Stable isotopes of chromium (Cr) and iron (Fe), both multivalent elements in silicate melts, are valuable proxies of redox conditions in magmatic systems. Partial melting and fractional crystallization have been identified as the dominant fractionation processes for Cr and Fe isotopes in high-temperature reservoirs that can lead to small but detectable isotope variations in igneous rocks. More recently, however, the source mineralogy has been suggested to play an important role, which can ultimately affect the magnitude of Cr and Fe isotopic fractionation during partial melting and thus the Cr and Fe isotopic composition of the originating melt.With the aim to investigate the role of magmatic processes and the source Cr and Fe isotope signatures on the isotope composition of these transition metals in normal mid-ocean ridge basalts (N-MORB), we analyzed 21 well-characterized MORB glasses from the southern East-Pacific Rise, Pacific-Antarctic Ridge and Mid-Atlantic Ridge. The Cr isotope compositions of N-MORB show a narrow range from −0.278 to −0.186 ‰ in δ53/52Cr (i.e., difference of a sample’s 53Cr/52Cr ratio relative to the international reference material NIST SRM979), with an average value of −0.237 ± 0.050 ‰ (2SD; n = 19). As such, the average N-MORB δ53/52Cr value is significantly lower than that of Bulk Silicate Earth of −0.12 ± 0.06 ‰ and the Cr isotope compositions reported for most ocean island basalts ranging from ∼ −0.23 to 0.00 ‰. Iron isotopic compositions of these MORB range from +0.032 to +0.137 ‰ in δ56/54Fe (i.e., difference of a sample’s 56Fe/54Fe ratio relative to the international reference material IRMM014) and are within the range of previously published MORB data. The lack of correlations between N-MORB Cr isotope signatures and indices of magmatic differentiation suggests a negligible control of this process on Cr stable isotopes. Partial melting modeling using pMELTS provides evidence that the significant offset towards lower δ53/52Cr values of N-MORB cannot be produced by decompression partial melting of a lherzolithic source such as the depleted upper mantle alone. Instead, we suggest that the lower δ53/52Cr values of MORB could be linked to intrinsic small-scale 53Cr-depleted pyroxene-rich domains in the upper mantle that influence the melt’s Cr isotopic budget during partial melting.
Read full abstract