The paper suggests distinguishing between the methodologies of conceptual analysis and notional analysis. The differ-ence lies in how the notion and concept are interpreted. In the paper, a notion is viewed as an individual opinion or un-derstanding of something, whereas a concept represents a general notion or abstract idea. It is assumed that many simi-lar concepts exist with varying scopes and contents. A concept is treated as an objectified notion developed and solidi-fied through social experience. The primary representation of the results of established conceptual analysis methods is shown to be a semantic network, where the vertices are concepts and the arcs represent relationships between them. However, it is noted that classical set theory and semantic networks are insufficient to formalize notions and concepts; instead, the theory of structures must be employed. Conceptual analysis is described as a technique for synthesizing formal concept descriptions using Boolean and Cartesian construction operations. The challenges of applying concep-tual analysis within the framework of the theory of structures are outlined. The development of notional analysis is linked to the demand for precise, unambiguous, and consistent notion descriptions, driven by the variability of their properties. Notional analysis is defined as a method for formal normal descriptions using generalization and associa-tion operations. Generalization entails combining notions such that the entities of the generalized notions become enti-ties of the resulting notion. Association involves merging notions, with each entity of the resulting notion including one entity from each of the associated notions. Notional analysis addresses issues encountered when describing concepts using a corpus-based approach by generating diverse descriptions of notions. It is demonstrated that both conceptual and notional analyses are rooted in the theory of structures. The paper identifies areas where these analyses are effec-tively applied and provides an example of using notional analysis in the design of a technical device.
Read full abstract