Subunit Exchange Research Articles

PH Dependence of Oligomerization and Functional Activity of Alpha B Crystallin

αB-crystallin, a small heat shock protein dispersed throughout the body, impacts cellular processes in ways that can help rescue the cell from various insults or traumas. Environmentally dependent oligomerization enables αB-crystallin to carry out its role as a chaperone protein. Stress conditions such as heat, ischemia and acidosis can induce phosphorylation of three serine residues of αB-crystallin at positions 19, 45, and 59 on the N-terminal domain. The oligomeric states, subunit exchange and efficiency of αB-crystallin are linked to different phosphorylation states. We have studied the pH-dependence of the hyper-phosphorylated αB-crystallin using a S19E, S45E, S59E triple mutant of αB-crystallin. Chaperone efficiency using insulin as an aggregation model was measured by observing changes in light scattering of insulin in the presence of the wild type and mutant αB-crystallin. Maximal chaperone function was observed at pH 7 for both mutant and wild type with the mutant exhibiting enhanced function. Efficiency for both declined rapidly at higher and lower pHs. Dynamic information can shed light on both subunit exchange and oligomerization, and when studied at different pHs for both the mutant and wild type can inform us about this important regulatory mechanism. These data are obtained using dual-color Fluorescence Cross-Correlation Spectroscopy and single molecule FRET. αB-crystallin labeled at lysine residues with Alexa Fluor 488 is used for FCCS and Alexa Fluor 555 are used for our FRET experiments. Both experiments use Alexa Fluor 647 as an acceptor.

PDV1 and PDV2 Differentially Affect Remodeling and Assembly of the Chloroplast DRP5B Ring.

Chloroplasts divide by binary fission, which is driven by a ring-like multiprotein complex spanning the inner and outer envelope membranes (OEMs) at the division site. The cytosolic DYNAMIN-RELATED PROTEIN 5B (DRP5B/ARC5) is a mechanochemical GTPase involved in binary fission of the chloroplast membrane in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana), but the dynamics of its interactions with the chloroplast membranes and their regulation by guanine nucleotides and protein effectors remain poorly characterized. Using an Arabidopsis phot2 mutant with defects in chloroplast photorelocation movement, we determined that the ring structures of DRP5B at the chloroplast division site underwent subunit exchange with a cytosolic DRP5B pool. Mutant DRP5B proteins with impaired GTPase activity retained the ability to self-assemble at the constriction sites of chloroplasts, but did not rescue the chloroplast division defects in the Arabidopsis drp5B mutant. Our in vivo kinetic measurements of the DRP5B mutant T82D suggested that turnover of the DRP5B ring at the chloroplast division site is coupled to GTP hydrolysis. Furthermore, we established that DRP5B targeting to the chloroplast surface and assembly into a ring structure at the division site are specifically determined by the chloroplast outer OEM protein PLASTID DIVISION2 (PDV2), and that DRP5B-OEM dissociation is mainly mediated by PDV1, a paralog of PDV2. Thus, this study suggests that the mechanochemical properties of DRP5B on the chloroplast surface are dynamically regulated by its GTPase activity and major binding partners.

The impact of different mutations at arginine141 on the structure, subunit exchange dynamics and chaperone activity of Hsp16.3.

Hsp16.3, a molecular chaperone, plays a vital role in the growth and survival of Mycobacterium tuberculosis inside the host. We previously reported that deletion of three amino acid residues (142 STN144 ) from C-terminal extension (CTE) of Hsp16.3 triggers its structural perturbation and increases its chaperone activity, which reaches its apex upon the deletion of its entire CTE (141 RSTN144 ). Thus, we hypothesized that Arg141 (R141) and Ser142 (S142) in the CTE of Hsp16.3 possibly hold the key in maintaining its native-like structure and chaperone activity. To test this hypothesis, we generated two deletion mutants in which R141 and S142 were deleted individually (Hsp16.3ΔR141 and Hsp16.3ΔS142) and three substitution mutants in which R141 was replaced by lysine (Hsp16.3R141K), alanine (Hsp16.3R141A), and glutamic acid (Hsp16.3R141E), respectively. Hsp16.3ΔS142 or Hsp16.3R141K mutant has native-like structure and chaperone activity. Deletion of R141 from the CTE (Hsp16.3ΔR141) perturbs the secondary and tertiary structure, lowers the subunit exchange dynamics and decreases the chaperone activity of Hsp16.3. But, the substitution of R141 with alanine (Hsp16.3R141A) or glutamic acid (Hsp16.3R141E) perturbs its secondary and tertiary structure. Surprisingly, such charge tampering of R141 enhances the subunit exchange dynamics and chaperone activity of Hsp16.3. Interestingly, neither the deletion of R141/S142 nor the substitution of R141 with lysine, alanine and glutamic acid affects the oligomeric mass/size of Hsp16.3. Overall, our study suggests that R141 (especially the positive charge on R141) plays a crucial role in maintaining the native-like structure as well as in regulating subunit exchange dynamics and chaperone activity of Hsp16.3.

Catalytic subunit exchanges in the cellulosomes produced by Ruminiclostridiumcellulolyticum suggest unexpected dynamics and adaptability of their enzymatic composition.

Cellulosomes are complex nanomachines produced by cellulolytic anaerobic bacteria such as Ruminiclostridiumcellulolyticum (formerly known as Clostridiumcellulolyticum). Cellulosomes are composed of a scaffoldin protein displaying several cohesin modules on which enzymatic components can bind to through their dockerin module. Although cellulosomes have been studied for decades, very little is known about the dynamics of complex assembly. We have investigated the ability of some dockerin-bearing enzymes to chase the catalytic subunits already bound onto a miniscaffoldin displaying a single cohesin. The stability of the preassembled enzyme-scaffoldin complex appears to depend on the nature of the dockerin, and we have identified a key position in the dockerin sequence that is involved in the stability of the complex with the cohesin. Depending on the residue occupying this position, the dockerin can establish with the cohesin partner either a nearly irreversible or a reversible interaction, independently of the catalytic domain associated with the dockerin. Site-directed mutagenesis of this residue can convert a dockerin able to form a highly stable complex with the miniscaffoldin into a reversible complex forming one and vice versa. We also show that refunctionalization can occur with natural purified cellulosomes. Altogether, our results shed light on the dynamics of cellulosomes, especially their capacity to be remodeled even after their assembly is 'achieved', suggesting an unforeseen adaptability of their enzymatic composition over time.

Thermokinetic Analysis of Protein Subunit Exchange by Variable-Temperature Native Mass Spectrometry.

Many protein complexes are assembled from a varying number of subunits, which are continuously exchanging with diverse time scales. This structural dynamics is considered to be important for many regulatory and sensory adaptation processes that occur in vivo. We have developed an accurate method for monitoring protein subunit exchange by using native electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), exemplified here for an extremely stable Rad50 zinc hook (Hk) dimer assembly, Zn(Hk)2. The method has two steps: appropriate protein/peptide mutation and native ESI-MS analysis using a variable-temperature sample inlet. In this work, two Hk mutants were produced, mixed with wild-type Hk, and measured at three different temperatures. A thermokinetic analysis of heterodimer formation allowed us to determine the enthalpy, entropy, and Gibbs free energy of activation for subunit exchange, showing that the reaction is slow and associated with a high enthalpic barrier, consistent with the exceptionally high stability of the Zn(Hk)2 assembly.

Structural Insights into the Regulation of Ca2+/Calmodulin-Dependent Protein Kinase II (CaMKII).

Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) is a highly conserved serine/threonine kinase that is ubiquitously expressed throughout the human body. Specialized isoforms of CaMKII play key roles in neuronal and cardiac signaling. The distinctive holoenzyme architecture of CaMKII, with 12-14 kinase domains attached by flexible linkers to a central hub, poses formidable challenges for structural characterization. Nevertheless, progress in determining the structural mechanisms underlying CaMKII functions has come from studying the kinase domain and the hub separately, as well as from a recent electron microscopic investigation of the intact holoenzyme. In this review, we discuss our current understanding of the structure of CaMKII. We also discuss the intriguing finding that the CaMKII holoenzyme can undergo activation-triggered subunit exchange, a process that has implications for the potentiation and perpetuation of CaMKII activity.

Occurrence and stability of hetero-hexamer associations formed by β-carboxysome CcmK shell components.

The carboxysome is a bacterial micro-compartment (BMC) subtype that encapsulates enzymatic activities necessary for carbon fixation. Carboxysome shells are composed of a relatively complex cocktail of proteins, their precise number and identity being species dependent. Shell components can be classified in two structural families, the most abundant class associating as hexamers (BMC-H) that are supposed to be major players for regulating shell permeability. Up to recently, these proteins were proposed to associate as homo-oligomers. Genomic data, however, demonstrated the existence of paralogs coding for multiple shell subunits. Here, we studied cross-association compatibilities among BMC-H CcmK proteins of Synechocystis sp. PCC6803. Co-expression in Escherichia coli proved a consistent formation of hetero-hexamers combining CcmK1 and CcmK2 or, remarkably, CcmK3 and CcmK4 subunits. Unlike CcmK1/K2 hetero-hexamers, the stoichiometry of incorporation of CcmK3 in associations with CcmK4 was low. Cross-interactions implicating other combinations were weak, highlighting a structural segregation of the two groups that could relate to gene organization. Sequence analysis and structural models permitted the localization of interactions that would favor formation of CcmK3/K4 hetero-hexamers. The crystallization of these CcmK3/K4 associations conducted to the elucidation of a structure corresponding to the CcmK4 homo-hexamer. Yet, subunit exchange could not be demonstrated in vitro. Biophysical measurements showed that hetero-hexamers are thermally less stable than homo-hexamers, and impeded in forming larger assemblies. These novel findings are discussed within the context of reported data to propose a functional scenario in which minor CcmK3/K4 incorporation in shells would introduce sufficient local disorder as to allow shell remodeling necessary to adapt rapidly to environmental changes.

SDS22 selectively recognizes and traps metal-deficient inactive PP1

The metalloenzyme protein phosphatase 1 (PP1), which is responsible for ≥50% of all dephosphorylation reactions, is regulated by scores of regulatory proteins, including the highly conserved SDS22 protein. SDS22 has numerous diverse functions, surprisingly acting as both a PP1 inhibitor and as an activator. Here, we integrate cellular, biophysical, and crystallographic studies to address this conundrum. We discovered that SDS22 selectively binds a unique conformation of PP1 that contains a single metal (M2) at its active site, i.e., SDS22 traps metal-deficient inactive PP1. Furthermore, we showed that SDS22 dissociation is accompanied by a second metal (M1) being loaded into PP1, as free metal cannot dissociate the complex and M1-deficient mutants remain constitutively trapped by SDS22. Together, our findings reveal that M1 metal loading and loss are essential for PP1 regulation in cells, which has broad implications for PP1 maturation, activity, and holoenzyme subunit exchange.

Co-expression of CCT subunits hints at TRiC assembly.

The eukaryotic cytosolic chaperonin, t-complex polypeptide 1 (TCP-1) ring complex or TRiC, is responsible for folding a tenth of the proteins in the cell. TRiC is a double-ringed barrel with each ring composed of eight different CCT (chaperonin containing TCP-1) subunits. In order for the subunits to assemble together into mature TRiC, which is believed to contain one and only one of each of these subunits per ring, they must be translated from different chromosomes, correctly folded and assembled. When expressed alone in Escherichia coli, the subunits CCT4 and CCT5, interestingly, form TRiC-like homo-oligomeric rings. To explore potential subunit-subunit interactions, we co-expressed these homo-oligomerizing CCT4 and CCT5 subunits or the archaeal chaperonin Mm-Cpn (Methanococcus maripaludis chaperonin)with CCT1-8, one at a time. We found that CCT5 shifted all of the CCT subunits, with the exception of CCT6, into double-barrel TRiC-like complexes, while CCT4 only interacted with CCT5 and CCT8 to form chaperonin rings. We hypothesize that these specific interactions may be due to the formation of hetero-oligomers in E. coli, although more work is needed for validation. We also observed the interaction of CCT5 and Mm-Cpn with smaller fragments of the CCT subunits, confirming their intrinsic chaperone activity. Based on this hetero-oligomer data, we propose that TRiC assembly relies on subunit exchange with some stable homo-oligomers, possibly CCT5, as base assembly units. Eventually, analysis of CCT arrangement in various tissues and at different developmental times is anticipated to provide additional insight on TRiC assembly and CCT subunit composition.

Apical assemblies of intermediate filament-like protein FilP are highly dynamic and affect polar growth determinant DivIVA in Streptomyces venezuelae.

Streptomyces spp. grow as branching hyphae, building the cell wall in restricted zones at hyphal tips. The organization of this mode of polar growth involves three coiled-coil proteins: DivIVA and Scy, which form apical protein complexes referred to as polarisomes; and the intermediate filament-like protein FilP, which influences cell shape and interacts with both Scy and DivIVA. Here, we use live cell imaging of Streptomyces venezuelae to clarify the subcellular localization and dynamics of FilP and its effect on hyphal morphology. By monitoring a FilP-mCherry fusion protein, we show that FilP accumulates in gradient-like zones behind the hyphal tips. The apical gradient pattern of FilP localization is dependent on hyphal tip extension and immediately dissipates upon growth arrest. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching experiments show that FilP gradients are dynamic and subject to subunit exchange during vegetative growth. Further, the localization of FilP at hyphal tips is not directly dependent on scy, even though the strongly perturbed morphology of most scy mutant hyphae is associated with mislocalization of FilP. Finally, we find that filP has an effect on the size and position of the foci of key polar growth determinant DivIVA. This effect likely contributes to the phenotype of filP mutants.

Enhanced pH Dependent Modulation of Alpha Crystallin Chaperone Function and Subunit Exchange in an N-Terminal Phosphorylation Mimic

Enhanced pH Dependent Modulation of Alpha Crystallin Chaperone Function and Subunit Exchange in an N-Terminal Phosphorylation Mimic

From Peripheral Proteins to Membrane Motors - Mass Spectrometry Comes of Age

What can we learn from the study of a protein complex in the gas phase of the mass spectrometer? Aside from the compositional information that is available from obtaining the molecular mass of an intact protein complex, many additional properties can be deduced: these include polydispersity and heterogeneity, which are some of most challenging properties of protein complexes, making them almost impossible to study by conventional structural biology approaches. Mass spectrometry is providing significant insight into protein composition within assemblies by uncovering the effects of post-translational modifications, the dynamics of subunit exchange and changes in interactions in response to small molecule binding. Recent breakthroughs, which combine the study of intact membrane complexes with knowledge of lipid binding sites, is informing both the oligomerisation and downstream coupling of GPCRs. While the majority of these studies of membrane proteins have been performed in detergent micelles very recently we have successfully employed a new means of ionizing proteins directly from membranes. Following sonication of lipid vesicles and application of high electric fields, proteins are effectively drawn out of their native membrane locations into the gas phase of the mass spectrometer. This new approach is revealing many new interactions that have been lost following disruption in detergent micelles.

Topological Analysis of Transthyretin Disassembly Mechanism: Surface-Induced Dissociation Reveals Hidden Reaction Pathways.

The proposed mechanism of fibril formation of transthyretin (TTR) involves self-assembly of partially unfolded monomers. However, the mechanism(s) of disassembly to monomer and potential intermediates involved in this process are not fully understood. In this study, native mass spectrometry and surface-induced dissociation (SID) are used to investigate the TTR disassembly mechanism(s) and the effects of temperature and ionic strength on the kinetics of TTR complex formation. Results from the SID of hybrid tetramers formed during subunit exchange provide strong evidence for a two-step mechanism whereby the tetramer dissociates to dimers that then dissociate to monomers. Also, the SID results uncovered a hidden pathway in which a specific topology of the hybrid tetramer is directly produced by assembly of dimers in the early steps of TTR disassembly. Implementation of SID to dissect protein topology during subunit exchange provides unique opportunities to gain unparalleled insight into disassembly pathways.

Metallochaperone function of the self-subunit swapping chaperone involved in the maturation of subunit-fused cobalt-type nitrile hydratase.

The transition metal (iron or cobalt) is a mandatory part that constitutes the catalytic center of nitrile hydratase (NHase). The incorporation of the cobalt ion into cobalt-containing NHase (Co-NHase) was reported to depend on self-subunit swapping and the activator of the Co-NHase acts as a self-subunit swapping chaperone for subunit exchange. Here we discovered that the activator actingas a metallochaperone transferred the cobalt ion into subunit-fused Co-NHase. We successfully isolated two activators, P14K and NhlE, which were the activators of NHases from Pseudomonas putida NRRL-18668 and the activator of low-molecular-mass NHase from Rhodococcus rhodochrous J1, respectively. Cobalt content determination demonstrated that NhlE and P14K were two cobalt-containing proteins. Substitution of the amino acids involved in the C-terminus of the activators affected the activity of the two NHases, indicating that the potential cobalt-binding sites might be located at the flexible C-terminal region. The cobalt-free NHases could be activated by either of the two activators, and both the two activators activated their cognate NHase more efficiently than did the noncognate ones. This study providedinsights into the maturation of subunit-fused NHases and confirmed the metallochaperone function of the self-subunit swapping chaperone.

Mispacking of the Phe87 Side Chain Reduces the Kinetic Stability of Human Transthyretin.

Aggregation of transthyretin (TTR) causes TTR amyloidoses. The native TTR tetramer (a dimer of dimers) is stabilized by packing of phenylalanine 87 (F87) into a hydrophobic cavity of a neighboring protomer across the strong dimer interface. X-ray structures at acidic pH show that the side chain of F87 can be displaced from its binding pocket, but the resultant solution conformations remain unknown. Here we used 19F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and 19F-labeled C10S-S85C TTR to characterize two local conformations of the loop containing F87. At neutral pH, F87 packs correctly into the interprotomer cavity in the dominant conformational state (93% population, T) whereas the remaining minor population is a mispacked tetramer (T*). The population of T* can be enhanced in heterotetramers by mixing C10S-S85C TTR with increasing molar ratios of A120L TTR, where a bulky leucine residue is introduced to disfavor the T state by steric hindrance. Exchange between the T and T* states in the presence of A120L is mediated by subunit exchange from the C10S-S85C tetramer. Compared to the TTR tetramer in which the dimers are correctly packed, mispacking of one or both dimer pairs leads to an increase in the urea unfolding rate of 4-fold or at least 15-fold, respectively. Consistent acid-mediated tetramer dissociation was observed by 19F NMR aggregation assays. Our results highlight the important role of the interprotomer F87 side chain packing in determining the kinetic stability of the TTR tetramer; mispacking of F87 in the T* state predisposes it for rapid dissociation and entry into the aggregation pathway.

Transgenic zebrafish models reveal distinct molecular mechanisms for cataract-linked αA-crystallin mutants

Mutations in the small heat shock proteins α-crystallins have been linked to autosomal dominant cataracts in humans. Extensive studies in vitro have revealed a spectrum of alterations to the structure and function of these proteins including shifts in the size of the oligomer, modulation of subunit exchange and modification of their affinity to client proteins. Although mouse models of these mutants were instrumental in identifying changes in cellular proliferation and lens development, a direct comparative analysis of their effects on lens proteostasis has not been performed. Here, we have transgenically expressed cataract-linked mutants of αA- and αB-crystallin in the zebrafish lens to dissect the underlying molecular changes that contribute to the loss of lens optical properties. Zebrafish lines expressing these mutants displayed a range of morphological lens defects. Phenotype penetrance and severity were dependent on the mutation even in fish lines lacking endogenous α-crystallin. The mechanistic origins of these differences were investigated by the transgenic co-expression of a destabilized human γD-crystallin mutant. We found that the R49C but not the R116C mutant of αA-crystallin drove aggregation of γD-crystallin, although both mutants have similar affinity to client proteins in vitro. Our working model attributes these differences to the propensity of R49C, located in the buried N-terminal domain of αA-crystallin, to disulfide crosslinking as previously demonstrated in vitro. Our findings complement and extend previous work in mouse models and emphasize the need of investigating chaperone/client protein interactions in appropriate cellular context.

Subunit exchange enhances information retention by CaMKII in dendritic spines.

Molecular bistables are strong candidates for long-term information storage, for example, in synaptic plasticity. Calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein Kinase II (CaMKII) is a highly expressed synaptic protein which has been proposed to form a molecular bistable switch capable of maintaining its state for years despite protein turnover and stochastic noise. It has recently been shown that CaMKII holoenzymes exchange subunits among themselves. Here, we used computational methods to analyze the effect of subunit exchange on the CaMKII pathway in the presence of diffusion in two different micro-environments, the post synaptic density (PSD) and spine cytosol. We show that CaMKII exhibits multiple timescales of activity due to subunit exchange. Further, subunit exchange enhances information retention by CaMKII both by improving the stability of its switching in the PSD, and by slowing the decay of its activity in the spine cytosol. The existence of diverse timescales in the synapse has important theoretical implications for memory storage in networks.

Function and regulation of the Caenorhabditis elegans Rab32 family member GLO-1 in lysosome-related organelle biogenesis.

Cell type-specific modifications of conventional endosomal trafficking pathways lead to the formation of lysosome-related organelles (LROs). C. elegans gut granules are intestinally restricted LROs that coexist with conventional degradative lysosomes. The formation of gut granules requires the Rab32 family member GLO-1. We show that the loss of glo-1 leads to the mistrafficking of gut granule proteins but does not significantly alter conventional endolysosome biogenesis. GLO-3 directly binds to CCZ-1 and they both function to promote the gut granule association of GLO-1, strongly suggesting that together, GLO-3 and CCZ-1 activate GLO-1. We found that a point mutation in GLO-1 predicted to spontaneously activate, and function independently of it guanine nucleotide exchange factor (GEF), localizes to gut granules and partially restores gut granule protein localization in ccz-1(-) and glo-3(-) mutants. CCZ-1 forms a heterodimeric complex with SAND-1(MON1), which does not function in gut granule formation, to activate RAB-7 in trafficking pathways to conventional lysosomes. Therefore, our data suggest a model whereby the function of a Rab GEF can be altered by subunit exchange. glo-3(-) mutants, which retain low levels of GLO-3 activity, generate gut granules that lack GLO-1 and improperly accumulate RAB-7 in a SAND-1 dependent process. We show that GLO-1 and GLO-3 restrict the distribution of RAB-7 to conventional endolysosomes, providing insights into the segregation of pathways leading to conventional lysosomes and LROs.

To Build by Destruction

In this issue of Molecular Cell, Weith etal. (2018) demonstrate that p97, together with a SEP adaptor, can catalyze ordered subunit exchange to facilitate the biogenesis of protein phosphatase-1 (PP1) holoenzyme, establishing a novel ubiquitin-independent "segregase" function for this versatile ATPase.

Ubiquitin-Independent Disassembly by a p97 AAA-ATPase Complex Drives PP1 Holoenzyme Formation

The functional diversity of protein phosphatase-1 (PP1), with its countless substrates, relies on the ordered assembly of alternative PP1 holoenzymes. Here, we show that newly synthesized PP1 is first held by its partners SDS22 and inhibitor-3 (I3) in an inactive complex, which needs to be disassembled by the p97 AAA-ATPase to promote exchange to substrate specifiers. Unlike p97-mediated degradative processes that require the Ufd1-Npl4 ubiquitin adapters, p97 is targeted to PP1 by p37 and related adapter proteins. Reconstitution with purified components revealed direct interaction of the p37 SEP domain with I3 without the need for ubiquitination, and ATP-driven pulling of I3 into the central channel of the p97 hexamer, which triggers dissociation of I3 and SDS22. Thus, we establish regulatory ubiquitin-independent protein complex disassembly as part of the functional arsenal of p97 and define an unanticipated essential step in PP1 biogenesis that illustrates the molecular challenges of ordered subunit exchange.