Asymmetrical loading produces a temporary functional scoliosis, but the long term effect of such weight bearing is unclear. It is also unknown whether chronic, static submaximal loading is sufficient to incite adaptive bone mineral density (BMD) or lean tissue responses. This is of concern due to the adaptive nature of bone, muscle, and connective tissue. Also of interest is the potential development of muscular strength imbalances due to external stress. PURPOSE To determine to what extent (if any), muscular and/or skeletal adaptations occur due to asymmetrical static loading. METHODS Eight healthy male commercial cameramen (44±7 yrs) underwent infrared thermographic imaging of the upper body, isometric scapular elevation strength testing, scapular and shoulder manual muscle testing, and dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) bone mineral and lean tissue measurements. Researchers conducted two-way repeated measures ANOVA testing to determine within subject differences between loaded (right) and unloaded (left) sides of the body for upper body mean surface temperature, trunk/arm bone mineral and lean tissue content, scapular regional BMD, femoral neck BMD, and scapular elevation isometric force generation. RESULTS Participants' left sided trunk/arm lean tissue masses were significantly greater than right. (19,304±3245 vs. 18,519±3068 g, p < 0.05) No significant differences existed bilaterally for any other dependent variable. CONCLUSION Repetitive asymmetrical static loading with a hand held commercial camera was insufficient to induce adaptive bone or lean tissue changes within the loaded side of the body. However, participants did demonstrate increased lean tissue mass in the left trunk/arm region. Further research is recommended to determine whether repetitive, asymmetrical loading induces adaptive changes within the unloaded side of the body during camera carriage. Supported in part by Gatorade Sports Science Institute U.S. Student Grant Program.
Read full abstract