Background Numerous surgical techniques have been described in the literature for pancreatic stump management following left resection, but there is only one prospective, randomised study. A prospective randomised pilot study was designed to assess five different pancreatic stump management techniques after distal resection in an attempt to identify which was the most effective in terms of complications and ease of execution. Methods Sixty-nine consecutive patients were randomly assigned to five different treatment groups: manual suturing, suturing plus fibrin glue, suturing plus polypropylene mesh, pancreaticojejunostomy and suturing with a stapler. All presented a soft residual pancreas. Results The overall incidence of pancreatic fistula was 19%, ranging from 7% to 33% in the different treatment groups. None of the techniques Significantly reduced the incidence of postoperative complications. Discussion On weighing the complications observed against ease and speed of execution, the construction of a pancreaticojejunostomy and closure of the stump with a mechanical stapler may be regarded as the procedures to be tested in future.