The reactive fragment [Tp′Rh(PMe3)], generated from the thermal precursor Tp′Rh(PMe3)(Me)H, is found to cleave the C–Cl bonds of chlorohydrocarbons under mild conditions. Reaction with chloromethane gives clean formation of an initial C–H activation product, which rearranges to form the C–Cl activation product at 30 °C. Reaction with dichloromethane or benzyl chloride gives a mixture of C–Cl activation products as well as products from chlorination. Reaction with chlorocyclohexane gives a mixture of intermediates from C–H activation, which react further upon heating to give a C–Cl cleavage product as well as the β-chloride elimination product Tp′Rh(PMe3)(Cl)H plus cyclohexene. Complete conversion from a C–H activation product to a C–Cl activation product was observed in the reaction with 1,2-dichloroethylene, where β-elimination is circumvented. Activation of 1-chlorobutane, 1,2-dichloroethane, or 1,4-dichlorobutane gives a mixture of C–Cl activation products as well as Tp′Rh(PMe3)(Cl)H plus olefin. Similar to the case for activation of methylene chloride, C–Cl activation and hydride/chloride exchange was observed in the reaction with benzyl chloride, where C–H activation was not seen. The reaction with chlorobenzene gives isomeric species resulting from C–H activation, which react further to give the corresponding chloride derivatives upon heating. Reaction with pentachlorobenzene gives a cyclometalated product from C–H bond cleavage in the phosphine ligand. These reactions are compared and contrasted with related photoreactions with the [Tp′Rh(CNneopentyl)] analogue, where C–H activation is solely observed in most cases. Mechanistic studies suggest the spectator ligand dependent reactivity relies greatly on the dissociation energy of the Tp′Rh–L bond.