Regionalization is of great practical importance, being applied in fields ranging from air space to water distribution. Canada has one of the highest waste generation rates in the world, disposing an average of 694.4 kg/cap in 2018. Waste management costed Canadians about CAD $3.3 billion in 2016, with collection and transportation making up 41.3% of this expenditure. Regionalized waste management systems are becoming popular in Canada and around the world; and design and optimization of regions is vital. Different spatial statistics are used to optimize 3 sub-regions in Saskatchewan (Regina, Leinan, and Beatty). Centroidal Voronoi Tessellation is generally the most efficient method. When the ratio of populated places to road length is low (0.010), ‘median center’ better optimized populated places in each sub-region. Computational demand was highest in Beatty (19.0 iterations), followed by Regina (9.67 iterations) and Leinan (5.33 iterations) indicating a trade-off between the number of sub-regions, computational efficiency, and optimized percent standard deviation. A strong linear relationship is observed in some cases between percent SD of optimized parameters and standard deviation of area, indicating the importance of relative size in optimization. In Regina, Median center (rank = 2) was ranked higher than mean center (rank = 3), while the opposite was true in Beatty. Feature distribution within regions and different spatial statistics in the algorithm should be explored. This work is of practical importance in waste management and other fields where region development is important.
Read full abstract