AbstractIt is widely recognized that the accuracy of notch fatigue calculations can be improved significantly when those calculations are based on the elastic‐plastic response strain at the notch root, as opposed to the remotely applied loads or stresses. Two of the most widely used approximations for this response are Neuber's rule and Glinka's equivalent strain energy density method. In the present work, a survey of some of the many published evaluations of these methods was first conducted, and then, additional detailed comparisons with elastic‐plastic finite element analyses for a series of semicircular and V‐shaped notch configurations were performed. Based on the observed limitations of both the Neuber and Glinka approaches, and with the guidance of the elastic‐plastic finite element results, a new (and more robust) approach for the estimation of notch response strains is proposed. This approach calls for the definition of a generalized notch response curve (GNRC), which is dependent on both the material stress–strain curve and the notch geometry. Once defined, the GNRC allows the determination of the response strain for any applied stress.