Spectral Induced Polarization Signals Research Articles

Monitoring of copper adsorption on biochar using spectral induced polarization method

Copper contaminant generated from mining and industrial smelting poses potential risks to human health. Biochar, as a low-energy and cost-effective biomaterial, holds value in Cu remediation. Spectral Induced Polarization (SIP) technique is employed in this study to monitor the Cu remediation processes of by biochar in column experiments. Cation exchange at low Cu2+ concentrations and surface complexation at high Cu2+ concentrations are identified as the major mechanisms for copper retention on biochar. The normalized chargeability (mn) from SIP signals linearly decreased (R2 = 0.776) with copper retention under 60 mg/L Cu influent; while mn linearly increases (R2 = 0.907, 0.852) under high 300 and 700 mg/L Cu influents. The characteristic polarizing unit sizes (primarily the pores adsorbing Cu2+) calculated from Schwartz equation match well with experimental results by mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP). It is revealed that Cu2+ was driven to small pores (∼3 μm) given high concentration gradient (influent Cu2+ concentration of 700 mg/L). Comparing to activated carbon, biochar is identified as an ideal adsorbent for Cu remediation, given its high adsorption capacity, cost-effectiveness, carbon-sink ability, and high sensitivity to SIP responses – the latter facilitates its performance assessment.

Spectral induced polarization signatures of smoldering remediation enhanced with colloidal activated carbon: An experimental study

Monitoring the remediation of soil and groundwater contaminated by organic compounds remains highly challenging. Thermal treatments, such as smoldering combustion, have become established remediation techniques for destroying contaminants. Smoldering combustion can now be supported by colloidal activated carbon (CAC), with CAC being able to both adsorb contaminants and supplement the fuel source for destroying them. Despite this potential, effective performance monitoring of smoldering remediation remains limited. The objective of this study is to investigate the potential of the spectral induced polarization (SIP) geoelectrical technique to assess the performance of smoldering remediation of soils supplemented with CAC. SIP column experiments were first conducted to assess the response of SIP (i.e., real and imaginary components of the complex electrical conductivity) to varying concentrations of CAC in imitated field soils that contain, or do not contain, organic matter (OM). Results demonstrate that increasing OM and CAC contents increase both the real and imaginary conductivities, with the imaginary conductivity also showing frequency dependence. Smoldering and SIP column experiments were then conducted to assess the effectiveness of SIP for detecting changes in soils of varying OM and CAC contents that have been remediated by smoldering. Examination of the soils before and after smoldering indicates that SIP can track the evolving real conductivity and imaginary conductivity (in particular) between different soil compositions and different stages of the remedial process. High resolution scanning electron microscopy imaging was performed on all samples to validate the SIP and smoldering experiments, confirming significant reductions in carbon after smoldering. Overall, this study suggests that SIP has potential to track changes associated with the addition of remedial fluids like CAC in the subsurface, and the destruction of contaminants adsorbed to CAC by smoldering combustion.

Detection of Iron Disulfide Materials in Geological Porous Media Using Spectral Induced Polarization Method

Summary Iron sulfide (FeS) scale is a known problem that can significantly impact oil and gas (O&G) production. However, current monitoring methods cannot detect the problem at early stages, not until it is too late for any meaningful remedial action. Spectral induced polarization (SIP) is an established geophysical method increasingly used in near-surface environmental applications. The unique characteristics of the SIP method, mainly the sensitivity to both bulk and interfacial properties of the medium, allow for the potential use as a characterization and monitoring tool. SIP is particularly sensitive to metallic targets, such as FeS, with direct implications for the detection, characterization, and quantification of FeS scale. In a column setup, various concentrations of pyrite (FeS2), a common form of FeS scale, within calcite were tested to examine the SIP sensitivity and establish qualitative and quantitative relationships between SIP signals and FeS2 properties. The concentration of FeS2 in the samples directly impacts the SIP signals; the higher the concentration, the higher the magnitude of SIP parameters. Specifically, the SIP method detected the FeS2 presence as low as 0.25% in the bulk volume of the tested sample. This study supports the potential use of SIP as a detection method of FeS2 presence. Furthermore, it paves the way for upcoming studies utilizing SIP as a reliable and robust FeS scale characterization and monitoring method.

The influence of roots on soil's electrical signature

Detecting and monitoring roots and their activity in soil is of great importance as it controls water and nutrient transport, soil carbon dynamics, and soil microorganisms. However, roots are hidden in the soil, they are heterogeneous, and dynamics; therefore, in-situ measurements of their properties and the involved processes are highly challenging. The spectral induced polarization (SIP) is a geophysical method that allows noninvasive mapping of subsurface properties and processes. Recently, the quadrature conductivity (measured with the SIP method) was positively correlated with root biomass and root surface area in hydroponics. Unlike the nonpolarized hydroponic solution (at frequencies <1000 Hz, relevant to the SIP method), the soil is a polarizable medium, and various soil-root interactions (e.g., water and nutrient uptake, root exudation, etc.) are expected to influence the soil SIP signature. Therefore, this research aimed to assess the impact of roots on the SIP signature of soil. We conducted a series of experiments in which we measured and monitored the SIP signature of soil in which wheat plants are growing. Supplementary measurements included soil water content, pore water salinity, and root biomass. Our results show that, unlike in hydroponic, there is an inverse relationship between root biomass and quadrature conductivity. Most of the decrease in the quadrature conductivity was associated with the water content decrease. We suggest that the unexplained decline in the quadrature conductivity is associated with various soil-root interactions, such as selective uptake of nutrients and root exudation, but further research is needed.

Spectral Induced Polarization (SIP) of Denitrification‐Driven Microbial Activity in Column Experiments Packed With Calcareous Aquifer Sediments

AbstractSpectral Induced Polarization (SIP) has been suggested as a non‐invasive monitoring proxy for microbial processes. Under natural conditions, however, multiple and often coupled polarization processes co‐occur, impeding the interpretation of SIP signals. In this study, we analyze the sensitivity of SIP to microbially‐driven reactions under quasi‐natural conditions. We conducted flow‐through experiments in columns equipped with SIP electrodes and filled with natural calcareous, organic‐carbon‐rich aquifer sediment, in which heterotrophic denitrification was bio‐stimulated. Our results show that, even in the presence of parallel polarization processes in a natural sediment under field‐relevant geochemical conditions, SIP is sufficiently sensitive to microbially‐driven changes in electrical charge storage. Denitrification yielded an increase in imaginary conductivity of up to 3.1 (+140%) and the formation of a distinct peak between 1 and 10 Hz, that matched the timing of expected microbial activity predicted by a reactive transport model fitted to solute concentrations. A Cole‐Cole decomposition allowed separating the polarization contribution of microbial activity from that of cation exchange, thereby helping to locate microbial hotspots without the need for (bio)geochemical data to constrain the Cole‐Cole parameters. Our approach opens new avenues for the application of SIP as a rapid method to monitor a system's reactivity in situ. While in preceding studies the SIP signals of microbial activity in natural sediments were influenced by mineral precipitation/dissolution reactions, the imaginary conductivity changes measured in the biostimulation experiments presented here were dominated by changes in the polarization of the bacterial cells rather than a reaction‐induced alteration of the abiotic matrix.

Statistical analysis for biogeochemical processes in a sandy column with dynamic hydrologic regimes using spectral induced polarization (SIP) and self-potential (SP)

SUMMARYThe capillary fringe (CF) is characterized by transient and steep redox gradients and is thought to be a hot spot for biogeochemical processes. Understanding chemical fate and transport in the CF is significant, however, biogeochemical dynamics at the CF are poorly understood because of the difficulty to measure representatively with high spatio-temporal resolution at depths under dynamic hydrologic regimes. Hydrogeophysics is a developing field that uses minimally intrusive and quick response methods to monitor hydrological properties. Two geoelectrical methods [spectral induced polarization (SIP) and self-potential (SP)], which are sensitive to the solid–liquid interfaces (SIP) and biogeochemical processes (SP) can address the above difficulty. The challenge lies on linking the geoelectrical responses with biogeochemical processes, where many different processes contribute to the signals. We conducted a soil column experiment under five hydrologic regimes focusing on nitrogen transformations with SIP and SP measurements: (1) a static regime with a stable water level; (2) an infiltration regime with periodic pulse infiltration events with a constant water level and (3) fluctuating regimes with water level fluctuations under three drying-wetting frequencies (6/12/18-day-cycle). This is the first large lab-scale work in a well-controlled and highly instrumented soil column. The dynamic hydrologic conditions stimulated complex biogeochemical processes at the CF, and therefore the SIP and SP signals result from many physical and biogeochemical processes. Therefore, we relied on statistical analysis in this study for a novel interpretation. Spearman correlation analysis supported water content played the most important role in real conductivity (σ′) dynamics in the vadose zone, whereas fluid conductivity dominated σ′ in the saturated zone. Both correlation analysis and spatial moment analysis implicated that water content was the driving factor for both σ′ and imaginary conductivity (σ″). A multiple linear regression model indicated the gradient of redox potential, the gradient of soil matric potential and water content were the three main influencing factors for the SP signals. We proposed that the water level fluctuation can efficiently facilitate microbial electron transfer through ions transport between the different redox zones, and aggregate redox processes to create SP signal gradients. Depth zonation analysis, using six environmental indexes (Eh and nitrogen species; water content; real conductivity; imaginary conductivity; SP signal; microbial community composition), suggested that water content induced by soil hydrology was the most dominant factor, captured by all the indexes. In turn, it led to indirect inference on biogeochemical processes and resultant geoelectrical signals. Applying geoelectrical methods to such biogeochemical processes will not only lead to a better understanding of the mechanistic meanings of the geoelectrical signals, but also build relationships between geoelectrical signals and biogeochemical parameters to facilitate a novel way to monitor biogeochemical processes.

Spectral induced polarization of heterogeneous non-consolidated clays

SUMMARY Clays are ubiquitously located in the Earth’s near surface and have a high impact on the subsurface permeability. Most geo-electrical characterizations of clays do not take into account the heterogeneous nature of clay geological media. We want to better understand the influence of heterogeneities on the geo-electrical signature, thus we collected a data set of spectral induced polarization (SIP) of artificial heterogeneous non-consolidated clay samples. The samples are made of illite and red montmorillonite in a parallel and perpendicular disposition (with respect to the applied electric field). Another sample is a homogeneous mixture composed of the same volumetric fraction of illite and red montmorillonite. For all the samples, the polarization is dominated by the red montmorillonite, given by the shape of the spectra (presence or lack of a peak at a particular frequency). We compared the experimental data with classical mixing laws and complex conductance network models to test how to better predict the SIP signature of such mixtures when the SIP spectra of the two components are known. The real conductivity is better predicted by the mixing laws, but the shape of the spectra (presence of polarization peaks at particular frequencies) is best predicted by the conductance network models. This study is a step forward towards a better characterization of heterogeneous clay systems using SIP.

Evaluation of aqueous Cd2+ and Pb2+ removal by natural loess using spectral induced polarization and microscopic characterization.

Mining and landfill activities can cause serious soil and groundwater contamination with lead (Pb) and cadmium (Cd). Loess soils are common and have been reported as effective for the removal of heavy metals. The spectral induced polarization (SIP) technique has been approved for its nondestructive ability to characterize the contaminant transport process and surface geochemical properties in porous media. In the present study, SIP was applied to monitor Pb2+ and Cd2+ removal processes using loess through column flow-through experiments. The outflow aqueous geochemical analyses indicated a better retention capability of loess for Pb2+, which was through precipitation induced by calcite dissolution and aqueous pH increment, as confirmed by SEM-EDS and XRD results. Cd retention took place mainly through ion exchange with Ca2+ and Mg2+ on the loess surface. The SIP signals showed a continuous decrement on the magnitude of imaginary conductivity during both Pb2+ and Cd2+ flow-through, which was attributed to the total surface area and decrement of polarizable surface charges. The SIP signals differentiated the interactions between loess and Pb2+/Cd2+ by displaying a peak shift to a higher frequency on the imaginary conductivity spectra during Pb2+ flow-through, which was attributed to calcite dissolution and proved by the high correlation (R2 = 0.9366) between the estimated dissolved calcite mass and the peak of imaginary conductivity. The above results suggest that loess has a great potential for field heavy metal remediation applications, and the SIP technique displays a promising capability of monitoring the remediation performance.

Modeling and Experimental Study of the Effect of Pore Water Velocity on the Spectral Induced Polarization Signature in Porous Media

AbstractInduced polarization (IP) is increasingly applied for hydrological, environmental and agricultural purposes. Interpretation of IP data is based on understanding the relationship between the IP signature and the porous media property of interest. Mechanistic models on the IP phenomenon rely on the Poisson‐Nernst‐Plank equations, where diffusion and electromigration fluxes are the driving forces of charge transport and are directly related to IP. However, to our knowledge, the impact of advection flux on IP was not investigated experimentally and was not considered in any IP model. In this work, we measured the spectral IP (SIP) signature of porous media under varying flow conditions, in addition to developing and solving a model for SIP signature of porous media, which takes flow into consideration. The experimental and the model results demonstrate that as bulk velocity increases, polarization and relaxation time decrease. Using a numerical model, we established that fluid flow near the particle deforms the electrical double layer (EDL) structure, accounting for the observed reduction in polarization. We found a qualitative agreement between the model and the measurements. Still, the model overestimates the impact of flow rate on SIP signature, which we explain in terms of the flow boundary conditions. Overall, our results demonstrate the sensitivity of the SIP signature to fluid flow, highlighting the need to consider fluid velocity in the interpretation of the SIP signature of porous media, and opening an exciting new direction for noninvasive measurements of fluid flow at the EDL scale.

Evaluating iron remediation with limestone using spectral induced polarization and microscopic techniques

Groundwater contamination with iron caused by mining and landfill activities has fueled the development of remediation strategies. Permeable reactive barriers (PRBs) are commonly applied in subsurface remediation because of their high removal effect and low costs. Spectral induced polarization (SIP) technique has been approved for its nondestructive ability to monitor the geochemical processes in porous media. In this study, SIP technique was applied for monitoring iron remediation by limestone at column scale. The chemical analysis showed the pH of the porous fluid increased - attributed to the dissolution of limestone, which promoted the precipitation of iron. The precipitate phases included both γ-FeOOH and Fe2O3 based on X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) results. The micro computed tomography (CT) technique investigated the uneven distribution of the precipitates in the column, which indicated the existence of preferential flow. SIP signals revealed the quantity of the accumulated iron precipitates, which was proved by the chemical measurement and calculation. SIP signals also derived the time evolution of both the average precipitate size and size distribution, which elucidated the processes of precipitate crystal growth and aggregation during Fe flow-through. Above results suggest that SIP holds the promise of monitoring the engineering barrier performance.

Modeling Plant Roots Spectral Induced Polarization Signature

AbstractMonitoring the growth, architecture, and function of plant roots is of great interest. One promising noninvasive geoelectrical monitoring approach is spectral induced polarization (SIP). However, the roots' SIP signature is underexplored, not well understood, and a mechanistic model has not been proposed. Here, we developed a mechanistic model for SIP's response of roots, which is based on the Poisson‐Nernst‐Planck equation. The modeling results suggest that the magnitude of root polarization is linearly related to the root's external surface area and that the polarization length scale is the root's diameter. We suggest that injecting a current to the plant's stem results in higher polarization associated with the root‐cells' total surface area. In this case, the polarization length scale is the cell diameter. Overall, we quantified the link between the root's dimensions and their electrical signature, which may inspire SIP application for root phenotyping.

Content and morphology of lead remediated by activated carbon and biochar: A spectral induced polarization study

Soil and groundwater contamination with lead (Pb) poses serious challenges for the environment. Activated carbon (AC) and biochar have huge potential application in the in-situ remediation processes through permeable reactive barriers (PRB). Spectral induced polarization (SIP) technique recently showed promises in nondestructively monitoring the spatio-temporal characteristics of physical, chemical and biological processes in porous media. In this study SIP technique was used for monitoring Pb remediation by AC and biochar in column scale. The calculated characteristic grain/pore size evolutions from SIP signals on AC, agreed well with the size of precipitates measured by SEM and mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP) methods. The content increment process of the retained Pb on AC was also recorded via the magnitude increment of the imaginary conductivity. The mechanisms of Pb–AC and Pb-biochar interactions were investigated using SEM-EDS, TEM, FTIR, XRD, and XPS measurements. It showed that AC immobilizes through physical adsorption and precipitation, whereas complexation with functional groups is the remediation mechanism for biochar. Furthermore, the observed SIP responses of both AC and biochar are two orders of magnitude higher than those of typical natural soils or silica materials. This distinct difference is an additional advantage for the field application of SIP technique in PRB scenarios.

Complex conductivity signatures of microbial induced calcite precipitation, field and laboratory scales

SUMMARYSoil stabilization processes aim at enhancing soil's engineering properties. Although the concept is straightforward, it involves physical and chemical changes to the subsurface that could result in local environmental changes. Compared to conventional soil stabilization methods (such as cement grouting), bio-mediated soil stabilization, such as microbial-induced calcite precipitation (MICP), offers the opportunity to minimize environmental impact, but the underlying processes need to be well understood for proper applications. Accurate characterization and long-term monitoring are paramount for the success of soil improvement, especially MICP treatments. Spectral induced polarization (SIP), an established geophysical method, has shown to be sensitive to MICP processes and products (e.g. calcite). In this work, we performed a two-phase study to explore SIP's suitability as a monitoring tool. Phase 1 involved a laboratory scale MICP study under controlled conditions and phase 2 a pilot field scale study. In the laboratory, MICP was induced through the introduction of ureolytic microorganisms, while in the field, indigenous soil microbes were stimulated to promote ureolysis. In both cases, traditional geochemical monitoring, along with spatiotemporally dense SIP monitoring, were performed. Over the course of the laboratory study, SIP successfully tracked the MICP progress as well as the calcite precipitation behaviour. Similarly, the SIP results of the field scale study showed to be sensitive to the subsurface changes in response to MICP. SIP offered spatiotemporally rich information on the MICP progress and process status. The similarity between observed signal trends in the laboratory and field in this study clearly proved that SIP signals from MICP in controlled laboratory environments can be successfully used to study field MICP applications despite scale and complexity differences.

Monitoring lime and cement improvement using spectral induced polarization and bender element techniques

Abstract Spectral induced polarization (SIP) and bender element (BE) techniques show a high sensitivity to particle size, particle distribution and content of generated hydration products, which essentially govern the efficiency of ground improvement. In this context, both SIP and BE were integrated on a column setup to monitor the processes of lime and cement stabilization. A 5 mmol/L Na2CO3 solution was injected into the sand-lime mixture to produce CaCO3 precipitation, while deionized water was injected into the sand-cement mixture to induce the hydration of cement. The average diameters of the precipitated particles or clusters were calculated from the relaxation time, which was a significant parameter of SIP signals, via the Schwarz equation. Two pairs of BE were used to demonstrate the heterogeneity of the product precipitation, which was probably caused by the location of the inflow and outflow on the SIP-BE column. SIP and BE showed the capability of nondestructively monitoring the spatiotemporal chemical evolution processes, which could be helpful for engineering applications.

Application of spectral induced polarization for characterizing surfactant-enhanced DNAPL remediation in laboratory column experiments

The widespread presence of entrapped dense non-aqueous phase liquid (DNAPL) in the subsurface poses a continuing challenge to groundwater remediation. Cost-effective and high-resolution subsurface characterization is a critical issue for further DNAPL recovery due to the complexity of DNAPL source zone architecture (SZA). Geophysical techniques provide a noninvasive, spatially continuous and cost-effective way for monitoring the DNAPL remediation process. In particular, the spectral induced polarization (SIP) method has shown great potential in environmental problems. In this study, we performed real-time SIP measurements on DNAPL contaminated soil in columns to quantitatively assess the ability of SIP method for monitoring surfactant-enhanced DNAPL remediation process. Chemical data was simultaneously collected during the remediation process to verify the results obtained by SIP method. Taking account into the variations of subsurface environment, we conducted a series of column flushing experiments under different flow rate, surfactant concentrations and fluid salinities. The results highlight that SIP method is able to effectively monitor the DNAPL remediation process, as well as to evaluate the remediation efficiency under different conditions. The variations in the flow rate, the concentration of surfactant and the salinity of pore water not only affect remediation effectiveness, but also have an impact on the SIP signatures. This study shows that SIP performs better for monitoring DNAPL remediation at a relatively low flow rate of ~ 0.4 m/d, low surfactant concentration of 5000 mg/L and high salinity of 1.0 S/m, with an error of saturation estimation (RMSES) <0.1.

Relationship between wheat root properties and its electrical signature using the spectral induced polarization method

AbstractMeasuring root properties, the “hidden half” of the plant, is challenging due to their heterogeneous and dynamic nature. A promising method for noninvasive mapping of roots and their activity, spectral induced polarization (SIP), has been introduced. However, measurements of root properties together with their SIP responses are missing, limiting the interpretation of a root's SIP signature. In this study, we coupled SIP measurements of roots in hydroponic solution with measurements of root biomass, surface area, and diameter. Furthermore, we monitored the SIP response of roots poisoned by cyanide, which results in depolarization of the root's cell membrane potential. We found a linear correlation between root biomass and surface area, and the low‐frequency electrical polarization. In addition, we demonstrate the relationship between root cell membrane potential and root polarization. Based on the results, we suggest that in comparison with the stem‐based approach used by other researchers, the polarization in the contact‐free method used in this study is related to the external surface area of the root and external architectural structures such as root diameter and root hair. Overall, a direct link between root properties and their electrical signature was established.

Combining spectral induced polarization with X-ray tomography to investigate the importance of DNAPL geometry in sand samples

Although many studies have been performed to investigate the spectral induced polarization (SIP) response of nonaqueous phase liquid (NAPL)-contaminated soil samples, there are still many uncertainties in the interpretation of the data. A key issue is that altered pore space geometries due to the presence of a NAPL phase will change the measured IP spectra. However, without any information on the NAPL distribution in the pore space, assumptions are necessary for the SIP data interpretation. Therefore, experimental data of SIP signals directly associated with different NAPL distributions are needed. We used high-resolution X-ray tomography and 3D image processing to quantitatively assess NAPL distributions in samples of fine-grained sand containing different concentrations of tetrachloroethylene and link this to SIP measurements on the same samples. The total concentration of the sample constituents as well as the volumes of the individual NAPL blobs were calculated and used for the interpretation of the associated SIP responses. The X-ray tomography and image analysis showed that the real sample properties (porosity and NAPL distributions) differed from the targeted ones. Both contaminated samples contained less NAPL than expected from the manual sample preparation. The SIP results showed higher real conductivity and lower imaginary conductivity in the contaminated samples compared to a clean sample. This is interpreted as an effect of increased surface conductivity along interconnected NAPL blobs and decreased surface areas in the samples due to NAPL blobs larger than and enclosing grains. We conclude that the combination of SIP, X-ray tomography, and image analysis is a very promising approach to achieve a better understanding of the measured SIP responses of NAPL-contaminated samples.

Mineralogical and textural controls on spectral induced polarization signatures of the Canadian Malartic gold deposit: Applications to mineral exploration

Applications of the spectral induced polarization (SIP) method to mineral exploration are limited by our knowledge of the relationships among rock texture, mineral composition, and electrical properties. Laboratory SIP responses were measured on rock samples from the Canadian Malartic gold deposit. Field SIP responses were also measured at the outcrop scale, along a profile that intersects a well-studied mineralized zone. The mineralogy and the texture of sedimentary rocks from this deposit were quantitatively determined with mineral liberation analysis. A systematic decrease (Pearson [Formula: see text]) in total chargeability with increasing fraction of the sulfide mineral interfaces associated with feldspar minerals (namely, K-feldspar and albite) was observed. On the other hand, total chargeability increased with the fraction of sulfide mineral interfaces associated with carbonates and micas (Pearson [Formula: see text]). At Canadian Malartic, proximal alteration in the mineralized zones is marked by rocks that lack a foliation plane and that were subjected to pervasive K-feldspar, albite, and pyrite alteration. In contrast, distal alteration in sedimentary rocks is marked by biotite, albite, carbonate, and pyrite that are oriented along the regional [Formula: see text] foliation. In the least-altered (LA) sedimentary rocks, quartz and biotite are associated with pyrrhotite and ilmenite as the main sulfide and oxide mineral phases, respectively. SIP measurements conducted at district and outcrop scales and along a drill core indicated that proximally altered sedimentary rocks were characterized by low total chargeability values ([Formula: see text] to [Formula: see text] in the laboratory and [Formula: see text] in the field). In contrast, the LA sedimentary rocks were characterized by total chargeability values up to [Formula: see text] in the laboratory and [Formula: see text] in the field. We conclude that mineralized zones associated with this type of ore deposit are characterized by low chargeability anomalies.

Cell concentrations and metabolites enhance the SIP response to biofilm matrix components

We investigated the relative effect of different bacterial biofilm components to influence spectral induced polarization (SIP) signals and Cole-Cole model parameters (i.e. normalized chargeability (S m−1) and relaxation time (τ)) in order to reduce the ambiguity associated with interpretation of SIP signatures in biostimulated environments. SIP measurements were collected over a frequency range, (i.e. 0.1 Hz–1 kHz) from experimental columns containing Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 (non-mucoid bacterial strain) cell suspensions alone and cell suspensions mixed with different molecules associated with P. aeruginosa biofilm matrix (alginate, DNA and phenazine). Results from SIP measurements of cell density investigations suggest an increase in phase (~ 200%), imaginary conductivity (σ″ S m−1), and normalized chargeability (S m−1) values as cell densities increase (1.50–5.55 × 109 CFUml−1), yet no significant change in the real conductivity (σ′ S m−1) or relaxation time was observed. The addition of alginate resulted in a suppression of phase (φ mrads), imaginary conductivity (σ″ S m−1), and normalized chargeability (S m−1) response. However, a mixture of cells and alginate increased all parameters but with no significant changes in real conductivity (σ′ S m−1) or relaxation time. Similar trend was observed in the DNA treatments; increasing concentrations of DNA reduced the imaginary conductivity (σ″ S m−1), phase (φ mrads), and normalized chargeability (S m−1) response. In contrast, the addition of phenazine, a secondary metabolite of P. aeruginosa, resulted in a significant increase in both imaginary conductivity (σ″ S m−1), phase (φ mrads), and normalized chargeability (S m−1) values especially at larger concentrations (>50 mM). Our work suggests that cell density and metabolites are significant factors increasing the polarization response in biofilms and advances the interpretation of electrical signals associated with biofilms in the subsurface.

The Relative Importance of Saturated Silica Sand Interfacial and Pore Fluid Geochemistry on the Spectral Induced Polarization Response

AbstractAdsorption at the solid‐pore fluid interface is a key mechanism controlling the mobility of nutrients and contaminants in subsurface soils and sediments. The spectral induced polarization (SIP) method has been shown to be sensitive to the quantity and type of adsorbed ions. Extending previous results, we investigated the relevance of pH, solution conductivity, and ion type on the SIP response of saturated silica sand. We also performed adsorption experiments to evaluate whether adsorption plays a relevant role on the effect of saturating solution conductivity and pH. Given their environmental relevance and different electrochemical characteristics, we focused on exploring the influence of Cu2+ and Na+ adsorption on the SIP signature. The adsorption results confirm the expected and modeled pH influence on the adsorption of both Cu2+ and Na+. The measured quadrature conductivity spectra indicate that pH and solution conductivity control the electrical double layer electrochemical state and its capacitive behavior. On the contrary, no appreciable SIP signal changes are associated with ion substitution. The adsorption experiments highlight low values of site occupancy for Na and Cu, which suggests that the effects of pH and fluid conductivity are unrelated to their control on the ion adsorption. We interpret the solution conductivity as a proxy for ionic strength. The relative importance of pH and solution conductivity over ion type helps to further constrain the interpretation of SIP results in field geochemical and biogeochemical characterization and monitoring.