Reviewed by: The Life and Loves of E. Nesbit: Victorian Iconoclast, Children's Author, and Creator of The Railway Children by Eleanor Fitzsimons Claudia Nelson (bio) The Life and Loves of E. Nesbit: Victorian Iconoclast, Children's Author, and Creator of The Railway Children by Eleanor Fitzsimons. Abrams, 2019. Edith Nesbit may well have led the most engrossing life of any children's writer. There's something to fascinate everyone here. Nesbit's domestic conduct overturns the stereotypes of Victorian middle-class propriety; after marrying her first husband, Hubert Bland, two months before the birth of their first child, she passed off as hers two of his children by her friend and companion Alice Hoatson, who became an indispensable part of the Bland-Nesbit household even as Nesbit herself indulged in a lengthy series of romantic friendships—or perhaps romances—with male protégés. Nesbit's intellectual deportment is equally eye-catching, given her passionate commitment to ideologies ranging from socialism (the nonviolent brand espoused by the Fabians, of whom Nesbit was a founding member) to [End Page 179] the belief that Francis Bacon was the real author of Shakespeare's plays. And, of course, she published poems, plays, nonfiction, horror stories, New Woman fiction, and—particularly beloved and influential—children's literature. Small wonder, then, that since her death in 1924, Nesbit has attracted multiple biographers. The first of these, Doris Langley Moore, had the advantage of direct contact with Nesbit intimates including Hoatson and Nesbit's adopted daughter, Rosamund. First published in 1933, Moore's E. Nesbit: A Biography was revised and reissued in 1968 after the deaths of its subject's immediate family members made possible greater candor; this account of Nesbit's life thus has a particularly good claim to authenticity and necessarily functions as an important source for any subsequent biographer. Moore's most significant successor in this role, Julia Briggs, published A Woman of Passion: The Life of E. Nesbit in 1987. Briggs, a distinguished academic whose subjects also included Virginia Woolf, produced both in and beyond her Nesbit biography what remain some of the most brilliant and insightful readings of the author's children's fiction available; her work is indispensable to any scholar interested in Nesbit's writing for the young. Other biographies, ranging from Noel Streatfeild's quirky Magic and the Magician: E. Nesbit and Her Children's Books (1958) to Elisabeth Galvin's The Extraordinary Life of E. Nesbit (2018), thus have serious competition in vying for the attention of the Nesbit devotee. Nesbit's most recent biographer, Eleanor Fitzsimons, is a journalist specializing in historical and women's issues; she is also the author of Wilde's Women: How Oscar Wilde Was Shaped by the Women He Knew (2015). The Life and Loves of E. Nesbit reflects its author's strong interest in historical detail, which appears to overshadow her interest in literary content. What is most admirable about this new biography is Fitzsimons's extensive research. Not only has she tracked down some hard-to-find throwaway publications from Nesbit's years as a hack writer, she also takes the trouble to provide the reader with thumbnail sketches of an immense cast of supporting characters. To take an example at random, we are informed that "[Nesbit's niece] Dorothea and Richard's youngest daughter, Pamela, a poet, died in mysterious circumstances when she apparently fell from a cliff on March 27, 1935. She was twenty years old. Diana, their eldest daughter, also died young. Richard married for a second time in November 1935, but his wife Edith Harriet Weston, an American, died less than four months later. He left for America in 1940 but returned to Capri in 1947 and died there on December 22" (223). This passage, which appears in a footnote, is an aside in the book, but it nonetheless suggests both what is pleasurable and what is tedious in this biography. Fitzsimons's willingness to educate herself and her readers helps bring Nesbit's world to life, but simultaneously there is a remarkable dearth of interpretation. Rarely do we hear why tangential material (in this case, events occurring a decade or two after Nesbit...
Read full abstract