Stage Of Black Hole Evaporation Research Articles

Black hole evaporation and its remnants with the generalized uncertainty principle including a linear term

In recent years, researchers have investigated the evaporation of Schwarzschild black holes using various forms of the generalized uncertainty principle (GUP), metric quantum correction, and non-commutative geometry, respectively. However, there are differences between the GUP correction and the other two methods in terms of describing the later stages of black hole evaporation. Furthermore, some studies argue that the GUP with a negative parameter cannot effectively correct black hole evaporation, while others contend that the positivity or negativity of the GUP parameters should not affect the correction results. Taking the above into consideration, we reconsider black hole evaporation with the generalized uncertainty principle including a linear term (LGUP), and examine the case of negative parameters. The results indicate that the evaporation behavior of both Schwarzschild black holes and Reissner–Nordström black holes, under LGUP correction, is consistent with the results of metric quantum correction and non-commutative geometry. Additionally, the negative parameter LGUP can also effectively correct for black hole evaporation.

What Is the Fate of Hawking Evaporation in Gravity Theories with Higher Curvature Terms?

During the final stages of black hole evaporation, ultraviolet deviations from general relativity eventually become dramatic, potentially affecting the end state. We explore this problem by performing nonlinear simulations of wave packets in Einstein-dilaton-Gauss-Bonnet gravity, the only gravity theory with quadratic curvature terms which can be studied at a fully nonperturbative level. Black holes in this theory have a minimum mass but also a nonvanishing temperature. This poses a puzzle concerning the final fate of Hawking evaporation in the presence of high-curvature nonperturbative effects. By simulating the mass loss induced by evaporation at the classical level using an auxiliary phantom field, we study the nonlinear evolution of black holes past the minimum mass. We observe a runaway shrink of the horizon (a nonperturbative effect forbidden in general relativity) which eventually unveils a high-curvature elliptic region. While this might hint to the formation of a naked singularity (and hence to a violation of the weak cosmic censorship) or of a pathological spacetime region, a different numerical formulation of the initial-value problem in this theory might be required to rule out other possibilities, including the transition from the critical black hole to a stable horizonless remnant. Our Letter is relevant in the context of the information-loss paradox, dark-matter remnants, and for constraints on microscopic primordial black holes.

Infrared effects in the late stages of black hole evaporation

As a black hole evaporates, each outgoing Hawking quantum carries away some of the black holes asymptotic charges associated with the extended Bondi-Metzner-Sachs group. These include the Poincaré charges of energy, linear momentum, intrinsic angular momentum, and orbital angular momentum or center-of-mass charge, as well as extensions of these quantities associated with supertranslations and super-Lorentz transformations, namely supermomentum, superspin and super center-of-mass charges (also known as soft hair). Since each emitted quantum has fluctuations that are of order unity, fluctuations in the black hole’s charges grow over the course of the evaporation. We estimate the scale of these fluctuations using a simple model. The results are, in Planck units: (i) The black hole position has a uncertainty of sim {M}_i^2 at late times, where Mi is the initial mass (previously found by Page). (ii) The black hole mass M has an uncertainty of order the mass M itself at the epoch when M ∼ {M}_i^{2/3} , well before the Planck scale is reached. Correspondingly, the time at which the evaporation ends has an uncertainty of order sim {M}_i^2 . (iii) The supermomentum and superspin charges are not independent but are determined from the Poincaré charges and the super center-of-mass charges. (iv) The supertranslation that characterizes the super center-of-mass charges has fluctuations at multipole orders l of order unity that are of order unity in Planck units. At large l, there is a power law spectrum of fluctuations that extends up to l ∼ {M}_i^2/M , beyond which the fluctuations fall off exponentially, with corresponding total rms shear tensor fluctuations ∼ MiM−3/2.

A possible thermodynamic origin of the spacetime minimum length

In this paper, by applying the generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) at the final stage of black hole evaporation, we have proposed a thermodynamic explanation for the minimal scale of quantum gravity, i.e. it may stem from the basic requirements of the third law of thermodynamics for quantum gravitation system. At the same time, we have interestingly found that the third law of black hole thermodynamics acts as a supervisor in quantum gravity spacetime to ensure the causality of the spacetime as that does in classical gravity.

Generalized uncertainty principle and black hole thermodynamics * * Supported by the Program for NCET-12-1060, by the Sichuan Youth Science and Technology Foundation (2011JQ0019), FANEDD (201319), the Innovative Research Team in College of Sichuan Province (13TD0003), Ten Thousand Talent Program of Sichuan Province, Sichuan Natural Science Foundation (16ZB0178) and Meritocracy Research Funds of China West Normal University (17YC513, 17C050)

Banerjee-Ghosh's work shows that the singularity problem can be naturally avoided by the fact that black hole evaporation stops when the remnant mass is greater than the critical mass when including the generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) effects with first- and second-order corrections. In this paper, we first follow their steps to reexamine Banerjee-Ghosh's work, but we find an interesting result: the remnant mass is always equal to the critical mass at the final stage of black hole evaporation with the inclusion of the GUP effects. Then, we use Hossenfelder's GUP, i.e., another GUP model with higher-order corrections, to restudy the final evolution behavior of the black hole evaporation, and we confirm the intrinsic self-consistency between the black hole remnant and critical masses once more. In both cases, we also find that the thermodynamic quantities are not singular at the final stage of black hole evaporation.

The role of collapsed matter in the decay of black holes

We try to shed some light on the role of matter in the final stages of black hole evaporation from the fundamental frameworks of classicalization and the black-to-white hole bouncing scenario. Despite being based on very different grounds, these two approaches attempt at going beyond the background field method and treat black holes as fully quantum systems rather than considering quantum field theory on the corresponding classical manifolds. They also lead to the common prediction that the semiclassical description of black hole evaporation should break down and the system be disrupted by internal quantum pressure, but they both arrive at this conclusion neglecting the matter that formed the black hole. We instead estimate this pressure from the bootstrapped description of black holes, which allows us to express the total Arnowitt–Deser–Misner mass in terms of the baryonic mass still present inside the black hole. We conclude that, although these two scenarios provide qualitatively similar predictions for the final stages, the corpuscular model does not seem to suggest any sizeable deviation from the semiclassical time scale at which the disruption should occur, unlike the black-to-white hole bouncing scenario. This, in turn, makes the phenomenology of corpuscular black holes more subtle from an astrophysical perspective.

Ineffective higher derivative black hole hair

Inspired by possibility that the Schwarzschild black hole may not be the unique spherically symmetric vacuum solution to generalisations of general relativity, we consider black holes in pure fourth order higher derivative gravity treated as an effective theory. Such solutions may be of interest in addressing the issue of higher derivative hair or during the later stages of black hole evaporation. Non-Schwarzschild solutions have been studied but we have put earlier results on a firmer footing by finding a systematic asymptotic expansion for the black holes and matching them with known numerical solutions obtained by integrating out from the near horizon region. These asymptotic expansions can be cast in the form of trans-series expansions which we conjecture will be a generic feature of non-Schwarzschild higher derivative black holes. Excitingly we find a new branch of solutions with lower free energy than the Schwarzschild solution, but as found in earlier work, solutions only seem to exist for black holes with large curvatures meaning that one should not generically neglect even higher derivative corrections. This suggests that one effectively recovers the non-hair theorems in this context.

Black hole event horizons — Teleology and predictivity

General Relativity predicts the existence of black holes. Access to the complete spacetime manifold is required to describe the black hole. This feature necessitates that black hole dynamics is specified by future or teleological boundary condition. Here, we demonstrate that the statistical mechanical description of black holes, the raison d’être behind the existence of black hole thermodynamics, requires teleological boundary condition. Within the fluid–gravity paradigm — Einstein’s equations when projected on spacetime horizons resemble Navier–Stokes equation of a fluid — we show that the specific heat and the coefficient of bulk viscosity of the horizon fluid are negative only if the teleological boundary condition is taken into account. We argue that in a quantum theory of gravity, the future boundary condition plays a crucial role. We briefly discuss the possible implications of this at late stages of black hole evaporation.

Unitary S matrices with long-range correlations and the quantum black hole

We propose an S matrix approach to the quantum black hole in which causality, unitarity and their interrelation play a prominent role. Assuming the 't Hooft S matrix ansatz for a gravitating region surrounded by an asymptotically flat space-time we find a non-local transformation which changes the standard causality requirement but is a symmetry of the unitarity condition of the S matrix. This new S matrix then implies correlations between the in and out states of the theory with the involvement of a third entity which in the case of a quantum black hole, we argue is the horizon S matrix. Such correlations are thus linked to preserving the unitarity of the S matrix and to the fact that entangling unitary operators are nonlocal. The analysis is performed within the Bogoliubov S matrix framework by considering a spacetime consisting of causal complements with a boundary in between. No particular metric or lagrangian dynamics need be invoked even to obtain an evolution equation for the full S matrix. Constraints imposed by the new causality requirement and implications for the effectiveness of field theoretical descriptions and for complementarity are also discussed. We find that the tension between information preservation and complementarity may be resolved provided the full quantum gravity theory either through symmetries or fine tuning forbids the occurrence of closed time like curves of information flow. Then, even if causality is violated near the horizon at any intermediate stage, a standard causal ordering may be preserved for the observer away from the horizon. In the context of the black hole, the novelty of our formulation is that it appears well suited to understand unitarity at any intermediate stage of black hole evaporation. Moreover, it is applicable generally to all theories with long range correlations including the final state projection models.

ON THE EFFECT OF ENERGY CONSERVATION ON BLACK HOLE EVAPORATION

We consider the emission of Hawking radiation by black holes as a consequence of a tunneling process. By requiring energy conservation in the derivation of the emission rate we get a well-known deviation from an exact thermal spectrum. A model that takes into account the implications of energy conservation, as well as the back-scattered radiation, is then constructed in order to describe the evolution of black holes as they evaporate. The evaporation process in this model is compared with the results in the standard "thermal" approximation. This allows us to point out the relevance that energy conservation might have in the last stages of black hole evaporation. We also comment about the possible implications of energy conservation in the information loss paradox.

Black hole evaporation in a noncommutative charged Vaidya model

The aim of this paper is to study the black hole evaporation and Hawking radiation for a noncommutative charged Vaidya black hole. For this purpose, we determine spherically symmetric charged Vaidya model and then formulate a noncommutative Reissner-Nordstr$\ddot{o}$m-like solution of this model which leads to an exact $(t-r)$ dependent metric. The behavior of temporal component of this metric and the corresponding Hawking temperature is investigated. The results are shown in the form of graphs. Further, we examine the tunneling process of the charged massive particles through the quantum horizon. It is found that the tunneling amplitude is modified due to noncommutativity. Also, it turns out that black hole evaporates completely in the limits of large time and horizon radius. The effect of charge is to reduce the temperature from maximum value to zero. It is mentioned here that the final stage of black hole evaporation turns out to be a naked singularity.

WORMHOLES AND CHILD UNIVERSES

Evidence to the case that classical gravitation provides the clue to make sense out of quantum gravity is presented. The key observation is the existence in classical gravitation of child universe solutions or "almost" solutions, "almost" because of some singularity problems. The difficulties of these child universe solutions that are due to their generic singularity problems will be very likely be cured by quantum effects, just like for example "almost" instanton solutions are made relevant in gauge theories with the breaking of conformal invariance. Some well-motivated modifcations of general relativity where these singularity problems are absent even at the classical level are discussed. High energy density excitations, responsible for UV divergences in quantum field theories, including quantum gravity, are likely to be the source of child universes which carry them out of the original space–time. This decoupling could prevent these high UV excitations from having any influence on physical amplitudes. Child universe production could therefore be responsible for UV regularization in quantum field theories which take into account semiclassically gravitational effects. Child universe production in the last stages of black hole evaporation, the prediction of absence of trans-Planckian primordial perturbations, connection to the minimum length hypothesis, and in particular the connection to the maximal curvature hypothesis are discussed. Some discussion of superexcited states in the case these states such as Kaluza–Klein excitations are carried out. Finally, the possibility of obtaining "string like" effects from the wormholes associated with the child universes is discussed.

UV/IR MIXING AND BLACK HOLE THERMODYNAMICS

The goal of this paper is to investigate the final stage of the black-hole-evaporation process in the framework of Lorentz-violating modified dispersion relations (MDRs). As a consequence of MDRs, the high energy sector of the underlying field theory does not decouple from the low energy sector — a phenomenon known as UV/IR mixing. In the absence of exact supersymmetry, we derive an MDR which shows UV/IR mixing by a novel energy dependence. Then we investigate the effects of this type of MDRs on the thermodynamics of a radiating noncommutative Schwarzschild black hole. The final stage of black hole evaporation obtained in this framework is compared with existing pictures.

RELIC RADIATION FROM AN EVAPORATING BLACK HOLE

This paper presents a non-string-theoretic calculation of the microcanonical entropy of relic integer-spin Hawking radiation, at fixed total energy E, from an evanescent, neutral, non-rotating four-dimensional black hole. The only conserved macroscopic quantity is the total energy E which, for a black hole that evaporates completely, is the total energy of the relic radiation. Through a boundary-value approach, in which data for massless, integer-spin perturbations are set on initial and final space-like hypersurfaces, the statistical-mechanics problem becomes, in effect, a one-dimensional problem, with the "volume" of the system determined by the real part of the time separation at spatial infinity — the variable conjugate to the total energy. We count the number of field configurations on the final space-like hypersurface that have total energy E, assuming that initial perturbations are weak. We find that the density of states resembles the well-known Cardy formula. The Bekenstein–Hawking entropy is recovered if the real part of the asymptotic time separation is of the order of the semi-classical black-hole lifetime. We thereby obtain a statistical interpretation of black-hole entropy. Corrections to the microcanonical entropy are computed, and we find agreement with other approaches in terms of a logarithmic correction to the black-hole area law, which is universal (independent of black-hole parameters). This result depends crucially upon the discreteness of the energy levels. We discuss the similarities of our approach with the transition from the black-hole to the fundamental-string regime in the final stages of black-hole evaporation. In addition, we find that the squared coupling, g2, which regulates the transition from a black hole to a highly-excited string state, and vice versa, can be related to the angle, δ, in the complex-time plane, through which we continue analytically the time separation at spatial infinity. Thus, in this scenario, the strong-coupling regime corresponds to a Euclidean black hole, while the physical limit of a Lorentzian space–time (the limit as δ → 0+) corresponds to the weak-coupling regime. This resembles the transition of a black hole to a highly-excited string-like state, which subsequently decays into massless particles, thereby avoiding the naked singularity.

SEMICLASSICAL AND QUANTUM BLACK HOLES AND THEIR EVAPORATION, DE SITTER AND ANTI-DE SITTER REGIMES, GRAVITATIONAL AND STRING PHASE TRANSITIONS

An effective string theory in physically relevant cosmological and black hole space–times is reviewed. Explicit computations of the quantum string entropy, partition function and quantum string emission by black holes (Schwarzschild, rotating, charged, asymptotically flat, de Sitter dS and anti-de Sitter AdS space–times) in the framework of effective string theory in curved backgrounds provide an amount of new quantum gravity results as: (i) gravitational phase transitions appear with a distinctive universal feature: a square-root branch point singularity in any space–time dimensions. This is of the type of the de Vega–Sánchez transition for the thermal self-gravitating gas of point particles. (ii) There are no phase transitions in AdS alone. (iii) For dS background, upper bounds of the Hubble constant H are found, dictated by the quantum string phase transition. (iv) The Hawking temperature and the Hagedorn temperature are the same concept but in different (semiclassical and quantum) gravity regimes respectively. (v) The last stage of black hole evaporation is a microscopic string state with a finite string critical temperature which decays as usual quantum strings do in nonthermal pure quantum radiation (no information loss). (vi) New lower string bounds are given for the Kerr–Newman black hole angular momentum and charge, which are entirely different from the upper classical bounds. (vii) Semiclassical gravity states undergo a phase transition into quantum string states of the same system, these states are duals of each other in the precise sense of the usual classical–quantum (wave–particle) duality, which is universal irrespective of any symmetry or isommetry of the space–time and of the number or the kind of space–time dimensions.

Quantum scalar field on a three-dimensional (BTZ) black hole instanton: Heat kernel, effective action, and thermodynamics

We consider the behaviour of a quantum scalar field on three-dimensional Euclidean backgrounds: Anti-de Sitter space, the regular BTZ black hole instanton and the BTZ instanton with a conical singularity at the horizon. The corresponding heat kernel and effective action are calculated explicitly for both rotating and non-rotating holes. The quantum entropy of the BTZ black hole is calculated by differentiating the effective action with respect to the angular deficit at the conical singularity. The renormalization of the UV-divergent terms in the action and entropy is considered. The structure of the UV-finite term in the quantum entropy is of particular interest. Being negligible for large outer horizon area $A_+$ it behaves logarithmically for small $A_+$. Such behaviour might be important at late stages of black hole evaporation.

HOW FAST DOES A BLACK HOLE RADIATE INFORMATION?

If the information that falls into a black hole comes back out in the Hawking radiation, how fast might it be expected to do so? An estimate based on the average entropy of a subsystem shows that it may come out so slowly in the initial stages of black hole evaporation that it would never be predicted by a perturbative analysis.

Can black-hole entropy be quantized ?

The remnant mass at the last stage of black hole evaporation is of the order of the Planck mass and the corresponding entropy is of the order of 2 πk B. On the basis of Bekenstein's work, I have derived that the minimum entropy increase when a black hole accretes matter is 2 πk B; this gives a lower bound of the Planck mass on the mass accretable by a black hole, which corresponds again to a minimum black hole entropy of the order of 2 πk B. Moreover, the minimum entropy and the minimum entropy increase are not affected by gravitation, hence the above statements also hold in the eraly universe. Hence I propose the conjecture that black hole entropy is qunatized with quantum 2 πk B.

Does string theory solve the puzzles of black hole evaporation?

We point out that the massive modes of closed superstring theories may play a crucial role in the last stages of black hole evaporation. If the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy describes the true degeneracy of a black hole — implying loss of quantum coherence and the unitary evolution of quantum states-it becomes entropically favorable for an evaporating black hole to make a transition to a state of massive string modes. This in turn may decay into massless modes of the string (radiation) avoiding the naked singularity exposed by black hole evaporation in the semiclassical picture. Alternatively, quantum coherence may be maintained if the entropy of an evaporating black hole is much larger than that given by the Bekenstein-Hawking formula. In that case, however, the transition to massive string modes is unlikely. String theories might thus resolve the difficulty of the naked singularity, but it appears likely that they will still involve loss of quantum coherence.

Role of string excitation in the last stages of black-hole evaporation.

We argue that the massive modes of the superstring can play an important role in the last stages of black-hole evaporation. If the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is the true statistical entropy of an evaporating black hole, it becomes probable for a black hole to disappear by making a transition to an excited string state. This excited string state can then decay to massless radiation, avoiding the naked singularity of the semiclassical picture. We also construct the energy-volume phase diagram separating the three phases: pure radiation, black hole and radiation, and massive string modes and radiation.