Stability Of Membrane Proteins Research Articles

Polar Interactions Trump Hydrophobicity in Stabilizing a Membrane-Interacting Protein

The vast majority of membrane-bound proteins consist of bundles of hydrophobic α-helical transmembrane domains. How these proteins adopt their native, biologically active structures in the apolar milieu of a membrane is increasingly well understood. However, it is still under debate to what extent polar interactions contribute to membrane-protein stability. For example, the membrane-interacting protein Mistic exhibits a net charge of −12 at pH 7 but, in NMR experiments, displays a concentric ring of interactions with apolar detergent tails typical of more hydrophobic membrane proteins. Moreover, as a fusion tag, Mistic supports the production and membrane insertion of integral membrane proteins in Escherichia coli. Thus, in spite of its unusually polar surface, Mistic in many aspects behaves like a conventional membrane protein.Here, we demonstrate that, upon addition of urea, Mistic unfolds reversibly form detergent micelles following a two-state equilibrium and exhibits the same unfolded reference state irrespective of the detergent used. Unfolding titrations from alkyl maltoside detergents revealed that alkyl tails of 12 carbon atoms preserve the conformational stability of the protein best. However, on top of such hydrophobic interactions, we discovered that zwitter-ionic and charged detergent head groups render Mistic extraordinarily resistant against unfolding, so that the protein largely retains its secondary structure even at urea concentrations higher than 7 M. Notably, for the application of Mistic as a fusion tag, polar or charged detergents have been found to be very successful in solubilizing the protein, which is in excellent agreement with our in vitro stability data. Thus, Mistic represents a unique model system to quantitatively assess the contribution of polar interactions to membrane-protein folding and extends the established view that hydrophobic interactions are the single most important contributors to the stability of membrane-interacting proteins.

Measuring membrane protein stability under native conditions

The thermodynamic stability of proteins is typically measured at high denaturant concentrations and then extrapolated back to zero denaturant conditions to obtain unfolding free energies under native conditions. For membrane proteins, the extrapolations are fraught with considerable uncertainty as the denaturants may have complex effects on the membrane or micellar structure. We therefore sought to measure stability under native conditions, using a method that does not perturb the properties of the membrane or membrane mimetics. We use a technique called steric trapping to measure the thermodynamic stability of bacteriorhodopsin in bicelles and micelles. We find that bacteriorhodopsin has a high thermodynamic stability, with an unfolding free energy of ∼11 kcal/mol in dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine bicelles. Nevertheless, the stability is much lower than predicted by extrapolation of measurements made at high denaturant concentrations. We investigated the discrepancy and found that unfolding free energy is not linear with denaturant concentration. Apparently, long extrapolations of helical membrane protein unfolding free energies must be treated with caution. Steric trapping, however, provides a method for making these measurements.

C-Terminal Truncations of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae PMA1 H + -ATPase Have Major Impacts on Protein Conformation, Trafficking, Quality Control, and Function

The C-terminal tail of yeast plasma membrane (PM) H(+)-ATPase extends approximately 38 amino acids beyond the final membrane-spanning segment (TM10) of the protein and is known to be required for successful trafficking, stability, and regulation of enzyme activity. To carry out a detailed functional survey of the entire length of the tail, we generated 15 stepwise truncation mutants. Eleven of them, lacking up to 30 amino acids from the extreme terminus, were able to support cell growth, even though there were detectable changes in plasma membrane expression, protein stability, and ATPase activity. Three functionally distinct regions of the C terminus could be defined. (i) Truncations upstream of Lys(889), removing more than 30 amino acid residues, yielded no viable mutants, and conditional expression of such constructs supported the conclusion that the stretch from Ala(881) (at the end of TM10) to Gly(888) is required for stable folding and PM targeting. (ii) The stretch between Lys(889) and Lys(916), a region known to be subject to kinase-mediated posttranslational modification, was shown here to be ubiquitinated in carbon-starved cells as part of cellular quality control and to be essential for normal ATPase folding and stability, as well as for autoinhibition of ATPase activity during glucose starvation. (iii) Finally, removal of even one or two residues (Glu(917) and Thr(918)) from the extreme C terminus led to visibly reduced expression of the ATPase at the plasma membrane. Thus, the C terminus is much more than a simple appendage and profoundly influences the structure, biogenesis, and function of the yeast H(+)-ATPase.

Amino Acid Capture by Aqueous Interfaces. Implications for Biological Uptake

The interactions of natural amino acids with water-hydrophobic interfaces are central to the control of key biological processes, such as passive transport, and to the overall structure and stability of membrane proteins. We still have a very poor knowledge of these interactions, and our aim in this work is to investigate the thermochemistry and dynamics properties of simple aliphatic amino acids (glycine and valine) across a water-organic interface. The study has been carried out by means of Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics simulations focusing on the role that the hydrophobicity of the side chain has on the phase transfer mechanism of the amino acid. Data for the energetics of the uptake processes have been reported, and it is expected that the reported results will be helpful in the design of future experiments with systems of biological relevance. We have shown that neutral tautomers exhibit a noticeable affinity for the interface that increases with increasing hydrophobicity of the side chain. Moreover, the zwitterionic form of valine (but not that of glycine) does also exhibit a significant affinity for the interface. An important finding is that the neutral and zwitterionic tautomers are roughly isoergonic in the organic layer close to the interface. This result suggests a two-step mechanism for the water-to-organic phase transfer that involves neutralization of a partially hydrated zwitterion in the organic layer prior to uptake into the bulk. Though the mechanisms for glycine and valine are similar, the predicted energetics and dynamics for the first step display noteworthy differences that should be measurable and may have important biological implications.

Quantification of free cysteines in membrane and soluble proteins using a fluorescent dye and thermal unfolding

Cysteine is an extremely useful site for selective attachment of labels to proteins for many applications, including the study of protein structure in solution by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), fluorescence spectroscopy and medical imaging. The demand for quantitative data for these applications means that it is important to determine the extent of the cysteine labeling. The efficiency of labeling is sensitive to the 3D context of cysteine within the protein. Where the label or modification is not directly measurable by optical or magnetic spectroscopy, for example, in cysteine modification to dehydroalanine, assessing labeling efficiency is difficult. We describe a simple assay for determining the efficiency of modification of cysteine residues, which is based on an approach previously used to determine membrane protein stability. The assay involves a reaction between the thermally unfolded protein and a thiol-specific coumarin fluorophore that is only fluorescent upon conjugation with thiols. Monitoring fluorescence during thermal denaturation of the protein in the presence of the dye identifies the temperature at which the maximum fluorescence occurs; this temperature differs among proteins. Comparison of the fluorescence intensity at the identified temperature between modified, unmodified (positive control) and cysteine-less protein (negative control) allows for the quantification of free cysteine. We have quantified both site-directed spin labeling and dehydroalanine formation. The method relies on a commonly available fluorescence 96-well plate reader, which rapidly screens numerous samples within 1.5 h and uses <100 μg of material. The approach is robust for both soluble and detergent-solubilized membrane proteins.

Solubilization and Stabilization of Isolated Photosystem I Complex with Lipopeptide Detergents

It is difficult to maintain a target membrane protein in a soluble and functional form in aqueous solution without biological membranes. Use of surfactants can improve solubility, but it remains challenging to identify adequate surfactants that can improve solubility without damaging their native structures and biological functions. Here we report the use of a new class of lipopeptides to solubilize photosystem I (PS-I), a well known membrane protein complex. Changes in the molecular structure of these surfactants affected their amphiphilicity and the goal of this work was to exploit a delicate balance between detergency and biomimetic performance in PS-I solubilization via their binding capacity. Meanwhile, the effects of these surfactants on the thermal and structural stability and functionality of PS-I in aqueous solution were investigated by circular dichroism, fluorescence spectroscopy, SDS-PAGE analysis and O2 uptake measurements, respectively. Our studies showed that the solubility of PS-I depended on both the polarity and charge in the hydrophilic head of the lipopeptides and the length of its hydrophobic tail. The best performing lipopeptides in favour of PS-I solubility turned out to be C14DK and C16DK, which were comparable to the optimal amphiphilicity of the conventional chemical surfactants tested. Lipopeptides showed obvious advantages in enhancing PS-I thermostability over sugar surfactant DDM and some full peptide amphiphiles reported previously. Fluorescence spectroscopy along with SDS-PAGE analysis demonstrated that lipopeptides did not undermine the polypeptide composition and conformation of PS-I after solubilization; instead they showed better performance in improving the structural stability and integrity of this multi-subunit membrane protein than conventional detergents. Furthermore, O2 uptake measurements indicated that PS-I solubilized with lipopeptides maintained its functionality. The underlying mechanism for the favorable actions of lipopeptide in PS-I solubilization and stabilization is discussed.

Hydrophobic variants of ganglio-tripod amphiphiles for membrane protein manipulation

Membrane proteins operate in unique cellular environments. Once removed from their native context for the purification that is required for most types of structural or functional analyses, they are prone to denature if not properly stabilized by membrane mimetics. Detergent micelles have prominently been used to stabilize membrane proteins in aqueous environments as their amphipathic nature allows for shielding of the hydrophobic surfaces of these bio-macromolecules while supporting solubility and monodispersity in water. This study expands the utility of branched diglucoside-bearing tripod agents, designated ganglio-tripod amphiphiles, with introduction of key variations in their hydrophobic sections and shows how these latter elements can be fine-tuned to maximize membrane protein solubilization while preserving characteristics of these molecules that afford stabilization of rather fragile assemblies. Their efficacy rivals benchmark detergents heavily used today, such as n-dodecyl-β-d-maltoside.

Membrane protein stability depends on the concentration of compatible solutes – a single molecule force spectroscopic study

Compatible solutes are small, uncharged, zwitter ionic, osmotically active molecules produced and accumulated by microorganisms inside their cell to counteract different kinds of environmental stress. They enhance protein stability without interfering with the metabolic pathways even at molar concentrations. In this paper, we report the stabilizing effects of compatible solutes, ectoine, betaine and taurine on membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin at different concentrations. Using atomic force microscopy based single molecule force spectroscopy the impact of the osmolytes was quantified by measuring the forces required to pull the protein out of the membrane and the change in the persistence lengths of the unfolded polypeptide chain. Increase in unfolding forces were observed, indicating the strengthening of intramolecular interactions, which are vital for protein stability. The decrease in persistence lengths was recorded and showed increasing tendencies of the polypeptide strand to coil up. Interestingly, it was revealed that these molecules have different stabilizing effects on protein unfolding at different concentrations. The results show that the unfolding of single protein provides insight to the structure-dynamic relationship between the protein and compatible solute molecules at sub-nanometer scale. This also helps to understand the molecular mechanism involved in protein stabilization by organic osmolytes.

Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP)-Based Overexpression Screening and Characterization of AgrC, a Receptor Protein of Quorum Sensing in Staphylococcus aureus

Staphylococcus aureus AgrC is an important component of the agr quorum-sensing system. AgrC is a membrane-embedded histidine kinase that is thought to act as a sensor for the recognition of environmental signals and the transduction of signals into the cytoplasm. However, the difficulty of expressing and purifying functional membrane proteins has drastically hindered in-depth understanding of the molecular structures and physiological functions of these proteins. Here, we describe the high-yield expression and purification of AgrC, and analyze its kinase activity. A C-terminal green fluorescent protein (GFP) fusion to AgrC served as a reporter for monitoring protein expression levels in real time. Protein expression levels were analyzed by the microscopic assessment of the whole-cell fluorescence. The expressed AgrC-GFP protein with a C-terminal His-tagged was purified using immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) and size exclusion chromatography (SEC) at yields of ≥10 mg/L, following optimization. We also assessed the effects of different detergents on membrane solubilization and AgrC kinase activity, and polyoxyethylene-(23)-lauryl-ether (Brij-35) was identified as the most suitable detergent. Furthermore, the secondary structural stability of purified AgrC was analyzed using circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. This study may serve as a general guide for improving the yields of other membrane protein preparations and selecting the appropriate detergent to stabilize membrane proteins for biophysical and biochemical analyses.

Correction to “Tandem Facial Amphiphiles for Membrane Protein Stabilization”

Correction to “Tandem Facial Amphiphiles for Membrane Protein Stabilization”

Dodecyl Maltoside Protects Membrane Proteins In Vacuo

Molecular dynamics simulations have been used to characterize the effects of transfer from aqueous solution to a vacuum to inform our understanding of mass spectrometry of membrane-protein-detergent complexes. We compared two membrane protein architectures (an α-helical bundle versus a β-barrel) and two different detergent types (phosphocholines versus an alkyl sugar) with respect to protein stability and detergent packing. The β-barrel membrane protein remained stable as a protein-detergent complex in vacuum. Zwitterionic detergents formed conformationally destabilizing interactions with an α-helical membrane protein after detergent micelle inversion driven by dehydration in vacuum. In contrast, a nonionic alkyl sugar detergent resisted micelle inversion, maintaining the solution-phase conformation of the protein. This helps to explain the relative stability of membrane proteins in the presence of alkyl sugar detergents such as dodecyl maltoside.

Structure Determination of Membrane Proteins in Their Native Phospholipid Bilayer Environment by Rotationally Aligned Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy

One of the most important topics in experimental structural biology is determining the structures of membrane proteins. These structures represent one-third of all of the information expressed from a genome, distinguished by their locations within the phospholipid bilayer of cells, organelles, or enveloped viruses. Their highly hydrophobic nature and insolubility in aqueous media means that they require an amphipathic environment. They have unique functions in transport, catalysis, channel formation, and signaling. Researchers are particularly interested in G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) because they modulate many biological processes, and about half of the approximately 800 of these proteins within the human genome are or can be turned into drug receptors that affect a wide range of diseases. Because of experimental difficulties, researchers have studied membrane proteins using a wide variety of artificial media that mimic membranes, such as mixed organic solvents or detergents. More sophisticated mimics include bilayer discs (bicelles) and the lipid cubic phase (LCP), but both of these contain a very large detergent component, which can disrupt the stability and function of membrane proteins. To have confidence in the resulting structures and their biological functions and to avoid disrupting these delicate proteins, the structures of membrane proteins should be determined in their native environment of liquid crystalline phospholipid bilayers under physiological conditions. This Account describes a recently developed general method for determining the structures of unmodified membrane proteins in phospholipid bilayers by solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Because it relies on the natural, rapid rotational diffusion of these proteins about the bilayer normal, this method is referred to as rotationally aligned (RA) solid-state NMR. This technique elaborates on oriented sample (OS) solid-state NMR, its complementary predecessor. These methods exploit the power of solid-state NMR, which enables researchers to obtain well-resolved spectra from "immobile" membrane proteins in phospholipid bilayers, to separate and measure frequencies that reflect orientations with respect to the bilayer normal, and to make complementary distance measurements. The determination of the structures of several membrane proteins, most prominently the chemokine receptor CXCR1, a 350-residue GPCR, has demonstrated this approach.

Modulating lipid dynamics and membrane fluidity to drive rapid folding of a transmembrane barrel

Lipid-protein interactions, critical for the folding, stability and function of membrane proteins, can be both of mechanical and chemical nature. Mechanical properties of lipid systems can be suitably influenced by physical factors so as to facilitate membrane protein folding. We demonstrate here that by modulating lipid dynamics transiently using heat, rapid folding of two 8-stranded transmembrane β-barrel proteins OmpX and OmpA1–171, in micelles and vesicles, can be achieved within seconds. Folding kinetics using this ‘heat shock’ method shows a dramatic ten to several hundred folds increase in refolding rate along with ~100% folding efficiency. We establish that OmpX thus folded is highly thermostable even in detergent micelles, and retains structural characteristics comparable to the protein in bilayers.

Membrane Depth-Dependent Energetic Contribution of the Tryptophan Side Chain to the Stability of Integral Membrane Proteins

Lipid solvation provides the primary driving force for the insertion and folding of integral membrane proteins. Although the structure of the lipid bilayer is often simplified as a central hydrophobic core sandwiched between two hydrophilic interfacial regions, the complexity of the liquid-crystalline bilayer structure and the gradient of water molecules across the bilayer fine-tune the energetic contributions of individual amino acid residues to the stability of membrane proteins at different depths of the bilayer. The tryptophan side chain is particularly interesting because despite its widely recognized role in anchoring membrane proteins in lipid bilayers, there is little consensus about its hydrophobicity among various experimentally determined hydrophobicity scales. Here we investigated how lipid-facing tryptophan residues located at different depths in the bilayer contribute to the stability of integral membrane proteins using outer membrane protein A (OmpA) as a model. We replaced all lipid-contacting residues of the first transmembrane β-strand of OmpA with alanines and individually incorporated tryptophans in these positions along the strand. By measuring the thermodynamic stability of these proteins, we found that OmpA is slightly more stable when tryptophans are placed in the center of the bilayer and that it is somewhat destabilized as tryptophans approach the interfacial region. However, this trend may be partially reversed when a moderate concentration of urea rather than water is taken as the reference state. The measured stability profiles are driven by similar profiles of the m-value, a parameter that reflects the shielding of hydrophobic surface area from water. Our results indicate that knowledge of the free energy level of the protein's unfolded reference state is important for quantitatively assessing the stability of membrane proteins, which may explain differences in observed profiles between in vivo and in vitro scales.

Crystal structure of the integral membrane diacylglycerol kinase

Diacylglycerol kinase (DgkA) catalyzes the ATP-dependent phosphorylation of diacylglycerol to phosphatidic acid for use in shuttling water-soluble components to membrane derived oligosaccharide and lipopolysaccharide in the cell envelope of Gram-negative bacteria1. For half a century, this 121-residue kinase has served as a paradigm for investigating membrane protein enzymology1,3-7, folding8,9, assembly10-13, and stability1,14. Here, we present crystal structures for three functional forms of this unique and paradigmatic kinase, one of which is wild type (WT). These reveal a homo-trimeric enzyme with three transmembrane helices and an N-terminal amphiphilic helix per monomer. Bound lipid substrate and docked ATP identify the putative active site which is of the composite, shared site type. The crystal structures rationalize extensive biochemical and biophysical data on the enzyme. They are however at variance with a published solution NMR model2 in that domain swapping, a key feature of the solution form, is not observed in the crystal structures.

A detergent-free strategy for the reconstitution of active enzyme complexes from native biological membranes into nanoscale discs

BackgroundThe reconstitution of membrane proteins and complexes into nanoscale lipid bilayer structures has contributed significantly to biochemical and biophysical analyses. Current methods for performing such reconstitutions entail an initial detergent-mediated step to solubilize and isolate membrane proteins. Exposure to detergents, however, can destabilize many membrane proteins and result in a loss of function. Amphipathic copolymers have recently been used to stabilize membrane proteins and complexes following suitable detergent extraction. However, the ability of these copolymers to extract proteins directly from native lipid bilayers for subsequent reconstitution and characterization has not been explored.ResultsThe styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymer effectively solubilized membranes of isolated mitochondria and extracted protein complexes. Membrane complexes were reconstituted into polymer-bound nanoscale discs along with endogenous lipids. Using respiratory Complex IV as a model, these particles were shown to maintain the enzymatic activity of multicomponent electron transporting complexes.ConclusionsWe report a novel process for reconstituting fully operational protein complexes directly from cellular membranes into nanoscale lipid bilayers using the SMA copolymer. This facile, single-step strategy obviates the requirement for detergents and yields membrane complexes suitable for structural and functional studies.

Stabilizing membrane proteins through protein engineering

Integral membrane proteins (IMPs) are crucial components of all cells but are difficult to study in vitro because they are generally unstable when removed from their native membranes using detergents. Despite the major biomedical relevance of IMPs, less than 1% of Protein Data Bank (PDB) entries are IMP structures, reflecting the technical gap between studies of soluble proteins compared to IMPs. Stability can be engineered into IMPs by inserting stabilizing mutations, thereby generating proteins that can be successfully applied to biochemical and structural studies when solubilized in detergent micelles. The identification of stabilizing mutations is not trivial, and this review will focus on the methods that have been used to identify stabilized membrane proteins, including alanine scanning and screening, directed evolution and computational design.

Corrigendum: A New Class of Amphiphiles Bearing Rigid Hydrophobic Groups for Solubilization and Stabilization of Membrane Proteins

Corrigendum: A New Class of Amphiphiles Bearing Rigid Hydrophobic Groups for Solubilization and Stabilization of Membrane Proteins

Steroid-based facial amphiphiles for stabilization and crystallization of membrane proteins

Amphiphile selection is a critical step for structural studies of membrane proteins (MPs). We have developed a family of steroid-based facial amphiphiles (FAs) that are structurally distinct from conventional detergents and previously developed FAs. The unique FAs stabilize MPs and form relatively small protein-detergent complexes (PDCs), a property considered favorable for MP crystallization. We attempted to crystallize several MPs belonging to different protein families, including the human gap junction channel protein connexin 26, the ATP binding cassette transporter MsbA, the seven-transmembrane G protein-coupled receptor-like bacteriorhodopsin, and cytochrome P450s (peripheral MPs). Using FAs alone or mixed with other detergents or lipids, we obtained 3D crystals of the above proteins suitable for X-ray crystallographic analysis. The fact that FAs enhance MP crystallizability compared with traditional detergents can be attributed to several properties, including increased protein stability, formation of small PDCs, decreased PDC surface flexibility, and potential to mediate crystal lattice contacts.

From Cells to Peptides: “One-Stop” Integrated Proteomic Processing Using Amphipols

In proteomics, detergents and chaotropes are indispensable for proteome analysis, not only for protein extraction, but also for protein digestion. To increase the protein extraction efficiency, detergents are usually added in the lysis buffer to extract membrane proteins out of membrane structure and to maintain protein in solutions. In general, these detergents need to be removed prior to protein digestion, usually by precipitation or ultrafiltration. Digestion often takes place in the presence of chaotropic reagents, such as urea, which often need to be removed prior to mass spectrometry. The addition and removal of detergents and chaotropes require multiple steps that are time-consuming and can cause sample losses. Amphipols (APols) are a different class of detergents that have physical and solubilization properties that are distinct from conventional detergents. They have primarily been used in protein structure analysis for membrane protein trapping and stabilization. Here, we demonstrate a simple and rapid protocol for total and membrane proteome preparation using APols. We demonstrate that APols added for cell lysis help maintain the proteome in solution, are compatible with protein digestion using trypsin, and can readily be removed prior to mass spectrometry by a one-step acidification and centrifugation. This protocol is much faster, can be performed in a single tube, and can readily replace the conventional detergent/chaotrope approaches for total and membrane proteome analysis.