Abstract Purpose Concerns have been raised about the effect of repetitive head impacts and subconcussive blows in contact sports, though studies have largely focused on the effect in late-life or retired professional athletes. We examined the effect of extended participation (months-to-years) in low/non-contact vs high contact/collision sports within a sample of high school athletes on the Immediate Post-Concussion Assessment and Cognitive Test (ImPACT). Method A multisport sample of 1650 athletes (34% Female; 1088 contact, 528 non-contact; age 14–18) without a history of concussion completed baseline ImPACT testing across two times points (time between administrations ranging from 7–45 months; M = 20.40), with active sport participation between administrations. Results Repeated mixed-measure ANOVA revealed increased performance across ImPACT administrations for all composites (p < 0.001; partial Œ∑2 = 0.02–0.23). With the exception of a very small effect on Impulse Control composites (partial Œ∑2 = 0.003), there was no statistically significant difference between high contact and low contact sport groups across composite scores (p < 0.05). Conclusions Our findings showed no meaningful changes in neurocognitive performance in high school athletes exposed to high degrees of contact sports for months/years, with both contact groups demonstrating a consistent mild–moderate practice effect over time. This also aligns with the recent systematic literature review finding no increased risk of neurological/neurocognitive disease in amateur contact athletes in later life (Iverson et al, 2023). Future prospective studies with longer follow up and incorporation of additional measures (e.g., mental health, expanded testing, and biomarkers) will be important to improve our understanding of the risk of contact exposure in athletes.
Read full abstract