Stop Codon Reassignment Research Articles

Complex phylogenetic distribution of a non-canonical genetic code in green algae

BackgroundA non-canonical nuclear genetic code, in which TAG and TAA have been reassigned from stop codons to glutamine, has evolved independently in several eukaryotic lineages, including the ulvophycean green algal orders Dasycladales and Cladophorales. To study the phylogenetic distribution of the standard and non-canonical genetic codes, we generated sequence data of a representative set of ulvophycean green algae and used a robust green algal phylogeny to evaluate different evolutionary scenarios that may account for the origin of the non-canonical code.ResultsThis study demonstrates that the Dasycladales and Cladophorales share this alternative genetic code with the related order Trentepohliales and the genus Blastophysa, but not with the Bryopsidales, which is sister to the Dasycladales. This complex phylogenetic distribution whereby all but one representative of a single natural lineage possesses an identical deviant genetic code is unique.ConclusionsWe compare different evolutionary scenarios for the complex phylogenetic distribution of this non-canonical genetic code. A single transition to the non-canonical code followed by a reversal to the canonical code in the Bryopsidales is highly improbable due to the profound genetic changes that coincide with codon reassignment. Multiple independent gains of the non-canonical code, as hypothesized for ciliates, are also unlikely because the same deviant code has evolved in all lineages. Instead we favor a stepwise acquisition model, congruent with the ambiguous intermediate model, whereby the non-canonical code observed in these green algal orders has a single origin. We suggest that the final steps from an ambiguous intermediate situation to a non-canonical code have been completed in the Trentepohliales, Dasycladales, Cladophorales and Blastophysa but not in the Bryopsidales. We hypothesize that in the latter lineage an initial stage characterized by translational ambiguity was not followed by final reassignment of both stop codons to glutamine. Instead the standard code was retained by the disappearance of the ambiguously decoding tRNAs from the genome. We correlate the emergence of a non-canonical genetic code in the Ulvophyceae to their multinucleate nature.

The appearance of pyrrolysine in tRNA His guanylyltransferase by neutral evolution

tRNA(His) guanylyltransferase (Thg1) post-transcriptionally adds a G (position -1) to the 5'-terminus of tRNA(His). The Methanosarcina acetivorans Thg1 (MaThg1) gene contains an in-frame TAG (amber) codon. Although a UAG codon typically directs translation termination, its presence in Methanosarcina mRNA may lead to pyrrolysine (Pyl) incorporation achieved by Pyl-tRNA(Pyl), the product of pyrrolysyl-tRNA synthetase. Sequencing of the MaThg1 gene and transcript confirmed the amber codon. Translation of MaThg1 mRNA led to a full-length, Pyl-containing, active enzyme as determined by immunoblotting, mass spectrometry, and biochemical analysis. The nature of the inserted amino acid at the position specified by UAG is not critical, as Pyl or Trp insertion yields active MaThg1 variants in M. acetivorans and equal amounts of full-length protein. These data suggest that Pyl insertion is akin to natural suppression and unlike the active stop codon reassignment that is required for selenocysteine insertion. Only three Pyl-containing proteins have been characterized previously, a set of methylamine methyltransferases in which Pyl is assumed to have specifically evolved to be a key active-site constituent. In contrast, Pyl in MaThg1 is a dispensable residue that appears to confer no selective advantage. Phylogenetic analysis suggests that Thg1 is becoming dispensable in the archaea, and furthermore supports the hypothesis that Pyl appeared in MaThg1 as the result of neutral evolution. This indicates that even the most unusual amino acid can play an ordinary role in proteins.

Connection between stop codon reassignment and frequent use of shifty stop frameshifting

Ciliated protozoa of the genus Euplotes have undergone genetic code reassignment, redefining the termination codon UGA to encode cysteine. In addition, Euplotes spp. genes very frequently employ shifty stop frameshifting. Both of these phenomena involve noncanonical events at a termination codon, suggesting they might have a common cause. We recently demonstrated that Euplotes octocarinatus peptide release factor eRF1 ignores UGA termination codons while continuing to recognize UAA and UAG. Here we show that both the Tetrahymena thermophila and E. octocarinatus eRF1 factors allow efficient frameshifting at all three termination codons, suggesting that UGA redefinition also impaired UAA/UAG recognition. Mutations of the Euplotes factor restoring a phylogenetically conserved motif in eRF1 (TASNIKS) reduced programmed frameshifting at all three termination codons. Mutation of another conserved residue, Cys124, strongly reduces frameshifting at UGA while actually increasing frameshifting at UAA/UAG. We will discuss these results in light of recent biochemical characterization of these mutations.

Tandem Stop Codons in Ciliates That Reassign Stop Codons

Tandem stop codons are extra stop codons hypothesized to be present downstream of genes to act as a backup in case of read-through of the real stop codon. Although seemingly absent from Escherichia coli, recent studies have confirmed the presence of such codons in yeast. In this paper we will analyze the genomes of two ciliate species--Paramecium tetraurelia and Tetrahymena thermophila--that reassign the stop codons TAA and TAG to glutamine, for the presence of tandem stop codons. We show that there are more tandem stop codons downstream of both Paramecium and Tetrahymena genes than expected by chance given the base composition of the downstream regions. This excess of tandem stop codons is larger in Tetrahymena and Paramecium than in yeast. We propose that this might be caused by a higher frequency of stop codon read-through in these species than in yeast, possibly because of a leaky termination machinery resulting from stop codon reassignment.

Distinct eRF3 Requirements Suggest Alternate eRF1 Conformations Mediate Peptide Release during Eukaryotic Translation Termination

Organisms that use the standard genetic code recognize UAA, UAG, and UGA as stop codons, whereas variant code species frequently alter this pattern of stop codon recognition. We previously demonstrated that a hybrid eRF1 carrying the Euplotes octocarinatus domain 1 fused to Saccharomyces cerevisiae domains 2 and 3 (Eo/Sc eRF1) recognized UAA and UAG, but not UGA, as stop codons. In the current study, we identified mutations in Eo/Sc eRF1 that restore UGA recognition and define distinct roles for the TASNIKS and YxCxxxF motifs in eRF1 function. Mutations in or near the YxCxxxF motif support the cavity model for stop codon recognition by eRF1. Mutations in the TASNIKS motif eliminated the eRF3 requirement for peptide release at UAA and UAG codons, but not UGA codons. These results suggest that the TASNIKS motif and eRF3 function together to trigger eRF1 conformational changes that couple stop codon recognition and peptide release during eukaryotic translation termination.

The Development, Ultrastructural Cytology, and Molecular Phylogeny of the Basal Oomycete Eurychasma dicksonii, Infecting the Filamentous Phaeophyte Algae Ectocarpus siliculosus and Pylaiella littoralis

The morphological development, ultrastructural cytology, and molecular phylogeny of Eurychasma dicksonii, a holocarpic oomycete endoparasite of phaeophyte algae, were investigated in laboratory cultures. Infection of the host algae by E. dicksonii is initiated by an adhesorium-like infection apparatus. First non-walled, the parasite cell developed a cell wall and numerous large vacuoles once it had almost completely filled the infected host cell (foamy stage). Large-scale cytoplasmic changes led to the differentiation of a sporangium with peripheral primary cysts. Secondary zoospores appeared to be liberated from the primary cysts in the internal space left after the peripheral spores differentiated. These zoospores contained two phases of peripheral vesicles, most likely homologous to the dorsal encystment vesicles and K-bodies observed in other oomycetes. Following zoospore liberation the walls of the empty cyst were left behind, forming the so-called net sporangium, a distinctive morphological feature of this genus. The morphological and ultrastructural features of Eurychasma were discussed in relation to similarities with other oomycetes. Both SSU rRNA and COII trees pointed to a basal position of Eurychasma among the Oomycetes. The cox2 sequences also revealed that the UGA codon encoded tryptophan, constituting the first report of stop codon reassignment in an oomycete mitochondrion.

Nonstandard genetic codes and translation termination

Genetic code is not universal. Various non-standard versions of the code were found in mitochondrial, prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes. Stop codons are used to signal the ribosome stop translation of the coding sequence and prone to reassignment to sense codons. Class-1 termination factors recognize stop codons and promote hydrolysis of the peptidyl-tRNA in ribosome (RF1, RF2 in prokaryotes and eRF1 in eukaryotes). The class-1 factor termination specificity is changed in non-standart codes organisms. Pyrrolysine and selenocysteine use dissimilar decoding strategies. The various non-standart code origin hypotheses are described. It was proposed that specificity alteration of the class-1 release factor was a starting point for stop codon reassignment.

Consequences of Stop Codon Reassignment on Protein Evolution in Ciliates with Alternative Genetic Codes

Tetrahymena thermophila and Paramecium tetraurelia are ciliates that reassign TAA and TAG from stop codons to glutamine codons. Because of the lack of full genome sequences, few studies have concentrated on analyzing the effects of codon reassignment in protein evolution. We used the recently sequenced genome of these species to analyze the patterns of amino acid substitution in ciliates that reassign the code. We show that, as expected, the codon reassignment has a large impact on amino acid substitutions in closely related proteins; however, contrary to expectations, these effects also hold for very diverged proteins. Previous studies have used amino acid substitution data to calculate the minimization of the genetic code; our results show that because of the lasting influence of the code in the patterns of substitution, such studies are tautological. These different substitution patterns might affect alignment of ciliate proteins, as alignment programs use scoring matrices based on substitution patterns of organisms that use the standard code. We also show that glutamine is used more frequently in ciliates than in other species, as often as expected based on the presence of the 2 new reassigned codons, indicating that the frequencies of amino acids in proteomes is mostly determined by neutral processes based on their number of codons.

Distinct Paths To Stop Codon Reassignment by the Variant-Code Organisms Tetrahymena and Euplotes

The reassignment of stop codons is common among many ciliate species. For example, Tetrahymena species recognize only UGA as a stop codon, while Euplotes species recognize only UAA and UAG as stop codons. Recent studies have shown that domain 1 of the translation termination factor eRF1 mediates stop codon recognition. While it is commonly assumed that changes in domain 1 of ciliate eRF1s are responsible for altered stop codon recognition, this has never been demonstrated in vivo. To carry out such an analysis, we made hybrid proteins that contained eRF1 domain 1 from either Tetrahymena thermophila or Euplotes octocarinatus fused to eRF1 domains 2 and 3 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We found that the Tetrahymena hybrid eRF1 efficiently terminated at all three stop codons when expressed in yeast cells, indicating that domain 1 is not the sole determinant of stop codon recognition in Tetrahymena species. In contrast, the Euplotes hybrid facilitated efficient translation termination at UAA and UAG codons but not at the UGA codon. Together, these results indicate that while domain 1 facilitates stop codon recognition, other factors can influence this process. Our findings also indicate that these two ciliate species used distinct approaches to diverge from the universal genetic code.

A high percentage of Euplotes genes require a +1 translational frameshift for expression

A previous survey of Euplotes genes available in GenBank indicated that >5% required a +1 translational frameshift for expression, much higher than observed in other organisms. Because this sample of sequences was non‐random and biased towards highly expressed genes, we have randomly selected and sequenced 25 Euplotes crassus macronuclear DNA molecules to more accurately assess the frequency of frameshifting. Three new +1 frameshift genes were identified, and all have sequence features similar to the previously postulated frameshift sites. The results indicate that the frequency of Euplotes+1 frameshift genes is indeed high, and likely >10%. We have also examined the evolution of one of two frameshift sites present in the telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) genes of E. crassus. TERT gene segments were isolated from five additional Euplotes species. FS2 was found only in E. crassus and the closely related E. vannus, and phylogenetic analyses indicate that the site arose late in the evolution of the Euplotes group. Moreover, a novel frameshift site (FS3) was identified solely in the TERT gene of E. minuta. These results indicate that frameshift sites have arisen within genes during the recent history of Euplotes, and that it may be an ongoing process. Overall, the data suggest to us that the appearance of a frameshift site in a Euplotes gene is selectively neutral, or near‐neutral. This would require an efficient mechanism of frameshifting in Euplotes. A model will be presented linking frequent frameshifting to a second unusual genetic feature of Euplotes, stop codon reassignment.

Decoding the Decoding Region: Analysis of Eukaryotic Release Factor (eRF1) Stop Codon-Binding Residues

Peptide synthesis in eukaryotes terminates when eukaryotic release factor 1 (eRF1) binds to an mRNA stop codon and occupies the ribosomal A site. Domain 1 of the eRF1 protein has been implicated in stop codon recognition in a number of experimental studies. In order to further pinpoint the residues of this protein involved in stop codon recognition, we sequenced and compared eRF1 genes from a variety of ciliated protozoan species. We then performed a series of computational analyses to evaluate the conservation, accessibility, and structural environment of each amino acid located in domain 1. With this new dataset and methodology, we were able to identify eight specific amino acid sites important for stop codon recognition and also to propose a set of cooperative paired substitutions that may underlie stop codon reassignment. Our results are more consistent with current experimental data than previously described models.

Newly sequenced eRF1s from ciliates: the diversity of stop codon usage and the molecular surfaces that are important for stop codon interactions

The genetic code of nuclear genes in some ciliates was found to differ from that of other organisms in the assignment of UGA, UAG, and UAA codons, which are normally assigned as stop codons. In some ciliate species, the universal stop codons UAA and UAG instead encode glutamine. In some other ciliates, the universal stop codon UGA appears to be translated as cysteine or tryptophan. Eukaryotic release factor 1 (eRF1) is a key protein in stop codon recognition, thus, the protein is believed to play an important role in the stop codon reassignment in ciliates. We have cloned, sequenced, and analyzed the cDNA of eRF1 from four ciliate species of three different classes: Karyorelictea ( Loxodes striatus), Heterotrichea ( Blepharisma musculus), and Litostomatea ( Didinium nasutum, Dileptus margaritifer). Phylogenetic analysis of these eRF1s supports the hypothesis that the genetic code in ciliates has deviated independently several times from the universal genetic code, and that different ciliate eRF1s may have undergone different processes to change the codon specificity. Using computational methods, we have also suggested areas on the surface of eRF1s that are important for stop codon recognition in ciliate eRF1s.

The molecular basis of nuclear genetic code change in ciliates.

The nuclear genetic code has changed in several lineages of ciliates. These changes, UAR to glutamine and UGA to cysteine, imply that eukaryotic release factor 1 (eRF1), the protein that recognizes stop codons and terminates translation, changes specificity. Here we test whether changes in eRF1 drive genetic code evolution. Database sequence analysis reveals numerous genetic code alterations in ciliates, including UGA --> tryptophan in Blepharisma americanum and the distantly related Colpoda. We sequenced eRF1 from four ciliates: B. americanum, a heterotrich that independently derived the same eRF1 specificity as Euplotes, and three spirotrichs, Stylonychia lemnae, S. mytilus, and Oxytricha trifallax, that independently derived the same genetic code as Tetrahymena (UAR --> glutamine). Distantly related ciliates with similar codes show characteristic changes in eRF1. We used a sliding window analysis to test associations between changes in specific eRF1 residues and changes in the genetic code. The regions of eRF1 that display convergent substitutions are identical to those identified in a recently reported nonsense suppression mutant screen in yeast. Genetic code change by stop codon reassignment is surprisingly frequent in ciliates, with UGA --> tryptophan occurring twice independently. This is the first description of this code, previously found only in bacteria and mitochondria, in a eukaryotic nuclear genome. eRF1 has evolved strikingly convergently in lineages with variant genetic codes. The strong concordance with biochemical data indicates that our methodology may be generally useful for detecting molecular determinants of biochemical changes in evolution.