Objectives: The aim of this study was to determine differences in palliative care needs inwomenwith gynecologic cancers from anurban, inner city, academic facility compared to a suburban, community facility and also, to identify interventions that could improve palliative care for gynecologic cancer patients in varying locations. Methods: 71 women with gynecologic cancer were prospectively identified, 54 from an urban, inner city academic cancer center, and 17 from a suburban community cancer center in the same metropolitan area. All subjects were asked to complete a standardized, validated questionnaire intended to determine their palliative care needs after diagnosis but prior to treatment. Palliative care trained, Master's level social workers introduced themselves and the questionnaire to patients, and offered to help with additional needs. Completed questionnaires were collected and appropriate data was extracted. The data was depersonalized and analyzed by the authors. Statistical differences were assessed with SigmaStat V.2.0. Results: All patients were treated by board-certified gyn oncologists. The types of cancers seen and treatments offered (all of which met NCCN guidelines) were similar. Inner city academic patients were less likely to complete the questionnaire than the suburban community patients (64% vs 100% of those offered, p b 0.001). Patients from the inner city academic group were younger (54 years old vs 61 years old, p b 0.05) and more likely to be African–American (77% vs 29%, p b 0.05) than those from the suburban community group. The ratio of Medicaid to private/Medicare insurance coverage was higher in inner city academic patients than suburban community patients (58% vs 22%, p b 0.05). The most common palliative care concerns identified by suburban community patientswere: 1) pain, 2) anxiety, 3) depression, 4) nausea/vomiting. In comparison, the most common concerns identified by inner city academic patients were: 1) paying for medications, 2) travel to the treatment facility, 3) pain, and 4) child care. Conclusion: There are major differences in the palliative care needs of patients from an inner city academic facility compared to a suburban community facility. Interventions proposed for the suburban community facility were early access to: 1) grief counseling, 2) patient support groups, and 3) Nurse–Navigator services. Interventions proposed for the inner city academic facility include early access to: 1) programs for assistance with medication costs (local philanthropies, facility-based pharmacy discounts), 2) travel services (cab vouchers, coordination of treatments with public transportation schedules), and 3) on-site child care facilities. Further, inner city academic patients should be encouraged to voice their palliative care concerns. More specific determinations of patient concerns are needed to help structure palliative care services in different types of facilities.
Read full abstract