FIFTEENTH-CENTURY SETTINGS OF THE GLORIA AND CREDOFifteenth-Century Liturgical Music VIII: Settings of the Gloria and Credo. Transcribed and Edited by Peter Wright. (Early English Church Music, 55.) London: Published for the British Academy by Stainer & Bell, 2013. [Foreword, p. v; acknowledgements, p. vi; contents, p. vii-viii; abbrevs. & list of plates, p. ix; introd., p. xi-xxiv; score, p. 1-303. ISMN 979-0-2202-2349-5, ISBN 978-0-85249-933-7. £95.]Anonymous music, especially polyphonic music from before 1600, creates endless problems for the musicologist. Unlike paintings, there are no x-rays to reveal ear- lier layers of composition, or paint pig- ments to analyze via mass spectrometry. The tools for analyzing stylistic features re- main unrefined, compared to the elegant assessments of brush strokes, perspective, color, and narrative typical of art history. For fifteenth-century Latin music, musicol- ogists rely on large-scale markers including genre, mensuration, text distribution, and cantus firmus treatment to determine the origins of anonymous works. This is true for English music, which retained distinc- tive characteristics even as it circulated anonymously across Europe, often with the ascription Anglicanus or de Anglia. During the same period, virtually no music from the Continent was copied in England itself.These circumstances inform Peter Wright's impressive edition of individual Gloria and Credo movements for the series Early English Church Music. The volume is divided in four parts: complete settings of the Gloria and Credo, followed by fragmen- tary settings of the Gloria and Credo. Only five of the nineteen complete works have composer attributions, to which Wright provisionally adds two more. Three of the twenty-nine incomplete settings survive with attributions. The edition prefaces each work with an editorial commentary that in- cludes easy-to-read critical notes, plainsong cantus firmi, and an individual discussion of text setting. In keeping with the current editorial policy of the series, the music is rendered in diplomatic notation, but tran- scribed in score, to the extent of displaying coloration and conflicting mensurations among voices, of which there are many. Each part has measure markers to denote the length of one breve. Because mensural notation is contextual in orientation, the length of individual notes and the coordi- nation among voices are shown by their rel- ative spacing on the page. Conceptually, this editorial method offers a strong visual representation of the separate, yet interde- pendent voices that sound in performance.The parameters of the edition-the de- termination of which settings are English- are based on the work of a small cadre of scholars, notably Brian Trowell (Music un- der the Later Plantagenets [Ph.D. diss., University of Cambridge, 1960]), Charles Hamm (A Catalogue of Anonymous English Music in Fifteenth-Century Conti- nental Manuscripts, Musica Disciplina 22 [1968]: 47-76), Gareth R. K. Curtis (Stylistic Layers in the English Mass c. 1400-1450, Proceedings of the Royal Musical Association 109 [1982-83]: 23-38), and Andrew Wathey (Gareth R. K. Curtis and Andrew Wathey, Fifteenth- Century English Liturgical Music: A List of the Surviving Repertory, Royal Musical Association Research Chronicle 27 [1994]: 1-69). It is disappointing that the introduc- tion sidesteps a discussion of thirteen ex- cluded works, which are listed only in foot- note 27. As Wright notes, however, views of what defines a musical composition as English are bound to change as our un- derstanding of English style increases (p. xiv). It is to this understanding that the edition makes its greatest contribution.The inclusion of the twenty-eight frag- ments is important from a historical point of view; all occur in sources of English provenance. Of these, only Gloria no. 27 has questionable origins. A single voice part in alto clef, it possesses a bouncy tune- fulness more characteristic of Latin music from Italy. …
Read full abstract