Abstract High-frequency wave propagation in near-inertial wave shear has, for four decades, been considered fundamental in setting the spectral character of the oceanic internal wave continuum and for transporting energy to wave-breaking. We compare idealized ray tracing numerical results with metrics derived using a wave turbulence derivation for the kinetic equation and a path integral to study this specific process. Statistical metrics include the changing ensemble mean vertical wavenumber, referred to as a mean drift, dispersion about the mean drift, time lagged correlation estimates of wavenumber and phase locking of the wave packets with the background. The path integral permits us to identify the mean drift as a resonant process and dispersion about that mean drift as non-resonant. At small inertial wave amplitudes; ray tracing, wave turbulence and the path integral provide consistent descriptions for the mean drift of wavepackets in the spectral domain and dispersion about the mean drift. Extrapolating these results to the background internal wavefield over-predicts downscale energy transports by an order of magnitude. At oceanic amplitudes, however, the numerics support diminished transport and dispersion that coincide with the mean drift time scale becoming similar to the lagged correlation time scale. We parse this as the transition to a non-Markovian process. Despite this decrease, numerical estimates of downscale energy transfer are still too large. We argue that residual differences result from an unwarranted discard of Bragg scattering resonances. Our results support replacing the long standing interpretive paradigm of extreme scale-separated interactions with a more nuanced slate of ‘local’ interactions in the kinetic equation.