Once humans master verbal communication, we babble incessantly on any topic under the sun. But even animals that are equipped with less sophisticated communication systems depend on the same resonances that we skilfully shape with our vocal tracts for communication. Stephan Reber from the University of Vienna, Austria, explains that vibrations – produced when air is pushed past the vocal folds – force air trapped in the vocal tract to vibrate (resonate) and it is these resonances that shape bird song and human syllables. Animals also use the frequency of these resonances (how high or low the sound appears) to communicate their body size, with the frequency of a resonance honestly reflecting their size – although some species are known to exaggerate by deepening their resonances. However, no one knew whether reptiles, such as crocodiles and alligators, used resonances to communicate with others. ‘Anurans – frogs and toads – do not seem to use them’, explains Reber, who decided to find out whether modern day reptilian relatives of the dinosaurs, such as crocodiles and alligators, use resonance for communication.Unsure how to distinguish between the vibrations produced by the vocal folds and resonance vibrations produced by air in the rest of the vocal tract, Reber asked his thesis advisor – Tecumseh Fitch – for advice, and recalls Fitch's simple response: ‘Just put one in heliox’. Explaining that sounds travel much faster in heliox than in normal air, changing the frequency of vocal resonances and producing the Mickey Mouse sound effect that we make after inhaling helium, Reber realised that if the reptiles used resonances in vocal communication, inhaling the modified air should also shift the frequency of sounds produced by resonance. However, he also knew that immersing large alligators in heliox and getting them to serenade on demand would be easier said than done.Travelling to the St Augustine Alligator Farm Zoological Park, USA, home to all 23 species of crocodilians, Reber and Judith Janisch were fortunate to find a small Chinese alligator in isolation in a tank. ‘And when the big alligators in one of the other enclosures were bellowing, she always bellowed’, recalls Reber with a smile. Realising that he could convert her enclosure into a rudimentary sound box complete with heliox atmosphere and that the female would happily bellow on demand when played recordings of her own voice, Reber teamed up with the conservation centre's filtration expert, Mark Robertson, to adapt her holding tank. And when he recorded her bellowing grunts in normal air and heliox, Reber was delighted that the grunts sounded different in the heliox atmosphere.Returning to Austria, Reber then joined Takeshi Nishimura to begin scrutinising the baffling frequency spectra for evidence of shifted resonances. After months of painstaking analysis, he could clearly see that although the bellows sounded deeper in heliox, there were resonances that had shifted to higher frequencies: one increased from 400 to 800 Hz, while the second rose from 1600 to 3200 Hz. Now he could add members of the crocodilian order to the roll-call of animals that use air resonance for communication.Reber admits that he is pleased that these ancient animals produce calls that are shaped by vocal tract resonance and is keen to find out how body size affects the frequency of an animal's vocal resonances. He is also excited that this is another piece of compelling evidence that dinosaurs may also have used acoustic resonance to communicate size. ‘If you see it [resonance] in the last two groups [birds and crocodilians] that share a common ancestor with all extinct dinosaurs, we can infer that dinosaurs probably used formants [resonances] too for communication’, says Reber.
Read full abstract