antagonism. Bacterial strains MS-3y, Mst 8.2 and Mst 7.4 were the most effective with more than 70% disease reduction in plant growth of wheat. The complete 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis demonstrated that Mst 8.2 is aPseudomonas fluorescens strain. In conclusion, Mst 8.2 with its multi-mechanisms of defense has excellent potential to be used as successful biocontrol agent against R. solani root rot disease in wheat. Key words: Bioantagonism, rhizobacteria, Pseudomonas, wheat, siderophore.

Resource concentration by insects and implications for plant populations

Summary1. The distribution of herbivores among plant patches may be an important factor determining plant population persistence. The resource concentration hypothesis proposes that herbivores are more abundant per unit plant at higher host plant densities and this has been found to occur in many systems. However, the opposite pattern, resource dilution, in which the herbivores are more abundant in low‐density patches and situations in which the number of insect herbivores per unit plant remains constant, also occurs.2. We developed a simulation model to explore how the distribution of insects per plant affects plant population decline and persistence. We varied the numbers of plants per patch and the distribution pattern, i.e. whether insects were found in a resource concentration distribution, a resource dilution distribution or a distribution in which insect abundance increased linearly with plant density.3. Resource concentration resulted in longer persistence of plant populations. Plant populations declined more rapidly with either weak resource dilution or directly proportional insect distribution patterns. As the intensity of resource concentration increased, the decline in plant population density was reduced, and plant persistence increased because of increasing variance in insect load. Under strong resource dilution, increasing variance in the insect load also led to a reduction in plant population decline and an increase in plant persistence.4. We complement our model with field data from the diffuse knapweed, Centaurea diffusa biocontrol system. We compared the relationship with plant density of a successful biocontrol agent, Larinus minutus, and an unsuccessful one, Urophora affinis. Larinus minutus density was directly proportional to plant density, while U. affinis showed a resource concentration pattern with higher rates of attack in high‐density patches.5. Synthesis: Patterns of insect distribution with host plant density will alter the extent to which patches of differing plant densities decline or persist. Resource concentration promotes persistence of the insect–plant system because increased herbivore pressure in high‐density patches leads to negative density‐dependent plant growth. Weak resource dilution and a distribution of insects that is directly proportionate to plant density can accelerate plant population decline. Strong resource dilution leads to positive density dependence with higher population growth in large patches. Our simulation model and field data demonstrate that the relationship between insect distribution and plant densities can influence plant population dynamics and has implications for choices of weed biological control agents.

The potential of beneficial microorganisms in agricultural systems

The potential of beneficial microorganisms in agricultural systems

Larval morphology ofLixus carduiOlivier andLixus filiformis(Fabricius) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae): biological control agents for scotch and musk thistles

Lixus cardui is a successful biocontrol agent against scotch thistle already introduced to Australia. Lixus filiformis is a potential biocontrol agent for musk thistles in native distribution areas in the Palearctic. Mature larvae of both Lixus Fabricius species collected from Onopordum acanthium and Carduus nutans are described, illustrated and comparative remarks presented.

St. John’s wort beetles would not have been introduced to New Zealand now: A retrospective host range test of New Zealand’s most successful weed biocontrol agents

St. John’s wort, Hypericum perforatum, was a serious weed in New Zealand (NZ) pastures in the 1930s. Following successful biological control of the weed in Australia, two agents, the chrysomelid beetles Chrysolina hyperici and C. quadrigemina, were introduced to NZ in 1943 and 1965, respectively. At the time, the Australian host specificity testing, which had not included other Hypericum spp., was deemed sufficient for approval for release in NZ. We reviewed worldwide reports which suggest that St. John’s wort beetles will attack a range of Hypericum species in the field. A series of laboratory tests were conducted to simulate modern host-range-testing protocols. Larval feeding choice, larval development and female oviposition choice all suggested that at least two of NZ’s indigenous Hypericum species were suitable hosts for the two Chrysolina species, and a third indigenous Hypericum, while an unsuitable host, was not altogether avoided. We conclude that the two Chrysolina species would not have been approved for introduction to NZ under current risk assessment protocols. Had this happened, NZ would have missed out on one of its greatest biocontrol success stories, despite there being no evidence for subsequent impacts on the populations of indigenous congeners. This case stresses the need for better procedures to predict the realized host-range of an agent from the potential range in contained host-range testing, and raises issues surrounding risks and benefits to indigenous biodiversity.

Preliminary results on the phytophagous insect fauna on Onopordum acanthium (Asteraceae) in Bulgaria

The Scotch thistle, Onopordum acanthium (Asteraceae) has the Eurasian origin and represents an invasive weed in the USA and Australia. It is a serious problem in pastures, along roadsides, rangeland, etc. The weed is very common in Bulgaria and in 2009-2010 several sites with large populations of O. acanthium have been located. The weekly surveys of some of the sites, mainly in the region of Plovdiv, revealed a significant diversity of phytophagous insect species, some of which had very high population density. More than 30 species have already been identified and observations on the phenology and biology of some of them have been conducted. For some of the species, such as endophagous Larinus latus, Lixus cardui, Eublemma amoena, Trichosirocalus briesei, or ectophagous Cassida rubiginosa etc. found during our surveys, there are reports in the literature describing them as having been already introduced as successful biocontrol agents in Australia. Endophagous species like lepidopteran Myelois circumvoluta and Pyroderces argyrogrammos which feed on the stems and the head, and the tephritid flies Tephritis postica and Chaetostomella cylindrica which feed on the capitula, seem quite destructive for the weed, but need to be further studied regarding host specificity. Species like Vanessa cardui and Brachycaudus cardui were found regularly, but in low population density, mainly due to the high rate of parasitism.

Revisiting Leafy Spurge Biocontrol: A Case Study

History of Biocontrol Introductions Biological control efforts were expanded in North Dakota in the mid-1980s7 (Table 1). The stem-boring beetle (Oberea erythrocephala), the hawk moth (Hyles euphorbiae), and the gall midge (Spurgia esulae) are established at low population levels throughout the state.8 In addition, four Aphthona species are also established in North Dakota. Aphthona fl ava is established but shows a slow population increase.7 A. nigriscutis was originally the most successful biocontrol agent;9 however, a mixed population of black beetles, A. czwalinae and A. lacertosa, reproduced and expanded rapidly in the mid-1990s and became the most successful Aphthona species in reducing the leafy spurge.9,10 Successful establishment of Aphthona is variable along with its effectiveness in controlling leafy spurge across variable habitats in North Dakota.7,9,11 Temperature, moisture, soil type, ground cover, slope, and/or associated vegetation at release sites affects fl ea beetle survival and establishment10,12 with different Aphthona species exhibiting differing preferences to these factors.13 Post-establishment monitoring is an important aspect of classical biological control. However, limited quantitative post-establishment data are available, especially, for Aphthona spp.

The living strategy of nematophagous fungi

The infection structures, trophism, and ecological character of nematophagous fungi are reviewed in this article on the basis of data extracted from the literature and the most recent experiments conducted in this area. Traditionally, nematophagous fungi are classified into four groups according to their modes of attacking nematodes: nematode-trapping fungi using adhesive or mechanical hyphal traps, endoparasitic fungi using their spores, eggparasitic fungi invading nematode eggs or females with their hyphal tips, and toxin-producing fungi immobilizing nematodes before invasion. In the present review, we focus on the first two groups. The living strategies of these nematophagous fungi depend on the diversity of their infection structures, such as different traps and spore types, which determine the modes of infecting nematodes. The diversity of trophic modes of nematophagous fungi is an important prerequisite for fungal survival and activity in soil. The abundance and activity of Hirsutella rhossiliensis and H. minnesotensis, representatives of endoparasites and potential biocontrol agents against nematodes, are highly dependent on environmental factors. Comprehensive understanding of the survival and activity of nematophagous fungi in soil is fundamental for the exploitation of these fungi as successful biocontrol agents.

What makes a successful biocontrol agent? A meta-analysis of biological control agent performance

Abstract We qualitatively reviewed the biocontrol literature in two major journals, Biological Control and Environmental Entomology, over the past 10 years by scoring 878 studies into 11 biocontrol-oriented questions. Quantitative meta-analyses were then used on data from 145 studies to examine the effects of different types of biocontrol agents (parasitoids, predators, and pathogens) on several attributes of weed and pest populations. Results for our qualitative review showed that most biocontrol studies were focused on lepidopteran pests, and that parasitoids were the most common biocontrol agents used. Our quantitative review showed that, for weeds, biocontrol agents significantly reduced weed biomass (−82.0%), flower (−98.9%), and seed production (−89.4%). For pests, our quantitative review showed that biocontrol agents significantly reduced pest abundance by 130% compared to control groups, increased parasitism (+139.0%) and increased overall pest mortality (+159.0%) compared to targets not exposed to biocontrol agents. Effects on pest mortality tended to be stronger for parasitoids than predators, although reductions caused in pest abundance were much stronger when predators were used as biocontrol agents. Addition of two or more biocontrol agents increased mortality by 12.97% and decreased pest abundance by 27.17% compared to single releases. Separate sets of meta-analyses demonstrated that the negative impacts of biocontrol on non-target species were much smaller than those for target species, although adverse effects of biocontrol on non-target organisms are based on small sample sizes and should be interpreted with caution. Our results also showed that biocontrol efficacy tended to be higher when agents were generalists than when they were specialists. Large fail–safe numbers found for most of the estimated effects indicate the robustness of the results found for the efficacy of biological control programs.

Early establishment and dispersal of the weevil, Mogulones cruciger (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) for biological control of houndstongue (Cynoglossum officinale) in British Columbia, Canada

First released in Canada in 1997 to control the invasive rangeland weed, houndstongue (Cynoglossum officinale), the European root weevil, Mogulones cruciger, is showing early potential as a successful biocontrol agent. Out of 22 experimental releases in southeastern British Columbia, Canada, 100% established, regardless of initial release size (range 100–400). These founding populations persisted beyond 2 years, and quickly dispersed through a treed and variable landscape to colonise new houndstongue patches surrounding the original release patches. Within 3 years, the weevil had moved 1.42 km. Both initial, within-patch and later, between-patch dispersal followed a similar pattern, with M. cruciger adults and/or their feeding/oviposition damage being more concentrated nearest the original points of release and declining with distance. Within-patch, this pattern of distribution and also the rate of spread of weevils were similar regardless of initial release size; suggesting density-independence in dispersal behaviour at this scale. Closer investigation of the sequence of invasion at a larger spatial scale suggested that the weevil arrived at, colonized and increased in number on the closest host patches first. Three years post release, both distance from release patch and the number of M. cruciger released, were significant predictors of the amount of feeding/oviposition damage, and presumably weevil population size, within newly colonized houndstongue patches surrounding the original releases. These data, and the finding that more weevils were retrieved from patches where higher numbers of weevils were released in the previous year (i.e., 300 or 400 vs 100 or 200), suggest that release number and placement of releases within a landscape can be manipulated for effective houndstongue control.